An APPENDIX , written by way of Letter to the Publisher ; Being an Answer to some Objections , made by several Persons , to the precedent Discourse .
I Received yours ; and am very well contented , that objections be made against my Hypothesis concerning Tides : being proposed but as a conjecture to be examined ; and upon that Examination , rectified , if there be occasion ; or rejected , if it will not hold water .
1 .
To the first objection of those you mention ; That it appears not how two Bodies , that have no tie , can have one common Center of Gravity : that is ( for so I understand the intendment of the objection ) can act or be acted in the same manner , as if they were connected : I shall only answer , that it is harder to show How they have , than That they have it .
That the Loadstone and Iron have somewhat equivalent to a Tie ; though we see it not , yet by the effects we know .
And it would be easy to show , that two Load-stones , at once applied , in different positions , to the same Needle , at some convenient distance ; will draw it , not to point directly to either of them , but to some point between both ; which point is , as to those two , the common Center of Attraction ; and it is the same , as if some one Loadstone were in that point .
Yet have these two Load stones no connexion or tie , though a Common Center of Virtue according to which they jointly act .
And as to the present case , How the Earth and Moon are connected ; I will not now undertake to show ( nor is it necessary to my purpose ; ) but , That there is somewhat , that doth connect them , ( as much as what connects the Load-stone , and the Iron , which it draws , ) is past doubt to those , who allow them to be carried about by the Sun , as one Aggregate or Body , whose parts keep a respective position to one another : Like as Jupiter with his four Satellites , and Saturn with his one .
Some Tie there is , that makes those Satellites attend their Lords , and move in a Body ; though we do not See that Tie , nor Hear the Words of Command .
And so here .
2 .
To the second objection ; That , at Chatham and in the Thames , the Annual Spring-tydes , happen about the AEquinoxes ; not ( as this Hypothesis doth suppose elswhere to have been observed ) about the begining of February and November .
If their meaning be , that Annual High Tides , do then happen , and then only : If this prove true , it will case me of half my work .
For it is then easily answered , that it depends upon the Obliquity of the Zodiac ; the parts of the AEquinoctial answering to equal parts of the Zodiac , being near the Solstitial points greatest , and near the AEquinoctial points least of all .
But beside this Annual Vicissitude of the AEquinoxes , not to say , of the 4 .
Cardinal Points ( which my Hypothesis doth allow and assert ; ) I believe it will be found , that there is another Annual vicissitude answering to the Suns Apogaeum and Perigaeum .
And that the greatest Tides of all , will be found to be upon a result of these two causes Cooperating : which(as doth the Inequality of Natural days , depending on these same causes ) will light nearer the times , I mention .
To what is said to be observed at Chatham and in the Thames , contrary to that I allege as observed in Rumney marsb : I must at present apechein , and refer to a melius inquirendum .
If those who object this contrary observation , shall , after this notice , find , upon new Observations heedfully taken , that the Spring tides in February and November , are not so high , as those in March and September ; I shall then think the objection very considerable .
But I do very well remember , that I have seen in November , very high Tides at London , as well as in Rumney Marsh .
And , the time is not yet so far past , but that it may be remembered ( by your self or others then in London ) whether in November last when the Tides were so high at Dover , at Deal , at Margate , and all along the Coast from thence to Rumney Marsh , as to do in some of those places much hurt , ( and , in Holland , much more ; ) whether , I say , there were not also at the same time , at London , ( upon the Thames ) very high Tides .
But a good Diary of the Height and time both of High-water , and Low-water , for a year or two together , even at Chatham , or Greenwich ; but rather at some place in the open Sea , or at the Lands end in Cornwal , or on the West parts of Ireland ; or at St. Hellens , or the Bermodas , &amp;c. would do more to the resolving of this point , than any verbal discourse without it .
3 .
