Some Considerations Touching a Letter in the Journal des Scavans of May 24 .
1666 .
In Num. 9 .
of these Transactions were published the Schemes and Descriptions of certain Ways of Sounding the Depth of the Sea without a Line ; and of Fetching up Water from the bottom of it ; together with some Experiments already made with the former of these two Contrivances .
The Author of the French Journal des Scavans found good , to insert them both in his Journal of May 3 .
but in another of May 24 .
intimates , that the said Schemes and their Descriptions are not very clear and intelligible ( he means , that they were not well understood by French Readers ) proposing also some Difficulties , relating to that Subject , and esteemed by him necessary to be satisfied , before any use could be made of the said Instruments .
Upon this occasion , the Author of these Tracts thinks fit , here to represent , First , That Englishmen and such others , as are well versed in the English tongue , find no difficulty in understanding the descriptions of these Engines , nor in apprehending their structure , exhibited by the Figures , especially if notice be taken of the Emendation , expressed at the end of Num. 10 .
about the misgraving the Bended end of the Springing Wire ( which it seems has not been noted in France , tho ' the said Num. 10 is known to have been seen there a pretty while before their Journal of May 24 .
was published ) .
And as for the particular of the Bucket , fetching water from the bottom of the Sea , both the Figure and the annexed Description thereof are so plain and clear , that it is some wonder here , that any difficulty of understanding them is pretended by any , that hath but ordinary skill in Cutts and the English language .
Mean while , that way , which the French Author recommends for this purpose as more simple , Videl .
a BrassPump with double Values , is not at all unknown in England , nor his bin left untried there ; but was found inconvenient , in respect that the Valves in descending did not fully open , and give the water a free passage through the Cavity of the Vessel , nor in ascending shut so close , as to hinder the water from coming in at the top : Whereas by the way proposed in Num. 9 .
both is performed with great ease and security .
Secondly , Whereas the French Author is of opinion , that it is unknown , how much time a Heavy Body requires to sink in water , according to a certain depth ; he may please to take notice , that that hath been made out in England by frequent Experiments ; by which , several Depths , found by this Method of sounding without a Line , were examined by trying them over again in the same place with a Line , after the common way .
And as to that Quaere of his , Whether a heavy Body descends in the same Proportion of swiftness in Water , that it would do in Air ?
The Answer is , that it does not ; but that , after it is sunk one or two fathoms into the Water , it has there arrived to its greatest swiftness , and keeps , after that , an equal degree of velocity ; the Resistance of the water being then found equal to the Endeavour of the heavy Body downwards .
Thirdly , When the same Author alleges that it must be known , when a Light Body reascends from the bottom of the water to the top , in what proportion of time and swiftness it rises .
He seems not to have considered , that in this Experiment , the times of the descent and assent are both taken and computed together ; so that for this purpose , there needs not that nicety , he discourses of .
Fourthly , Whereas it is further excepted , That this way of Sounding Depths is no new Invention ; The answer is ready , that neither is it pretended to be so , in the often quoted Tract ; it being only intimated there , that the manner of performing it , as it is in that place represented and described , is new .
Lastly , To rectify the said Author 's mistake , as if the instrument of fetching up Water from the bottom of the Sea , were chiefly contrived , to find out , Whether in some places of the Sea any Sweet Water is to be met with at the bottom : There will need no more , than to direct him to the Book it self Num. 9 .
where p. 149 .
towards the end , the First use of this Bucket is expressed to be , to know the degrees of Saltness of the Water according to its nearness to the top or bottom ; or rather to know the constitution of the Sea-water in several depths of several Climates , which is a matter , much better to be found out by Trial , than Discourse .
Neither is it any where argued in that Book ( as the French Journal insinuates ) that , because sweet water is found at the Bottom of the Sea of Baharem , therefore it must , but only that it may , be found so elsewhere .
And since the same Journal admits , that those Sweet water-springs , which yield the sweet water , that is found at the said place , have been formerly on the Continent , far enough from the Sea , which hath afterwards covered them .
It will be , it is presumed , lawful to ask , Why in many other places there may not be found the like ?
And besides , how we do know , but that there may be in other parts , Eruptious of large Springs at the bottom of the Sea , as well as there ?
Printed with Licence for John Martyn , and James Allestry , Printers to the Royal-Society .
1666 .

