187 c a ah ff b gg bi cc kc lab a c Concerning the Apparent Magnitude of the Sun and Moon , or the Apparent Distance of two Stars , when nigh the Horizon , and when Higher elevated .
IDO not design so much to establish any thing of my own that may be satisfactory in solving this admirable Appearance , as to detect the Errors of those that have offered at a Solution thereof , and have come short ( as I conceive ) of being satisfactory ; that thereby I may again set the Minds of Philosophers on Work , and rouse them up to enquire a new after this surprising Phenomenon .
That I may do this the more effectually , I shall briefly declare the Matter of Fact , and then proceed to the Reason thereof , given by several , and to their Confutations .
First therefore it is well known that the mean apparent Magnitude of the Moon is 30 m. 30 s. we will take it Numero Rotundo to be 30 , that is , an Arch of a great Circle in the Heavens of 30 Minutes is covered by her Diameter , and this we 'll suppose to be her apparent Diameter , at a full Moon in the midst of Winter , and when she 's in the Meridian , and at her greatest Northern Latitude , and consequently the utmost that she can be elevated in our Horizon ; it is as well known also , that when she is in this Posture , being looked upon by the naked Eye , she appears ( that we may accomodate all to sensible Measures ) to be Magnitudinis Pedalis , about a Foot broad .
But the same Moon being looked upon just as she rises , she appears to be three or four Foot broad , and yet if with an Instrument we take her Diameter , both in one Posture and t'other , we shall find that still she shall be but 30 Minutes ; the several ways of trying this I will not mention , they being as various as are the Methods of taking the Moon 's apparent Diameter , common enough amongst the Astronomers ; neither will I insist upon the Truth of the Matter of Fact , for that I think cannot reasonably be questioned , after so many Trials and so many Experiments thereof , faithfully recorded by undoubted Witnesses ; and it would be very unreasonable to imagine that so many Authors should rack their Brains for solving an Appearance , wherein they were not certain of the Matter of Fact .
But because of Nullius in Verba , I can assert that I have accurately tried it myself , and I have so found it : One of the Ways I proceeded was thus , I took a very good Tellescope of about 6 Foot long , in the inward Focus of whose Eye-Glass I applied a very fine Lattice made of the single Hairs of a Man 's Head ; then looking with this at the Moon when she was just risen and looked extraordinarily big , I observed what Number of the Squares of the Lattice were occupied by her Body ; then observing her again , when more elevated and free from all extravagant Greatness , I still found the same Squares of the Lattice possessed by her .
This way is equivalent to that now more used , of taking her Diameter by Mr. Townly 's Micrometers : But I have also tried and found the same thing by an accurate Sextant , taking the Distance of the Moon 's opposite Limbs .
Now this Phenomenon affords two Things to be considered , first why the Moon ( I still name the Moon as being an Object more adapted for our Sight , for the same thing holds in the Sun ) should seem bigger about the Horizon , than when more elevated ; and secondly , she appearing bigger , how it comes to pass , that her Diameter being taken , it is no greater than when she appears less .
But the Disquisition concerning this latter being likely to Comprehend the former , I shall not divide my Discourse into two Branches , but proceed in the Method proposed .
Only I desire it may be noted , that I suppose the Horizontal and Meridional Moon to be found both of the same Angle , whereas in Truth the Meridional Moon ( tho ' appearing less ) shall be found of the greater Angle : Which increases the Wonder .
But this proceeding from the different distances that one and t'other is looked at , ( the Meridional Moon being nigher us by almost a Semidiameter of the Earth ) and consequently easily solved that way ; I have therefore chosen to put between them a plain equality , for avoiding Confusion and Intricacy in Discourse .
Wherefore let us hear what the Ingenious of these latter Days can say to this Appearance .
