A Discourse concerning the Spiral , instead of the supposed Annular , Structure of the Fibres of the Intestins ; discovered and shown by the Learned and Inquisitive Dr. William Cole to the R. Society .
DIscoursing ( near two years since ) with a very ingenious Person , concerning the Mechanical reason of the Peristaltick motion of the Intestines , which is by Anatomists deduced principally from Annular fibres , constituting , according to the received doctrine(with the right fibres immediately investing them , though , by the by , I take these to make a distinct coat ) one of the coats of them ; his sense was ( which he told me was that likewise of some others of his acquaintance ) that they might be rather numerous , though small , Sphincter-muscles , than single fibres , to which that motion is to be attributed ; Muscles being in most , if not all , other instances owned to be the adequate instruments of motions analogous to this ; and fibres , though absolutely necessary , yet being no otherwise so , than as ( a number of them being collected , and fitly disposed ) they constitute a Muscle .
The Conjecture seemed to me more probable than the vulgarly received opinion : but yet ( with all respect to the abettors of either ) several difficulties occurred to me , whether of the two suppositions soever were allowed .
For , first , I conceived it might be doubted ( each of these , whether single fibres , or muscles , being supposed distinct , as I think they generally are , and , if annular , I conceive , must be ) how the actuating matter , or impression ( according to the opinion of some learned men ) should be transmitted from one to another down along the whole tract of the Intestines ; since Natures usual way , for the propagation of Animal motion , is by a Continuation of vessels , ( or at least fibres , whether they be concave or not ) from the part where it begins to that to which it is imparted , either for the conveyance of some actuating substance , or ( according to the other Hypothesis ) the communicating an impression .
But there being , in the Annular supposition , no such continuation of vessels or fibres , a lateral contiguity being all that can be pretended , it might perhaps be urged , that the influent and moving matter ( according to that notion ) might be transmitted by mutual inosculations between the contiguous fibres along their sides ; which , if there be no Communication by vessels , was the only way , I could guess at , to solve the doubt ; for , the notion of an Impression would hardly do the business , since it seemed not evident , that there could be , in that supposition of a Continuity of fibres , tensity enough in the Intestins to carry on such a motion .
But to this I considered , Secondly , That such a supposition seemed not very agreeable to Natures methods , which ordinarily makes use of Vessels ( and those both close , and as direct as the design and organization of the part will bear , ) for the transmission of the fluid substances in the bodies of animals , not lateral emissaries ; except where some great inconvenience is designed to be prevented by the help of such conveyances ; as , for instance , by the Anastomoses , discovered to be between veins and veins , arteries and arteries , in which vessels the blood running with a large and rapid stream , should any of them chance to be obstructed , the Circulation , so necessary to life , must needs be intercepted , without some lateral conveyance of it into others of the same kind : Which inconvenience yet I supposed would hardly be alleged in the present case ; that fabric of those vessels seeming to be designed for extraordinary emergencies , but these being , according to the present supposition , the constant and necessary ducts of this actuating matter .
But nevertheless , Thirdly , Thirdly , It seemed difficult ( to me at least ) to solve this Intestinal contraction , though these lateral apertures were supposed : For , if fibres ( whether considered as single , or as constituting a muscle ) be contracted according to their length from some influent matter , it must be(according to my sense ) from a distension of them in breadth ; and , in order to that , this matter must undergo some consinement in the part to be distended ; but if they have lateral perforations ( and those in the opposite part proportionate to those in that which admits this matter , which must , I conceive , be granted , since the contraction is all along the Intestines proportionate , ) how canit be supposed , a distension ( at least such a one as is here required ) can happen , when the matter designed to effect it has so ready a passage forth , especially its determination from the impelling cause being in right lines downward ?
If it were objected , that the motion of this substance might be supposed to be lateral as well as direct , in regard there would be a passage for it into the fibres as well as through the Anastomoses , and that in proportion larger than through these , whence nothing seems to hinder but that a distension of them might follow ; I supposed , it might be replied , that , by reason of such a distorsion of part of the impelled matter , it seems , that the impressed motion would be soon lost ( according to the laws of motion ) unless the impelling cause were more violent than I see reason in this case to imagine it to be .
But indeed I think , no Anatomists have observed , that muscles ( supposing these such ) receive their actuating matter in at their sides , or , when their motion ceases , send it forth that way ; but all , so far as has been observed , are senced with a considerably compact , and ( comparatively ) impervious membrane .
