A Discourse of Dr R. Witty , relating to the Notes of Dr Foot in Numb. 52 .
and to those of Dr. Highmore in Numb. 56 .
of these Tracts ; concerning Mineral Waters , and Extracts made out of them : Communicated to the Publisher , by way of Letter .
Sir , I Must always acknowledge myself much obliged to you for the reiterated mention you have been pleased to make of my Book in your Transactions , and your patient condescension to the trouble , that hath ensued therefrom to you , whereas I could not have any ground of hope , that any thing of mine should have fallen under your notice .
And this goodness of yours gives me encouragement to presume at this time to desire your favour in theperusal of these lines , which are occasioned oned from some Observations , I have met with in your sad Transactions , referring to my subject .
And First , in No. 51 .
p. 1039 l. 40 .
in mentioning the Principles of Scarbrough-water , there was pretermitted Vitriol , which I suppose was not designedly done .
This I was to premise , because some things that follow do refer to that Mineral .
Next , I cannot but take notice of D. Foot 's ingenious Notes and Letter in your Numb. 52 .
p. 1050 : which he grounds upon your enlarged Account of my Book , about the Volatil parts of Mineral waters , together with his Queries .
To all which though I might have returned a speedy Answer from old Observations , yet I was willing to stay , till my occasions could permit me to step over to Scarbrough to renew my Experiments ; wherein as I resolved to be more Critical , so I hope my return will be more satisfactory to all , that are concerned .
As for Tachenius , to whom he refers , I cannot get him in London , and therefore can say nothing to his Principles .
It is certain , that these sorts of Mineral waters are more pleasant to the palate , and also more effectual , if they be drunk at the Fountains , then when carried at distance : Yet some of them will endure carriage much better than others .
Such of them , as are impregnated with a body of Minerals , as Scarbrough , Malton , and the Sulphur-well at Knaresbrough , will better endure carriage than the Sweet-weell at Knares-brough , and the Sauvenir in Germany &amp;c. which have imbibed little or nothing but the Volatil Spirits or Vapors of some Minerals , which quickly evaporate , if removed from their Springs .
Now though Scarbrough-water will endure carriage as far as any I know , and yet retain its purging quality , even to many days or weeks , when it stinks , because of its large proportion of Mineral Salts , which are not lost by carriage , and will carry it through the Body ; yet certain it is , that it suffers a great alteration and decay of virtue , being conveyed at distance ; which probably must proceed from the loss of some volatil parts ; whereupon are also lost some alterative properties , by which it should fortify the Crasis of the Stomach and other Nervous parts , or open Obstructions , or expel the Stone , &amp; c : And thence it is , that I never saw a good cure done by it at distance .
Nor can it be supposed , that these waters , which have in them a Body of Mineral Salts , can want those Volat I Spirits , which others possess , that have no Minerals at all .
Nay its plain , that even Scarbrough-water being drunk at the Town , which is but a quarter of a mile from the Spaw , hath nothing so pleasant a relish upon the palate , as it hath at the Fountain(and some observe , its not so operative : ) But whether that Alteration come from a sudden loss of any Spirits , I shall not hastily determine , but do rather chuse to make it out thus : It is such an Alteration as we observe in Wine or Ale , which , after a while , looses the brisk taste or relish , which it had being new drawn out of the Cask , whereby it is not so grateful to the Palate , while yet perhaps there is little or no loss of any Vinous or Frumental Spirit ; but then , after a day or two , it becoms whitish in Colour , and suffers some degrees of Putrefaction : Notwithstanding I could never discern it to loose of its quantity , as Frambesarius and Van Heer do affirm concerning the German , as I have cited them p. 101 .
of my Answer .
Now , that I may yet more fully make out the touth of what I have asserted about the Principles of Scarbrough-Spaw , I here present to your view these several parts of it , with the manner of Extraction .