And first we find the celebrated Des-Cartes attributing this Appearance rather to a deceived Judgment , than to any natural Affection of the Organ or Medium of Sense ; for the Moon ( says he ) being nigh the Horizon , we have a better Opportunity and Advantage of making an Estimate of her , by comparing her with the various Objects that incur the Sight , in its way towards her ; so that tho ' we imagine she looks bigger , yet it is a mere Deceit : For we only think so , because she seems nigher the Tops of Trees , or Chimneys , or Houses , or a space of Ground , to which we can compare her , and Estimate her thereby ; but when we bring her to the Test of an Instrument that cannot be deluded or imposed upon by these Appearances , then we find our Estimate wrong , and our Senses deceived .
These Thoughts , my-thinks , are much below the accustomed Accuracy of the Noble DesCartes ; for certainly if it be so , I may at any time increase the apparent bigness of the Moon , tho ' in the Meridian ; for it would be only by getting behind a Cluster of Chimnies , a ridge of a Hill , or the top of Houses , and comparing her to them in that posture , as well as in the Horizon : besides if the Moon be looked at just as she is rising from an Horizon determined by a smooth Sea , and which has no more Variety of Objects to compare her to , than the pure Air ; yet she will seem big , as if looked at over the rugged Top of an uneven Town , or rocky Country .
Moreover , all Variety of adjoining Objects may be taken off , by looking through an empty Tube , and yet the deluded Imagination is not at all helped thereby .
I come next to the Solution hereof given by the Famous Thomas Hobbs : And for this we shall stand in need of the first Fig. wherein says he , let the Point G be the Center of the Earth , and F the Eye on the Surface of the Earth ; on the same Center G , let there be struck the two Arches , EH determining the Atmosphere , and AD to represent that blue Surface in which we imagine the fixed Stars ; and let FD be the Horizon .
Divide the Arch AD into three equal Parts by the Lines B F , C F ; it is manifest that the Angle AFB is greater than the Angle BF C , and this again greater than the Angle CF D. Wherefore , says he , to make the Angle CFD equal to the Angle CF B , the Arch CD must be greater than the Arch C B ; and consequently , that the Moon may in the Horizon appear under the same Angle as when Elevated , she must cover a greater Arch , and therefore seem greater ; that is , the Moon in the Meridian appearing under the Angle BF C , that she may appear under an equal Angle in the Horizon , as suppose CF D , it is necessary that Arch CD should be greater than C B ; and consequently tho ' she appear to subtend a greater Arch when in the Horizon than when Elevated , yet she appears under the same Angle .
And all this without Refraction .
The Geometry of this Figure is most certainly true and Demonstrable .
At this I quarrel not ; but it makes no more in our present Difficulty than if nothing had been said : For the Philosopher has here made a Figure of his own , and from thence he argues as confidently , as if Nature would accommodate herself to his Scheme , and he not obliged to accommodate his Scheme to Nature ; for here he has made the Circle GF representing the Earth very large in Proportion to the Circle A D ; and then indeed taking the Point F in the Earth 's Surface , and by Lines from thence dividing the Angle AFD into whatever equal Parts , the intercepted Arches A B , B C , C D , shall be unequal .
But if he had considered , that the Earth is as it were a Point in respect of the Sphere of the fixed Stars , nay the very Annual Orbit of the Earth is almost , if not altogether imperceptible ( saving the Truth of Mr. Hook 's Attempt ) he would have found that the Lines F B , F C , F D , must be all conceived as drawn from the point G , and then equal Angles will intercept equal Arches , and equal Arches equal Angles : And so it happens ( at least beyond the Possibility of Discovery of Sense ) to the Eye on the Surface of the Earth .
And besides he should have considered , that all Observations Astronomical are performed as from the Center of the Earth , and therefore it is that they keep such a stir about Parallax ; so that his drawing his Lines so far from G as F is , and to another concentrick Circle so nigh as A D , deceived him in this Point .
The Famous Gassendus has written 4 large Epistles on this Subject , the Substance of all which is , that the Moon being nigh the Horizon and looked at thro ' a more foggy Air , casts a weaker Light , and consequently forces not the Eye so much as when brighter ; and therefore the Pupil does more enlarge itself , thereby transmitting a larger Projection on the Retina .
