Numb.59 .
PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS .
May 23 .
1670 .
The CONTENT S. The Answer of Monsieur Marriotte to Monsieur Pecquet , concerning the Principal Organ of Vision ; where occurr divers considerable Experiments .
A Continuation of Dr. Edward Brown 's Account concerning the Mines of Hungary ; where is a particular relation of the Hungarian Copper-mine , together with a Narrative of the many natural Baths in that Country and in Austria .
An Account of 3 Books : 1 .
COSMOPOEIA DIVIN A , per Ludov .
de Beaufort M. D. II .
CA RT ESIUSMOSAIZAN S , Auth. Joh. Amerpoel .
III .
The DIVINEHISTORY of the GENESIS of the WORL D , explicated and illustrated .
The Answer Of Monsieur Mariotte to Monsieur Pecquet , about the Opinion , that the Choroeides is the Principal Organ of Sight ; communicated to the Publisher from Paris , and Englished as follows .
SIR , I Have in your Answer * seen the reasons , which hinder you from believing that the Choroeides is the Principal Organ of Sight ; but though they were very Acute , and carried a great deal of Probability with them , yet I did not find them strong H enough * Vid. No. 35 .
of these Tracts , p.668 , 659 , 670 , enough to oblige me , to grant back again this Preeminence to the Retina .
You say , in your first Objection , that if the Sclerotis and the Chorocides be taken away from an Eye that is very fresh , and that the Retina be left distended on the Vitreous Humor , one shall not be able to see well through this membrane : whence you conclude , that it is not transparent enough , to let so much light , as is sufficient for vision pass upon the Choroeides .
In my opinion , there is good reason to doubt of this consequence , seeing there may be a great deal of difference between the Retina of a dead Animal , after it hath been exposed to the Ayre , and that of a living Animal , while it is exactly shut up between the Vitreous humour and the Choroeides .
Different dispositions do ordinarily change the qualities of things ; Fat , which is transparent when it is melted , grows opacous after it is cold again ; and the Tunica cornea of an Eye being held some hours in ones hand , in a hot Ayre grows thick , and a little after entirely opacous .
But to the end you may be persuaded , that the Choroeides is sufficiently enlightned in a living Animal , you must take the Eye of an Ox ( newly killed ) while it is hot , and cut it in two , in such manner that a good part of the vitreous humour may remain extended upon the Retina ; then you shall see distinctly the colours of the Choroeides , the basis of the Optic nerve , the trunk of the little vessels which proceed from thence , and their dispersion through the thickness of the Retina , with so much perspicuity that you cannot even discern , whether there be a Retina beyond the Vitreous humour or no. Hence you may judge , that the light , which the Objects send to the Choroeides , is more than sufficient for vision , seing that being much weakned by the reflexion and by a second passage through the Retina and the Vitreous humour , it is yet strong enough to form a clear and distinct vision of the Choroeides in our Eyes .
Not that I deny the Retina to have some whiteness in a living Animal , and that it is a little less transparent than the other Humours , chiefly in that part which is contiguous to the Choroeides ; and Nature may have made it so on purpose to temper the brightness of great lights , and to hinder dazeling ; in like manner as she hath spread over our skin an insensible Epidermis , to keep it from being too easily hurt by those bodies that touch us , and by the Excess of heat and cold .
But if I should absolutely deny , that the Retina hath any opacity in a living Animal , your Experiment would not convince me , it being made but upon a Retina , whose more subtle and transparent parts are evaporated ; and I might propose to you for an example a piece of white paper , through which , when it is wet , one sees distinctly enough whatever is contiguous to it ; and which presently resumes its first opacity , when it is a little while exposed to the Air : And if this Example were not sufficient , I might allege the little Crystalline , which is found in the middle of the Crystalline humour of many Animals , and is as it were the kernel of it ; the which , being as transparent as the other humours of the Eye in a living Animal , becomes in two or three days after his death white and opacous , notwithstanding that it be left enclosed in the Eye , and that the Exterior Crystalline remain still transparent .
Your second Experiment to prove the opacity of the Retina , which is to put it into water , is also extremely deceitful : For , you make no doubt but the Hyaloeides , which envelops the Vitreous humour , is perfectly transparent : nevertheless if you lay in a dish half full of water , part of the Vitreous humour , the parts of the Hyaloeides , which stick to it , will appear whitish and thick like a spiders web , although the Vitreous humour do still retain its transparency .
