Mr. Newton 's Answer to the precedent Letter , sent to the Publisher .
Sir , THe things opposed by Mr. Line being upon Trials found true and granted me ; I begin with the new question about the proportion of the length of the Image to its breadth .
This I call a new one ; for , though Mr. Line in his last Letter spake against so great a length as I assign , yet , as it seems to me , it was not to grant any transverse length shorter than that assigned by me , ( for in his first Letter he absolutely denied that there would be any such length ; ) but to lay the greater emphasis upon his discourse whilst in defence of common Optiques he was disputing in general against a transverse Image : And therefore in my Answer I did not prescribe the just quantity of the refracting Angle with which I would have the Experiment repeated : which would have been a necessary circumstance , had the dispute been about the just proportion of the length to the breadth .
Yet I added * this Note , that the bigger the angle of the Prism is , the greater will be the length in proportion to the breadth : not imagining but that when he had found in any Prism the length of the Image transverse to the axis , he would easily thence conclude , that a prism with a greater angle would make the Image longer , and con sequently that by using an angle great enough he might bring it to equal or exceed the length assigned by me ; as indeed he might : for by taking an Angle of 70 or 75 degrees , or a little greater , *In my first Letter in Phil. Trans. N. greater , he might have made the length not only five , but six of eight times the breadth and more .
No wonder therefore , that Mr. Lucas found the Image shorter than I did , seeing he tried the Experiment with a less Angle .
The Angle indeed which I used was but about 63 degrees 12 minutes , and his is set down 60 degrees : the difference of which from mine , being but 3 degrees 12 minutes , is too little to reconcile us , but yet it will bring us considerably nearer together .
And if his Angle was not exactly measured , but the round number of 60 degrees set down by guess or by a less accurate measure ( as I suspect by the conjectural measure of the refraction of his Prism by the ratio of the signs 2 to 3 , set down at the same time , instead of an Experimental one , ) then might it be two or three degrees less than 60 , if not still less and all this , if it should be so , would take away the greatest part of the difference between us .
But however it be , I am well assured , my own observation was exact enough .
For I have repeated it divers times since the receipt of Mr. Lucas 's Letter , and that without any considerable difference of my Observations either from one another , or from what I wrote before .
And that it might appear experimentally , how the increase of the Angle increases the length of the Image , and also that no body who has a mind to try the Experiment exactly , might be trouble to procure a Prism which has an angle just of the bigness assigned by me ; I tried the Experiment with divers Angles , and have set down my Trials in the following Table ; where the first column expresses the six Angles of two Prisms which I used , which were measured as exactly as I could by applying them to the angle of a Sector ; and the second column expresses in inches the length of the Image made by each of those Angles ; its breadth being two inches , its distance from the Prism 18 feet and four inches , and the breadth of the hole in the Windowshut 1/ 4 of an inch .
The Angles of The Lengths of degr .
min. the Image .
56 10 7~ The first Prism 60 24 91/ 2 63 26 10~ The Angles of The Lengths of degr .
min. the Image .
54 0 7~ the second Prism .
62 12 10~ 63 48 10~ You may perceive , that the length of the Images in respect of the angles that made them , are something greater in the second Prism than in the first ; but that was because the glass , of which the second Prism was made , had the greater refractive power .
The days in which I made these Trials were pretty clear , but not so clear as I desired , and therefore afterwards meeting with a day as clear as I desired , I repeated the Experiment with the second Prism , and found the lengths of the Image made by its several angles to be about 1/ 4 of an inch greater than before , the measures being those set down in this Table .
The Angles of The Lengths of degr .
min. the Image .
54 0 7~ the second Prism 62 12 101/ 2 63 48 11 The reason of this difference I apprehend was , that in the clearest days the light of the white skies , which dilutes and renders invisible the faintest Colours at the ends of the Image , is a little diminished in a clear day , and so gives leave to the Colours to appear to a greater length ; the Suns light at the same time becoming brisker , and so strengthning the Colours and making the faint ones at the two ends more conspicuous .
