A Letter of Mr. Franc .
Linus , written to the Publisher from Liege the 25th of Febr.1675 .
st.n .
being a Reply to the Letter printed in Numb. 110 .
by way of Answer to a former Letter of the same Mr. Linus , concerning Mr. Isaac Newton 's Theory of Light and Colours .
Honoured Sir , IN yours of Dec. 17 .
which I received about the end of Jan you say , I may rest assured , First , that the Experiment was made in clear days .
Secondly , that the Prism was placed close to the hole , so that the light had no room to diverge : And thirdly , that the Image was not Parallel ( as I conjectured ) but Transverse to the Axis of the Prism .
Truly , Sir , if these Assertions be admitted , they do indeed directly cut off what I said of Mr. Newton 's being deceived by a bright cloud .
But if we compare them with Mr. Newton 's Relation of the Experiment in the Phil. Transactions , N. 80 p.3076 .
it will evidently appear , they cannot be admitted as being directly contrary to what is there delivered .
For there he tells us , the ends of the coloured Image , he saw on the opposite wall , near five times as long as broad , seemed to be Semicircular .
Now these Semicircular Ends are never seen in a clear day , as Experience shows .
From whence follows against the first Assertion , That the Experiment was not made in a clear day .
Neither are those Semicircular Ends ever seen , when the Prism is placed close to the Hole ; which contradicts the second Assertion .
Neither are they ever seen , when the Image is Transverse to the length or Axis of the Prism ; which directly opposes the third Assertion .
But if in any of these three Cases , the Image be made so much longer than broad ( as easily it may , by turning the Prism a little about its Axis ) near five times as long as broad , than the one End thereof will run out into a sharp Cone or Pyramis like the flame of a Candle , and the other into a Cone somewhat more blunt ; both which are far from seeming Semicircular : Whereas , if the Image be made not in a clear day , but with a bright cloud , and the Prism not placed close to the Hole , but in a competent distance from the same ( as you see it placed in the Scheme of the Experiment in N.84 .
p. 4091 .
) then these Semicircular Ends always appear with the sides thereof straight lines just as Mr. Newton there describes them .
Neither is the length of the Image Transverse , but Parallel to the length of the Prism .
Out of all which evidently follows , that the Experiment was not made in a clear day ; nor with the Prism close to the Hole ; nor yet with the Image Transverse(as is now affirmed , ) but by a bright Cloud , and a Parallel Image ( as I conjectured ; ) and I hope you will also now say , I had good reason so to conjecture , since it so well agrees with the Relation .
And Experience will also show you , if you please to make trial , as it was made , in a dark Chamber , and observe the difference between such an Image made by a bright Cloud , and another made by the immediate rays of the Sun : For , the former you shall always find Parallel , with the Ends Semicircular ; but the latter you shall find Transverse , with the Ends Pyramidical , as aforesaid , whenever it appears so much longer than broad .
More might be said out of the same Relation , to show that the Image was not Transverse .
For , if it had been Transverse , Mr. Newton , so well skilled in Opticks , could not have been surprised ( as he says he was ) to see the length thereof so much to exceed the breadth ; it being a thing so obvious and easy to be explicated by the ordinary Rules of Refraction .
That other place also , in the next page 3077.(where he says , the Incident Refractions were made in the Experiment equal to the Emergent , ) proves again that the said oblong Image was not Transverse , but Parallel .
For it is impossible , the Transverse Image should be so much longer than broad , unless those two Refractions be made very unequal , as both the computation according to the common Rules of Refraction , and Experience testifies .
Wherefore Mr. Newton had no reason to tax ( in page .4091 .
) P. Pardies of Hallucination , for making in page 4088 .
those two Refractions very unequal : For , that learned Optike very well saw , that in a clear day so great an inequality of length and breadth could not be made , unless those two Refractions were also made very unequal .
These places , I say , might be added to the former , and further here explicated if need were ; but there being no need , I cease to detain you any longer herein .