Fourthly , I considered , that all muscles are observed to have two tendons , one at each extremity , by the approach of one whereof toward the other , its motion , which is contraction , is performed ; but it seems hard to conceive , that these tendons should coincide ( as in this supposition they must ) and , if they do , I presumed it would be difficult to determine , what part of these circular muscles ( if such ) the tendons are , and where the motion should begin in each ; it being observed , that all muscles are sastned to some , either simply or comparatively , unmovable part , toward which ( ordinarily ) they move , and by which the instinct of motion is from the nerves conveyed to them : But no Anatomists , ( so far as I had observed ) having discovered , that any one part of these muscles , or moving fibres , whichsoever they be , has any stricter cohesion than other with any of the adjacent parts , I conceived , I might be allow 'd the liberty to doubt of the Hypothesis , especially if I could satisfy my self better by another .
For instead of these solutions there occurred to my thoughts a third way , which ( provided experience would countenance it ) seemed more mechanically adjusted to solve the Phenomenon ; viz. That those fibres , which have been esteemed annular , might perhaps be spiral , and so be continued down in one tract to the lowest extremity of the intestines ; withal , that their sinalness , compared with the compass they setch about the intestine , might very easily , I conceived , impose upon any , who made not those reflections , or tried not to unravel them ; their declination being , for that reason , not easily discernible : Which if true , it seemed probable to me , that when either a bare motion shall be impressed on them at their beginning , or any substance impelled into them , they being to be supposed in statu naturali moderatly tense , so long as the moving cause continues , the motion must be successively continued all along their tracts , and , that being in ambitum , must therefore , whilst it lasts , by abbreviating these fibres , straiten the intestine , and so thrust forward what is contained in it , especially if they proved to have a muscular fabric .
The conjecture as it was not disrelished by the person to whom I proposed it , so gratisied me the more for the seeming easiness of the performance ; Nature 's operations being the most easy and simple that can be imagined , though for that reason very often , I doubt , overlooked .
But the notion lay afterward long dormant , till , about half a year since , being revived by I know not what occasion , I considered it was too unphilosophical to acquiesce in bare speculation , when autopsy might be consulted ; and therefore I set upon the experiment , which I first made in a portion in the upper intestines of an Ox , which , by reason of their largeness of proportion to those of most other species of animals , seemed fittest for the trial ; afterwards in those of Sheep and Calves , beside the repetition of it in Oxen , and not only in the smaller intestines , but in the colon and caecum also .
The circumstances and result of which trials are as follows .
To effect a due disjunction of the membranes and fibres ( which I found it was hard , if not impossible , for me to make while it was raw , ) I was sain to cause the intestine of Oxen to be boiled 5 or 6 hours , of Sheep 4 ; whereby the compages of the parts was so loosned , that the two outward coats , viz.the common one , and that consisting of right fibres were easily separated ( if it were attempted soon after it was taken out of the water ) from that to which my search was destined , and lest those reputed annular ones naked ; ( though , by the way , too long coction would prove prejudicial on the other hand , by too much intenerating the fibres .
) These at the top of the intestine I attempted to separate from one another ; and when those , which had been decurtated by the unequal cutting of the knife , were taken off , I found , First , that I could not separate a single fibre from his fellows to any considerable distance , all of them ( to my observation ) being very small , and in the separation running smaller and smaller , and withal by reason of their implication or stricter cohesion one with another easily breaking ; but a congeries of them ( to be observed especially , though not precisely always , in those places , where by gently extending the intestines several times , and then letting it return again , the cohesion of the several series of them became loosned)which at first view would resemble a pretty large fibre , would without much difficulty rise together ; the very small constituting fibres of which clusters yet , if the boiling had been very long continued , whereby the compages was very much relaxed , would in the raising be very apt to separate from one another , and appear distinct , by reason of their insertions , by and by to be mentioned .
Secondly , that when , beginning at the top , I attempted the separation of one of these ( supposed annular ) clusters of fibres towards my right hand ( on that side of the intestine , I mean , which was turned towards me ) a whole ring would come off together , ( excepting that some fibrillae , which , rising from contrary parts , decussated one another at the top in that phasis , would a little retain it ) which at first staggered me as to my forementioned conjecture ; but endeavouring it towards my left , I found , for the most part , I could easily enough unravel that cluster to a considerable length , viz.that of sometimes more than two or three spans , before ruption ( of the whole cluster I mean , ) which yet at last 'twould be subject to .
