A Discourse on this PROBLE M ; Why Bodies dissolved in Menstrua Specifically lighter than themselves swim therein .
By Mr. WILLIAM MOLYNEUX , of Dublin .
Member of the Royal Society .
THe Liberty of Philosophising being now universally granted between all men , I am sure that a difference in Opinion will be no breach of affection between two entirely Loving Brothers : And therefore I shall take the freedom to Propose my Own thoughts in a matter wherein my Brother Mr. Thomas Molyneux hath Appeared publicly in the Novelles de la Republique des Lettres , Mois d ' Aout 1684 .
Art 4 .
and Mois de Janvier 1685 .
Art .
7 .
The Problem proposed is , Why Bodies dissolved float in Liquors lighter than themselves ; as for Example : Mercury dissolved in strong Spirit of Nirte swims therein , tho ' each small Particle of Mercury , be far heavier than so much of the Liquor whose place it occupies .
This , says he , cannot be solved by the prime Law of Hydrostaticks , which is , that a Body which in an equal Quantity is heavier than a like quantity of Liquor , sinks in that Liquor ; thus a Cubick Inch of Iron being heavier than a Cubick Inch of Aqua-Fortis , and each Particle ( how small soever ) of Iron being heavier then a like Particle of Aqua-Fortis ; Iron being put into AquaFortis should sink , and yet we find , that Iron being dissolved in a convenient Quantity of Aqua-Fortis floats therein , and does not fall to the Bottom .
The Reason which my Brother gives for this is , that the Internal Motion of the Parts of the Liquor , does keep up the Particles of the dissolved solved Solid , for they being so very Minute , are Moveable by the least Force imaginable , and the Action of the Particles of the Menstruum , is sufficient to drive the Atoms of the dissolved solid Body from place to place ; and consequently , notwithstanding their Gravity , they do not sink in the Liquor lighter than themselves .
As a Proof of this in the 7th .
Article of Janvier 1685 , he offers an Experiment known in Chemistry , that a Menstruum over a digesting Fire ( as the Chymist speaks ) will dissolve a greater Quantity of a Body put into it , than when it is off the Fire , and if it be taken off the Fire , and suffered to cool , a great Portion will precipitate of that which was perfectly dissolved , whilst the Menstruum continued hot .
For , says he , the Particles of the Menstruum acquire a more violent agitation by the Fire , and are therefore able to raise and keep up a greater Quantity of the dissolved Body , or hereby they are able to Resist a greater Gravity .
It has been objected against this Notion , that the common Experiment of precipitation , by mixing an Alkaly with an Acid , seems to contradict this ; for thereby the Fluidity of the Menstruum is not taken away , and consequently , the internal Agitation of its Parts is not diminished , and yet thereupon , the Particles of the dissolved Body precipitate all to the Bottom .
To this he answers in the forecited Article of January , that all Mixtures of different Liquors introduce in each a different Conformation of Pores , and therefore the Infusion of a new Liquor , drives the insensible Parts of the dissolved Body from their Places , and forces them to strike against each other , and cling together , and so becoming more big and heavier than formerly , the internal Agitation of the Liquor is no longer able to move and sustain them , and consequently they fall to the Bottom .
This , as fairly and shortly as I can propose it , is his Sentiment of this Phenomenon .
But I conceive another Account may be given of this Appearance , and that the foresaid Law of Hydrostaticks is a little deficient .
It is true indeed , if we consider only the specific Gravity of a Liquor , and the specific Gravity of a solid Particle floating therein , the forementioned Rule is exact ; but in sinking there is a requisite separation of the Parts of the Liquor by the sinking Body ; and there being a natural Inclination in the Parts of all Liquors to Union , arising from an Agreement or Congruity of their Parts , there is a resistance therein to any thing that separates this Conjunction : Now unless a Body have weight enough to overcome this Congruity or Union of Parts , such a Body will float in a Liquor specifically lighter than it self .
But that a heavy Body , as Mercury or Iron may have its Parts reduced to that Minuteness , that their Gravity or Tendency downwards , is not strong enough to separate the Cohesion or Union of the Parts of a Liquor , will be manifest , if we consider , that the Resistance made by the Medium to a falling Body , is according to the Superficies of the Body ; but as the Body decreases in Bulk , its Superficies does not proportionably decrease ; thus a Sphere of an Inch Diameter , has not eight times less Superficies than a Sphere of two Inches Diameter , tho ' it have eight times less Bulk , and consequently passing through a Medium , as suppose Air or Water , the Sphere of an Inch Diameter is , proportionably to its Bulk , more resisted , than a Sphere of two Inches Diameter in proportion to its Bulk ; and hence it will come to pass , that at last a Body may be reduced to that Minuteness , that its Gravity pressing downwards ( which is according to its Bulk ) may be less than the resistance of the Medium , which operates on the Surface of the Body ; seeing as I said before , the Surfaces of Bodies do not decrease so fast as their Bulks , these decreasing in a Triplicate , but those in a Duplicate Ratio of the Bodies Diameters .