For I have observed , that in days something cloudy , whilst the Prism has stood unmoved at the window , the Image would grow a little longer or a little shorter , accordingly as the Sun was more or less obscured by thin Clouds which passed over it ; the Image being shortest when the Cloud was brightest and the Suns light faintest .
Whence it is easy to apprehend , that , if the light of the Clouds could be quite taken away , so that the Sun might appear surrounded with darkness , or if the Suns light were much stronger than it is , the colours would still appear to a greater length .
In all these Observations the breadth of the Image was just two inches .
But observing , that the sides of the two Prisms , I used , were not exactly plain , but a little convex , ( the convexity being about so much as that of a double Convex-glass of a sixteen or eighteen foot Telescope ) I took a third Prism , whose sides were as much concave as those of the other were convex ; and this made the breadth of the Image to be two inches and a third part of an inch ; the angles of this Prism , and the lengths of the Image made by each of those Angles being those expressed in this Table .
The Angles of the Prism .
The Lengths of the degr .
Image in inches .
58 81/ 2 591/ 2 9 621/ 2 101/ 4 In this case you see , the concaveifigure of the sides of the Prism by making the rays diverge a little , causes the breadth of the Image to be greater in proportion to its length than it would be otherwise .
And this I thought fit to give you notice of , that Mr. Lucas may examine , whether his Prism have not this fault .
If a Prism may be had with sides exactly plain , it may do well to try the Experiment with that ; but its better , if the sides be about so much convex as those of mine are , because the Image will thereby become much better defined .
For this convexity of the sides does the same effect , as if you should use a Prism with sides exactly plain , and between it and the hole in the Window shut , place an Object-glass of an 18 foot Telescope , to make the round Image of the Sun appear distinctly defined on the wall when the Prism is taken away , and consequently the long Image made by the Prism to be much more distinctly defined ( especially at its straight sides ) than it would be otherwise .
One thing more I shall add : That the utmost length of the Image from the faintest Red at one end to the faintest Blew at the other , must be measured .
For in my first Letter about Colours , where I set down the length to be five times the breadth , I called that length the utmost length of the image ; and I measured the utmost length , because I account all that length to be caused by the immediate light of the Sun , seeing the Colours ( as I noted above ) become visible to the greatest length in the clearest days , that is , when the light of the Sun transcends most the light of the Clouds .
Sometimes there will happen to shoot out from both ends of the Image a glaring light a good way beyond these colours , but this is not to be regarded , as not appertaining to the Image .
If the measures be taken right , the whole length will exceed the length of the straight sides by about the breadth of the Image .
By these things set down thus circumstantially , I presume Mr. Lucas will be enabled to accord his trials of the Experiment with mine ; so nearly , at least , that there shall not remain any very considerable difference between us .
For , if some little difference should still remain , that need not trouble us any further , seeing there may be many various circumstances which may conduce to it ; such as are not only the different figures of prisms , but also the different refractive power of Glasses , the different diameters of the Sun at divers times of the year , and the little errors that may happen in measuring lines and angles , or in placing the prism at the window ; though , for my part , I took care to do these things as exactly as I could .
However Mr. Lucas may make sure to find the Image as long or longer than I have set down , if he take a prism whose sides are not hollow ground , but plain , or ( which is better ) a very little convex , and whose refracting angle is as much greater than that I used , as that he has hitherto tried it with , is less ; that is , whose angle is about 66 or 67 degrees , or ( if he will ) a little greater .
Concerning Mr. Lucas 's other Experiments , I am much obliged to him that he would take these things so far into consideration , and be at so much pains for examining them ; and I thank him so much the more , because he is the first that has sent me an experimental examination of them .
By this I may presume he really desires to know what truth there is in these matters .
But yet it will conduce to his more speedy and full satisfaction if he a little change the method which he has propounded , and instead of a multitude of things try only the Experimentum Caucis .