To the third Objection , That supposing the Earth and Moon to move about a Common center of gravity ; if that the highest Tides be at the New-moon , when the moon being nearest to the Sun , the Earth is farthest from it , and its compound motion at the swiftest ; and that the Tides abate as the Earth approaches nearer , till it comes into the supposed Circle of her Annual motion : It may be demanded , why do they not still abate as the Earth comes yet nearer to the Sun and the swiftness of its compound motion still slackens ?
And so , why have we not Spring tides at the New Moon ( when the motion is swiftest ) and Neap-tides at Full Moon ( when the motion is slowest ) but Spring tides at both ?
The answer ( if observed ) is already given in my Hypothesis it self .
Because the effect is indifferently to follow , either upon a sudden Acceleration , or a sudden Retardation .
( Like as a loose thing , lying on a moving body ; if the body be thrust suddenly forward , that loose thing is cast back , or rather left behind , not having yet obtained an equal impetus with that of the body , on which it lies ; but if stopped , or notably retarded , that loose incumbent is thrown forward , by its formerly contracted impetus not yet qualified or accomodated to the slowness of the Body , on which it lies .
) Now both of these happening , the one at the New Moon , the other at the Full Moon , do cause high Tides at both .
4 .
To the fourth Objection , That the highest Tides are not at all places , about the New Moon and Full Moon ; and particularly , that , in some places of the East Indies , the Highest Tides are at the Quadratures : I must first answer in general ; That as to the particular varieties of Tides in several parts of the World , I cannot pretend to give a satisfactory account , for want of a competent History of Tides , &amp;c. Because ( as is intimated in what I wrote in the general ) the various positions of Chanels , Bays , Promontories , Gulfs , Shallows , Currents , Trade-winds , &amp;c. must needs make an innumerable variety of Accidents in particular places , of which no satisfactory account is to be given from the general Hypothesis ( though never so true ) without a due consideration of all those .
Which is a task too great for me to undertake , being so ill furnished with materials for it .
And then as to the particular instance of some places in the East Indies , where the highest Tides are at the Quadratures : I suppose , it may be chiefly intended of those about Cambaia , and Pegu .
At which places , beside that they are situate at the inmost parts of Vast Bayes , or Gulfs ( as they are called ) they have also vast In~draughts of some hundred Miles within Land ; which when the Tides are out , do lye ( in a manner ) quite dry : And may therefore very well be supposed to participate the effect of the Menstrual Tides many days after the cause of them happens in the open Sea , upon a like ground as in Straights and narrow Channels the Diurnal Tides happen some hours later than in the Ocean .
And a like account must be given of particular accidents in other places , from the particular situation of those places , as Bays , Chanels , Currents , &amp;c. 5 .
To the 5 .
Objection , That the Spring-Tydes happen not , with us , just at the Full and Change , but two or three days after .
I should with the more confidence attempt an Answer , were I certain , whether it be so in the Open Seas , or only in our Channels .
For the Answers will not be the same in both cases .
If only in our Channels , where the Tides find a large in-draught ; but not in the Open Seas : we must seek the reason of it from the particular position of these places .
But if it be so generally in the wide Open Seas : We must then seek a reason of it from the general Hypothesis .
And , till I know the matter of Fact , I know not well , which to offer at ; lest whilst I attempt to salve one , I should fall foul of the other .
I know that Mariners use to speak of Spring-Tydes at the New and Full of the Moon ; though I have still had a suspicion that it might be some days after , as well in the open Seas , as in our narrower Channels ; ( and therefore I have chosen to say , in my Papers , About the New and Full , rather than At the New and Full ; and even when I do say At , I intend it in that laxer sense in which I suppose the Mariners are to be understood , for Near that time : ) Of which suspicion you will find some intimations even in my first Papers : But this though I can admit ; yet , because I was not sure of it , I durst not build upon it .
The truth is , the Flux and Reflux of water in a vessel , by reason of the jogging of it ; though it follow thereupon ; yet is , for the most part , discernable some time after .
For there must , upon that jog , be some time for Motion , before the Accumulation can have made a Tide .
And so I do not know but that we must allow it in all the Periods .
