The Answer of Dr. Papin to several Objections made by Mr. Nuis against his Engine for raising Water by the rarefaction of the Air , whereof a description is given in No. 178 .
of these Transactions .
Having seen in the Nouvelles de la Republ .
des Lettres of the Month of December last , some difficulties which Mr. Nuis doth find in my new way for raising Water , publish't in the Philosophical Transactions of the month of January ; I am obliged to answer them as clearly as I can in these short notes .
In his first Objection he saith , that it would be a very hard matter to hinder but some Receptacles would come to be filled too much : So that the water filling also the pipes CDD would hinder the effect of the Engine .
To this I answer that it being necessary to let out the water of the highest Receptacle , I thought it might be conceived that the water may also be let out of the inferior Receptacles by inserting into each of them a crooked pipe , reaching a pretty way downwards , and having its lower aperture shut up with a valve ; whereby the water might run out when the Receptacle should be filled to a certain height : and so I did not Judge it needful to prevent this Objection .
The second Difficulty , which I had very well foreseen ( as it is plain in my first explication ) Iyes in the great quantity of Air to be rarefied : So that Mr. Nuis , by his computation , doth find that the Pump 's should every one contain , 84 cubick feet of rarefied Air to raise water at 12000 foot distance .
To this I may answer , first that I have not positively promised a good success but for Windsor and St. Germain ; but when I spoke of Versailles I used the word perhaps , thereby showing that before any one should go about such a great undertaking he should reflect upon it more than I would then do , not having occasion for such work : but since I have seen Mr. Nuis his Objection , I have been Obliged in order to answer him to make the following computation .
Let the distance as he supposes be 12000 foot , and the Capacity of each Receptacle be about one half of a cubick foot : I might make the wheel with the Axis to make their revolution in one minute of time , and so order all things that the Air under the ascending plugs might come to be rarefied to such a degree , that by its Elasticity it might not counterpoise more than 7 foot of water:but at the same time the Air in the Receptacles A A , B B , would even in it 's great est dilatation be able to counterpoise 17 foot : so it is plain that the Air will be driven from the Receptacles into the Pumps by a strength equivalent to ten foot of water : Now if we compute after the method published in the Transaction of the month of October last , what should be the Velocity of the Air driven by such a pressure : we shall find that the said Velocity will be about 740 foot in a second : So that in half a minute , during which the plug goes up , this Air might pass above 22000 foot , although it were not rarifi 'd at all ; but being rarefi 'd , as we do suppose it to be , it might go a great deal further .
I must now take notice that according to the Honourable Mr. Boile 's Experiments quoted by Mr. Nuis , the Rarefaction of the Air is much lesser than he takes it to be : For the Water contained in the Pipe N O. is so far from causing the Air to fill up a space four times bigger , that it will not extend it self to a space once bigger than before ; considering therefore the Velocity of the Air and the small dilatation it doth suffer , if any one will take the trouble to compute , he will find that if the Pumps have in Diameter the Diagonal of a Square Foot , and the same heighth : and if the small Tubes of communication be made of 1/ 9 part of an Inch in Diameter , so that being 12000 Foot long , they may contain about one cubick Foot of Air , that would be more than sufficient to make the necessary Rarefaction in the Receptacles : And thus much might answer Mr. Nuis his Objection .
But for the good success of the Engine it is not enough to make the Air pass from the Receptacles into the Pumps , it must also return from the Pumps into the Receptacles : Now for this intent it would be necessary to set the Recepticles but five Foot above one another ; so to drive the Water up the Pipe NO , it would be enough that the Air in the Receptacle B should press with a strength equivalent to 23 Foot of Water : For it is plain that 5 Foot in the Pipe N O , together with a pressure equivalent to 17 Foot which I have supposed to be in the upper Receptacle A , will make but 22 Foot in all : and therefore 23 Foot pressing in the Receptacle B must prevail and cause the Water to ascend : now the pressure in the Receptacle being but 23 Foot , and the Air in the Pump returning to its ordinary pressure , which is about 33 Foot ; it is plain that the Air going back to the Receptacle will be driven by a strength equivalent to 10 Foot , as well as it had been in coming from the Receptacle towards the Pump : and so the bigness assigned for the communication-Pipes will also prove more than sufficient to this effect .
From what I have been saying it is plain , that in great distances there should be made as many Pumps as Receptacles , as I had propounded in the first explication of my Engine : and for to raise Water but 60 Foot high , there should be required 13 or 14 Receptacles and as many Pumps of the bigness aforesaid .
Some people may take this for a great difficulty .
But I answer that in this Engine this is not so much as it seems at first ; because the pressure being all from without , there is no need of any great strength to resist it , and so the Metal for the Pumps will cost but little : there may also be found occasions where to make so good use of them , that such an Engine as I have described would in a years time save labour enough to pay for many Pumps , since it might every hour raise about 1800 pounds of Water to the height of 60 Foot : Mean while I do n't pretend to have given here the best proportion for the bigness of every part of the Engine ; but it may be , by altering the Capacity of the Pumps , of the Pipes , or of the Receptacles , a much more considerable effect might be produced : but I'le leave this to be looked after by those that may have occasion for it ; and for my part I content my self having shown the truth of what I had at first , though but doubtfully , propounded : For the River Seine , where it is nearest to Versailles , not being above 20000 Foot distant , it is easy to see that , to supply this increase of distance , we might lessen at pleasure the capacity of the Receptacles , or increase the capacity of the Pumps and of the Pipes , or cause the wheel to spend more time in its revolution : it is true the Engine would produce less effect , but upon a great River the number of the Engines might be multiplied , and vast quantitys of Water still be raised .
I shall therefore , to prevent new difficulties , add only this : that as well as in the Receptacles I have a way to prevent the overflowing with Water ; so in the Pumps I might also prevent the overfilling with Air , by making a Valve that should open as soon as the Air in the Pump should be more comprest than the outward Air : So the Air getting in through any pores would constantly be let out .
As for the third objection wherein Mr. Nuis says that it doth not appear how the Water in our Engine may , by Rarefaction , ascend higher than 32 Foot .
I answer that the Water doth not at any time ascend higher than from a lower Receptacle into the next upper Receptacle , which heighth is but 12 Foot : So that it is plain enough that the pressure of the Air may be sufficient to drive it up .
It is indifferent whether it be by Rarefaction or otherwise that the Water comes into the Receptacle A ; it is enough that the Water is there , and that the Air presses upon it with such a strength as will prevail against all that opposes it , as I have shown above .
To the fourth Difficulty I answer : That although the use of the Pipes be meerly for the conveying of Air : They may nevertheless easily be filled with Water when need requires , and so the defects in them may as well be found out as in the Pipes that are used for the conveying of Water .
This is all I may answer at present , and I shall make an end with assureing Mr. Nuis that i'le make use of his advice when ever he will be pleased to give it me .

