Mr. Flamsteads Letter of July 24 .
1675 .
to the Publisher , relating to another , printed in Num. 110 .
of these Tracts , concerning M. Horroxes Lunar Systeme .
I Have never before troubled you on the like occasion , which makes me hope , you will pardon this , which I write with no small reluctance .
: Nor had I now adventured to concern you with it , if I had not found it frequently the subject of the Transactions , to vindicate good Inventions to their proper Authors .
The vulgarly received Lunar Systemes , though as little agreeable to Nature , as the Heavens , were entertained from one Astronomer to another with little alterations , from the Noble Tycho to the Author of the Caroline Tables : But when I had found by many curious and careful measures of the Moons diameters , that the Heavens would never admit those Hypotheses , which made the diameter of the Perigeon-Moon in the Quadratures larger than the Full Moon on the Perigee ; and that only the Systeme of Mr. Horrox , which I had found in Mr. Crabtrees letters , would represent it as observed broadest at Full ; and afterwards that it would accord well with some Observations to which the Vulgar Tables agreed not within 1/ 5 of a degree : I thought , it might be worth my labour to adorn it with Numbers , that it might be fit for trial , as soon as it appeared in public ; to which I added an explication to be found in the Edition of his posthumous works .
This Systeme has been well approved of by several good Astronomers , and Mr. Street has esteemed it so good , that he has printed a figure of it with the description of his Planetary instrument ; but without acknowledging the proper Author , or so much as naming him more then once , and then in such terms , as may persuade any person not well acquainted with Mr. Horrox his works , that he was but some inconsiderable Astronomer , and Mr. Streets print a clear different Systeme .
All , faith he , being somewhat different from the limitations of the Theory of Horrox and Tables therewith ~ .
This obliged me when I found it only different in the position of the Libratory circle , to take notice of it in a letter to Mr. Collins , from whom you received the information , and with my consent printed the extract of it : In which I designed nothing but to assert to the dead an Invention , which he esteemed the best he ever lighted upon , and which , questionless , is the chief of his Monuments : This had I neglected , I had been unjust to the dead , whose papers passed through my hands to the Public ; nor have , I hope , been at all injurious to Mr. Street in it , as may appear by my Letter , if considered by any uninteressed person .
For , my assertion concerning his figure of the Lunar Systeme was , that the contrivance of it , for the Motion of Longitude , was no other then what was taken from Mr. Horrox 's Theory and my Explication ; whereby I conceive no man would understand me of his Numbers , since I never mentioned them , and he has published none , but course Mean motions , with a little Table or two for finding the Latitude ; but I took notice , that the form was the same , and the Excentricity varied , the Reflection or Variation altered in the same proportion as in the Horroxian Theory ; which that they are , I suppose he will not be so disingenious to deny , since it will be manifestly evident to any that will be at the pains to compare his print with the 116 and 117 Schemes , belonging to my Explication : After which I know not what he has , that he may call his own , or that can entitle him to this Systeme .
Perhaps he will say , he has transferred the Libratory Circle from the Orbis magnus to the transverse diameter of the Ellipsis .
But this is not material , since the effect is still the same ; and supposing the same diameter of the Libratory circle , the same AEquations will be found to a second : So that hereby he only has gained a pretext to call the Systeme his own , but he has rendred the Case of the Libration less intelligible .
He adds , that he has increased the quantity of the greatest Libration 22~ min. so that the semidiameter of the little circle , that shows the variation , may subtend the greater AEquation of the Apogee , the mean excentricity being Radius .
This indeed is an ingenious conceit ; yet amounts it to no more , than an alteration ; which whether the Heavens will admit of , we may justly question .
I find by Mr. Horroxes papers , that he used at first 12~ precise , but upon ~ experience diminished it to 11~ .
48~ .
This is all the ~ difference betwixt Mr. Streets print and the Horroxian System ; for which whether he may justly call it his own , and charge me with untruths for denying it , I leave to such persons as are skilled in the Lunar Theory to judge .
But , for my own part , I think , he has no more title to it , than Monsieur Duret had to the invention of the Elliptical Hypothesis , because he published it and the Rudolphine Tables in a better form , reduced to the Meridian of Paris ; which he confesses in the title page of his Richeleian Tables ; whose Ingenuity had Mr. Street imitated , he had done but justice to the memory of the dead , and saved me the trouble of this letter .
But the main part of his defence is , that his Numbers are not the same with those published with the Horroxian Theory , and therefore the Systeme not the same .
I argue not how illogical the inference is ; but how little ingenious , you may judge , in that he has published none but the aforementioned course ones , so that for the Excencricity and Variation we must believe him gratis : Besides , it is not at all material ; for I affirmed nothing concerning his Numbers at all , but the form or Contrivance of the Lunar plate , which he has not nor can make appear to be any other than the Horroxian Systeme a little altered ; but we may justly doubt , whether or no amended .
Nor is it pertinent what he says concerning the working of proportions in Triangles Mechanically .
If he knew , how to do it , before me , no less did others much longer before him ; nor am I at all beholding to him for this skill : But if he prefers calculations before it , to what purpose is this print of the Lunar plate or his contention about it ?
I might add , what besides he is beholding to Mr. Horrox for , which he has scarce acknowledged ; but I will forbear , not only to give him no cause of further controversy , but also that I may no further trouble you , till I have a better and more grateful occasion , Sir , I am your Servant John Flamstead .