It is not then a sufficient proof to know , whether the Retina be opaque in a living Animal , by putting it into the water : And by what trial soever you make of it , after it has been exposed to the Ayre , you can draw no consequence to prove that it is opaque in its Natural state : For the Crystalline it self becomes a little thickish in water , and if it be left there some time , or exposed to the frost , it becomes white and opaque like snow .
It is therefore necessary for resolving our difference , and for knowing with certainty , whether the light of objects pass alm st all entire to the Choroeides , or whether it is almost all intercepted lie the Retina , to bring observations made on the Retina and the Choroeides , while they are in their natural state , as I shall do in the following Experiment .
Place by night a lighted Candle very near your Eyes , and cause a dog , distant from the candle 8 or 10 paces , to look upon you , then you shall see in his eyes , a light sufficiently bright , which I hold to proceed from the reflexion of the light of the Candle , whose image is painted on the Choroeides of the dog , which having much whiteness and luster causes this very strong reflexion ; for if it proceeded from the Crystalline or Retina , the same appearance would be seen in the Eyes of Man , Birds , and other animals , who have the Choroeides black , which is not found so by us .
It is therefore manifest by this Experiment , that the luminous rays do pass with a great deal of force as far as the Choroeides , and that the-Retina receives very little impression .
Now this appearance is made in this manner : The little picture of the candle which is upon the Choroeides of the dog , ( where is the Focus of the Crystalline and other humours together ) sending rays back through these humours , makes its reciprocal Focus towards the candle , and by consequence the eyes which are near to the point , where these rays do reunite , ought to see the Crystalline of the dog very much illuminated .
They that are skilled in Opticks known the demonstration : and there is an effect , wholly like unto this , to be seen by a very easy Experiment .
Place around Glass-bottle , full of very clear water , 8 .
or 10 paces from a Candle , and put behind the bottle , at near the distance of its Semidiameter , a white paper , in such manner that one may see the light of the Candle , which hath passed thorough the bottle , reunited in a little space upon the Paper ; then they , who have their eyes near the Candle , shall see the bottle full of light , which will disappear , if you hold the paper either nearer to , or farther from the bottle .
And if one hold a small lighted wax-candle in the place of the Paper , and you hold your eye in the place of the former candle , you shall see the bottle yet more enlightned then it was before : And one may easily judge , that the light which appears in the dogs eye , proceeds from a like cause .
The same experiment may be made in the eyes of several other Animals , and particularly of Cats , in whose eyes this light appears bluish , which shows , that it proceeds from their choroeides which hath much of this Colour ; but this Colour , nor any other which may be in the Choroeides , brings no confusion to the Sense of Seeing , for the Senses receive no impression from their own Organs .
The rest of this first Objection hath almust no other foundation , but an interpretation you give to some words of my writing different from my sense ; for , when I said , that dark and opaque bodies receive a great deal of impression from the light ; I did mean dark and opaque bodies both together ; for it had been sufficient for me to name dark bodies , since all dark bodies are opaque ; but my thought on this subject was , and still is , that transparent bodies , as the Ayre , the Water , and the Retina in a living Animal , receive little impression from light , and that Opaque bodies receive a great deal , but that dark bodies receive more then all other Opaque bodies , and the Air and the Water a little less than the Retina .
Nor do I believe , that darkness is absolutely n cessary for Vision , but only for a strong vision ; nor that the picture of objects ought to be expressed on the Organ of Vision ; for , it suffices , that the rays of each point of the Objects be reunited in a distinct and separated point , according as they answer one another ; and you will easily agree , that as a Convex glass makes the image of the Sun to appear on white paper with a great deal of brightness and light , and on black paper very obscurely ; although black paper ( which soon takes fire ) receives a great deal more impression than white : So the rays of illuminated objects do reunite on a whitish Choroeides , and express there a visible picture , and on a dark Choroeides , a very obscure one , and which cannot be seen ; but then the impression is also much stronger in the black than in the white : And this is the cause , why Men and Birds see better and more distinctly then the greatest part of other Animals ; for their Choroeides being black , nd by consequence very sensible oflight , they contract much their pupilla or sight-hole of the Eye , which makes the Rays , that pass there from each point of the Object , to be all very near the Axis of the Chrystallin , and to reunite more exactly in a point , then in the Eyes of most other Animals , which have their Choroeides white towards the Axis of Sight , and by consequence less sensible of light , who in recompense can very much dilate the Pupilla of their Eyes , when they stand in need of a great light ; but also their Sight is not so distinct , because the Rays , which fall on the Extremity of the Crystalline , do intersect the Axis too near in their refraction .