In this Opinion I do find he is not alone , for in the Journals des Scavans , this Disquisition being again revived by a French Abbe , He therein follows this Sentiment of Gassendus ; it was first published in the 3d Conference presented to the Dauphin in August 1672 , but by Reason of an Objection moved by Father Pardye , it was fain to be republished with some Additions and Amendments in Octob. 1672 .
The Addition was , that this Contracting and enlarging of the Pupil causes a different Shape in the Eye ; an open Pupil making the Crystalline flatter and the Eye longer , and the narrower Pupil shortning ning the Eye , and making the Crystalline more convex , the first attends our looking at Objects which are remote , or which we think so ; the latter accompanies the viewing Objects nigh at Hand .
Likewise an open Pupil and flat Crystalline attends Objects of a more sedate Light , whilst Objects of more forcible Rays require a greater Convexity , and narrow Pupil .
From these Positions the Abbe endeavoured to give an Account of our Phenomenon , as follows .
When the Moon is nigh the Horizon , by Comparison with interposed Objects , we are apt to imagine her much farther from us than when more elevated , and therefore ( says he ) we order our Eyes as for viewing an Object farther from us , that is , we something enlarge the Pupil , and thereby make the Crystalline more flat : Moreover the Duskishness of the Moon in that Posture does not so much strain the Sight ; and consequently the Pupil will be more large , and the Crystalline more flat : Hence a larger Image shall be projected on the Fund of the Eye , and therefore the Moon shall appear larger .
And this Disposition of the Eye that magnifies her , magnifies also the Divisions of our forementioned Lattice , and consequently she by her Body shall possess no more of the Divisions , than when she seems less .
These two forementioned Accidents , viz. the Moon 's imaginary Distance and Duskishness , gradually vanishing as she rises , a different Species is hereby introduced in the Eye , and consequently she seems gradually less and less , till again she approaches nigh the Horizon .
These two Opinions of Gassendus and the Abbe being so nigh a Kin , I shall consider them both together , and first I assert that a wider or narrower Aperture increases not , neither diminishes the Projection on the Retina .
I know Honoratus Faber in his Synopsis Optica endeavours to prove the clear contrary to this my Assertion , and that after this Manner .
Fig II .
AB is an Object , OF the greater Aperture of the Pupil , admitting the Projection KI on the Retina , whereas the lesser Aperture CD admits only the Projection G H ; but GH is less than K I , wherefore a lesser Aperture diminishes the Projection .
I admire that any Man that undertook ( as Honoratus Faber ) to write of Opticks more accurately than all that went before him , should be guilty of so very gross an Error ; and I do more admire that the celebrated Gassendus , and with him the Noble Hevelius , should be of the same Opinion : For tho ' the foresaid Figure and Demonstration hold most certainly true in direct Projections , as in a dark Room with a plain Hole ; yet it will not hold in Projections made by Refraction , as it is in those on the Retina in the Eye , by means of the Crystalline and other Coats and Humours of the Eye .
For a Destmonstration of this observe the third Fig. wherein let AB be a Remote Object , and OF the Crystalline at its large Aperture , projecting the Image IM on the Retina .
Let then CD be the lesser Aperture of the Pupil before the Crystalline : I say the Image IM shall be projected as large as before , for the Cone of Rays EAF consists partly of the Cone of Rays CA D , therefore where the former EAF is projected , the latter CA D , as being a part of the former , shall be projected also .
So that no more is effected by this narrow Aperture , but that the Sides of the Radiating Cones are intercepted , and consequently the Point I shall be affected with less Light , but it shall still be in the same place : What is said of that Cone and that Point , may be said of all other Cones and other Points of the Object .
From hence appears first , the Invalidity of the Account given of the Moon 's Appearance by Gassendus from this Reason ; 2ly , The Reason appears why a Tellescope 's greater or lesser Aperture , makes no difference in the Angle it receives : For imagine OF to be an Object-Glass of a Tellescope , and it is plain .
