Some Observations , Directions and Inquiries Concerning the Motion of Sap in Trees , in pursuance of what was formerly begun therein , about the latter end of 1668 .
and the next following Spring , by Dr Ezerel Tonge , and Francis Willoughby Esq ; We shall here begin , according to the order of time , with the late Communications of D. Tonge , which , are as follows ; I Now begin my Inquiries and remarks upon the last published Observations of those Ingenious persons Mr Willoughby and Mr Wray in your Ph. Transact. N. 48 .
June 21 .
1669 , And First , to the 3d and 4th Experiments I propose this Inquiry ; At what Season of the year , Month , day , and in what wind and weather , Branches and young Trees ( especially small Branches ) are so full of Sap , that , being held perpendicular , they will bleed at both ends , as is there related ; and Roots , both ways ?
And what gage the Barometers and Thermometers then held ?
And in what forwardness their Buds and Leaves , or Chats were then shot , or broken ?
And of what Diameter such Roots were ?
The latter part of the 4th Experiment appearing so manifestly to disagree with some Experiments , I have made this Year , as well as formerly in Roots and Branches of Trees ; whereby I found , that not only Cold weather , but Cold Wind and Sun-setting stopped or abated the Motion of Sap in the Sycamore : Which puzleth me , how to direct an Inquiry to find out the Cause of this singular Experiment , add of the Observations also in the 11th Experiment , which highly confirms this .
The best directions I can at present devise , ( until the Experimenters shall please to give us an account of the Time , Season , and that not only by the Month , day , hour , but also by the wind , and the motions of the weather-glass , before , after , and at the instant of those Observations ; ) are the ensuing ; which we than conclude with some other inquiries .
1 .
What the difference of the Seasons of that Experiment was from the foregoing§ 2 Whether the Heat were so great , when the Sycamores so sensibly abated , that it coagulated their Juice , and , by thickning it into Jelly and so into wood , ended the running ?
And therefore 3 .
Whether this Experiment of Cold , promoting , and of Heat , stopping the bleeding , were not in the later end of their running only , and not in the former ?
And if so , Whether 4 , the rising of Sap be not rather to be attributed to the Degree of heat , than the Abatement of Heat§ 5 .
Whether the reason , that the Birch increased , when the Sycamore abated , be not also to be imputed to this , that the Birch runs not ordinarily till March ( unless in a forward season ) and the Sycamore and lesser Maple in January ; and so the season of the ones Sap , beginning sooner , doth also end sooner : And whether thereupon it be not observed , that the season of the Birches Jellying into wood will not commence till a greater heat , as that of May ; whereas the Maple-Sap probably will condense to Jelly and wood in a lesser heat , as that of March going out , or April beginning§ 6 .
Whether this be not also probably the reason of what is observed in the 12th Experiment in the same N.48.viz .
the Sycamores running more on the North , and less on the South-side , contrary to my yesterdays Observation ( March 1 16 69/ 70 , )the Southern branches yet dropping in the afternoon when others ceased§ 7 .
Whether the Birch also in such seasons , after the Maple and Sycamore cease running , will not bleed more in colder weather , suppose in the middle or beginning of May , or latter end of April , and so verify my Experiment of the Sycamore running in hotter , and staying in colder seasons , or in the sign Pisces , the latter end of February , and the beginning of March ; and on the contrary , running in colder and staying in hotter seasons , viz. of Aries or the latter end of March and the beginning of April : Or briefly , In what Signs , and what weather as to wet and dry chiefly , the Birch and Maple bleed in hot , and stay in cold weather , &amp; vice versa ?
Which temper of weather I would have accurately observed by Weather-glasses and Barometers .
8 .
If this be found to verify my Conjecture , then Whether by the running and staying of these Trees , and the first rising and ceasing of their Sap , may not probably ( in some measure , by diligent Observation and comparing ObC 2 servations servations of time , season , weatherglasses , )be found the difference of Climats , Land , and Scituation ; as also of Years forwardly or late fruitful , or of years unfruitful§ 9 .
Whether the Observations of Quality as well as Quantity of Sap by Distillations after fermentation , &amp; c may not also conduce to the Prognostique of the Fruitfulness or Barrenness of a year , especially in Walnuts , and such Fruit-Bearers as yield plenty of Sap , and by analogy and observation from them to others : As ( e.g. ) whether a fruitful or unfruitful year of Hazel or Filbert-nuts may not probably be discovered by their Scarlet-blossoms , not appearing this year till now ?
( March 2 .
) 10 .
Whether Ablaqueation ( or digging about and baring the roots of Trees ) will retard the rising of sap in the Walnut &amp;c. and what other effect it will have on fruit , &amp; c ?
And whether such Baring of Roots of Pear , Plum and Cherrytrees ( which are as much forwarder than Apples , as Maples are than Birch &amp;c. ) and generally of all forwarder Trees , should not be made in different seasons(accordingly)from Mulberries and such like§ 11 .