For as the menslrual High Tide , is not ( at least with us ) till some Days after the Full and Change ; so is the Diurnal High water , about as many Hours after the Moons coming to South ; ( I mean , At Sea : for in Chanels it varies to all Hours , according as they are nearer or further from the open Sea : ) And the Annual High-Tydes of November and February ; somewhat later than ( what I conjecture to be from the same causes ) the greatest Inequalities of the natural Days , happening in January and October .
But this though I can admit , yet ( till I am sure of the matter of Fact ) I do not build upon .
And since it hath hitherto been the custom to speak with that laxness of expression ; assigning the times of New-moon , Full-moon , and Quadratures , with the Moons coming to South , for , what is near those times : I did not think my self obliged in my conjectural Hypothesis ( while it is yet but a Candidate ) to speak more nicely .
If the Hypothesis for the maine of it be found Rational ; the Niceties of it are to be adjusted , in time , from particular Observation .
Having thus given you some Auswers to the Objections you signify to have been made by several persons to my Hypothesis , and that in the same order your Paper presents them to me : I shall next give you some account of the two Books , which you advised me to consult ; so far as seems necessary to this business : Which , upon your intimation , I have since perused , though before I had not .
And first , as to that of Isaac Vossius , De motu Marium &amp; Ventorum ; Though I do not concur with him in his Hypothesis ; That all the Great motions of the Seas , &amp;c. should arise only from so small a warming of the water as to raise it(where most of all ) not a Foot in perpendicular , ( as in his 12th Chapter ; ) Or that there is no other connexion between the Moons motion , and the Tides menstrual period , than a casual Synchronism ( which seems to be the doctrine of his 16th and 18th Chapters ; ) Beside many other things in his Philosophy , which I cannot allow : Yet I am well enough pleased with what is Historical in it , of the matter of Fact : Especially if I may be secure , that he is therein accurate and candid , not wresting the Phenomenon to his own purpose .
But I find nothing in it , which doth induce me to vary from my Hypothesis .
For , granting his Historicals to be all true ; the account of the constant Current of the Sea Westward , and of the constant Eastern Blasts , &amp;c. within the Trepicks , is much more plausibly , and ( I suppose ) truly rendered by Galilaeo long since , from the Earths Diurnal motion : ( which , near the AEquator .
describing a greater Circle , than nearer the Poles , makes the Current to be there more conspicuous and swift , and , consequently , the Eddy , or recurrent motion , nearer the Poles , where this is , more remiss : ) than can easily be rendered by so small a Tumor , as he supposes .
Not to add ; that his account of the Progressive motion , which he fansieth to follow upon this Tumetaction , and by Acceleration to grow to so great a height near the Shore ( as in Chap. 13 .
and 14 .
) is a Notion , which seems to me too extravagant to be salved by any laws of Staticks .
And that of the Moons motion only Synchronizing with the Tides , casually , without any Physical connexion ; I can very hardly assent to .
For it can hardly be imagined , that any such constant Synchronisme should be in Nature ; but where , either the one is the cause of the other , or both depend upon someCommon cause .
And where we see so fair a foundation for a Physical connection .
I am not prone to ascribe it to an Independent Synchronism .
In sum ; His History doth well enough agree with my Hypothesis ; and I think , the Phenomenon are much better salved by mine , than his .
And then as to Gassendus , in his discourse De AEstu Maris ; I find him , after the relating of many other Opinions concerning the Cause of it , inclining to that of Galilaeo , ascribing it to the Acceleration &amp; Retardation of the Earths motion , compounded of the Annual and Diurnal ; And moreover attempting to give an account of the Menstrual Periods from the Earths carrying the Moon about it self , as Jupiter doth his Satellites ; which together with them is carried about by the Sun , as one Aggregate ; ( and that the Earth with its Moon is to be supposed in like manner to be carried about by the Sun , as one Aggregate , cannot be reasonably doubted , by those who entertain the Copernican Hypothesis , and do allow the same of Jupiter and his Satellites .
