A Dioptrick Problem , Why four Convex-glasses in a Telescope , show Objects Erect .
by William Molineux of Dublin Esq. R. S. Soc. IN the Journal des Scavans for Munday the 17th .
of September 1685 .
page .
466 .
Amst. Edition , we find this passage .
As Perspectives of one Convex-glass make Objects appear Upright , which those of two Convex-glasses invert , and again those of three rectify ; so it should seem that those of four ought to invert : And yet Experience shows us that Objects appear upright through these glasses .
The Singularity of this Phenomenon obliges all Skil 'd in Dioptricks to inquire the reason thereof , but hitherto they have found none .
Mr. Regis , who applies himself particularly to this part of Natural Philosophy , believes that he has hit upon the Reason , and makes us hope that he will suddenly Publish it Thus far the Journal , but it does not tell us whose remark this is , though I am apt to believe it was written by Mr. Regis himself , to the Publisher of the Journal .
To me this Phenomenon appears very easily explicable , from the consideration of placing Glasses in a Tube .
Which is thus ; after the Object-glass , the Eye-glass is placed so much distant ( towards the Eye ) from the Focus of the Objectglass as is the Focus of the Eye-glass ; then the middle Eye-glass is placed so much distant from the Focus of the first Eye-glass , as is the Focus of this middle Eye-glass ; lastly the nearest Eyeglass is placed so much distant from the Focus of this middle Eye-glass , as is the Focus of this nearest Eye-glass ; and the Eye looking through them all is placed in the Focus of this nearest Eye-glass .
I say therefore first , that one single Convex-glass , cannot properly be said by it self to show Objects erect or reverse , but in respect of placeing of the Eye that looks through it .
For if the Eye that looks through such a single Convex-glass be placed nigher thereto , then the Glasses Focus , the Objects are erect , if the Eye be placed just in the Focus , the Objects are neither erect nor reversed , but all in confusion between both ; and if the Eye be placed further from the Glass than the Focus , the Objects are reversed .
I mean here distant Objects , the Rays flowing from any point whereof may be counted to come parallel towards the Object-glass , for such Objects we are to consider when we speak of looking thro ' Telescopes .
This being laid down , I assert .
Secondly , that the Object-glass of a Telescope reverses the Object , both to the EyeGlass and the Eye , that looks through it : For the Eye-glass is placed farther from the Object-glass than is the Focus of the Object-glass .
But the Eye-glass does nothing towards the Rectification or Reversion ; the Eye being placed just in it 's Focus .
Thus we see that the Reversing of Objects in a Telescope of two Convex-glasses proceeds wholly from the Object-glass and its position , and the Eye-glass has nothing to do in the Affair ; for were the Eye it self in the place of the Eye-glass it would see the Objects inverted thro ' the single Object-glass .
I come now to consider the second Eye-glass placed after the first Eye-glass .
( the first Eye-glass being that next the Object-glass ) And here it is manifest that placing this as it ought in a Telescope , if we place our Eye nearer to this middle Eye-glass than it 's Focus , the Eye sees the Objects inverted and confused : Place the Eye in the Focus , it sees the Objects all in confusion , neither erect nor reversed ; for here again there is a distinct Representation of the Objects to be received on a piece of Paper , as in the Focus of the Object-glass ; and the Eye being placed at any time at this place ( which is usually called the DistinctBase ) sees all in confusion .
But then let the Eye be placed farther from this middle Glass then its Focus(for so is the third or immediate Eye-glass , it being always distant from the middle Eye-glass , the Aggregate of both their Foci ) it perceives the Objects erect and Lastly .
the third or immediate Eye-glass does nothing towards the erecting or reversing the Species , which it receives erect from the middle Eye-glass ; no more than in a Telescope of two Convex-glasses , the Eye-glass does to the Species it receives from the Object-glass , as we have shown before .
The reason that this last or immediate Eye-glass has nothing to do in the erecting or reversing the Species is the same , as in a Telescope of two Convex-glasses , viz. the Eye is placed in its Focus , and therefore sees the Species as it is represented in the Distinct Base ; that is , the Species is inverted in the Distinct Base of the Object-glass , and therefore a single Convex Eye-glass brings it to the Eye inverted ; but in the Distinct-Base of the middle or second Eye-glass the Species is erect , and therefore the third or immediate Eye-glass brings it to the Eye erect .
Wherefore we are to consider the Telescope consisting of an Object-glass and three Eye-glasses , as two Telescopes , each consisting of two Convex-glasses .
The first consists of the Object-glass and first Eye-glass , and this inverts the Species ; that is , the Species is inverted in the Distinct-Base of the Object-glass , and so brought into the Eye .
The second Telescope consists of the two immediate Eye-glasses , and this erects what the former inverted , that is , the Species in the Distinct-Base of the middle Eye-glass is erect , and is so brought into the Eye by the Eye-glass ; the Eye-glasses themselves in neither case having any thing to do with the erecting or inverting , but meerly in representing in the same posture the Species immediately before them .
The French Problem therefore should not have broken a Telescope of four Convex-glasses into four pieces , but into two , and the case would have been plain ; whereas by breaking it into four Perspective-Glasses , they attribute that to two of them , which neither of them does , viz. inverting and erecting .
Therefore I say lastly , that one Convex-glass as posited in a Telescope inverts ; the second(that is the first Eye-glass ) does nothing towards erecting or reversing , but represents the Image as it is in the Distinct-Base of the Object-glass before it , that is , inverted .
The third Glass erects , or rather restores what was before inverted .
The fourth represents the Image as it receives it from the Distinct-Base of the third , that is , erect .
And this I think a sufficient Solution of this Problem .

