Dr. Wallis 's Answer to the foregoing Animadversions , directed in a Letter to the Publisher , March 19 .
1662/ 70 .
SIR , Yours with the enclosed Animadversions of M. Childrey on my Hypothesis of Tides , came so late to hand on Thursday last ( when the Post was almost ready to be gone ) that I had not time , by that Post , to give you an account of them .
And it is not much , I need to say now ; for I do not find , that he and I are like much to disagree .
That the Winds have a great influence on the Tides of particular Coasts and Havens , according as they are more or less stiff or slack , and blow from this or that part , I do not at all question ; but did always take for granted , as generally received , and upon good grounds .
And the like I say of Land waters ; which ( though as to the Sea they signify not much in this point ) are , as to In-land Rivers , very considerable ; especially as to Inundations upon rising of the Water : Which is rather by Checking than Promoting the Tides .
For certainly , these Land-waters , meeting the Tide of Flood , do hinder it from coming so far up the River as otherwise it would ; and consequently , if , notwithstanding such Landflouds , flouds , the Tide flow higher up the River than at other times , this must be derived from some other cause .
But , that the Tide and Land-floud should jointly make a greater Inundation than either singly would have done , is not to be doubted .
But he need not wonder , that in my Essay , though I grant both these , I said so little of either , because it was wholly beside my business ; which was , to give a Statical account of Stated Periods ( Diurnal , Menstrual , Annual , ) arising from Regular Motions ; not , of Accidental Extravagances , such as these are : And therefore I did , in the beginning of that Discourse preclude the Consideration of the Advantage or Disadvantage , which should arise from such uncertain Contingences , as Extrinsecal to that business .
His third thing suggested , The Moon 's Perigaeosis ; is so far from being contrary to my Hypothesis , that it is a great Part of it .
And ( if I do not much mis-remember , )it is , in one of my Letters to you , expressly mentioned assuch .
But forasmuch as it doth not still fall out at the same time of the Day , Month , or Year , I could not make it a Component of any of those noted Periods , Diurnal , Menstrual or Annual ; ( and of more Periods than these , I did not know that there hath been any general notice taken , of which I might think my self obliged to give an account : ) but it may very well influence any or all of those , according as it falls out advantageous or disadvantageous for them .
And as I do so readily concur with him in all the particulars by him suggested ; so I think he will not be difficult in assenting to all the Materials of my Hypothesis .
The account which I give of the Diurnal and Menstrual Periods ( from the Common Center of Gravity of the Earth and Moon , ) he doth allow as very Rational : And consequently ( which is the Foundation of it , ) that any Acceleration or Retardation of the Compound motion of the particular parts in the Earth 's Surface , is to give such an Accumulation of waters as causes a Tide ; and the Complication of such Accelerations and Retardations , concurring or interfering one with another , doth occasion the perplex Varieties in them : Of which therefore there is no clear account to be given , without considering severally the proper Effects of each , from whence doth result the Compound Effect of all together .
Now as to the two most signal motions of the Earth , the DiurB b2 nal nal and Annual ; if we suppose them each in themselves Equal , and both perfectly circular and upon Parallel Axes , though neither of them , singly considered , would give an Inequality of motion ; yet the compound of both together , being swiftest at Midnight and slowest at Noon , ( because the compound of both is , in that , the Aggregate , in this , the difference of them ) would give us two Tides in each Diurnal Revolution : But those always at Noon , and Mid-night .
If to these we add the Menstrual , whereby the Earth describes a small Epicycle about the Common Center of Gravity of the Earth and Moon ; and suppose this also Equal in it self , and Circular , about an Axe parallel to the rest : neither would this , of it self , give any Inequality ; but , compounded with the rest , it will .
For , this compounded with the Annual , doth , at the New Moon , increase ; at the Full , abate of that motion , as to all parts of the Earth 's Surface : But compounded with the Diurnal ( which , in this case , is much the more considerable , as recurring every day , ) it doth most add to , or abate of , that motion , as to each particular place of the Earth 's Surface , when the Moon is in the Meridian of that place , below or above the Horizon ; and would therefore , at those times , give us two Tides .
( For which , and other particulars of like nature , that they may be the better apprehended , I refer my self to the Inspection of the Schemes pertaining to my Hypothesis .