As touching the Vitriol , I must refer you to my Book , where I hope I have sufficiently proved it to be one of them , especially to p.42,43,44 ; since , it being there principally in its Volatil parts , it cannot be so especially represented to the senses at distance , while yet it is most conspicuous at the Well .
After Distillation or Evaporation of the Water , taken clear out of the Fountain , and strained from all sabulous mixture , there is found that Body of Minerals , signed A , viz. an ounce in five quarts , and in dry years , 10 drachms : Which I take to be the Product of the five Minerals , Iron , Vitriol , Alome , Nitre and Salt , which the water is impregnated withal , and seems to have a compound taste of sharpe Salt , acid , and somewhat stiptick ; and indeed a tertium diverse from them all .
Dissolve this body of Minerals in pure Spring-water , or distilled water , and then filter it through Cap-paper , there will stay a little Insipid Earth in the filter , but the water will be exceeding brackish .
Evaporate that water away , and there remains the body , signed B , which being duly prepared , and time allowed ( which I now have not ) I have sometimes seen to shoot into Stiria 's an inch long , being set to Chrystallize in a cold Cellar .
This I Judge to be , for the greater part , Niter , resembling much in taste that Niter .
which breaks out upon the Cliffe near the Well , mentioned p. 106 .
of my Answer .
Dissolve again this Body in distilled water , and filter it , and the water shall be very brackish , but there shall remain in the filter the powder , signed C , which seems to be the Aluminous part : This is sometimes found to be like a Christallin sand , as you have it in the paper , signed C C ; I think , the difference in the shooting arises from the different degrees of heat , which is given it .
Evaporat this water away , and you have a Salt , mark't D , or that ( D D ; ) the difference betwixt them is in the degrees of heat : In both which , if you note it , there are some small stiriae , which I take to be the nitrous particles interspersed .
This I have sometimes depurated , till it hath become as white as Chalk , and yet retained its Saltness , as you have it signed DD D. Now , whether this Salt be from the Sea , ` or rather the Salt of all the minerals , I shall leave it to others to Judge ; My opinion is , that it is nothing else than the product of the Minerals , which yet may receive some small addition from the Sea .
When the Spaw-water is first set upon the fire , there falls to the bottom a yellowish powder , which if that water be filtred , stays behind , mark't E : whether this be the same with the Ochre , that is found in the bottom of the vessel , when the water is conveyed at distance , I cannot say ; but they are both of a colour .
Here I had thought to have sent you the Black sediment(mentioned p. 66 .
of my Answer ) which falls to the bottom of the vessel , after the water hath received a tincture from the Gall , which also calcineth of a dark brown colour , which I take to be the Iron Mineral ; but it being hard frosty weather , when I was last at Scarbrough , it would not separate .
If you desire it , I shall supply it in Summer .
Now because my Adversary hath made a great rusle about the Calcining of the Minerals , which he saith is White , and thereupon endeavours to exclude Vitriol and Iron from their number ; I have sent you some of them ca'cin 'd , as they came out of the Crucible , signed F , which , you may see , have a manifest appearance of a red colour , ( to use his own expression , whose words I have cited p. 57 .
of my Answer : ) Now since this Co'our cannot be supposed to come from Niter , Alom , or Salt , it must , even upon his own principles , come from Vitriol , or Iron ; and I judge it to come from Iron , which is there in its body .
And if you take the body of Minerals , which we first spake of to be found in the Spaw-water , and calcine it , and so rub it into a fine powder , and then edulcorate it in pure or distilled water , and afterwards filter it , you shall find a nitrous Salt , not much different from what was expressed before , mark't B , and the other following parts also ; but a larger quantity stays always in the filter , chrystallized through the more vehement heat of the fire .
But there are other parts , which I fetch out of this body of Minerals , ?
which doubtless do much contribute to the Cures performed by this water , and used with other vehicles are of singular use in Hypochondriac diseases .