It is true , that to supply in some sort this defect , they have a little Crystalline in the middle of the great one , and this little Crystalline being of a more spiss consistence then the great one , its refraction is also more strong , and makes the rays , which come from one point in the Axis and pass near he Center of the Crystalline to refract more then if there had been but one Crystalline .
And by this means the greatest part of the Rays , which fall upon the Extremity of the great Crystalline , do intersect the Axis ; which causes their sight to be less confused , although it be never so distinct as that of Men and Birds , which have but one Crystalline .
Fishes have also a double Crystalline , for otherwise their sight would be more confused than that of other Animals who live in the Air , for their Crystalline being spherical , the rays cut the Axis more unequally than it it were lenticular and its convexities were of a greater sphere ; and it ought necessarily to be spherical , because the refraction of the Rays , which pass from the water into the Crystalline , is very small , and would make its focus too far distant if the Crystalline were lenticular .
The difficulty of your Second objection proceeds also from an Ambiguity of words , and consists in knowing , what we are to say it is , that has a great continuity and communication with the Brain .
My Hypothesis is , that the Nerves are all coated with the Pia Matter ( which envelops all the Spinal Marrow ) and have with it the same continuity of fibers ; so that if these nerves be never so little moved , the impression is carried to the Brain by the Continuity of these fibers ; and whether it be , that the texture is different in Nerves of different senses ; or that they contain some sp rituous liquors which determine their sensations , by some differences they have among themselves ; it is certain , that the Nerves of Sight , in what manner soever they are moved , represent Colours and Lights ; those of Hearing , Sounds , and those of the Touch , Pains , &amp;c. Now the Choroeides is an Expansion and dilatation of the Pia Matter , which enveloppes internally the Optique Nerve , and which comes from the tuberosity of the Spinal Marrow , by a continuity of fibe s ; whence it follows , that how little soever the Choroeides be touched , the impression may be easily communicated to the brain : And to the end , that the same thing may be said of the Retina , there must be a little channel in the Optic nerve , through which the Retina in its proper Substance extends it self to this tuberosity by a continuity of Fibers ; which is not seen , and you are constrained to say , that there are little filaments of nerves which come from the interior of the Optic , and expand themselves through the Retina , which have this continuity ; but if there were these filaments , they should spread themselves through the Retina , as from a Center to a Circumference , and should lye closer together near the Optic nerve , than a good way farther in the Retina : which nevertheless we do not observe to be so .
Besides , if you thrust a pin through the thickness of the Retina , you will often meet with filaments ; but if you look on them through a Convex glass , you will discover , that they end in little vessels of Veins and Arteries , which are in the Retina ; and infallibly , if there were any nerves , you might find them in the same manner , and they would stop the Pin , since they are as hard and firm as the little Arteries ; and when you say , that one may distinguish these filaments in the water , because the rest of the Retina disappears , that is repugnant to experience , and to what you have said before , viz. that the Retina may be seen all white in the water , and without transparency ; and you ought to show these filaments , or else we shall take them for a thing invented at pleasure .
You bring after that two Experiments ; the first of which is , that if an aperture be made on the upper part of the Eye , we may discover the Picture of the Objects on the anterior surface of the Retina ; but if this aperture be made in the white of the Eye , the aqueous humour will run to the Tunica Cornea , and make wrinkles , which will hinder the Picture from being distinct : Besides , he that looks in at this aperture , will hinder the Rays of the Object from passing into the Eye , and he shall see nothing there but his own image .
But if you mean , that the Tunica Cornea should be wholly taken off , there will not then be distance enough between the Chrystallin and the Retina , to make the Picture distinct .
