ANIMADVERSIONS Of Dr. Wallis , upon Mr. Hobs 's late Book , De Principiis &amp; Ratiocinatione Geometrarum .
These were communicated by way of Letter , written in Oxford , July 24 .
1666 .
to an Acquaintance of the Author , as follows : SInce I saw you last , I have read over Mr. Hobs 's Book Contra Geometras(or De Principiis &amp; Ratiocinatione Geometrarum)which you then showed me .
A New Book of Old matter : Containing but a Repetition of what he had before told us , more than once ; and which hath been Answered long ago .
In which , though there be Faults enough to offer ample matQ q2 ter ter for a large Confutation : yet I am scarce inclined to believe , that any will bestow so much pains upon it .
For , if that be true , which ( in his Preface ) he saith of himself , Aut solus insanio Ego , aut solus non insanio : it would either be Needless , or to no Purpose .
For , by his own confession , All others , if they be not mad themselves , ought to think Him so : And therefore , as to Them , a Confutation would be needless ; who , its like , are well enough satisfied already : at least out of danger of being seduced .
And , as to himself , it would be to no purpose .
For , if He be the Mad man , it is not to be hoped that he will be convinced by Reason : Or , if All We be so ; we are in no capacity to attempt it .
But there is yet another Reason , why I think it not to need a Confutation .
Because what is in it , hath been sufficiently confuted already ; ( and , so Effectually ; as that he professes himself not to Hope , that This Age is like to give sentence for him ; what ever Nondum imbuta Posteritas may do .
) Nor doth there appear any Reason , why he should again Repeat it , unless he can hope , That , what was at first False , may by oft Repeating , become True .
I shall therefore , instead of a large Answer , only give you a brief Account , what is in it ; &amp; , where it hath been already Answered .
The chief of what he hath to say , in his first 10 Chapters , against Euclids Definitions , amounts but to this , That he thinks , Euclide ought to have allowed his Point some Bigness ; his Line , some Breadth ; and his Surface , some Thickness .
But where in his Dialogues , page .151,152 .
he solemnly undertakes to Demonstrate it ; ( for it is there , his 41th Proposition : ) his Demonstration amounts to no more but this ; That , unless a Line be allowed some Latitude ; it is not possible that his Quadratures can be True .
For finding himself reduced to these inconveniences ; 1 .
That his Geometrical Constructions , would not consist with Arithmetical calculations , nor with what Archimedes and others have long since demonstrated : 2 .
That the Arch of a Circle must be allowed to be sometimes Shorter than its Chord , and sometimes longer than its Tangent : 3 .
That the fame Straight Line must be allowed , at one place only to Touch , and at another place to Cut the same Circle : ( with others of like nature ; ) He finds it necessary , that these things may not seem Absurd , to allow his Lines some Breadth , ( that so , as he speaks , While a Staight Line with its Out-side doth at one place Touch the Circle , it may with its In-side at another place Cut it , &amp;c. ) But I should sooner take this to be a Confutation of His Quadratures , than a Demonstration of the Breadth of a ( Mathematical ) Line .
Of which , see my Hobbius Heauton-timorumenus , from page .
114 .
to p. 1 .
9 .
And what he now Adds , being to this purpose ; That though Euclid 's ~ , which we translate , a Point , be not indeed Nomen Quanti , yet cannot this be actually represented by any thing , but what will have some Magnitude ; nor can a Painter , no not Apelles himself , draw a Line so small , but that it will have some Breadth ; nor can Thread be spun so Fine , but that it will have some Bigness ; ( page .
2,3,19,21 .
) is nothing to the Business ; For Euclide doth not speak either of such Points , or of such Lines .
He should rather have considered of his own Expediene page .
11 .
That , when one of his ( broad ) Lines , passing through one of his ( great ) Points , is supposed to cut another Line proposed , into two equal parts ; we are to understand , the Middle of the breadth of that Line , passing through the middle of that Point , to distinguish the Line given into two equal parts .
And he should then have considered further , that Euclide , by a Line , means no more than what Mr. Hobs would call the middle of the breadth of his ; and Euclide 's Point , is but the Middle of Mr. Hobs 's .
And then , for the same reason , that Mr. Hobs 's Middle must be said to have no Magnitude ; ( For else , not the whole Middle , but the Middle of the Middle , will be in the Middle : And , the Whole will not be equal to its Two Halves ; but Bigger than Both , by so much as the Middle comes to : ) Euclide 's Lines must as well be said to have no Breadth ; and his Points no Bigness .
In like manner , When Euclide and others do make the Term or End of a Line , a Point : If this Point have Parts or Greatness , then not the Point , but the Outer-Half of this Point ends the Line , ( for , that the Inner-Half of that Point is not at the End , is manifest , because the Outer-Half is beyond it : ) And again , if that Outer Half have Parts also ; not this , but the Outer part of it , and again the Outer part of that Outer part , ( and so in infinitum .
