A particular Answer of Mr. Isaak Newton to Mr. Linus his Letter , printed in Numb. 121 .
p.499 .
about an Experiment relating to the New Doctrine of Light and Colours : This Answer sent from Cambridge in a Letter to the Publisher Febr. 29 .
1675/ 6 .
Sir , BY reading Mr. Linus 's Letter when you showed it to meat London , I retained only a general remembrance , that Mr. Linus denied what I affirmed , and so could lately say nothing in particular to it ; but having the opportunity to read it again in Numb. 121 .
of the Transactions , I perceive he would persuade you , that the information you gave him about the Experiment is as inconsistent with my printed Letters as with experience ; and therefore , left any who have not read those Letters should take my silence in this point for an acknowledgment , I thought it not amiss , to send you something in answer to this also .
He tells you that , Where as you assure him , First , that the Experiment was made in clear days ; secondly , that the Prism was placed close to the hole , so that the light had no room to diverge ; and thirdly , that the Image was not parallel but transverse to the axis of the Prism : If these Assertions be compared with my Relation of the Experiment in the Phil. Transaction N. 80 .
p. 3076 .
it will evidently appear , they cannot be admitted as being directly contrary to what is there delivered .
His reasons are these : First , that I said , the ends of the long Image seemed semicircular , which , says he , never happens in any of the three cases above said .
But this is not to set me at odds with my self , but with the experiment ; for it is there described to happen in them all ; and I still say , it doth happen in them .
Let others try the Experiment , and judge .
Further he says , that the Prism is placed at a distance from the hole in the Scheme of the Experiment in N. 84 .
p 4091 .
But , what it it were so there ?
For , that is the Scheme of a demonstration , not of the experiment , and would have served for the demonstration , had the distance been put twenty times greater than it is .
In the Schemes of the Experiment N. 80 .
p. 3086 , and N. 82 .
p. 5016 .
it is represented close , and close enough in the Scheme , N. 83 .
p. 4061 : But Mr. Linus thought sit to wink at these , and pitch upon the Scheme of a Demonstration , and such a Scheme too as hath no hole at all represented in it .
For , the Scheme ~ Numb. 84 .
p. 491 is this ; A Fig. 1BI Fig. 2 .
n xGH Lm C in which the rays are not so far distant from one another at G L , but that the hole , had I expressed it , might have been put there , and yet have comprehended them .
But if we should put the hole at x , their decussation ; yet will it not be any thing to his OO purpose ; the distance xG or xL being but about half the breadth of a side of the Prism ( 1/ 2AC ) ~ h. I~ h. I 4.49 5.48~ which I conceive is not the twentieth part of the distance requisite in his conjecture , Thirdly , 3 .
He says , that more might be said out of my relation to show , that the Image was not transvers , for if it had been transvers , I could not have been surprised ( as I said I was ) to see the length thereof so much exceed the breadth , it being a thing so obvious &amp; easy to be explicated by the ordinary rules of Refraction .
But on the contrary , it may rather be said , that if the Image had been parallel , I could not have been surprised to see the length thereof so much exceed the breadth , it being a thing so extremely obvious as not to need any explication .
For who that had but common sense , and saw the whole Prism or a good part of it illuminated , could not expect the ligh should have the same long figure upon the wall that it had when it came out of the Prism ?
Mr. Linus therefore , while he would strengthen his argument by representing me well skilled in Opticks , does but overthrow it .
But whereas he says , I could not have been surprised at the length , had the Image been parallel , it being a thing so obvious and easy to be explicated by the ordinary rules of refraction : Let any Man take the Experiment entire as I have there delivered it , that is , with this condition , that the refractions on both sides the Prism were equal , and try if he can reconcile it with the ordinary rules of refraction .
On the contrary , he may find the impossibility of such a reconciliation , demonstrated in my Answer to P. Pardies N. 84 , p 4091 .
In the last place , he objects , that my saying in N. 80 .
p. 3077 , that the incident refractions were in the Experiment equal to the emergent , proves again , that the long image was parallel .
And yet that very saying is a sufficient argument , that I meant the contrary , because it becomes wholly impertinent , if applied to a parallelimage ; but in the o her case is a very necessary circumstance .
What is added therefore of P. Pardies , might have been spared , especially since that Learned Person understood my discourse to be meant of a transvers Image , and acquiesced in my Answers .
This in answer to Mr. Linus 's Letter : And now to take away the like suspicions from his Friends , if my declaration of my meaning satisfy not , I shall note some further passages in my Letters , whereby they may see , how I was to be understood from the beginning , as to the aforesaid three circumstances .
For the Day ; I express every where that the Experiment was tried in the Sun 's light , and in N. 80 .
p. 3077 , that the breadth of the Image by measure answered to the Sun 's diameter : But because it is pretended , I was imposed upon , I would ask , what the Experiment as it is advanced to that which I called the Experimentum tum Crucis , can have to do with a cloudy day ?
For , if the Experimentum Crucis ( which is that which I depend on ) can have nothing to do with a cloudy day , then is it to no purpose to talk of a cloudy day in the first Experiment , which does but lead on to that .
But if this satisfy not , let the Transactions N. 83 .
p. 4060 , beconsulted : For .
there I tell you , how by applying a Lens to the Prism , the straight edges of the oblong Image became distincter than they would have been without the Lens : A circumstance which cannot happen in Mr. Linus 's case of a bright Cloud .
For the Position of the Prism ; I tell you N.80 .
p.3076 , that it was placed at the Sun 's entrance into the Chamber , and in p.3085.I bad to make a hole in the shut , and there place the Prism , and in the next page I say again , that the Prism ABC is to be set close by the hole F of the window EG ; and accordingly represent it close in the Figure .
