An answer of the same to the Author of the perpetual Motion .
IN the last papers I published in Phil. Transact. N. 184 against this perpetual Motion described in N. 177 .
I entreated the Author to permit me to say nothing as to what alterations he might make in his Engine ; resolving to leave it to others to show him that upon that principle all he can do signifies nothing .
But I find since , in the Nouvelles de la Republ : for December last , that he still persists to urge some new contrivances , which being added he conceives his Engine must succeed .
To this I answer that I undertook only to show that his first device would fail , which yet I should scarce have done , if I had thought a dispute of this nature could have lasted so long .
To come therefore to the point , where he saith that this Engine may well succeed without alteration , because he hath tried with Liquors put into Bellows immersed in Water : I again say that I grant him the truth of the Experiments , but deny the consequences he would draw from them , I have already given the reasons of my dissent , which this Gentleman is not pleased to understand .
But to end all controversies he may please to consult Mr. Perrault , de la Hire , or any other at Paris well known to be skilled in Hydraulicks : and I doubt not but he will find them of the same opinion with Mr. Boyle , Mr. Hook and other knowing persons here , who all agree that our Author is in this matter under a mistake .