3ly , It is evident why a greater or less Aperture on a Tellescope should make the Objects appear lighter or darker , for thereby more or less Rays are admitted to determine on the Projection of each Point .
But all this by and by .
And this is sufficient for a Confutation of Gassendus and Faber ; but our forementioned Abbe superadds to a greater or lesser Aperture of the Pupil , as a necessary Consequent , a greater and lesser Convexity of the Crystalline , as also a lengthening and shortening the Tube of the Eye .
And this I must confess would do something if we find it true in our Case ; and this let us try .
First , says he , the Duskishness of the Moon nigh the Horizon admits the Pupil to enlarge itself , the Crystalline to flatten , and the Eye to lengthen : But what if we change our Object , and instead of the Moon take the Distance between some of the fixed Stars ; ( as suppose those of Orion 's Girdle , ) we shall find the same Phenomenon in them , and yet I hope neither he nor Gassendus will assert , that they at one time strain the Eye more than at another , or that at any time their Fulgur strains the Eye at all ; if he do , let him take Stars of the lesser Magnitudes , nay , even those that can but just be perceived , and then he will be convinced : Or let him consider whether this will hold in looking at the Sun through very dark Glasses , which render the Sight thereof as inoffensive to the Eye , as that of a green Field ; but perhaps he will then say that this other Reason holds , which is , 2ly .
that the greater imaginary Distance at which we think the Moon near the Horizon , than when more elevated , makes us contemplate her as if really she was so , viz. with ample Pupils , &amp;c. but this I have sufficiently overthrown in my Remarks against Des-Cartes : Therefore I pass it over , only subjoyning that if there were any thing in this Surmise , my-thinks the Horizontal Moon should be fancied nigher to us , than farther from us ; for if we are for trying Natural Thoughts , let us take Children to determine the Matter , who are apt to think , that could they go to the Edge of that Space that bounds their Sight , they should be able ( as they call it ) to touch the Sky ; and consequently the Moon seems then rather nigher to us than farther from us .
After I had writ thus far I accidentally cast my Eye upon Riccioli 's Treatise of Refraction , at the End of his 2d Volume of the Almagest , Lib. 10 .
Sect. 6 .
cap. I. Quest .
13 .
wherein he speaks of our present Difficulty ; but to my Wonder I find him assert , that he and Father Grimaldi had often taken the Horizontal Sun and Moon 's Diameters by a Sextant , when to the naked Eye they appeared very large ; ( Grimaldus directing his Sight to the left Edge , and Ricciolus to the right , ) and that even by the Instrument they always found the Diameters greater than when more elevated , the Sun often subtending an Angle of almost a Degree , and frequently 45 Minutes , the Moon also 38 or 40 Minutes .
This is down-right contrary to the Matter of Fact , which I have before alleged , and directly repugnant to the Matter of Fact asserted by the French Abbe in the forecited Journal .
Whether of us be in the right I leave to accurate Experiment to determine , and submit the Whole to the Decision of the Illustrious Royal Society .
Only give me leave to add one Word against Riccioli , for had his Experiments been accurately prosecuted , he should have tried them when the Horizontal Moon had looked ten times more large in Diameter than ordinary ; and then if it be true , that even by an Instrument she will be found proportionally broader than really , she should subtend an Angle of 300 Minutes , or 5 Degrees : For very often I have seen the Moon when she appeared 10 times broader than ordinary , which the small Addition of 8 or 10 Minutes to her usual Diameter will never Cause .
Lastly as an Apology for my reviving this Disquisition to that Noble Company of English Philosophers , I shall only intimate the Words of the forementioned Abbe 's Letter .
Pour la Raison de cette Appearance , &amp; de la tromperie de nos Sens , je la tiens plus Difficile a trouver , que les plus grands Equations d'Algebre , &amp; quand vous y aurez bien pens , vous m'Obligerez de m'en dire vostre Sentement , &amp;c. After which I have only to subscribe myself an unworthy Member , and an humble Servant and Admirer of that Illustrious Company .
Dublin , William Molyneux .