I took six ounces of the Minerals , which I put into a Report , and placed it in a furnace covered with Sand , increasing the fire gradually , the Receiver being close joined to the Retort , and so luted , as not the least Volatil spirit could evaporate .
First , came this in the Glass , signed G , about an ounce in quantity , which is the Phlegm .
Then with another Receiver , as well luted , the heat increasing , came the acid Spirit , signed H , near half an ounce in quantity .
I have sometimes found it much more sharpe and acid than this is , and indeed I took it too soon away from the fire : Yet this gives a Tincture to a decoction of Roses , like Spirit of Vitriol or Salt .
I have sometimes observed this sharpe spirit like Spirit of Vitriol , to chrystallize to the sides of the glass , when it hath been long kept , and loosing its acidity to become like the phlegm .
I now come to the Queries of D. Foot , to which I shall speak as to matter of fact , referring the Reason of things to be discussed by better heads .
To To the first , I distilled Scarborough Spaw-water in a Glass-still , luting the Receiver so close , that no spirit ( even of wine ) could escape me , and it yielded nothing but an insipid water , as ordinary Spring-water uses to do : And I think , I may confidently affirm , that none of those Mineral Springs will afford any other .
To the Second , The water of Scarbrough , and all such as are impregnated with a body of Minerals , whether they be let stand , or conveyed at distance , do let fall a yellowish sediment in time .
But so it is not in Knaresbrough sweet-well , nor such others as have no Minerals , but have only imbibed the Vapors or Odors of some Mineral .
To the third ; When such waters are moved by carriage , they do sooner precipitate that yellow sediment to the bottom , and especially if conveyed in oaken vessels .
To the fourth ; This yellowish sediment is plainly discernable both in their Spring-heads and streams ; nay , even Knaresbrough water doth a little colour the Cistern in tract of time , notwithstanding it hath very little of the substance .
To the fifth Those bottles that are stopped close , whether they be moved or not , will longer keep their brisk relish , than such as are left open , and also longer retain their medical virtues , together with their colour and sediment .
To the sixth ; I find not any difference in the Vessels , wherein Scarbrough-water is put , viz. a Glass-bottle or an Ox-bladder , save this , that that which was in the Bladder would not receive so black a tincture from the Gall , as the other , but rather a Claret .
To the seventh ; I could never yet devise , nor any other I have met with , to prevent the loss of the aperient virtue of Scarbrough-water , nor to hinder the precipitation of the yellow sediment , if removed at distance .
To the eighth ; Notwithstanding that Scarbrough-water lets fall the Ochre , yet it remains Purgative , from the rest of the Mineral Salts and Spirits , which yet it retains even till , and when it stinks : And perhaps being setid it may purge the more , as some have told me , who have drunk it , when they have been forced to stop their noses , though it hath been with very much prejudice to their health , as I have made out in my former Book , to wit Scarbrough-Spaw , ( Edit .
2 .
p 220 , 221 .
) But as for Knaresbrough Sweet-well , that will be found enervated , though no Ochre appear in the bottom .
To the ninth ; That of Knaresbrough , and such like , are better explicated , to have lost their virtues by an Avolation of Spirituous parts , since they have nothing else wherein the virtue can consist : whereas it will not serve for Scarbrough , from which these spirits cannot in reason be excluded ; nay they are found more eminently in the Minerals .
And therefore we must allow to it , and to such like , an intestine Alteration , or Precipitation of their parts , or some such Expression , which I refer to the Learned to consider of .
I now pass on to speak a few words concerning the 3 .
Chemical maxims , quoted by D. Foot .
It is very true , that great Medical virtues do consift in the Volatile Sulphurs of Metals and Minerals ; yet we may not exclude their fixed parts from their use in Physic , as the fix't Salt ofSteel , and even Steel it self we use with good success .
And Schroderus hath a great many singular good medicins , which he prepares even out of the fix't salts of all the Metals and Minerals .
