Some further Remarks on the Instrument proposed by an Anonymous French Author , for effecting a perpetual Motion , an account whereof is given in No. 177 of these Transactions , by Dr. Papin .
M. D : R. S. S. HAving seen in the Journal des Scavans of May 13th .
and in the Nouvelles de la Republique des Letres of the Month of June , that the Author of the perpetual Motion is not satisfied , but doth endeavour to answer the Objection that I propounded against his contrivance , in the Philosophical Transactions of the Month of December , 1685 .
I find I must explain my self more at large than I did in that Paper ; but I beg his pardon if I say nothing concerning the new disposition , which he says might be given to his Engine : My want of time makes me avoid new matters of dispute , and I think it enough for me , if I do but show that his first Description can never succeed .
I am very sorry , that this Author took so much trouble in trying his Bellows with several Liquors , as Oil , Mercury , Water .
I thought I had said nothing , that might make him believe , that I did in the least question the truth , which he intended to prove against me by those Experiments , and without any trials I am fully enough convinced that the Mercury in his Engine must follow the laws of the aequilibrium of fluid Bodies : But the consequence which he draws from that Principle , seems to be very groundless ; for altho ' the lowermost part of the Bellows be pressed by the weight of 40 inches of Mercury , it doth not follow , that all the parts which are situated higher must bare the same pressure : To the quite contrary , it is plain that the upper part having no Mercury above its bears none at all ; the parts that lye in the middle near the Axes of the Bellows , bear but 20 inches , and so all the rest must bear more or less , according as they lye higher or lower : It is evident therefore , that there are as many parts that bear less than 20 inches , as there are that bear more , and the increase of pressure following an Arithmetical Progression , it is undeniable , that all these pressures added together , will do no more than one uniform pressure , that would be equal to 20 inches every where .
Having thus found the quantity of pressure caused by the Mercury within the Bellows , we must remember that the pressure of the Atmosphere within the same Bellows , is equivalent but to 5 inches , as I observed in my first Paper vid .
Philosophical Transaction No 177 page .
1241 : So that we find that the inward pressure is equivalent but to 25 inches of Mercury in all .
Now the pressure of the Atmosphere upon the outside is every where equal to 27 inches ; from whence it appears that the pressure without is stronger than the pressure within , and so I had reason to say , that the Bellows standing upright , must rather shut than open .
I did not think to have given this Computation so at large , but I have been necessitated to do it ( as I said in the beginning ) since my first Paper was not sufficient to make me be understood by the Author of the Perpetual Motion , however , I will be careful to save the time of the Reader as much as I can ; and although I might observe some other things in his Description , that will increase the difficulty of opening the Bellows , I forbare to speak of them ; and I will stick only to that which is most material , and makes his perpetual Motion to be altogether impossible .
As for the Argument the Author draws from comparing his Engine to an ordinary Siphon ; I do beseech him to consider what a difference there is between a Siphon that lets the water run down at the bottom , and his Engine ; that should gather up the heavy liquor into the highest part of the Instrument , and I do not question but he will acknowledge the weakness of this Argument .

