An Account of the Observation , made by the Philosophical Academy at Paris , May 12 1667 about 9 .
of the Clock in the morning , of an Halo or Circle about the Sun ; together with a Discourse of M. Hugens de Zulechem , concerning the Cause of these Meteors , as also that of Parelia 's or Mock-Suns .
Englished out of French by the Publisher , to whom it was sent but lately from the worthy Author of the said Discourse .
THe Diameter of this Circle , which was exactly observed , was found to be of 44 degrees , and the breadth of the Limb thereof , of about half a degree .
The upper and lower part were of a vivid red and Jellow , with a little purple-coM 2 lour lour , but especially the upper ; the red was within the Circle .
The other parts appeared but whitish and of little clearness .
The space within the Halo was a little darker then that about it , especially towards the parts that were coloured .
Besides there was seen the portion of another great Circle , which touched the Halo above , and whose extremities were bent downward , as is represented in the I. Fig. in Tab. 2 .
This portion of a Circle had also its Colours like those of the Halo , but fainter .
The height of the Sun , at the beginning of the Observation , was about 46 .
degrees .
There were in the Air little white Clouds , which somewhat tarnished the blew colour of the Heavens , and lessened the brightness of the Sun , which shone as in an Eclipse .
The weather was cold , considering the season of the year , and it was affirmed for certain , that it had frozen the night before .
This Halo appeared in the same beauty and splendor of colours , unchanged , from 9 .
in the morning , ( when it began to be observed ) until about half an hour past ten ; after which time it became fainter and fainter till two of the clock in the afternoon , when it ended , after it had resumed a little more force some time before it disappeared .
The Observation of this Phenomenon engaged M. Hugens to propose to the Company , assembled at his Majesties Library , what he had meditated , some years ago , concerning the Cause , not only of these Halo 's , but also of the Parhelia , which have been hitherto look't upon by many as Prodogies , and as Prognosticks of some singular Event .
As for the Halo 's , he said , that they were formed by small round grains , made up of two parts , one transparent , the other opaque , the latter being enclosed in the former , as a cherrystone is in a cherry ; as may be seen in the II Figure , wherein AA represents one of these grains , and B the kernel or opaque part ( It is drawn much bigger than the natural , to render the thing the more intelligible .
) He related the Observations of those who have seen Hail formed after this manner , and , among others , that of M. Des-Cartes in his Treatise of Meteors ; and explained , how that some of these little grains , which swim up and down in the Air betwixt us and the Sun , being less distant from the axis , which extends itself from the Sun to our Eye , than of a certain angle , do necessarily hinder the rays , which fall on them , from coming to our Eyes , in regard that the opaque kernel is the cause that there is behind every such grain a space of a conical figure , as MNO in the II .
Figure , in which the Eye of the Spectator being scituated cannot see the Sun through that grain , though it may see him when posited elsewhere , as somewhere in P. And to make the Company the more distinctly to understand the effect , which these Grains suspended in the Air must produce , he drew the III Figure ; in which , B is the place of the Eye ; B A , the axis which passes from the Eye to the Sun ; C , M , F , some of the icy Grains with their kernel making them half opaque : Among which , the Grain C , being in the axis B A , and the lines C K , L H , representing the rays of the Sun nearest to the axis , the passage of which is not hindred by the opacity of the kernel , it is certain , not only that the grain C will not be able to transmit any ray of the Sun towards B , but also that , imagining the superficies of a Cone , whose top is in the Eye , and its sides B D , B E , parallel to the rays C K , L H , all the grains M M , which this superficies shall comprise , will likewise not suffer any ray to pass to the Eye , because it must needs be in their Cone of obscurity ; but those , that shall be without this superficies , as the grains F F , will let them pass , because the Eye is without their Cone of obscurity .
Whence it follows , that the Angle of this Cone BDE is that , which determins the Diameter of the Halo , which depends from the proportion , the opaque grain hath to the transparent , in which it is enclosed .
For , if this Diameter is of 44 degrees , as is observed in most Halo 's , the bigness of the opaqe grain will be to the transparent as 40 to 19 .
But he said , that this proportion was not always the same , and that the diversity of it was the cause , that sometimes there were seen many Halo 's , one about the other , all having the Sun for their Center .
