Signor Campani 's Answer : and Monsieur Auzout 's Animadversions thereon .
The other part of this French Tract , containing Campani 's Answer , and Mr. Auzout his Reflections thereon , begins with the pretended Shadows of the Ring upon Saturn , and of Saturn upon the Ring .
Concerning which , the said Campani declares , that he never believed them to be shadows , made by the Ring upon the Disk of Saturn , or by the body of Saturn upon the Ring , but the Rimms of these bodies , which being unequally Luminous , did show these appearances .
In which Explication , forasmuch as it represents , that the said Campani meant to note only the Inequality of the Light , which , he saith , his Glasses did discover , Mr. Auzout does so far acquiesce , that he only wishes , that his own Glasses would show him those differences .
Next to the Objection , made by Monsieur Auzout , against Signor Company , touching the Proportion of the Length of the Ring to its breadth , Campani replies , that the Glasses of Monsieur Auzout , show not all the particulars , that his do , and therefore are unfit for determining the true Figure and breadth of the apparent Ellipsis of the Ring .
To which M. Auzout rejoyns , that he is displeased at his being destitute of better Glasses , but that it will be very hard for the future to convince Campani touching the Proportion of the Ring , seing that the breadth of the Ellipsis is always diminishing , although , if the declination of the Ring remains always the same , one can at alltimes know , which may have been its greatest breadth .
But he assures , that the breadth of the Ring is not the half of its length , and that it doth not spread out so much beyond Saturn 's Body , as he hath alleged .
And withal desirs to know , what can be answered by Sig. Campani to M. Hugens , who being persuaded , that the Declination of the Ring is not above 23 deg. 30~ having seen the Ring to spread out above the Body of Saturn , concludes , in a Letter to M. Auzout , that the length of the Ring , is more than treble the Diameter of Saturn 's body , which , according to Campani , is only as about 67 to 31 .
Which difference yet dos not appear to M. Auzout to be so great ; but that M , Hugens perhaps will impute it to the Optical reason , which he ( Auzout)hath alleged of the Advance of the light upon the obscure space ; although he is ofOpinion , he should not have concluded sogreat a Length , if he had not seen the Breadth spread out more , than he hath done : for ( saith he ) if the Length of the Ring be to the body of Saturn , as 2 3/ 2 to 1 .
and the Inclination be 23 deg. 30~ the Ring will be just as large , as the body , without spreading outs but if the Ring be bigger , it will a little spread out ; and if it were treble , it must needs spread out the half of its breadth , which hath not so appeared to him .
Further , to M. Auzout 's change of Opinion , and believing , that the Advance or Sally , seen by him in Jupiter , was the shadow of one of his Moons , Campani declares , that he would not have him guilty of that change : Whereupon M. Auzout wonders , why Campani then hath not marked it in his Figure ; and would gladly lie know , whether that Sally be more easy to discover , than the shadows of the Satellites , which Campani believs , Auzout hath not seen ; and whether he be assured , that those obscure parts , which he there distinguishes , do not change : for if they should not change , than Jupiter would not turn about his Axis , which yet , he saith , it doth , according to the Observation made by Mr. Hook , May 9 1664 .
inserted in the first papers of these Transactions .
The full Discovery of which particular also he makes to be a part of Cassini 's and Campani 's work , seeing that they so distinct .
lie see the inequalities in the Belts , and see also sometimes other Spots besides the Shadows of the Satellites : where he exhorts all the Curious , that have the convenience of observing , to endeavour the discovery of a matter of that importance , which would prove one of the greatest Analogies for the Earth 's Motion .