Also in page .
3077 I tell you , that the distance of the Image from the hole or prism was 22 foot ; which is as much as to say , that the Prism ( suppose that side of it next the hole ) was as far from the Image as the hole it self was , and consequently that the Prism and Hole were contiguous .
Also in p.3078 , where instead of the Window shut I made use of a hole in a loose board , I tell you expressly , that I placed the board close behind the Prism .
All these passages are in my very first Letter about Colours ; and who therefore would imagine , that any one that had read that Letter should so much as suspect , that I placed the Prism , I say not at so great a distance as Mr. Linus supposes , but at any distance worth considering ?
Lastly , for the Position of the Image , it is represented transvers to the axis of the Prism in the figures N.80.p.3086 .
N.83.p.4061 , and N.85.p.5016 .
And in N.88.p.5093 , where I made use of two cross Prisms , I tell you expressly , that the Image was cross to both of them at an angle of 45 degrees .
The calculations also N. 80.p .
3077 .
are not to be understood without supposing the Image cross .
Nor are my notions about different Refrangibility otherwise intelligible : For in Mr. Linus 's supposition , the rays that go to the two ends of the Image , are equally refracted .
So for colours , the red , according to my description , falls at one end of the Image , and the blew at the other ; which cannot happen but in a transvers Image .
The same position is also demonstrable from what I said in N. 80 .
p. 3076 , about turning the long Image into a round one , by the contrary refraction of a second Prism , further explained in Num. 83 .
p. 4061 .
For this is not to be done in Mr. Linus surmise of a parallel Image , and therefore had Mr. Linus considered it , he could never have run into that surmise .
This I suppose is enough to manifest the three particulars ; any one of which being evidenced , is sufficient to take away the scruple .
And therefore Mr. Linus Friends need not fear but that the further directions I sent them lately for trying the Experiment are the same with those I have follow 'd from the beginning ; nor trouble themselves about any thing but to try the Experiment right .
But yet , because Mr. Gascoin has been pleased to insinuate his suspicion that I do differ from himself in those directions , I shall not scruple here to reduce them into particulars , and show where each particular is to be found .
1 .
Then , he is to get aPrism with an angle about 60 or 65 degrees , N. 80 .
p. 3077 , and p. 3086 .
If the angle be about 63 degrees , as that was which I made use of N. 80 .
p. 3077 , he will find all things succeed exactly as I described them there .
But if it be bigger or ~ , as 30 , 40 , 50 , or 70 degrees , the Refraction will be accordingly bigger or less , and consequently the Image longer or shorter .
If his Prism be pretty nearly equilateral ( such as I suppose are usually sold in other places as well as in England ) he may make use of the biggest angle .
But he must be sure to place the Prism so , that the Refraction be made by the two planes which comprehend this angle .
I could almost suspect , by considering some circumstances in Mr. Linus 's Letter , that his error was in this point , he expecting the Image should become as long by a little refraction as by a great one ; which yet being too gross an error to be suspected of any Optician , I say nothing of it , but only hint this to Mr. Gascoin , that he may examine all things .
2 .
Having such a Prism , he must place it so , that its Axis be perpendicular to the rays N. 84 , p. 4091 , lin. 18 , 19 .
A little error in this point makes no sensible variation of the effect .
3 .
The Prism must be so placed , that the Refractions on both sides be equal N. 80 , p. 3077 : which how it was to be readily done by turning it about its Axis , and staying it when you see the Image rest between too contrary motions , as I explained in my late Descriptions , so I hinted before N.80.p.3077 , lin. 34,35 , 36 .
If there should be a little error in this point also , it can do no hurt .
4 .
The Diameter of the hole I put 1/ 4 of an inch N. 80 , p. 3077 , and placed the Prism close to it , even so close as to be contiguous , N. 80 , p. 3077 , lin. 4 , 5 .
But yet there needs no curiosity in these circumstances .
The hole may be of any other bigness , and the Prism at a distance from the hole , , provided things be so ordered , that the light appear of a round form , if intercepted perpendicularly at its coming out of the Prism .
Nor needs there any curiosity in the day .
The clearer it is the better ; but if it be a little cloudy , that cannot much prejudice the Experiment , so the Sun do but shine distinctly through the cloud .
These things being thus ordered , if the refracted light fall perpendicularly on a wall or paper at 20 foot or more from the Prism , it will appear in an oblong form , cross to the axis of the Prism , red at one end , and violet at the other ; the length five times the breadth ( more or less according to the quantity of the refraction , ) the sides , straight lines , parallel to one another , and the ends confused , but yet seeming semi-circular .
I hope therefore , Mr. Linu 's Friends will not entertain themselves any further about incongruous surmises , but try the Experiment as Mr. Gascoin has promised .
And then , since Mr. Gascoin tells you , That the Experiment being of it self extraordinary and surprising , and besides ushering in new Principles into Opticks , quite contrary to the common and received , it will be hard to per swade it as a truth , till it be made so visible to all as it were a shame to deny it : if he esteem it so extraordinary , he may have the privilege of making it so visible to all , that it will be a shame to deny it .
For , I dare say , after his testimony no body else will scruple it .
And I make no question but he will hit of it , it being so plain and easy , that I am very much at a loss to imagine what way Mr. Linus took to miss .
Dat .
Cambridge Feb. 29 .
1675/ 6 .
An Extract of a Latin Letter of Signor Cassini , containing both his Considerations upon Mr. Flamsteed 's account of the Lunar Eclipse of Decemb.21 .
1675 ~ , and his own Observati ons of the same Eclipse .
~ See N. 121 , p. 495.of these