He added , that it was easy to know , why these Halo 's were always of a round figure , whether the Sun be little or much raised above the Horizon ; as also to give a reason of their Colours , which is the same with that in the Triangular GlassPrismes ; Prisms ; as is evident by the Tangents A D , drawn to the Grain A , at the points , where the Ray DA enters or coms out .
Further he took notice , that it was also manifest , why the red colour is in the interior circumference of the Halo .
And why the space , which it takes in , and chiefly near the most lively coloured parts , appears obscurer than the Air about ; viz. because it is there , where most Grains are , which transmit no rays of the Sun to our Eyes , and so do nothing but darken the Air , as the drops of water when it rains .
Moreover he noted , that M. Des Cartes , endeavouring to explain the Cause of these Halo 's , had committed a mistake , for want of Observations , truly relating this last circumstance : Because he maintains , that the space comprised within the Halo is clearer than the Air without ; and to render a reason of it , he supposes certain Grains , altogether transparent , having the form of a lentil ; which supposition cannot therefore be true , because what he deduceth from it , is contrary to what is observed : Besides that the roundness of the Halo in all the elevations of the Sun agrees not with it , as were easy to show .
He stayed not to examine the Generation of the half-dark grains , because he is shortly to publish a larger Treatise of this subject ; where he intends also to render a reason , why the dark kernel keeps certain proportions , rather than others , with the Grain , which contains it .
As to the Arch of the Circle , which above touched the last Halo seen May 12th , as also that the Colours were more vivid in this place , and in that below , then in the rest of the Circle ; he said , that these effects did not proceed from the Grains , he had been speaking of , but from another cause , which did also serve for the production of the Parhelia and the Circles which almost always accompany them .
Touching which Circles and Parhelia 's he told the Company , that besides the round and half-dark Grains , there were also formed in the Air certain little Cylinders of the like nature , and of which M. Des Cartes himself declared in his Treatise of Meteors to have observed some , not indeed with opaque kernels within , but that the same cause , which produces them in the round grains , could also produce them in Cylinders : Which being supposed to be such as the IV .
Figure represents them , viz. oblong icy grains , and roundish at both ends , having the inner kernel of the same shape , it was found , that from their different dispositions all the appearances of the Parhelia and their Circles did necessarily follow .
And first , that some of these Cylinders being erect , in the situation which probably they ought to have in being formed , there must appear in the Heavens a great white Circle , parallel to the Horizon , passing through the Sun , and of near the same breadth with him ; as hath been observed in the Phenomenon of Rome A. 1629 .
of which Gassendus and Des-Cartes have written , and which is here exhibited in the V. Figure .
That this Circle LKNM is caused by the reflection of the rays of the Sun upon the surface of these Cylinders ; it being easy to demonstrate , that there are none but those , which are raised at the same angle above the Horizon with that of the height of the Sun , that can reflect his rays to our Eye .
Whence it manifestly follows , that it must appear White , and throughout of equal altitude with the Sun itself , and by consequence parallel to the Horizon .
That considering afterwards the Transparency of these perpendicular Cylinders , and their opaque kernels , it is easily seen , that those of the white Circle , which are distant from the Sun at a certain angle , begin to give passage to his rays to strike our eyes , in the same manner as hath been said of the round half-dark Grains .
That these Cylinders are those , which on each side of the Sun make us see a Parhelion in the great white Circle , as hath been noted in the Observation of Rome ( where they are marked with K and N ) and in many others .
That these Parhelia have commonly luminous tails , because the Cylinders , which follow those first ones that form the Parhelia , and which are yet further distant from the Sun , let also pass his rays to our Eye , so that these Tails may be 20 degrees and more in length .
That the same Parhelia are always coloured , because they are made by refraction , as the Halo .
That besides , there are two other Images of the Sun , generated rated by these perpendicular Cylinders , and so disposed in the great white Circle , that the Spectator , turning his face towards the true Sun , hath them behind him ; as in the Roman Observation are the Parhelia L and M. That these are produced by two refractions and one reflexion in these Cylinders , in the same manner as the ordinary Rain-bow in the drops of water , according as M. Des-Cartes hath declared : So that the opaque kernels do nothing to the production of these two Suns , but that they may be sometimes so big , as to make them not appear .