In conclusion , I do not believe this Experiment can be made , much less that it is to be discerned whether this Picture be formed on the anteriour or posteriour surface of the Retina , since the thickness of it is less than half a line , or the 24th part of an inch ; and there is reason to believe , that you have trusted to the report of some other concerning this Experiment ; or that you have believed the images which appear in the Eyes to be painted on the Retina , whereas they proceed from the reflexion made on the exterior of the Cornea .
Your second Experiment is true and easy to be made , but according to you it were impossible ; for , since you hold , that it is on the anteriour part of the Retina , that the Picture is seen , and that you have elsewhere said , that one cannot well see through this Membrane , it follows , that you cannot see this Picture through the thickness of the Retina ; but because I believe , there remains transparency enough in that part of the Retina which is not exposed to the Air , I doubt not but the Picture may be seen on the posteriour part of it , after it is become sufficiently opake , though in a living Animal this Picture passes as far as the Choroeides , as it hath been already proved : and if the Retina it self were taken away , and there remained only the vitreous humour , you might notwithstanding see the inverted Picture of the Windows toward the bottom of the Eye , if you held it at the farther side of the room ; in the same manner as the Picture is to be seen in the Focus of the spherical Glass-bottle filled with water , though it seem to be on the exterior surface of the Glass ; and by consequence this Experiment proves not the opacity of the Retina .
In your third Objection you quote , what I said , a little otherwise than I spoke it ; for I put in my Writing , that the Retina was about half a line in thickness , and not half a line precisely ; which showed , I had not measured it exactly ; but if it were but a quarter of a line or less , it suffices that it had enough for the effect I did attribute to it : And for another , I did also mention in my Writing , which is , that the Rays of the same luminous point , which do not unite precisely in the same points in the Axis , are rectified by the concavity of the Retina , those that are farthest off the Axis more than those which are the nearest , which is the reason they unite better in the same point on the Choroeides ; the which point I hold ( with you ) to be Physical , since the points objective are so too ; but I hold it to be lesser than any that can be perceptible to the sight ; for we distinguish the different parts of very small objects , as the extremities of the breadth of the little arteries of the Retina , which make not an eigth part of its thickness ; and that which represents this small breadth , must be 25 or 30 times less in the Organ of our sight , that is to say , in the proportion of the distance of the Object , to the Centre of the sight , and of the distance of this Centre , to the Organ of vision ; and by consequence the thickness of the Retina is not proper for this smallness .
You see , then Sir , that hitherto your objections have been able but very lightly to shake my opinion , and that the transparency of the Retina is well enough established : Let us come now to the proof , I make of the Want of Vision , on the Basis of the Optic Nerve .
It must first of all be agreed , that in this Experiment , almost all men do loose sight of an entire circle of white paper , whose diameter is about the 9th or 10th part of its distance from the Eye .
Now the visual Triangle , whose Basis is the Diameter of the Circle , and whose top is the Center of vision , is proportioned to the Triangle , whose Basis is the Diameter of the picture of the Circle on the bottom of the eye , and the top , the same center of sight ; the which center being distant 6 or 7 lines from the basis of the optic nerve , whose breadth is about 3/ 4 of a line , this basis also will be about the 9th or 10th part of its distance from the Center of sight , and by the Principles of Opticks , the Image of the circle of the white paper , falling on the basis of the optic nerve , will cover it precisely ; and because the Paper then wholly disappears , it follows , that all the basis of the Optic nerve is insensible of light ; whence I conclude , that the Choroeides is the Principal Organ of sight ; and that the Retina is not , seeing it is placed in that part , and is there apparently disposed in like manner as to the rest of the bottom of the Eye .
To elude the force of this Argument , you allege other causes of this fault of sight ; the two first are almost like one another .
But it seems to me , that you suppose them without any ground : for , as I said before , there are no such filaments of nerves to be seen coming out of the basis of the optic nerve ; besides , they are not proper for vision , since they would leave in the parts of the Retina too great intervals empty ; and its necessary , that every point of the Object find a sensible point in the Organ of sight to unite his rays there ; which is found in the Choroeides , which is an Expansion of the sensible part of the nerve into a continued membrane .
