Fig : 3 .
E CD B F B A E C III .
Three Queries relating to Shells proposed by Mr. Samuel Dale , and answered by Dr. Martyn Lister .
R.S.S. The Queries .
THere are three things among Shells , in which I would be glad of Dr. Lister 's Assistance , which if you can procure , will be a great Favour , and desire it may be done as soon as possible .
1 .
What is the Entalia of the Shops ?
by what Authors described ?
under what Names ?
and how they differ from the Dentalia ?
2 .
Of what Shell is the Blatta Byzantina the Operculum ?
3 .
There are divers sorts of Purpurae among Authors , which is that of the Shops ~ Likewise which sort of Buccina and Umbilici Marini ought to be used in the Shops ?
The Answer to the Three Queries , by Dr. Lister .
1 .
As to the Entalia , I do not remember to have seen any thing in the Shops under that Name .
The Descriptions of the Dentalia in Scroder are very faulty , and both those and the Entalia by him should seem to be the Two Species of Dentalia , which are by me figured .
The Dentalium being that which is commonly and in Plenty found about the Island of Garnsey , and elsewhere where upon our Coast ; and is the same with that found in the Mediterranean .
It is a long , slender , round Pipe , a little bending and tapering , hollow and open at both ends , without any Crack or Flaw , naturally , white at one end , and usually a little reddish ; very smooth and polished on the out-side , and from thence and the Figure called a Dog-like Tooth .
The Entalium , or other Species of the Dentalia is very much longer and thicker than the former , much alike in other respects , save that this is streaked with high Ridges , and mostly of a greenish Colour .
This Species I guess to come from the Indies .
Note , that any thing that is wrought into , or channeled , is in the Modern Italian called an Intaglia ; whence I believe , and the nearness of the Word Dentalia , arose those distinctions of Names .
2 .
To the Second Quaere , I take the Blatta Byzantina to have succeeded the Unguis Odoratus , and to have been brought into the Shops in its place .
In Dioscorides 's time the best was brought from the Red Sea , viz. the palest and fattest ; the blacker , and less , from Babylon or the Persian Gulf ; but it seems later Times took up with those found about Constantinople ; whence the present Shop Blatta had its Name .
The Name of Blatta is given to this Operculum , from the Colour I guess ; as being of a dark Hair Colour , as the common Blatta Pistinaria , so common in London , is ; also this being a broad , thin , flat Beetle , like the Cover .
It is true , the same Dioscorides says , the Unguis was an Operculum ( ~ ~ ) like to that of the Purple Fish .
He means what was used in his Time ; in which it seems the Unguis Odoratus was lost , or was not brought to Europe .
But it will appear out of the same Dioscorides , that the Unguis was no Operculum .
It will be worth the while to make out this Mistake , and consequently the Errors the Moderns have been in to substitute ( 643 Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , doratus .
Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were alwaysOperculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Thumb Nail , and that for these Reasons .
Operculum belongs , and which therefore were alwayOperculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were alwaysOperculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , Operculum belongs , and which therefore were always , and easily to be caught .
2 .
He calls this Snail Conchylium , and by that general Name distinguishes it from all the other sorts , concerning which he treats in several Chapters ; which tho ' in general it take in both kinds , as well Turbinate as Bivalve ; yet it does more particularly denote a Concha or Bivalve .
3 .
The Onyx is expressly reckoned by Pliny amongst the Bivalves .
For ( l. 32 .
c. II .
) he makes all these Synonimous , Solen , sive Aulos , sive Donax , sive Onyx , sive Dactylus .
And again more particularly , ( lib. 9 .
c. 61 .
) he says , Concharum genere sunt Dactyli , ab Humanorum Unguium similitudine appellati .
So that in all probability the Onyx Odoratus brought more anciently out of the fresh-water Lakes about Ganges in India , was not unlike the common Onyx of the Mediterranean , which was of the Solen kind .
Whatever the Blatta Byzantina of our Shops is , which has certainly nothing of the Characters of the ancient Aromatic Unguis ; and which in all probability was lost upon the account of the difficult Passage from Ganges into Europe .
I lament its Loss , which I have reason to believe was a good Medicine , from its strong Aromatic Smell ; which is much wanting in our Testaceous Powders , of which this was one of the number , so much used , and that not without good reason now-a-days , which are all very flat and insipid .
To the Third , The Purpura of the Ancients is well made out , and figured by Fabius Columna : And it is one of the most common Murices of the Mediterranean Sea .
In this he could not be much mistaken , because , as I remember , he somewhere mentions heaps of those Shells where the Officinae Purpurae anciently were ; and also from the Purple Sanies the Fish yields of it self .
He mentions one or two more Species of Turbinate Snails , to be found in the Mediterranean , which yield a Purple Juice .
Upon the whole matter it is indifferent , what sort of Shell we use in the Shops , if it be to be calcined , provided it be a Sea-shell .
Nor do I find either Dioscorides or AEtius to have distinguished betwixt the Ostrea Purpura or Buccinum calcined ; but gives them all the same Caustic Virtue ; possibly some one Species may have it in a higher degree , as we see the various sorts of Lime-stone , if calcined , differ in strength .
One thing I shall not omit before I end this Paper , because it is now in my mind , that tho ' the Species of Shell or Purpura be scarce known to our Shops at this day , yet the use of the Purple Juice has been by Tradition at least transmitted down to our Times , and kept as a Secret even in these Islands , till Mr. Cole got hold of it , and published it .
Sir Robert Southwell the now President of the R. S. told me many years ago , that his own Mother in Ireland was famous for marking Handkerchiefs with the Juice of Fish ; which Mark would never wash out .
And the very Learned Mr. John Beaumont informs me of a passage in our Beda 's Ecclesiastical History relating to the Purple , as a known thing in his time .
The Passage is as follows : Bedae , Historia Ecclesiastica Gentis Angl. 1 .
I. C. I. Variis Conchyliorum generibus exceptis : in quibus sunt &amp; Musculae , quibus inclusam saepe Margaritam omnis quidem coloris optimam inveniunt , id est , &amp; rubicundi &amp; purpurei , &amp; hyacinthi &amp; Prasici sed maxim candidi .
Sunt &amp; Cochleae satis superque abundantes , quibus Tinctura coccinei coloris conficitur .
Cujus rubor pulcherrimus nullo unquam solis ardore , nulla valet pluviarum injuria pallescere ; sed quo vetustior , eo solet esse venustior .
You see from this Passage the Purple Trade of Dying was used in England , and very much valued .
Of Mr. Cole 's you have a Cut in the Philosophical Transactions , No. 178 .
Fig. 5 .
Represents the true Purpura of the Ancients by the Italians called Gerusolo .