That according to the Altitude of the Sun , more or less , these two Parhelia are more or less nigh to one another ; of which he promises to give the true measures in his Treatise of Parhelia 's .
That they should appear coloured , as the Rainbow , and that sometimes they have been seen such ; but that when they are faint , they may also seem white , even as the Halo 's , when they are not very bright .
That these same perpendicular Cylinders can also produce an Halo about the Sun , by reason of the rounding of their two ends ; which makes , that being distant from the Sun at a certain angle , on what side soever it be , they begin from thence to give passage to the rays , transmitting them to the Eyes of the Spectator .
And that these Halo 's are probably those , we see almost always pass through the two Parhelia that are on the side of the true Sun , as the Halo GKNI in the Phenomenon of Rome .
That there is yet an other scituation of these Cylinders very considerable , which is of those that are couchant , so as their axes are parallelto the plan of the Horizon , but turned divers ways , some one some another way , like needles confusedly thrown on the ground : Which Horizontal disposition is very natural to those Cylindrick Bodies , supported by the vapors , which rise from the earth , as may be made out Experimentally in Bodies thus figured , being let fall in the Air .
That it is in these Cylinders , that the Arches , which touch the Halo 's above or below , are formed ; such as there were in the Phenomenon observed at Rome A. 1630 .
which is described bed by P. Schenir in a Letter to M. Gassendus , as also in all those , which M. Hevelius hath related at the end of his Mercurius in Sole .
And that the Arch , which appeared upon this last Halo at Paris , was of the same kind .
That the figure of these Arches is different according to the different Altitudes of the Sun , and the several Magnitudes of the Diameters of the Halo 's .
That when the Sun is very nigh the Horizon , such an Arch appearing upon an ordinary Halo of 44 degrees , must represent as twere two Horns , as in the VI .
Figure , A B , A C : But that the Sun rising higher , those Horns become lower in proportion , and make such Arches as are represented in the same V I. Figure , where each height of the Sun is marked near the Arch , which it is to make : Of which the Demonstrations were reserved to the same Treatise of Parhelia 's That the place of the Arches where they touch the Halo 's , being more strongly enlightened and coloured than the rest , makes us Judge , that there are Parhelia in those places .
That the reason , why these Arches do ordinarily touch a Parhelion , was , that the same Cylinders couchant , which produce the Arch , produce also that Parhelion , by the means of their two round and transparent Ends , in the same manner as hath been said of the perpendicular Cylinders .
And that the Parhelion last seen at Paris had been formed in these couchant Cylinders .
That that was also confirmed , by reason that it was brighter in the superior and inferior part , than any where else ; which necessarily coms to pass in a Parhelion caused by Cylinders thus disposed , whereas when produced by the round Grains , it must appear every where equally strong .
That in these same Cylinders parallel to the Horizon , there is also found the Cause of the White Cross , observed together with the Paraselene 's or Mock-moons by M. Hevelius , and exhibited at the end of his Mercurius in Sole : the perpendicular Fillet of that Cross , coming from the reflection of the rays of the Moon upon the surface of these Cylinders ; as the other Fillet , parallel to the Horizon , is produced by the reflection of the perpendicular Cylinders which make the great white Circle , of which this Fillet is a part .
That yet the Moon must not be very high above the Horizon , to the end that the couN ching ching Cylinders may produce this effect : And that it should be well heeded , when the like Meteor shall appear , whether the perpendicular Fillet be not narrower where it passes through the Moon , than in other places , and especially upwards , where it must grow larger and dis-appear .
That besides the perpendicular Cylinders , and those that are couched parallel to the Horizon , there are often a great many , which move to and fro in the Air in all sorts of positions ; and that those , by the same reason that the round Grains do , must produce an Halo about the Sun , and even a more vivid one than that which is caused by the Grains , forasmuch as each Cylinder sends many more rays to the Eye , than each of these little Spheres .
That the little Halo DE F , in the Roman Phenomenon ( Fig. V. ) may very well have been caused by such Cylinders .
As to those Mock-suns , which sometimes show themselves directly opposite to the True Sun , ( such an one as was published by M. Hevelius , and observed Febr. 23 .