Besides , the causes of the defect of vision cannot be found in these Hypotheses ; for in the first , what reason can be given , that there should be no extremities of nerves opposite to the optic nerve .
since there would need only a simple direct continuation of some of its fibers unto the Anteriour part of the Retina ; and for the second ( which is the particular opinion ) I see not , how the void space in the middle of the inverted Tuft , can comprehend all that extent of the basis whence it proceeds , and why the filaments begin not to receive the impression of the luminous Rays , but upon the Extremity of this basis , since the rays of a luminous point , which unite themselves in a point at the bottom of the Eye , come from divers points of the Crystalline , and so , if one part of these rays were oblique , the other should be perpendicular , and if all the Rays should fall perpendicular on the Organ of sight , there would be no vision , since there is never but one single Ray of those which unite in a point , that falls perpendicular .
But I shall not enlarge my self to demonstrate these impossibilities , since I am persuaded , that these inverted tufts , and these filaments of which they are composed , are but things without a foundation , and which you would have much a doe to show us .
The other Cause which you bring , is the trunk of the vessels which proceed from the basis of the nerve .
Yet you cannot deny but they are very small , and that it is very hard to discern the little holes through which they pass , when the nerve is cut off above its insertion into the Eye ; and because they often come out of the basis by two several little holes , the diameter of each of which does not take up the space of above the eighth part of the diameter of the basis ; it follows , that if the rest of the nerve were sensible of light , we should not loose sight of a paper of two inches diameter at most , at ten foot distance : and sometimes in fixing one eye on a little piece of Paper , two other , very little ones , separated one from the other , would disappear ; which is contrary to experience : for the default of vision is continued .
Seing than the reasons which you alledg of this default of fight are either insufficient , or want an assured foundation , it follows , that that which I propose must stand , at least , in respect of any thing you urge against it .
And to confirm it yet more , I will add here some reasons and observations , which are neither in my letter nor in my writing .
The first observation which is very common , is that of the Pupilla dilates it self in the shade , and contracts it self in a great light , and it is very hard to find the cause of this unvoluntary motion , but by the Hypothesis , that the Choroeides is sensible of light , for then it is easy to conceive that it being hurt by too strong a vision , it may dilate or contract its fibers , which have one continuity with those of the forepatt of the uvea , so that it can contract its aperture , and when it is not hurt , relax it again : whereas if the Retina be supposed to be the Organ of sight , it will be very difficult to explain how this contraction is made .
The second is that of the glass bottle full of water , when a lighted candle is placed near its focus : for it is easy to prove that if one hold his hand between the Candle and the bottle , he will feel more heat than if he held it in the reciprocal Focus ; that is to say , the place where the Rays , which have passed thorough the bottle , make a great image of the flame of the Candle appear inverted upon a white surface opposed to it : for I draw this consequence , that the Image of a Candle , which is painted on the Choroeides of a dog , as I have proved to you , makes a much greater impression on the Retina of the dog , than on that of him that looks on it and sees it very bright ; whence I conclude that if the Retina were the Organ of sight , this dog would not see the objects indifferently inlightned , which are about the candle , although at 3 or 4 foot distance , because they would receive a great deal more impression from this reflexion , and that a great sensation doth obliterate a lesser ; which is contrary to experience , and it is not at all likely , there should be such a defect in the fight of Animals .
The third is , that the Eyes of Birds are so framed , that the Optique nerve after its insertion into the Eye is inflected , and extends it self on the Concavity of the Sclerotis about the breadth of 2 or 3 lines more or less according to the bigness of the Eyes ; and the length of this inflection is covered by the Choroeides , leaving but one little white streak in the middle , from whence the Retina takes its Original , which extends itself on the Choroeides through all the bottom of the Eye , but it is covered on the side of this white streak with a little black membrane as long as the inflexion of the nerve , and almost as broad ; which proceeds from the pia matter , and is as it were an appendix of the Choroeides : and if you consider the situation of this membrane , you will find it is near the Axis of sight , and that the rays of the Objects , which the Birds look on with both Eyes , fall precisely upon it after their refraction .
Since then in the place , where Vision ought to be strongest , the Retina is covered , and that no man doubts but Birds are more clear-sighted than other Animals ; you ought to acknowledge , that the Retina is not the principal Organ of Vision , but that that preeminence belongs to the Choroeides .

