A Discourse concerning the Modern Theory of Generation ; by Dr. George Garden of Aberdeen , being part of a Letter to Dr. William Musgrave , LL. D. Reg. Soc. S. and by him communicated to the Royal Society .
THE Subject I pitch upon , is that of the formation of Animals .
You know how wide and unsatisfying Mens Conjectures were upon this Head until this Age , in which first the deservedly Famous Dr. Harvey discovered the proper place of the formation of the Chick in the Cicatricula of the Egg , and the formation of the Parts so far as was discernable by the naked Eye ; and after him Malpighius by the help of exact Glasses , observed the first Rudiments of it there , both before and after Incubation : And R. de Graef and others , having upon many Observations concluded that the Testes Faeminei were the Ovaries of Females , and consequently that all Animals were ex ovo ; they began from hence to infer , that the Rudiments of each Animal were originally in the respective Females , and that the Male contributed only to give a new Ferment to the Mass of the Blood and Spirits , by which means a spirituous Liquor ( which the Blood in its.ordinary Ferment could not produce ) did insinuate its self into the same Ducts and Pores of the Rudiments of those Animals which were in greatest forwardness in the Ovary , and so extend , and enlarge all their Parts , and at last bring them to perfection , as Mr. Perrault does ingeniously discourse in the third Part of his Essais de Physique ; till now at last Leewenhoeck has discovered an infinite number of Animalcula in semine marium of all Kinds , which has made him condemn the former Opinions about the propagation of all Animals ex Ovo .
Now upon comparing the Observations and Discoveries which have been made with one another ; these three things seem to me very probable .
1 .
That Animals are ex Animalculo .
2 .
That these Animalcles are originally in semine Marium &amp; non in Faeminis .
3 .
That they can never come forward , nor be formed into Animals of the respective kind , without the Ova in faeminis .
The first of these seems probable from these three Observations .
1 .
That some such Thing has been so often observed by Malpighius in the Cicatricula of an Egg before Incubation , as the Rudiments of an Animal in the shape of a Tadpole , as may be seen in his first , and in his repeated Observations de formatione Pulli in Ovo .
2 .
The sudden appearance and displaying of all the Parts after Incubation makes it probable , that they are not then actually formed out of a Fluid , but that the Stamina of them have been formerly there existent , and are now expanded .
The first part of the Chick which is discovered with the naked Eye is , you know , the Punctum saliens , and that not till three days and nights of Incubation be past , and then on the fifth day the Rudiments of the Head and Body do appear .
This made Dr. Harvey conclude that the Blood had a being before any other part of the Body , and that from it all the Organs of the Faetus were both formed , and nourished ; but by Malpighius 's Observations we find that the Parts are then only so far extended as to be made visible to the naked Eye , and that they were actually existent before , and discernable by Glasses .
After an Incubation of thirty hours are to be seen the Head , the Eyes , and the Carina , with the Vertebrae , distinct , and the Heart .
After forty hours its Pulse is visible , and all the other Parts more distinct , which cannot be discerned by the naked Eye before the beginning of the fifth day ; from whence it seems very probable , that even the so early discovery of those Parts of the Faetus by the Microscope , is not the discerning of Parts newly formed , but only more dilated and extended by receiving of Nutriment meant from the Colloquamentum ; so that they seem all to have been actually existent before the Incubation of the Hen .
And what Swammerdam has discovered in the transformation of Insects , gives no small light to this , whilst he makes appear in the Explanation of the 13th Table of the General History of Insects , that in those large Eruca 's which feed upon Cabbage , if they be taken about the time they retire to be transformed into Aurelia 's , and plunged often in warm Water to make a Rupture of the outer Skin , you will discern through the Transparency of their second Membrane , all the Parts of the Butterfly , the Trunk , Wings , Feelers , &amp;c. folded up .
But that after the Eruca is changed into an Aurelia , none of these Parts can be discerned , they are so drenched with moisture , though they be there actually formed .
Another Consideration is from the Analogy , which we may suppose between Plants and Animals .
All Vegetables we see do proceed ex Plantula , the Seeds of Vegetables being nothing else but little Plants of the same kind folded up in Coats and Membranes : and from hence we may probably conjecture that so curiously an organized Creature as an Animal , is not the sudden product of a Fluid or Colliquamentum , but does much rather proceed from an Animalcle of the same kind , and has all its little Members folded up according to their several Joints and Plicatures , which are afterwards enlarged and distended , as we see in Plants .
Now though this Consideration alone may seem not to bear much weight , yet being joined to the two former they do mutually strengthen each other .
And indeed all the Laws of Motion which are as yet discovered , can give but a very lame account of the forming of a Plant or Animal .
We see how wretchedly Des Cartes came off when he began to apply them to this Subject ; they are formed by Laws yet unknown to Mankind , and it seems most probable that the Stamina of all the Plants and Animals that have been , or ever shall be in the World , have been formed ab Origin Mundi by the Almighty Creator within the first of each respective kind .
And he who considers the nature of Vision , that it does not give us the true magnitude , but the proportion of Things , and that what seems to our naked Eye but a Point , may truly be made up of as many Parts as seem to us to be in the whole visible World will not think this an absurd or impossible thing .
