The Sentiments of the Reverend and Learned Dr. John Wallis , R. S. Soc. upon the aforesaid Appearance , communicated in a Letter to the Publisher .
AS to the last Inquiry ( concerning which , you say , the Royal Society would be glad to know my Opinion ; ) about the apparent Magnitude of the Sun near the Horizon , greater than when considerably high : The Inquiry is ancient : And I remember , I discoursed it near forty Years ago with Mr. Foster , then Professor of Astronomy in Gresham College : Who did then assure me ( from his own Observation , I suppose ; for I have never examined it myself , ) that the apparent Magnitude taken by Instrument ( however the Fancy may apprehend it ) is not greater at the Horizon , than when higher .
And Mr. Caswell ( when your Letter was communicated to our Company here ) affirmed the same .
And ( though I have not myself made the Observation ) I do not doubt but the Thing is so .
For it is agreed ; That Refraction near the Horizon , though ( as to appearance ) it alters the Al itude of the Thing seen ; yet it alters not the Azimuth at all .
And it must needs be so .
For , since this equally respects all Points of the Horizon ; let the Refraction be what it will , the whole Horizon can be but a Circle : So that there is no Room for the Breadth of a Thing ( as to the Angle at the Eye ) to be made greater , whatever its Tallness may , ( the Refraction not equally affecting all Parts in the Circles of Altitude .
) Nor is there any Reason why this should rather thrust the other , than that the other thrust this , out of place .
Whereas , in the Altitude , it is otherwise : For while what is near the Horizon is enlarged , that which is further off is thereby contracted : Which as to the Azimuth or Horizontal Position cannot be .
In Spectacles indeed it is otherwise ; for they represent the Object every way enlarged ; and do thereby hide the adjacent Parts .
But in Refraction by Vapours , supposing all parts of the Horizon equally affected by them , one part cannot be expanded in breadth ( whatever it may be as to the heighth ) without thrusting out another , ( for the whole Horizon can be but a Circle ) and why one part rather than another ?
Unless we would say , ( as perhaps we may , if there shall appear a Necessity for it ) That the Rays of a lucid Body do expand themselves every way to the Prejudice of the parts adjacent , by covering them .
But supposing ( which I am apt to believe , till the contrary shall be evinced by Experiment ) that the Sun or Moon 's apparent Diameter taken by Instrument near the Horizon , is the same as taken in a higher Position , ( I mean , its Horizontal Diameter , or that parallel to the Horizon ; for the erect Diameter , in a Circle Perpendicular to the Horizon , may by the Refraction be varied , and thereby made , not greater , but less than when higher ; as hath been noted in the Name of Sol Ellipticus at the Horizon .
) supposing , I say , that the Sun 's apparent Diameter Horizontal , taken by Instrument , is the same near the Horizon , as in a higher Position , I take its imaginary Greatness which is fancied near the Horizon , to be only a Deception tion of the Eye ; or rather the Imagination from the Eye .
For sure it is , that the Imagination doth not estimate the Greatness of the Object seen , only by the Angle which it makes at the Eye ; but , by this compared with the supposed Distance .
True it is that , Caeteris paribus , we judge that to be the greater Object , which makes at the Eye the greater Angle : But not so if apprehended at different Distances .
For if through a Casement ( or lesser Aperture ) we see a House at 100 Yards distance ; this House ( though seen under a less Angle ) doth not to us seem less than the Casement through which we see it , or this greater than that , because it makes at the Eye the greater Angle : ) But the Imagination makes a comparative Estimate from the Angle and Distance jointly considered .
So that , of two things seen under the same or equal Angles , if to one of them there be ought which gives the Apprehension of a greater Distance , that to the Imagination will appear greater .
Now sure it is , that one great Advantage for Estimating of a Thing seen is , from the Variety of intermediate Objects between the Eye and the Thing seen .
For then the Imagination must allow room for all these Things .
Hence it is that if we see a thing over two Hills , between which there lies a great Valley unseen , it will appear much nearer than if we see the Valley also : And it will appear as just beyond the first Hill .
And if we move forward to the Top of the nearest Hill , ( that of the Valley may be seen ) it will then appear much further than before it did .
And on this Account it is , that the Sun setting , appears to us as if it were but just beyond the utmost of our visible Horizon ; because all between that and the Sun is not seen .
And , upon the same Account , the Heaven itself seems contiguous to the visible Horizon .
Now when the Sun or Moon is near the Horizon , there is a Prospect of Hills , and Vallies , and Plains , and Woods , and Rivers , and Variety of Fields , and Enclosures , between it and us : Which present to our Imagination a great Distance capable of receiving all these .
Or , if it so chance that ( in some Position ) these Intermediates are not actually seen : Yet having been accustomed to see them , the Memory suggests to us a View as large as is the visible Horizon .