) But though he would thus have the Earth and Moon looked upon as two parts of the same moved Aggregate , yet he doth still suppose ( as Galilaeo had done before him ) that the line of the Mean Motion of this Aggregate ( or , as he calls , motus aequabilis et veluti medius ) is described by the Center of the Earth ( about which Center he supposes both its own revolution to be made , and an Epicycle described by the Moons motion ; ) not by another Point , distinct from the Centers of both , about which , as the common Center of Gravity , as well that of the Earth , as that of the Moon , are to describe several Epicycles .
And , for that Reason fails of giving any clear account of this Menstrual Period .
( And in like manner , he proposes the Consideration as well of the Earths Aphelium and Peribelium , as of the AEquinoctial and Solstitial Points , in order to the finding a Reason of the Annual Vicissitudes ; but doth not fix upon any thing , in which himself can Acquiesce : And therefore leaves it in medio as he found it .
) It had been more agreeable to the Laws of Staticks , if he had , as I do , ) so considered the Earth and Moon as two parts of the same movable , ( not so , as he doth , aliam in Centro et sequentempraecise revolutionem axis , aliam remotius ac velut in circumferentia , but , ) so , as to make neither of them the Center , but both out of it , describing Epicycles about it : Like as , when a long stick thrown in the Air , whose one end is heavier than the other , is whirled about , so as that the End , which did first fly foremost , becomes hindmost ; the proper line of motion of this whole Body is not that , which is described by either End , but that , which is described by a middle point between them ; about which point each end , in whirling , describes an Epicycle .
And indeed , in the present case , it is not the Epicycle described by the Moon , but that , described by the Earth , which gives the Menstrual Vicissitudes of motion to the Water ; which would , as to this , be the same , if the Earth so move , whether there were any Moon to move or not ; nor would the Moons Motion , supposing the Earth to hold on its own course , any whit concern the motion of the Water .
But now , ( after all our Physical , or Statical Considerations)the clearest Evidence for this Hypothesis ( if it can be had ) will be from Celestial Observations .
As for instance ; ( see Fig.5 .
) Supposing the Sun at S ; the Earths place in its Annual Orb at T ; and Mars ( in opposition to the Sun , or near it ) at M : From whence Mars should appear in the Zodiac at ~ , and will at Full moon be seen there to be ; the Moon being at C and the Earth at c : ( and the like at the New-moon .
) But if the Moon be in the First quarter at A , and the Earth at a ; Mars will be seen , not at ~ but at ~ ; too flow : And when the Moon is at B , and the Earth at b. Mars will be seen at ~ ; yet too slow : till at the Fullmoon , moon , the Moon at C , the Earth at c , Mars will be seen at ~ , its true place , as if the Earth were at T. But then , after the Full , the Moon at D , the Earth at d ; Mars will be seen , not at ~ , but at ~ ; too forward : and yet more , when the Moon ( at the last Quarter ) is at E , the Earth at e , and Mars seen at ~ .
If therefore Mars ( when in opposition to the Sun ) be found ( all other allowances being made ) somewhat too backward before the Full moon , and somewhat too forward after the Full-moon , ( and most of all , at the Quadratures : ) it will be the best confirmation of the Hypothesis .
( The like may be fitted to Mars in other positions , mutatis mutandis ; and so for the other Planets .
) But this proof , is of like nature as that of the Parallaxis of the Earths Annual Orb to prove the Copernican Hypothesis .
If it can be observed , it proves the Affirmative ; but if it cannot be observed , it doth not convince the Negative , but only proves that the Semidiameter of the Earths Epicycle is so small as not to make any discernable Parallax .
And indeed , I doubt , that will be the issue .
For the Semidiameter of this Epicycle , being little more than the Semidiameter of the Earth it self , or about 11/ 3 thereof ( as is conjectured , in the Hypothesis , from the Magnitudes and Distances of the Earth and Moon compared ; ) and there having not as yet been observed any discernable Parallax of Mars , even in his nearest position to the Earth ; it is very suspicious , that here it may prove so too .
And whether any of the other Planets will be more favourable in this point , I cannot say .