But the second thing which later discoveries have made probable is , that these Animalcles are originally in Semine Marium &amp; non in faeminis .
And this I Collect from these Considerations .
1 .
That there are innumerable Animalcula discovered in Semine Masculo omnium Animalium .
Mr. Leewenhoeck has made this so evident by so many Observations , that I do not in the least .
question the truth of the thing .
The reason of their multitude , and some of the difficulties which arise thereupon , he has cleared to very good purpose , so that I shall not repeat them .
2 .
The observing the Rudiments of the Faetus in Eggs , which have been secundated by the Male , and the seeing no such thing in those which are not secundated , as appears from Malpighius his Observations , make it very probable that these Rudiments proceed originally from the Male , and not from the Female .
3 .
The resemblance between the Rudiments of the faetus in Ovo , both before and after Incubation , and the Animalcule , makes it very probable that they are one and the same .
The same shape and figure which Mr. Leewenhoeck gives us of the Animalcule , Malpighius likewise gives of the Rudiments of the Faetus , both before and after Incubation , yea , and even the Faetus 's of Animals do appear so at first to the naked Eye , so that Dr. Harvey does acknowledge that all Animals , even the most perfect are begotten of a Worm , De Gen. Anim .
Ex. 18 .
4 .
This gives a rational account of many Faetus 's at one Birth .
especially that of the Countess of Holland , and how at least a whole Cluster of Eggs in a Hen are fecundated by one Coition of the Male .
5 .
This gives a new light as it were to the first Prophecy concerning the Messiah , that the Seed of the Woman shall bruise the Head of the Serpent , all the rest of Mankind being thus most properly and truly the Seed of the Man .
6 .
The Analogy I have already mentioned , which we may rationally suppose between the manner of the propagation of Plants and Animals , does likewise make this probable .
Every Herb and Tree bears its Seed after its kind , which Seed is nothing else but a little Plant of the same kind , which being thrown into the Earth , as into its Uterus , spreads forth its Roots and receives its nourishment , but has its form within its self , and we may rationally conjecture some such Analogy in the Propagation of Animals .
The third Particular which later Discoveries make probable , is that Animals cannot be formed of these Animalcula without the Ova in faeminis , which are necessary for supplying of them with proper Nutriment : And this these Considerations seem to evince .
1 .
It is probable that an Animalcle cannot come forward if it do not fall into a proper Nidus .
This we see is the Cicatricula in Eggs , and tho ' a Million of them should fall into an Egg , none of them would come forward , but what were in the Center of the Cicatricula , and perhaps the Nidus necessary for their formation is so proportioned to their bulk , that it can hardly contain more than one Animalcle ; and this may be the reason why there are so few Monsters .
This we see is absolutely necessary in Oviparis , and the only difference which seems to be between them and the Vivipara in this matter is in this , that in the latter the Ova are properly nothing more but the Cicatricula with its Colliquamentum , so that the Faetus must spread forth its roots into the Uterus to receive its nourishment ; but the Eggs in Oviparis may be properly termed an Uterus in relation to the Faetus ; for they contain not only the Cicatricula with its Amnion and the Colliquamentum , which is the immediate nourishment of the Faetus ; but also the materials which are to be converted into that Colliquamentum , so that the Faetus spreads forth its roots no farther than into the white and yolk of the Egg , from whence it derives all its nourishment .
Now that an Animalcle cannot come forward without some such proper Nidus , Mr. Leewenhoeck will not readily deny ; for if there were nothing needful but their being thrown into the Uterus , I do not see why many hundreds of them should not come forward at once ; for as to what Mr. Leewenhoeck says , that one of them would bedwarf and choke the rest ; this might fall out in process of time : but at first I do not see why many of them should not grow together , whilst scattered in so large a Field : ( and yet no such thing is observed ) if there were not an absolute necessity of a Cicatricula for their growth and thriving .
Now , 2 .
That this Cicatricula is not originally in Utero , seems evident from the frequent Conceptions which have been found extra Uterum : Such as the Child which continued twenty six Years in the Woman of Thoulouse 's Belly , mentioned Numb. 139 .
of the Phil. Trans. And the little Faetus found in the Abdomen de St. Mere , together with the Testicle torn and full of clotted Blood recorded Numb. 150 .
both taken out of the Journals des Scavans : Such also seem to be the Faetus in the Abdomen of the Woman of Copenhagen , mentioned in the Nouvelles des Lettres , for Sept. 85 .
page .
996 .
all the Members of which were easily to be felt through the Skin of the Belly , and which she had carried in her Belly for four Years ; And the seven Years Gravidation related by Dr. Cole , Numb. 172 .
of the Transact. That these two were undoubtedly extra Uterum is uncertain , because the last was not opened after her death , and the former may be yet still alive .
