An Arithmetical Paradox , concerning the Chances of Lotteries , by the Honourable Francis Roberts , Esq ; Fellow of the R. S. AS some Truths ( like the Axioms of Geometry and Metaphysicks ) are self-evident at the first View , so there are others no less certain in their Foundation , that have a very different Aspect , and without a strict and careful Examination rather seem repugnant .
We may find Instances of this kind in most Sciences .
In Geometry , That a Body of an infinite Length may yet have but a finite Magnitude .
In Geography , That if Antwerp be due East to London , for that reason London cannot be West to Antwerp .
In Astronomy , That at the Barbadoes ( and other places between the Line and Tropic ) the Sun , part of the Year , comes twice in a Morning to some Points of the Compass .
In Hydrostaticks , That a hollow Cone ( standing upon its Basis ) being filled with Water , the Water shall press the bottom with three times the Weight , as if the same Water was frozen to Ice ; and Figures might be contrived to make it press a hundred times as much .
These Speculations , as they are generally pleasant , so they may also be of good use to warn us of the Mistakes we are liable to , by careless and superficial reasoning .
I shall add one Instance in Arithmetic , which perhaps may seem as great a Paradox as any of the former .
There are two Lotteries , at either of which a Gamester paying a Shilling for a Lot or Throw ; the First Lottery upon a just Computation of the Odds has 3 to 1 of the Gamester , the Second Lottery but 2 to 1 ; nevertheless the Gamester has the very same disadvantage ( and no more ) in playing at the First Lottery as the Second .
It looks very like a Contradiction , that the Disadvantage should be no greater in playing against 3 to 1 than 2 to 1 , but it may thus be resolved .
1st .
Lottery con3 Blanks 3 Prizes 16 pence Let the a piece .
sist of and of 2d .
422 shill .
In the first Lottery the Gamester hazards a Shilling to win a Groat , and the Chances being equal , it is evident there is 3 to one against him .
In the Second Lottery the Gamester ventures a Shilling against a Shilling , and the Lots being 4 to 2 , his Disadvantage is 2 to 1 .
And a Lot at either of them being truly worth just 8 Pence , ( viz. the 6th part of 3 times 16 Pence , or twice 2 Shillings ) the Disadvantage must be the very same in both Cases , that is , the Gamester pays a Shillingling for a Lot that is worth but 8 Pence .
The Method of finding this Answer being somewhat out of the common Road , I shall here add it , and thereby infinite Solutions of the same kind may be discovered .
1st Lottery .
2d Lottery .
Let a=the number of Blanks .
m=the number of Blanks b= the number of Prizes .
n =the number of Prizes r= the Value of a Prize .
s =the value of a Prize .
1= to what you pay for a Lot , viz. a Shilling .
So the Lottery has it 's Chances for 1 , and the Gamester his for r 1 .
Now the true Odds consisting of the compounded Proportion of the Chances and the Values , viz. a/ b and 1/ r-1 , the Share of the Lottery will be a , and that of the Gamester rb b. Therefore as the present case stands , the first Lottery must be a=3rb 3b , and by the like reasoning the second Lottery will be m=2s n-2 n. Now the Value of a Lot being the Sum of the Prizes divided by the number of Lots , ( which must be equal in both L'otteries ) it yields r b/ a+b =s n/ m+n .
So to proceed .
a1a=3rb 3b b2m=2sn2n r =§ 3r b/ a+b =s n/ m+n m4 ( * ) n5 ( * ) s6 ( * ) q =§ 7 Let r b/ a+b =q 7*a+b8rb=qa+qb 8~393rb=3qa+ 3qb 1+ 3b 10 3rb =a+ 3b 9 , 10 11 3qa + 3qb =a+ 3b Scope 12 If a=0 to avoid negative Numbers .
11 , 12 13 3b = 3qb 13 ~ 3b 14 q=1 12 , 14 15 q &gt; 1 makes a &lt; 0 q &lt; 1 makes a &gt; 0 Scope 16 If b =0 11 , 16 17 3qa =a 17 ~ 3a 18 q=~ 16 , 18 19 q &lt; ~ makes b &lt; 0 q &gt; ~ makes b &gt; 0 3 , 7 , 20 s n/ m+n =q 20 *m +n 21 sn = qm+qn 21 *2 22 2sn = 2qm+2qn 2+2n 23 2sn = m+2n 22 , 23 24 2q m+2 qn= m+2 n Scope 25 If m=0 24 , 25 26 2qn=2n 26 ~2n 27 q=1 25 , 27 28 q &gt; 1 makes m &lt; 0 q &lt; 1 makes m &gt; 0 Scope 29 If n=0 24 , 29 30 2qm=m 30 ~2m 31 q=~ 29 , 31 32 q &lt; ~ makes n &lt; 0 q &gt; ~ n &gt; 0 15,19,28,32 33 that abmn may be &gt; 0 , q must be &gt; ~ &lt; 1 33 , 4 ( * ) 34 Let therefore Q= 7 , 34 .
35 r b/ a+b = 2/ 3 35 * , 10 36 3rb = 2a + 26 = a+ 3b 36 37 a=b 20 , 34 .
38 s n/ m+n = 2/ 3 38 * 39 3sn = 2m+2n 39 *2 40 6sn = 4m+4n 23 *3 41 6sn = 3m+6n 40 , 41 42 4m+4n = 3m+6n 42 43 m=2n 1~ 37 44 1= 3r -3 44+3 45 3r =4 2~ n , 43 46 2= 2s -2 46 +2 47 2s =4 5 ( * ) 48 Let A=3 37 , 48 49 B=3 45 ~3 50 R= ~ , id est , 16 Pence .
6 ( * ) 51 Let M=4 43 , 51 52 N=2 47 ~2 53 S=22 Shillings .