) Now because this coming of the Moon to the Meridian , above and below the Horizon , or ( as Sea men call it ) the Moon 's Southing and Northing , doth , in a Month 's time , pass round the whole circle of 24 hours ; hence it comes to pass , that the time of the Tides doth so also : Which I take to be the true Account of the Menstrual period .
And because this Composition of the Menstrual with the Diurnal ( which seems by the Effect to be most predominant , though not to extinguish the other , ) casts the time at the Moon 's being in the Meridian ; and that of the Annual and Diurnal , when the Sun is in the Meridian : When both these happen at the same time , as at the Full and Change of the Moon ; the Tides must needs be the greater : Which I take to be the true Account of the Spring-Tydes , and Neap-Tydes .
And thus far ( which is the main of my Hypothesis , ) he concurs with me , as having given at least a very Rational and Probable Account .
If therefore there be no other Periods of Tides but these ; or no other remarkable , my work is done , and I need not be further solicitous : For , then there will seem to be either no other inequality of motions , or none considerable .
But , if there be also observable an Annual period , ( as very many think there is ; ) or any other such period , ( as perhaps there may be , ) then are we to seek for the Cause thereof in somewhat of Inequality , which doth ( for the Annual Period ) Annually recur ; or ( for any other Period , ) which doth recur in such a time as that other Period doth require .
Now forasmuch as the three Motions above mentioned are neither ( as was above supposed ) each Equal in it self , or perfectly Circular , nor all on Parallel Axes ; there is , both as to the Sun , and as to the Moon , at least a double Inequality ; the one , by reason of the Excentricity , and ( which depends thereon ) the Apogaeum and Perigaeum ; the other , by reason of the Obliquity of the Zodiac and the Moon 's Orbite , with the AEquinoctial , and with each other .
From every of which doth proceed some little Inequality of Motion in the Earth 's Surface : But whether so much as to make any remarkable alteration in the Tides , is hardly determinable than by observation .
Now for that of the Moon , both as to its Apogaeum and Perigaeum , ( with the Inequality of Motion depending on it ; ) and as to the Obliquity of its Orb both with the Zodiac and the AEquator ( which causes another Inequality both in the Motion of Longitude and Right Ascension , ) I have hitherto contented my self to insinuate it , in one of my Letters on this subject , without further insisting on it ; because I did not know of any Periodical Vicissitude of Tides consonant thereunto .
When any such shall be discovered , we have here a Foundation ready for the Salving of it .
But as to any Annual Vicissitude , it is not ofuse , because it doth not Annually recur .
But , because it hath been almost generally received , That there is an Observable Annual Period ; I did , for the salving of that , apply not the Inequality of the Natural Days , but those causes from whence that proceeds , the Excentricity of the Sun or Earth 's Orb , and the Obliquity of the Zodiac .
The former of these , if singly considered , would cast those Annual Tides in June and December ( the times of the Sun 's Apogaeum and Perigaeum , or rather the Earth 's Aphelium and Perielium , when are the slowest and the swistest Annual motions in the Zodiac : ) the latter , if considered alone , would cast them upon the two AEquinoxes , and the two Solstices , ( the times of the Least and of the Greatest Right Ascensions : ) But if both be jointly considered , they must cast these ( as they do the greatest Inequality of the Natural days ) at some intermediat times , between the Autumnal AEquinox in September , and the Perigaeum in December ; and again , between this Perigaeum , and the following Vernal AEquinox in March : As is more than probable ( without the trouble of any new computation ) from the greatest Inequality of the Natural Days , arising from the same causes : But whether precisely at the same time with that Inequality , or whether in all parts of the world at any one time , I do not undertake there to determine ; but rather believe the contrary , because the different Position of places may very much alter the Influence of both or either Causes .
I did only mention , as a thing very notorious , that it doth so constantly fall out on the coasts of Kent ; and particularly of Rumney marsh , about Allhallontide and Candlemas .
This Account of the Annual Vicissitude is that only , to which M. Childrey doth except ; opposing first , the Judgement of Seamen ( more considerable than that of the Inhabitants of Rumney Marsh , ) who use to say , either that the time of the year signifies nothing ; or , if at all , it is about the AEquinoxes .
Then , that if this be the cause , it will be constant , and that in February as well as in November .
And thirdly , that the Seamen about Weymouth have not observed any thing signal about those Times .