1661 ; ) that he could find nothing neither in the round Grains nor in the Cylinders , which should make these Suns necessarily to meet in the great White Circle , parallel to the Horizon , and that , if that should be always verified by future O servations , the cause of it must be looked for elsewhere : But that in the mean time he did believe , that that happened not but by chance ; which being so , a reason might be given of these Suns by the same supposition , which served also for the Anthelion , observed by M. Hevelius Sept. 6 .
1661 ; in which there were two coloured Arches of a Circle , opposite to the Sun , which did intersect one another , their intersection being the place of the False Sun .
Which although it be represented in the Figure of Hevelius at the same height with the true Sun , yet it was in truth higher by 15 degrees or more ; as he hath acknowledged himself afterwards : So that , if there had been a great white Circle in this Phenomenon , the Parhelion was not at all to have been in it .
That for the generation of these Suns , he did suppose a number of small Cylinders with opaque kernels , as the precedent ; which were carried in the Air , neither perpendicularly , nor couching ching , but inclined to the Plan of the Horizon at a certain angle being near an half right one ; to which were particularly appropriated those Cylinders , which M. Des Cartes saw fall from the Heavens , having Stars at both ends : As may be seen experimentally , by forming Cylinders of that fashion , which is represented in Fig. VII , and letting them descend in the Air or in Water .
That in these Cylinders was found , following the Calculus to be given in the Treatise of Parhelia 's , not only the Cause of the Anthelia made by the intersection of two Arches , as in Fig. VIII , but also that of some other Extraordinary Arches and Rods , that are sometimes observed near the Sun , of which notwithstanding there could nothing be as yet affirmed with certainty , for want of exact and faithful Observations .
To make all these different effects of the Cylinders manifest to the Eye , M. Hugens produced one of Glass , a foot long , of the shape of that in Fig. IV ; and for the kernel opaque in the middle , a Cylinder of Wood , and the ambient space filled with water , instead of transparent Ice : Which Cylinder being exposed to the Sun , and the Eye put in such places as was requisite , there were successively seen all those reflexions and refractions , that have been discoursed of .
Whence it might be concluded , that a great number of the like Cylinders , although very small in comparison to that , being found in the Air , and having the several postures that have been supposed , all the Appearances of the Parhelia and their Circles must exactly follow .
It was wished , for an entire confirmation of the truth of this Hypothesis , that some of those small Cylinders could be observed to fall to the ground at the time , when any Parhelia do appear : Which he showed could not easily be done , because that the vapors , which then rise from the Earth upwards , and which are the cause of their Cylindrical figure , keep them also suspended in the Air .
He added , that it was not to be thought strange , that such small grains of hail were thus kept up in the Air by the vapors , forasmuch as these , by being rarefied and dilated upwards , might have motion enough for this effect .
That that was more easy to conceive , than to imagine , how these same vapors could keep suspended a very great and weighty Circle of Ice , such as M. Des-Cartes supposes to explicate the cause of Parhelia 's and of the great White Circle of the Roman Phenomenon .
In which supposition were also to be noted the following difficulties ; viz. That therein there appears no reason , why the White Circle should pass through the Sun , as is always observed , and that it should shade him according as he changes in height , though the Phenomenon do sometimes last three or four hours : That this same White Circle , formed of Ice , being seen by Spectators distant enough from one another , could not appear round to all ( as it doth ) and to traverse the Sun : That , when Parhelia are observed , there appears not at all this round Cloud encompassed with the Icy Circle , which by its thickness should hide a part of the Heavens ; but that the Weather seems almost altogether serene , there being none but small clouds , which are seen to change places , whilst the great Circle and the Parhelia remain at rest .
That in this Hypothesis it happens not but by chance , that the Parhelia , which are at the side of the Sun , appear in the Intersections of an Halo and of the great White Circle ; which yet is observed to come to pass always , and shows , that the Causes of these Halo 's and of the Parhelia are very little different , against the opinion of Tab.2 .
N~.60 .
DD I II AA IV CB AA PP APP III N E MDP M MF MMO LC FF FLM V KH KEN B GDCFI Alt .
Sol.gr .
0 CB 10 20 VII A 30 VI 40 VIII