For , Thirdly , though those convolutions , as to the greatest part of them appeared distinct , yet I found , that from every one of them at short distances some fibres did obliquely , and the most of them , to my best observation , according to the course of those I have mentioned , insert themselves into the next convolution , and become a part of it ; though withal some I observed to have a contrary ten dency , or rather seemed to ascend from the lower to the upper convolution , and help to constitute it , and so to observe the course mentioned ; nay , sometimes would go farther than the next convolution , and , running under it , apply themselves obliquely to some higher , which yet being in a smaller number than the rest that lay in the order contrary to them , did not very much hinder the dissociation of the main ones : which fibres breaking off , and that in some places in greater numbers than in others , would at last ( and the sooner if the intestine began to grow dry , which 'twould quickly do ) cause the whole cluster to break off .
Fourthly , I observed , that as the most of these fibres would by degrees according to the order of the convolutions , insert themselves into the next , so some of them would ( in the same order ) pass over it , and more ( so far as I have observed ) would run under it , and either adjoin themselves to some more remote , or elude my searching by hiding themselves under them .
This insertion of these fibres seems to be the reason of the annular phasis , that I mentioned even now , in the contrary way of separation : For , the attempting it contrary to their order , must hinder in some measure the ready dissociation of the next convolutions upwards ; especially near the severed extremity , where there is less resistance of the adjacent parts ; the mentioned fibres also seeming somewhat bigger , and consequently stronger , in the upper , than after their insertion into the lower convolution : Though indeed Fifthly , I found , that if I began at a lower part of the intestine , and tried to unravel upwards , there was not much more difficulty in so doing , than when beginning above , I attempted it downwards ; of which the reason , I suppose , might be the tenderness of the part occasioned by long boiling , whereby I could not perhaps judge of the degrees of renitency in those small fibres .
In this contrary way of separation too , the operation , I observed , would not succeed , unless I attempted it in the contrary order , viz.towards my right hand .
Sixthly , when before boiling I caused the inside of the intestine to be turned outward , as I did in two trials , and afterward by taking off the glandulous and vascular coats(which I think to be distinct from one another , as I said before of those consisting of right fibres , and the supposed annular ones , )endeavoured to unravel the fibres , I found they would come off in the contrary order , viz. from my left hand toward my right ; which , I conceive , confirms the observation above delivered , in regard the intestine being inverted , the order of separation must be so too ; though I found(or thought ) the operation more difficult , by reason of some fibres lying in the opposite order ( mentioned under the third particular ) and in this appearance lying uppermost .
Seventhly , in one of these attempts of unravelling the fibres of the intestine of an Ox , so inverted , I found , that though the fibres I took up came off in the order I just now mentioned , yet running over some others , they made a more oblique excursion , and for two or three convolutions left betwixt them a considerable area of fibres , amounting ( according to my conjecture ) to five or six times , or more , the breadth of those that so came off , till going deeper and deeper among the other fibres , and at last running under them , they could be no longer traced , but brake off .
Whether this be usual , or only luses naturae , I cannot determine .
Eightly , I found it much more difficult ( in that one trial I made ) to unravel the fibres of the Caecum , than the other intestine , which seemed more interwoven than those of the rest , and to have contrary tendencies one among another .
This is the sum of my observations hitherto concerning this coat , which I take leave to think one concave and Helical muscle(if I may so style it : ) And that it might be supposed such , the forementioned insertions seemed to evidence , they appearing to me in the separating appositely enough to represent the fabric of a muscle delivered by the accurate Steno .
Where the tendons of it are fixed , is not evident ; but , if I may have the liberty to conjecture , I should think the upper of them to be radicated ( at least ) at the pylorus ( if not as high as the sphincter gulae ( if this be not it , ) since , the carneous coat of the stomach being by the Learned Dr. Willis found to be a muscular contexture , and there being a continuation of motion between that part and the intestines , it seems to me not altogether improbable they may be but one muscle ; and the other at the anus .
Whether the supposed annular fibres of the veins and arteries may not have the same fabric as those of the Intestines , since both these kinds of vessels seem to have a peristaltick contraction of their own , and not to be bare conduit-pipes to transmit the impelled blood , I propose to be considered and examined by persons of more acute hands and judgment ; as I do all what I have here delivered , not daring too much to trust even the informations of my own hands and eyes , till I find them confirmed by those of others , more judicious as well as dextrous in making experiments .