That which he observes in the second , viz. That Acids and Alcalies mutually operate upon one another , even to an utter amission of their former activities , and a production of a tertium neutrum ; as it is very true , so it is sufficiently verified in these Minerals , wherewith these waters of Scarbrough are impregnated : for they are become a quite other thing to what they are in their principles , agreeing in some things with them , and yet disagreeing in other things , as I have made out p. 18 , 19.and again p.61 .
62.so far as was pertinent to my purpose .
Concerning the third , there is not doubt to be made of its verity : And as to the Hypothesis , he draws from the said Premises , I have had occasion particularly to speak to it , p. 5 , 6 .
and again , p. 17 , 18 .
and therefore I shall say no more of it here , but pass on To the Numb. 56 .
p. 1128 .
which obliges me to say something , and that is to a Letter from Dr. Highmore ; to which Gentleman I am very much obliged for his Candour in owning any advantage I have gotten of my Adversary : though he saith , being a Stranger to the Water , he cannot judge , whether either of us hath gotten the right of his side ; and he doubts , whether some of the Mineral principles may not be left out .
I have made it appear , that my Antagonist , after all his severe denials of the Minerals I asserted to be in the Water , doth at last in his own Book assent to them all , p. 112 , 113 , of my Answer .
And I cannot take it unkindly , that Dr. H. or any other Learned and Ingenious Gentleman , that designs not to quarrel ( as he saith ) should for satisfaction ask further questions about it .
The Doctor is a stranger to this water , yet hath my Reasons for all the Minerals , ( besides my Adversaries concessions ; ) none of which I could leave out .
If he or any other Ingenious person , that is not yet satisfied , would be at the pains to take a view ( if these parts of the water , which I herewith present to your view , be not enough ) I doubt not but they would return to my opinion .
Next , he wonders , why I mention Alome among the rest , which ( he saith ) exiccat , adstringit , incrassat ; and he understands not , how this water should be so highly deoppilative , and beneficial to Hypochondriacal and Cachectical persons being impregnated with so great an Astringent , neither ( saith he ) doth the Dr. declare .
By this , as also by what follows it appears , that Dr. H. did read my Book , while I treated of the Minerals , very superficially , or else had much forgotten when he writ that Letter .
Nothing is more plain , than that our Water hath imbibed Alome , insomuch that Mr. S. in the former part of his Book , against me owns nothing else almost but Alome .
And for the adstringent , &amp;c. property of Alome , it is very true , what Dr. H. saith , to which I have also spoken expressly , p. 126 , 127 .
of my Answer , and plainly proved , that it can neither open Obstructions nor loose the Belly , from thence .
But I have fully evinced , that all the rest are there as well as Alome , and treated of them all , and their properties , communicated to this water , in my first Book , viz. Scarbrough-Spaw , Edit.2.p .
142,143 , 144 , 145.Besides that I have in the several places of my latterBook touched upon their virtues , as Vitriol , p. 71 , &amp;c. Iron , p.75,79 Niter , p. 85 .
Salt , p.86 .
And again more fully of them all , p. 130 , 131,132 .
So that I have plainly declared both negatively , that it cannot have these properties from the Alome ; and also affirmatively , from whence it hath them ; only from the Stiptick and Astringent properties of the Iron and Alome it is , that this water , though it be purgative , yet never runs the body into Dysenteries .
As to the tinging with Gall ( which he mentions ) I have proved that to proceed from the Vitriol , and that neither Alome crude nor calcined , nor any of the other , do communicate that property to the water ; excepting in one place of this Cliffe near the Spaw , where a little Alome-stone , that lies in the Vitriolin Juice , which breaks out about the breadth of an hat , will give a tincture with Gall , as the Earth also in that spot will do , because it is impregnated with Vitriol ; but all the 100 loads of Alome-Earth besides , that are in the .
Cliff , wlil not do it , neither crude nor calcined .