This Account does not at all oppose the Experiment of a~ over the Fire , being able to dissolve or sustain a greater Quantity of a heavy Body ; for the Reason of this , as it is given by my Brother , does not Contradict my Notion .
The Account likewise , that He gives of Chemical Precipitation agrees very well with what I propose : So that of these I shall say no more .
But because in the beginning of my Discourse , I say that the forementioned Law of Hydrostaticks is a little defective , I desire to explain my self a little further in that Point .
In Weights falling through the Air , were Gravity only considered , the Proportions of their Descents would be exactly as Galileo has Demonstrated ; but it is allow 'd by all , that the Resistance of the Air , not being considered in those Demonstrations , they are not Mathematically true in Practice , but that Really there is something of that Proportion hindred by the Airs Resistance .
Now , what is this less than to say , that the Resistance of the Air takes off some of the Operation of Gravity , or is able to withstand or oppose part of its Action ?
And if so , what shall we say , were an Iron Sphere let through a Medium of Water ?
Surely the Proportions of its descents would be much more disturbed herein , as Water is much more solid and difficult to be separated or passed through than Air , and consequently we must needs Grant , that more of the Operation of Gravity , is taken off or Resisted by this Opposition of the Water , than that of the Air .
And if so , Surely there may be a certain degree of Gravity , that may be quite taken off by the Resistance of the Water : Were a Pistol Bullet let fall through the Air , it would Descend imperceptibly nigh the Proportions that Galileo has assigned , but were a single grain of Sand so let fall , it would be much hindred in its Course , and the half of this Grain would be more obstructed ; what shall we then say of the ten thousandth part , or of a part the ten thousand millionth of this , and again of the Infinite Subdivisions of that , till at last we come to a part that would be wholly resisted , or kept up ; such as I conceive the Minute particles of a Body dissolved in a Menstruum .
On this account it is I say , that the forementioned Principle of Hydrostaticks is a little defective ; for it considers not the Natural Congruity of the Parts of a Liquor , whereby they desire , as 'twere , to unite and keep together , just as we see two Drops of Water on a Dry Board being brought together do jump and Coalesce , and therefore Liquors have an innate Power of Resisting a certain degree of force that would separate them ; such as I suppose the degree of Gravity in the most Minute Particles of a Body dissolved in a Menstruum .
The forementioned Rule holds true to the most nice Sense in Great Bodies but in those that are by many Millions of Divisions Smaller , it seems to fail .
This in short is my Conjecture in this matter , which I propose , as my Brother did his , with all submission imaginable , and thereby to give occasion to others to enquire into the Causes of this appearance , rather than to publish my own sentiment , as the undoubted solution thereof .
But this I must acknowledge , that the Internal motion of the parts of a Liquor seems so very agreeable to truth , and explicates so many Phaenomenea easily and plainly , that I would not be thought to deny it .
Neither would I be thought wholly to Reject my Brothers solution of this Problem ; for certainly that Motion ( whatsoever it is ) in a Menstruum , which is able to Dissolve such a solid Body as Iron , that is , which is able to disturb the close and strong Cohesion of the Parts of Iron , may very well be supposed sufficient to disturb or keep up these parts from resting in the Bottom of the Vessel , wherein the solution was made ; And certainly no better account can possibly be given of such solutions , than by supposing such an Internal motion in the Parts of the Menstruum insinuating themselves into the solid body , and loosening its Parts .
And tho ' it may be objected , that in the Parts of Water there may be supposed as Violent an Internal motion , as in the Parts of Aqua-Fortis , and yet we see Water will not dissolve Iron , as Aqua-Fortis does , and Common Bees-Wax is disturbed by neither of them , I leave the Nice Enquiry after this point to others , viz. What kind of Motion and peculiar Conformation of parts is requisite both in the Menstruum and in the Dissolved Body , that a solution may result from their Commixture .
Some Reflections on the foregoing Paper by Mr. T. M. What my Brother has laid down in this Discourse , I think does most undeniably evince that the received Law of Hydrostaticks is somewhat defective .
For Liquors , tho ' they are Fluid yet they are Bodies , and therefore consist of parts united ; which Union tho ' it be easily destroyed , yet of necessity it requires some degree of Force for the effecting it ; nor is it more manifest , if rightly considered , that a Flint requires Force for the separation of its parts , than that Fluids do for theirs .
But however , I imagine , this Property ought not to be relied upon as the sole Cause of this Appearance , to which my Brother has applied it ; nay perhaps does not so much as concur the least in the producing this effect ; my Reason in short is this : whatever is of sufficient Power to raise the minute Particles of a Heavy Body in a light Fluid , is certainly a sufficient cause to keep them in that state : now my Supposition may give some account of this ; what my Brother says , never can ; for he must necessarily suppose them first raised ; and then he gives the reason of their not sinking : Whereas it is not to be questioned but that that Force which raised them , is the same that keeps them from falling to the bottom .
But these Conjectures ( for I esteem them no more ) I leave to the Consideration of those that desire to enquire further into this Matter .