For it is not number of Experiments , but weight to be regarded ; and where one will do , what need many ?
Had I thought more requisite , I could have added more : For before I wrote my first Letter to you about Colours , I had taken much pains in trying Experiments about them , and written a Tractate on that subject , wherin I had set down at large the principal of the Experiments I had tried ; amongst which there happened to be the principal of those Experiments which Mr. Lucas has now sent me .
And as for the Experimeuts set down in my first Letter to you , they were only such as I thought convenient to select out of that Tractate .
But suppose those had been my whole store , yet Mr. Lucas should not have grounded his discourse upon a supposition of my want of Experiments , till he had examined those few .
For if any of those be demonstrative , they will need no assistants , nor leave room for further disputing about what they demonstrate .
The main thing he goes about to examine is , the different refrangibility of Light .
And this I demonstrated by the Experimentum Crucis .
Now if this demonstration be good , there needs no further examination of the thing ; if not good , the fault of it is to be shown : for the only way to examine a demonstrated proposition is , to examine the demonstration .
Let that Experiment therefore be examined in the first place , and that which it proves be acknowledged , and then if Mr. Lucas want my assistance to unfold the difficulties which he fancies to be in the Experiments he has propounded , he shall freely have it ; for then I suppose a few words may make them plain to him : whereas , should I be drawn from demonstrative Experiment to begin with those , it might create us both the trouble of a long dispute , and by the multitude of words , cloud rather than clear up the truth .
For if it has already cost us so much trouble to agree upon the matter of fact in the first and plainest Experiment , and yet we are not fully agreed ; what an endless trouble might it create us , if we should give our selves up to dispute upon every Argument that occurs , and what would become of Truth in such a tedious dispute ?
The way therefore that I propound , being the shortest and clearest ( not to say , the only proper way , ) I question not but Mr. Lucas will be glad that I have recommended it , seeing he professes , that it is the knowledge of truth that he seeks after .
And therefore at present I shall say nothing in answer to his Experimental discourse , but this in general ; that it has proceeded partly from some misunderstanding of what he writes against , and partly from want of due caution in trying Experiments ; and that amongst his Experiments there is one , which when duly tried , is , next to the Experimentum Crucis , the most conspicuous Experiment , I know , for proving the different refrangibility of Light , which he brings it to prove against .
By the Post-script of Mr. Lucas 's Letter , one not acquainted with what has passed , might think , that he quotes the Observation of the R.Society against me ; whereas the relation of their Observation , which you sent to Liege , contained nothing at all about the just proportion of the Length of the Image to its Breath according to the angle of the Prism , nor any thing more ( so far as I can perceive by your last ) than what was pertinent to the things then in dispute , viz. that they found them succeed as I had affirmed .
And therefore since Mr. Lucas has found the same success , I suppose , that when he expressed , that he much rejoiced to see the Trials of the R. Society agree so exactly with his , he meant only so far as his agreed with mine .
And because I am again upon this first Experiment , I shall desire , that Mr. Lucas will repeat it with all the exactness and caution that may be , regard being had to the information about it , set down in this Letter ; and then I desire ~ have the length and breadth of the Image with its distance from the Prism , set down exactly in feet and inches , and parts of an inch , that I may have an opportunity to consider what relation its length and breadth have to the Suns diameter .
For I know , that Mr. Lucas Observation cannot hold where the refracting angle of the Prism is full 60 degrees , and the day is clear , and the full length of the Colours is measured , and the breadth of the Image answers to the Sun 's diameter : And seeing I am well assured of the truth and exactness of my own Observations , I shall be unwilling to be diverted by any other Experiments , from having a fair end made of this in the first place .
Sir , I am , &amp;c. Postscript .
I Had like to have forgotten to advise , that the Experimentum Crucis , and such others as ( ball be made for knowing the nature of Colours , be made with Prisms which refract so much , as to make the length of the Image five times its breadth , and rather more than less ; for , otherwise Experiments will not succeed so plainly with others as they have done with me .

