Fig. IV .
d ~ Ann.1670 VI A Letter from Liege concerning .
Mr. Newton 's Experiment of the coloured Spectrum ; together with some Exceptions against his Theory of Light and Colours .
Honrd Sir , MR Gascoigne having received your obliging Letter of Jan. 18 , with fresh directions from Mr. Newton ; but wanting convenience to make the Experiment according to the said instructions , he has requested me to supply his want .
In compliance with his request I have made many Trials ; the issue whereof I here acquaint you with : next , with some exceptions , grounded on Experiments , against Mr. Newton 's new Theory of Light and Colours .
The vertical angle of my Prism was 60 deg ; the distance of the Wall , whereon the coloured Spectrum appeared , from the Window , about 18 foot : The diameter of the Hole in the Windowshuts in length the line a , which upon occasions I contracted to half the said diameter ; but still with equal success as to the main of the Experiment .
The refractions on both sides the Prism , were as near as I could make them , equal , and consequently about 48 deg. 40~ , the refractive power of Glass being computed according to the Ratio of the Sines 2 to 3 .
The distance of the Prism from the hole in the Shuts was about 2 inches : The Room darkned to that degree as to equal the darkest night , while the hole in the Shuts was covered .
Now as to the issue of my Trials ; I constantly found the length of the coloured image ( transverse to the axis of the Prism ) considerably greater than its breadth , as of en as the Experiment was made on a clear day ; but if a bright Cloud were near the Sun , I found it sometimes exactly as Mr. Line wrote you , namely broader than long , especially while the Prism was placed at a great distance from the hole Which Experiment will not , I conceive , be questioned by Mr. Newton , it being so agreeable to the received laws of Refractions .
And indeed the Observations of these two Learned persons , as to this particular , are easily reconcileable to each other , and both to truth ; Mr Newton ( as appears by his Letter of Nov. last , wherein more fully he delivers his mind ) contending only for the length of the Image ( transverse to the axis of the Prism ) in a very clear day ; whereas Mr. Line only maintained the excess of breadth , parallel to the same axis , while the Sun is in a bright cloud .
Though as to what is further delivered by Mr. Newton ( Phil. Transact. N. 80 .
p. 3077 ; and opposed by Mr. Line , N. 129 .
p 501 .
) namely that the length of the coloured Image was five times the diameter of its breadth ; I never yet have found the excess above thrice the diameter , or at most 31/ 2 , while the refractions on both sides the Prism were equal .
So much as to the matter of fact .
Now as to Mr. Newton 's Theory of Light and Colours , I confess , his neat Set of very ingenious and natural inferences , was to me upon the first perusal a strong conjecture in favour of his new doctrine ; I having formerly observed the like chain of Inferences upon search into Natural truths .
But since several experiments of Refractions remain still untouched by him , I conceived , a further search into them would be very proper in order to a further discovery of the truth of his Assertion .
For , accordingly as they are found either agreeing with , or disagreeing from , his new Theory , they must needs much strengthen then , or wholly overthrow the same .
The Experiments I pitched upon for this purpose , are as follow : 1 .
Having frequently observed , that the form of Objects viewed in the Microscope ( or rather of the Microscope it self consists almost in an indivisible point , I concluded , two very small pieces of Silk , the one scarlet , the other violet colour , placed near together , should , according to Mr. Newton 's Theory , appear in the Microscope in a very different degree of clarity , in regard their unequal refrangibility must cause the scarlet rays or species to over-reach the Retina , while placed in the due focus of the violet ones , and consequently must occasion a sensible confusion in the vision of the former , one and the same point of the Scarlet object affecting several nerves in the Retina .
Yet upon frequent trials I have not been able to perceive any inequality in this point .
2 .
The second Experiment I made in Water .
I took a brass Ruler , and fastening thereunto several pieces of Silk , red , yellow , green , blew and violet , I placed it at the bottom of a square vessel of Water : then I retired from the Vessel so far as not to be able to see the aforesaid Ruler and coloured Silks otherwise than by help of the refracted Ray .
Now , did Mr. Newton 's doctrine hold , I conceived , I should not see all the mentioned Colours in a straight line with the Ruler , in regard the unequal refrangibility of different Rays must needs displace some more than others .
Yet in effect , upon many Trials , I constantly found them in as straight a line as the bare Ruler had appeared in .
3 .
To advance this Experiment , I adjoined a second refraction to the former of the Water , by placing my Prism so as to receive perpendicularly the refracted species of the Silk and Ruler ; whereby only the emergent species suffered a second refraction .
But still with equal success , as to their appearing in a straight line , to the eye placed behind the Prism .
4 .
To these two Refractions I further added a third , by receiving the coloured species obliquely upon the Prism ; whereby both incident and emergent species suffered their respective refractions .
But still with the same success as formerly , as to the straight line they appeared in .
For further assurance in this Experiment , ~ prepossession , occasioned from previous knowledge of the Silks scituation in a straight line , might possibly prejudice the judgment of the eye ( as sometimes I have observed to happen to the judgment the Eye passes upon the distance of Objects ) I called into the room some unconcerned persons , wholly ignorant what the Experiment aimed at ; and demanding whether they saw not the coloured Silks and Ruler in a crooked line ?
they answered in the negative .
5 .
The next Experiment I made in uncompounded Colours ( as Mr. Newton terms them , Prop. 5 &amp; 13 .
) as follows .