To the first , I answer ; if not then , but at the AEquinoxes , then so much of the Hypothesis as concerns the Excentricity may be spared , ( or allowed to be so little as not to be remarkable ; ) and that of the Obliquity alone will give a sufficient account of it .
Or if ( to which he seems rather to incline , ) there be no such Annual Vicissitudes at all ; then may that of the Obliquity be spared also , and the Hypothesis perfect without it .
And , till some such be observed and acknowledged , it will be sufficient to say , That , though both the Excentricity and Obliquity do cause some Inequality in the Motion ; yet so little , as that in the Tides it is not remarkable , they falling just as if the three Motions , ( Annual , Menstrual , Diurnal , ) were all exactly Circular , and on Parallel Axes .
To the second , which concerns matter of Fact in Rumney-Marsh ; I say , that ( according to the best account I can there get , and the unanimous consent as well of Fisher-men and other Water-men , as of other Inhabitants , ) it is constant ; hardly missing ( or very seldom ) any one year ( be the weather fair or foul ; ) and as well about Candlemass , as about Allhallontide , every year , though not then so high : Of which ( though they do not pretend to give any reason of it , ) I think a Cause may be very rationally assigned .
For , if you consult the Tables of the Inequality of Natural Days ( which parallel I make use of for the Explication of this , ) you will find , that about one of the Extremes ( in January ) the Increase and Decrease of the Natural Days fluctuates very much ; sometime increasing , sometime decreasing , according as this or that of the two Causes , thwarting one another , doth prevail : But about the other Extreme ( in October , ) it is much otherwise ; the Increasings and Decreasings going on in a continual course for a long time together .
And the same Causes , applied to the business of Tides , may very rationally be supposed to produce as unequal effects .
To the third , That the Sea men at Weymouth have not observed any such signal Effects about Allhallontide and Candlemas : It is very possible that they have not , and that nothing signal on those Coasts uses to happen at those times : For , I fix that matter of Fact principally on Rumney-Marsh , ( and that it doth there constantly happen , I am pretty well out of doubt , ) and do but by conjecture extend it to the River of Thames ( as having its Mouth not far from those Coasts , )where yet , I think , you can be my Witness , that it hath been observed several years to succeed accordingly .
What variety is on other Coasts , I am not certain : But ( from an Account read in the R. Society in my hearing , about the end of the year 1667 .
) I understand that about Chepstom bridge(and consonantly , I suppose , on the Severne at other places , ) they observe the like to happen about the beginning of March , and end of September , ( the one as much before the Vernal , as the other is after the Autumnal AEquinox , like as in our case it happens , ) which they call by the name of St. Davids stream , and Michaelmas-stream ; as we do those in Kent , Candlemas stream , and Allhallon-stream : ( And when Sea-men take so much notice of particular Tides as to give names to them , it is a great presumption , that it is for some remarkable kable Accident usually happening at those Seasons .
) Of these different Seasons at Chepstow bridge from those of Rumney-Marsh , I gave you my remarks in a Letter of mine to you in March following .
And the like differences , I suppose , will be observable on other Coasts , according as their positions be advantageous or disadvantageous to the one or the other of the two Causes , on which this Phenomenon depends .
But since it is not yet ( it seems ) agreed , Whether such an Annual Phenomenon do happen ; or , if so , not at that time ; ( so that , for ought yet appears , it may be at the Seasons I design , that is , between the Winter-Solstice and the two AEquinoxes on either side of it ; though , on several Coasts , severally remote , ) I think it best to let this part of the Hypothesis stand as it is , unrevoked , as that , which , when it shall be discovered and agreed on , stands ready enough to give a rational account of it , and , in the mean time , does no hurt .
And in such a Complication of Causes so abstruse , scarce any thing but Observation will determine , which of the Causes , and in what degree , is to be Judged praedominant .
And if to this of the Sun 's or Earth 's , be added that of the Obliquity and Excentricity of the Moon 's Orbite ( of which , for the reason above-mentioned , I had taken so little notice , ) it will , if it do no good , at lest do no hurt .
And I the rather think , it may be considerable , because the Earth and Moon'sAppropinquation and Elongation , doth really alter the Distance of the Common Center of Gravity ( of the Earth and Moon ) from the Earth ( rendring the Earth 's Epicycle Elliptical ; ) and much favours what M. Childrey observes of the Moon in Perigaeo .
And this is the sum of what I thought proper to return you , upon those Animadversions ,