) So that , as long as Any thing of Line remains , we are not yet at the End : And consequently , if we must have passed the whole Length , before we be at the End ; then that End ( or Punctum terminans ) has nothing of Length ; ( for , when the whole Length is past , there is nothing of it left .
And if Mr. Hobs tells us ( as page .
3 .
) that this End is not Punctum , but only Signum ( which he does allow non esse nomen Quanti ) even this will serve our turn well enough .
Euclid 's ~ , which some Interpreters render by Signum , others have thought fit ( with Tully ) to call Punctum : But if Mr. Hobs like not that name , we will not contend about it .
Let it be Pun .
ctum , or let it be Signum ( or , if he please , he may call it Vexillum .
) But then he is to remember , that this is only a Controversy in Grammar , not in Mathematicks : And his Book should have been entitled Contra Grammaticos , not , Contra Geometras .
Nor is it Euclide , but Cicero , that is concerned , in rendring the Greek ~ , by the Latin Punctum , not by Mr. Hobs 's Signum .
The Mathematician is equally content with either word .
What he saith here , Chap. 8 .
&amp; 19 .
( and in his fifth Dial .
p. 105 .
&amp;c. ) concerning the Angle of Contact ; amounts but to thus much , That , by the Angle of Contact , he doth not mean either what Euclide calls an Angle , or any thing of that kind ; ( and therefore says nothing to the purpose of what was in controversy between Clavins and Peletarius , when he says , that An Angle of Contact hath some magnitude : ) But , that by the Angle of Contact , he understands the Crookedness of the Arch ; and in saying , the Angle of Contact hath some magnitude , his meaning is , that the Arch of a Circle hath some crookedness , or , is a crooked line : and that , of equal Arches , That is the more crooked , whose chord is shortest : which I think none will deny ; ( for who ever doubted , but that a circular Arch is crooked ?
or , that , of such Arches , equal in length , That is the more crooked , whose ends by bowing are brought nearest together ?
) But , why the Crookedness of an Arch , should be called an Angle of Contact ; I know no other reason , but , because Mr. Hobs loves to call that Chalk , which others call Cheese .
Of this see my Hobbins Heauton-timorumenus , from page .
88 .
to p. 100 .
What he faith here of Rations or Proportions , and their Calculus ; for 8 .
Chapters together , ( Chap. 11 .
&amp; c , ) is but the same for substance , what he had formerly said in his 4th .
Dialogue , and elsewhere .
To which you may see a full Answer , in my Hobbius Heauton-tim .
from page 49 .
to p. 88 .
which I need not here repeat .
Only ( as a Specimen of Mr. Hobs 's Candour , in Falsifications ) you may by the way observe , how he deals with a Demonstration of Mr. Rook 's , in confutation of Mr. Hobs 's Duplication of the Cube : Which when he had repeated , page .
43 .
He doth then ( that it might seem absurd ) change those words , aequales quatuor cubis DV ; ( page .
43 .
line 33 .
) into these ( p. 44 .
1 .
5 .
) a qualia quatuor Linis , nempe quadruplus Rectae DV : And would thence per swade you , that Mr. Rook had assigned a Solide , equal to a Line .
But Mr. Rook 's Demonstration was clear enough for Mr. Hobse 's Comment .
Nor do I know any Mathematician ( unless you take Mr. Hobs to be one ) who thinks that a Line multiplied by a Number will make a Square ; ( what ever Mr. hobs is pleased to teach us .
) But , That a Number multiplied by a Number , may make a Square Number ; and , That a Line drawn into a Line may make a square Figure , Mr. Hobs ( if he were , what he would be thought to be ) might have known before now .
Or .
( if he had not before known it ) he might have learned , ( by what I show him upon a like occasion , in my Hob .
Heaut .
page .
142 .
143 .
144 .
) ` How to understand that language , without an Absurdity .
Just in the same manner he doth , in the next page , deal with Clavius .
For having given us his words , page .
45 1 .
3 .
4 .
Dico hanc Lineam Perpendicularem extra circulum cadere ( because neither intra Circulum , nor in Peripheria ; ) He doth , when he would show an error , first make one , by falsifying his words , line 15 .
where instead of Lineam Perpendicularem , he substitutes Punctum A. Asif Euclide or Clavins hd denied the Point A. ( the utmost point of the Radius , ) to be in the Circumference Or , as if Mr. Hobs , by proving the Point A , to be in the Circumference , had thereby proved , that the Perpendicular Tangent AE had also lyen in the Circumference of the Circle .
But this is a Trade , which Mr. Hobs doth drive so often , as if he were as well faulty in his Morals , as in his Mathematicks .
The Quadrature of a Circle , which here he gives us , Chap. 20 .
21 .
23 .
is one of those Twelve of his , which in my Hobbius Heauton-timorumenus ( from page .
104 .
to page 119 ) are already confuted : And is the Ninth in order ( as ~ there rank them ) which is particularly considered , page .