V Vhether Amendment of ground , laid after the Sap ceaseth , be not fruitless as to that year , or much less beneficial than what is laid before§ 12 Whether the seasonableness of watering may not be found and promoted by a right Inquiry , and by a due satisfaction to these Queries§ 13 .
Whether Ablaqueation , watering , Amendment , &amp; c , according to these seasons , may not be so directed , as to increase Fruit , Wood , or both , or either at pleasure§ 14 .
Whether Ablaqucation , which so alters the rising of Sap , that it curdles them , when it should run , doth not hurt§ 15 .
Whether the same hath influx on the Leaves , Suckers and outward products of the Tree , or on the inward also , as fruit ; or only increases their quantity , by accident hindring the growth and draught of other parts which did rob the fruit§ 16 .
Whether the Cool seasons of the Night afford not some temperament in these cases , so that thereby , as tis in cool seasons , the Sap runs and Jellies by day , as it runs by night§ 17 .
Whether in some warm days , in which the Sycamore runs not at Noon or in the heat of the day , it run in the Night , or the Cool of the day , and , on the contrary , the Birch run by day or about Noon .
and cease at Night or Sun-set , in the same seasons§ 18 .
The same Queries might also be prosecuted in the Hop , which runs after the extreme heat of the Summer , after the Hops are ripe and gathered , or any other Plant , that runs in Summer or Autumn , if there be any such .
So far the Inquisitive Doctor for this time : To which we cannot but subjoyn the Letter of that Worthy and Observing Gentleman , Mr. V Villoughby , containing an Answer to such of the precedent remarks and Inquiries , as concerned him , and therefore were imparted to him .
It runs thus .
Sir , it is no wonder ; that Dr Tonges Experiments concerning the Bleeding of the Sycamore do not agree with ours , they being made in a different season ; his , in February , and ours towards the end of March , viz the Cold , which caused the Increase of the bleeding in the Sycamore and Walnut , happened upon the 23 .
24 .
25 .
26 .
March ; and one Sycamore , which ceased to bleed from the 11th of the same Month , bled afresh copiously from wounds that had been made so long before : The Buds before the cold were Just ready to open into Leaves , and the Sap had begun to coagulate above a sortnight before .
This year , making incisions in the Sycamore and common Maple , in January , immediately upon the relenting of the first Frost , we found that they both bled , and faster , as the weather grew hotter ; nor did the succeeding Cold promote , but rather hinder their bleeding .
So that the Learned Doctor doth most ingeniously conjecture , that the Ascent of Sap in Trees epends upon a certain Degree of heat , sufficient to raise , but not to coagulate their respective Juyces .
In those Months , wherein the Heat ordinarily falls short of that Degree , an accidental heat or warmth of weather promotes the bleeding ; but in those Months , wherein the ordinary temper of the Air exceeds that Degree , an extraordinary fit of colder weather makes them bleed again .
The Experiments concerning the Northern and Southern sides of Sycamores were made at the same time ; and are well solved by the same Hypothesis .
In Walnut-trees , we never yet found , that Heat promoted their bleeding , but always Cold .
From a wound , made in a Walnut-tree , in January , and the beginning of this pretent March , in mild weather , nothing issued ; but the weather changing and growing colder , it bled plentifully : Which seems not well to consist with that Hypothesis , and must be better examined .
Last year , the 6th and 7th of March we made the Experiments of the Bleeding of Poles ( held perpendicular ) at bo h ends , in Willow , Birch , and Sycamore : which may so easily and certainly be found to succeed , in a great latitude both as to the bigness of the boughs and temper of the weather , in the best Bleeding season , that there needs no such exact niceness in the Observation of those particulars .
The 11th of March , Roots of Birch , great and small , bled both ways ; and about the same time , Sycamore roots also .
Of all which I doubt not , but Dr Tonge is by this time fully satisfied by his own Experiments .
The same Birch , which first began to bleed the 3d of March this Year , bled 3 weeks sooner last year .
Trial would be made , whether Cold will dissolve the Sap already coagulated : Else it will be hard , in the Doctors Hypothesis , to give an account of the Trees dropping a new in Cold weather .
It was last Autumn observed by our ingenious Friend Mr Martin Lister , that upon the first Frost , which happened in November , a Sycamore bled copiously ; so that the Sap cannot be said to rise in January , but immediately after the Fall of the leaf , in this Tree .
Our Experiments , which you have already printed , are most true , and according to the Doctors Hypothesis , will very well agree with his .
His Deductions and Inquiries are very rational and well deserve to be made public .
Various interruptions have hindred us from the diligent prosecuting of these Experiments this Spring ; which that I may more critically make hereafter , I must pro ur two Sealed Thermometers and two Barometers .
I am &amp;c. Dat .
Middleton in Warwick-shire March 12 .
1669/ 70 .