Again , the Doctor wonders , why I make Iron and Vitriol two distinct Constituents of this water , and call it Ferrum Vitriolatum , inferring that Iron and Vitriol are both one , and not two distinct Minerals .
These are my Adversaries objections in his Book , to which the Doctor is not aware that I have given answer : To the Former , p. 5 , 6 viz that I might distinguish it from Vitriolum Cupreum , which is Emetick .
To the latter , I have been larger as the matter required , and have given , I think , satisfactory reasons from p. 35 , to 41 .
and clearly proved , that they are not the same thing .
But as these Gentlemen will have Vitriol and Iron to be one thing , so I find Dr. Jorden ( cap. 7 of Not .Baths)making a doubt , whether Alome and Vitriol be distinst in specie : so that by this reckoning it might have sufficed for all , to have mentioned any of the three , and I might have saved my self some labour .
But I suspect , I should not so have satisfied the most part of Learned men , in so confounding three of the principles , but might have expected a more just and severe reproof for it .
Next , Dr. H. observes , that I have said , that Vitriol , which is found alone upon the Rock will , by the Summer heat be turned into Iron , and then he makes inference upon the Hypothesis .
Which is a mistake ; for I do not say so in any part of my Book ; but p. 45 .
I do say , that some of that which is like ordinary Earth , falling down , turns to an Iron-stone , and is fusible in the fire .
In the next Sect.he is positive about the colour of Roman Vitriol , which I said to be factitious .
Concerning this , I find Authors much differing .
Galen ( l 9 .
de simpl .
med .
fac .
) mentions 3 .
sorts which he found at Cyprus , and tells of a green sort , but not a word of blew .
So Dr. Jorden , c. 7 .
Indeed Schroderus and Adrian Toll speak of a blew sort .
In this dissent of Writers , I consulted some Learned and observing Gentlemen , who had been at Rome , and they assure me , that the Romans add that colour , when they cast into forms .
Moreover if that be a right distribution of Vitriols into their several kinds , which some of our modern Chymists make , viz that there are but three sorts , Vitriol of Iron , of Copper , and white Vitriol , then , I think , it will follow , that I am in the right ; for , one is yellow , viz. that of Iron , the other green , and the white is that , which is made blew .
But it is not worth the while to contend about it .
In my 120 p. he saith , I am dissatisfied with what my Adversary asserts concerning the Saltness of the Sea proceeding from Fossil Salt , &amp;c. but rather that I allow the Peripatetical Torrefaction of the un to be the Cause .
All I say there , is , that the Peripateticks thought , it came short of an adequat cause , and thereupon they fly to that torrefaction ; but it does not therefore follow , that I allow it .
I he truth is , I like neither of the Opinions , but have Arguments against them both .
To speak out , I rather think , the Saltness of the Sea to be connatural to it ( as the freshness of other water is to it ) and that it was made so from the beginning , but that I reserved for another discourse .
As for the Argument which there I brought to back my assertion , viz. That if the Salt of the Sea should come from fossil Salt , it would kill the .
Fish , he saith , it is not convincing .
This I seconded by an Instance concerning the Salt-Sea , which kills all fish , and thence is called Mare mortuum : Which , I think , is of greater force to confirm it , than the Doctors instance of Oysters , which he has experimented to be preserved by Salt and water , can be to contradict it .
For those Zoophyta have but a dull and imperfect life , and are not so proper to be drawn into instance in our case .
We know , they will keep a long time in their own pickle or moisture , and we have also known them to stink , notwithstanding the addition of Salt and water , and therefore little judgment can be taken from them .
It is most certain ( as he observes ) that the Inland Salt-springs are such from fossil Salt , and it were worth trying , whether those Salt-springs would not kill a Pilchard , or any other sort of Sea-fish , that lives a perfect sensitive life : but , I fear , Sir , I have been too tedious .
You will , &amp;c.