But when the Sun or Moon is in a higher Position ; we see nothing between us and them ( unless perhaps some Clouds ) and therefore nothing to present to our Imagination so grear a Distance as the other is .
And therefore , though both be seen under the same Angle , they do not appear ( to the Imagination ) of the same bigness , because not both fancied at the same Distances : But that near the Horizon is judged bigger ( because supposed farther off ) than the same when at a greater Altitude .
It is true , that as to small and middling Distances ( beside this Estimate from Intermediates ) the Eye hath a means within itself to make some Estimate of the Distance .
As , when we already know the bigness of a Thing seen , to which we have been accustomed ; as a Man , a Tree , a House , or the like : If such Thing appear to us under a small Angle , and indistinct , and faintly coloured ; the Imagination doth allow such Distance , as to make such a Thing so to appear .
And , if this , thro ' a Prospective Glass , be represented to us under a bigger Angle , and more distinct : It is accordingly apprehended as so much nearer .
But the Case is otherwise , when we do not , by the known bigness , judge the Distance ; but , by the supposed Distance , judge of the bigness ; as in the Case before us .
And accordingly , different Persons , according to different fancied Distances , judge very differently .
As , if two Stars be showed to ignorant Persons , and you ask how far they seem to be asunder : One perhaps will say , a Foot ; another , a Yard , or more : And one shall say , The Sun appears to him as big as a Bushel ; another , as big as a Holland Cheese : Each estimating according to the fancied Distance .
Again ; in our two Eyes ( when the Object is seen by both ) there is yet another means of estimating how far off it is .
( And it is this by which we judge of Distances .
) Namely , there are , from the same Object , two different visual Cones , terminated at the two Eyes : Whose two Axes contain , at the Object , different Angles , according to different Distances : An acuter Angle at a great Distance , and more obtuse when nearer .
Now , that such Object may be seen by both Eyes , clearly ; it is requisite that the Eyes be put into such a Position , as that the Sight of each Eye receive the respective Axe at right Angles .
Which requires a different Position of the two Eyes , according to the different Distance of the Object .
As will manifestly appear ; if we look , with Attention , on a Finger ( or other small Object ) at two or three Inches distance from the Eye ; and then upon another like Object at three or four Yards beyond it : ( and this alternately several Times .
) For 'twill be manifest , that while we look intently on the one , we do not see the other ( or but confusedly ) though both be just before us .
And , as we change our View , from the one to the other , we manifestly feel a Motion of the Eyes ( by their Muscles ) from one Posture to another .
And according to the different Posture in the Eyes , requisite to a clear Vision by both , we estimate the Distance of the Object from us .
And hence it is , that they who have lost the Sight of one Eye , are at a great Disadvantage , as to estimating Distances , from what they could do while they had the Use of both .
But now when the Distance grows so great , as that the Position of these visual Axes become Parallel , or so near to Parallel , as not to be distinguishable from it : This Advantage is lost , and we can thenceforth only conclude , that it is far off ; but not how far .
Hence it is , that our View can make no Distinction of the Moon 's Distance , from that of the other Planets , or even of the fixed Stars : But they seem to us as equally remote from us ; though we otherwise know their distances from us to be vastly different .
Because the Parallax , ( as I may so call it ) from the different Position of the two Eyes , is quite lost , and undiscernable , in Distances much less than the least of these .
And so , of the fixed Stars amongst themselves : Which , though they seem equally remote from us ; many ( for ought we know ) be at Distances vastly different .
Nor can we tell , which of them is nearest : ( unless perhaps we may reasonably guess , those to be nearest , which seem biggest .
) Because , here not only the Parallax from the Distance of the two Eyes ; and that from the Earth 's Semidiameter ; but even that from the Semidiameter of the Earth 's great Orb , is quite lost ; and none remaining , whereby to estimate their Distance from us .
But ( to return to our Case in Hand ; ) though as to small Distances , we may make some Estimate from the known Magnitude of the Object : And , as to middling Distances , from the Parallax ( as I may call it ) arising from the Interval of the two Eyes : Yet even this latter will hardly reach beyond , if so far as the visible Horizon : And all beyond it , is lost .
So that , there being nothing lest to assist the Fancy in estimating so great a Distance , but only the intermediate Objects : Where these Intermediates appear to the Eye , ( as , when the Sun or Moon are near the Horizon ) the Distance is fancied greater , than where they appear not , ( as when farther from it : ) And consequently ( though both under the same or equal Angles ) that near the Horizon is fancied the greater .
And this I judge to be the true Reason of that Appearance .
You will excuse ( I hope ) what Excursion I have made ; because though some of them might have been spared , as to the present Case ; yet they are not impertinent to the Business of Vision ; and the Estimate to be thence made , of Magnitudes and Distances , by the Imagination .
The Sun 's Eclipse May 1st , was here observed about 1/ 2 a Digit ; between one and two a Clock after Noon .