Having cast two coloured Images upon the Wall , so as the Scarlet colour of the one did fall in a straight line ( parallel to the Horizon ) with the Violet of the other : I then looked upon both through another Prism , and found them still appear in a straight line parallel to the Horizon , as they had formerly done to the naked eye .
Now according to Mr. Newton 's Assertion of different refrangibility in different Rays , I conceive the Violet rays should suffer a greater refraction in the Prism at the eye , than the Scarlet ones , and consequently both colours should not appear in a straight line parallel to the Horizon .
6 .
Another Experiment I made in order to some further discovery of that surprising Phenomenon of the coloured Image , which occasioned Mr. Newtons ingenious Theory of Light and Colours , as also his excellent invention of the reflecting Telescope and Microscope .
Having then sometimes suspected , that not only the direct Sun-beams , but also other extraneous light might possibly influence the coloured Spectrum , I hoped to discover the truth of this suspicion by means of the Sun-spots , made to appear in the coloured Image by placing a Telescope behind the Prism .
But my endeavours proving ineffectual herein by reason of some intervening difficulties , I thought at length of a more feasible method in order to the designed discovery , as in the following Experiment .
I fastened a very white Paper-circle ( about an inch in diameter ) upon my Window-shuts ; and beholding it through my Prism , I found a Coloured image painted thereby upon my Retina , answerable in almost all respects to the former of the Sun-beams upon the Wall , especially when the Paper-circle was indifferently well illuminated .
This Image indeed appeared contrary to the former as to the scituation of Colours , that is , the Scarlet appearing above , the Violet below , though but faint .
But this I was not surprised at , having observed upon dissecting the eye , that objects are painted on the Retina after a contrary posture to what they appear to Sight .
Having thus rendred the Coloured image much more tractable than formerly it was , I conceived good hopes of some further discovery in the point mentioned .
In pursuance then of my former suspicion , having fixed my Prism in a steady posture , I caused the paper C to be applied close up to the Paper-circle ab d : whereupon the former Violet d , and Scarlet colour of G vanished into whiteness .
Next , I removed the mentioned Circle from the Shuts , and placed it in the open window , supported only by the edge d : whereupon , to my astonishment , all the former Colours exchanged postures in the Retina , the Scarlet now appearing below , the Violet above ; the intermediate Colours scarce discernible .
And here , on the by , it is very remarkable , that , during this Observation , I clearly perceived both Blewand Scarlet-light to be transparent , I being able to discern several objects through both , namely Steeples opposite to my window .
Whence it follows , that these Colours do in great part arise from the neighbouring light .
Lastly , I placed the Paper-circle anew , so as the one half b was fastened to the Shuts , the other semicircle a being exposed to the open Air .
Whereupon the semicircle a became bordered with Violet above , Scarlet below ; but the other semicircle b quite contrary .
Hence I make the following Inferences .
V. Tab. II .
Fig. 5 &amp; 6 .
First , That not only the Light reflected from the Paper-circle , but also from the ambient Air , hath great influence upon the Coloured image , especially as to the Violet and Scarlet colours .
Whence perchance it will not hereafter seem strange , that the coloured Spectrum on the Wall is so long , but only that the breadth is not greater .
Secondly , Were there a more luminous body behind the Sun , we should in all likelihood have the colours of the Spectrum in a contrary scituation to what they appear in at present : Whence ( thirdly ) it seems to follow , that the present scituation and order of Colours , arises not from any intrinsecal property of refrangibility ( as maintained by Mr. Newton ) but from contingent and extrinsecal circumstances of neighbouring objects .
For accordingly as the body behind the Paper-circle was more or less illuminated than the Circle it self , all the several Colours changed their scituation .
8 .
The next Experiment was made in order to Mr. Newtons doctrine of primary Colours , as Prop.5 .
Having covered the Hole in the Window-shuts with a thin slice of Ivory , the transmitted light appeared yellow ; but upon adding three , four , and more slices , it became red .
Whence it seems to follow , that Yellowness of light is not a primary colour , but a compound of Red , &amp;c. 9 .
The last Experiment was made in reference to Mr. Newton 's 12 Prop.where from his own principles he renders a very plausible Reason of a surprising Phenomenon , related by Mr. Hooke ; namely of two liquors , the one Blew , the other Red , both severally transparent , yet both , if placed together , became opake .
The reason whereof , saith Mr. Newton , is , because if one liquor transmitted only Red , the other only Blew , no rays could pass through both .
In reference then to this point , I filled two small Glasses with flat polished bottoms , the one with Aqua fortis , deeply died Blew ; the other with Oil of Turpentine , died Red ; both to that degree , as to represent all objects through them respectively Blew or Red .
Then placing the one upon the other , I was able to discern several bodies through both : whereas acccording to Mr. Newtons Theory , no object should appear through both Liquors ; because if one transmit only Red , the other only Blew , no rays can pass through both .
These Experimental Exceptions will not , I hope , be unwelcome to Mr. Newton , his only aim being the improvement of Natural knowledge , as it is also of , Sir , Your bumble Servant , Anthony Lucas .
Postscript .
Just upon the close of the adjoined Letter , I received from Mr. Gascoine , yours of May the fourth ; wherein you are pleased to favour us with an exact account of the famous Experiment of the coloured Spectrum , lately exhibited before the Royal Society .
I was much rejoiced to see the Trials of that Illustrious Company , agree so exactly with ours here , though in somewhat ours disagree from Mr. Newton , as you will understand by the enclosed impartial account from ,