Now grantD ing ing once the necessity of a proper Nidus for the formation of an Animalcle into the Animal of its respective kind ; these Observations make it probable that the Testes are the Ovaria appropriated for this use ; for though the Animalcles coming thither in such Cases may seem to be extraordinary , and that usually the Impregnation is in Utero ; yet it may be collected from hence , that the Cicatriculae or Ova to be impregnated are in Testibus faemineis ; for if it were not so , the accidental coming of Animalcles thither could not make them come forward more than in any other part of the Body , since they cannot be formed and nourished without a proper Nidus .
But , 3 .
It is acknowledged by all , that the Faetus in Utero for some considerable time after Conception has no Connexion with the Womb , that it sits wholly loose to it , and is perfectly a little round Egg with the Faetus in the midst , which sends forth its U mbilical Vessels by degrees , and at last lays hold on the Uterus .
Now from hence it seems evident , that the Cicatricula , which is the Fountain of the Animalcles nourishment , does not sprout from the Uterus , but has its Origin elsewhere , and falls in thither as into a fit Soil from whence it may draw Nutriment for the growth of the Faetus : else it cannot be easily imagined how it should not have an immediate Connexion with the Uterus from the time of Conception .
If you join all these three Considerations together , viz. that an Animalcle cannot come forward without a proper Nidus or Cicatricula ; that there have been frequent Faetus 's extra Uterum ; and that they have no Adhaesion to the Uterus for a considerable time after Conception , they seem to make it evident that Animals cannot be formed ex Animalculis without the Ova in faeminis .
To all these I shall subjoyn the proposal of an Experimentum Crucis , which may seem to determine whether the Testes Faemineae be truly the Ovaria , viz. Open the Ab domen of the Females of some kinds , and cut out these Testicles , and this will determine whether they be absolutely necessary for the formation of Animals .
There are some difficulties proposed against this Conjecture , which I think may be easily resolved .
Some object the distance between the Tubae or Cornua Uteri and the Testicles ; but to this is opposed by Swammerdam and others , the like distance between the Infundibulum , in Hens and Frogs , and the Ovary , and yet it cannot be denied that the Eggs are transmitted through this into the Uterus : and besides R. de Graef , and others , have by repeated Observations found that the Cornua Uteri do at certain times after Conception , embrace the Testes on both sides the Uterus .
They object in the second place the great disproportion between the pretended Eggs in the Ovary , and the Aperture of the Tubae or Cornua Uteri , the former being a great deal bigger than the latter : but both R. de Graef and Malpighius have cleared that matter by making appear , that these Bladders in the Ovary are not the Ova , but serve to form the Glandules within which the Ova are formed , which break through a small Papilla opening in the Glandule , which bears a proportion to the Aperture of the Tube .
They object , 3 .
The difficulty to conceive how these Eggs should be impregnated per semen Maris , both because there is no Connexion between the Tubae and the Ovary for its transmission , and for that Dr. Harvey could never discover any thing of it in Utero .
As to the last , Mr. Leewenhoeck has cleared that difficulty by the discovery of innumerable Animalcule Seminis Maris in Cornubus Uteri , and those living a considerable time after Coition .
Numb. 174 .
of the Transact. And as to the former we may either suppose that there is such an Inflation of the Tubae or Cornua uteri tempore Coitionis , as makes them embrace the Ovaria , and such an approach of the Uterus and its Cornua , as that it may easily transmit the Seed into the Ovary ; or else that the Ova are impregnated by the Animalcles after they descend into the Uterus , and not in the Ovary ; the former seems probable for this reason , that at least a whole Cluster of Eggs in a Hen will be fecundated by one tread of the Cock ; now this Fecundation seems to be in the Vitellary , and not in the Uterus , as the Eggs pass along from day to day , for it can hardly be supposed that the Animalcles should subsist so long , being scattered loosely in the Uterus , as to wait there for many days for the fecundation of the Eggs as they pass along .
The latter conjecture has this to strengthen it , that the Animalcles are found to live a considerable time in the Uterus , and that if they should impregnate the Ova in the Ovary it self , the Faetus would increase so fast , that the Ova could not pass through the Tubae Uteri , but would either burst the Ovary , or fall down into the Abdomen from the Orifices of the Tubae ; and that from hence proceed those extraordinary Conceptions in Abdomine extra Uterum .
But , 4 .
Mr. Leewenhoeck , Numb. 147 .
of the Transact. to weaken the third Consideration about the Conceptions being like unto an Ovum in the Womb , proposes a Parallel between these Animalcles and Insects , and insinuates that as the latter cast their Skins and appear of another shape , so the other which at first seem like Tadpoles , may cast their outer Skin and then be round , and that this may be the occasion of the round Figure of the Conception in the Womb .
To this it may be replied , that according to Mr. Leewenhoeck 's own sentiment , the Animalcles cannot come forward if they do not find the Punctum or proper place for their nourishment , to which it seems they must have some Adhaesion .
Now the Conception in Viviparis is not fastned unto the Womb for many days , nor does adhere to any point of it , so that it seems this roundish Body is not the Animalcle thus changed after having cast an outer Skin , but is rather the Cicatricula or little Egg , into which the Animalcle has entered as its Punctum or place of nourishment : Else I do not see why they should not be adhering to the Womb from the first Conception , or why ( as I have said ) many hundreds of them are not conceived and formed together , &amp;c.