106 .
107 .
108 .
I call it One , because he takes it so to be ; though it might as well be called Two .
For , as there , so here , it consists of Two branches , which are Both False ; and each overthrow the other .
For if the Arch of a Quadrant be equal to the Aggregate of the Semidiameter and of the Tangent of 30 .
Degrees .
( as he would Here have it , in Chap. 20 .
and There , in the close of Prop. 27 ; ) Then is it not equal to that Line , whose Square is equal to Ten squares of the Semiradius , ( as , There , he would have it , in Prop. 28 .
and , Here , in Chap. 23 .
) And if it be equal to This , then not to That .
For This , and That , are not equal : As I then demonstrated ; and need not now repeat it .
The grand Fault of his Demonstration ( Chap. 30 .
) wherewith he would now New-vamp his old False quadrature ; lies in those words Page 40 .
line 30 , 31 .
Quod Impossibile est nisi ba transeat per c. which is no impossibility at all .
For though he first bid us draw the Line R c , and afterwards the Line R d. Yet , Because he hath no where proved ( nor is it true ) that these two are the same Line ; ( that is , that the point d lies in the Line R c , or that Rc passes through d : ) His proving that Rd cuts off from ab a Line equal to the line of B c , doth not prove , that ab passes through c : For this it may well do , though ab lye under c. ( vid .
in case d lye beyond the line R c , that is , further from A : ) or though it lye above c , ( vid .
in case d be nearer , than R c , to the point A. ) And therefore , unless he first prove ( which he cannot do ) that Ad ( a sixth part of A D ) doth just reach to the line Rc and no further ; he only proves that a sixth part of ab is equal to the Line of B c. But , whether it lye above it , or below it , or ( as Mr. Hobs would have it ) just upon it ; this argument doth not conclude .
( And therefore Hugenius 's assertion , which Mr. Hobs , Chat .
21 .
would have give way to this Demonstration , doth , notwithstanding this , remain safe enough .
) His demonstration of Chap 23 .
( where he would prove , that the aggregate of the Radius and of the Tangent of 30 .
Degrees is equal to a Line , whose square is equal to 10 Squares of the Semiradius ; ) is confuted not only by me , ( in the place forecited ; where this is proved to be impossible ; ) but by himself also , in this same Chap. page .
59 ( where he proves sufficiently and doth confess , that this demonstration , and the 47 .
Prop. of the first of Euclide , cannot be both true .
) But , ( which is worst of all ; ) whether Euclid 's Proposition be False or True , his demonstration must needs be False .
I or he is in this Dilemma : If that Proposition be True , his demonstration is False , for he grants that they cannot be both True , page 59 line 21 .
22 .
And again , if that Proposition be False , his Demonstration is so too ; for This depends upon That , page 55 .
line 22 and therefore must fall with it .
But the Fault is obvious in His Demonstration ( not in Euclid 's Proposition : ) The grand Fault of it ( though there are more ) lies in those words , page 56 .
line 26 .
Erit ergo MO minus quam MR Where , instead of minus , he should have said majus .
And when he hath mended that Error ; he will find , that the major in page 56 .
line penult , will very well agree with majorem in page 57 .
line 1 ( where the Printer hath already mended the Fault to his hand ) and then the Falsum ergo will vanish .
His Section of an Angle in ratione data ; Chap. 22 hath no other foundation , than his supposed Quadrature of Chap. 20 .
And therefore , that being false ; this must fall with it .
It is just the same with that of his 6 .
Dialogue .
Prop. 46 .
which ( besides that it wants a foundation ) how absurd it is , I have already showed ; in my Hobbius Heauton timor .
page 119 .
120 .
His Appendix , wherein he undertakes to show a Method of finding any number of mean Proportionals , between two Lines given : Depends upon the supposed Truth of his 22 .
Chapter ; about Dividing an Arch in any proportion given : ( As himself professes : and as is evident by the Construction ; which supposes such a Section .
) And therefore , that failing , this falls with it .
And yet this is otherwise faulty , though that should be supposed True .
For , In the first Demonstration ; page 67 .
line 12 .
Producta Lf incidet in I ; is not proved ; nor doth it follow from his Quoniam igitur .
In the second Demonstration ; page 68 .
line 34 35 .
Recta L fincidit in x , is not proved ; nor doth it follow from his Quare .
In his third Demonstration ; page 71 : line 7 .
Producta YP transibit per M ; is said gratis ; nor is any proof offered for it .
And so this whole structure falls to the ground .
And withal , the Prop. 47 .
El .
I doth still stand fast ( which he tells us , page 59 , 61 , 78 .
must have Fallen , if his Demonstrations had stood : ) And so , Geometry and Arthemetick do still agree , which ( he tells us , page 78 : line 10 .
) had otherwise been at odds .
And this ( though much more might have been said , ) is as much as need to be said against that Piece .
Printed with Licence for John Martyn , and James Allestry , Printers to the Royal Society

