A further Account , touching Signor Campani 's Book and Performances about Optick-glasses .
In the above-mentioned French Tract there is also contained M. Auzout 's Opinion of what he had found New in the Treatise of Signor Campani , which was spoken of in the first Papers of these Transactions , concerning both the Effect of the Telescopes .
contrived after a peculiar way by the said Campani at Rome , and his New Observations of Saturn and Jupiter , made by means thereof .
First therefore , after that M Auzout had raised some scruple against the Contrivance of Signor Campani for making Great Optick-Glasses without Moulds , by the means of a Turn-lath , he examines the Observations , made with such Glasses : Where , having commended Campani 's sincerity in relating what he thought to have seen in Saturn , without accomodating it to M. Hugens 's Hypothesis , he affirms , that supposing , there be a Ring about Saturn , Signor Campani could not see in all those different times , that he observed it , the same Appearances , which he notes to have actually seen .
For , having seen it sometimes in Trine Aspect with the Sun , and Oriental ; sometimes , in the same Aspect , but Occidental ; sometimes in Sextil Aspect , and Occidental ; at another time , again in Trine , and Oriental , this Author cannot conceive , how Saturn could in all these different times have no difference in its Phasis , or keep always the same Shadow ; seeing that , according to the Hypothesis of the Ring , when it was Oriental , it must cast the Shadow upon the left side of the Ring beneath , without casting any on the right side : and when it was Occidental , it could not but cast it on the right side beneath , and nothing of it on the other .
Concerning the Shadow above , which Campani affirms to be made by the king upon the Body of Saturn , M. Auzout judges , that there could be no such Phenomenon , by reason of its Northern Latitude at the times , wherein the Observations were made , vid .
in April 1663 ; in the midst of August , and the beginning of October , next following , and in April 1664 , except it were in October , and the Shadow strong enough to become visible .
But as to the Shadow below , he agrees with Campani , that it does appear , yet not as he notes it , seeing that it must be sometimes on the one side , sometimes on the other ; and towards the Quadrat with the Sun it must appear biggest , as indeed he affirms to have seen it himself this year , insomuch that sometimes it seemed to him , that it covered the whole Ring , and that the Shadow , joining with the obscure space between both , did interrupt the circumference of the Ring ; but beholding it at other times in a clear Sky , and when there was no Trepidation of the Air , he thought , that he saw also the Light continued from without , although very slender .
But he acknowledges , that he could never yet precisely determine , by how much the largeness of the Ring was bigger than the Diameter of Saturn 's Body .
As for the proportion of the Length to the Breadth , he affirms , to have always estimated it to be two and a half , or very near so ; and to have found in his Observations , that in January last , one time , the length of Saturn was 12 Lines , and the breadth 5 .
Another time , the length was 12 .
Lines , and the breadth 4 .
and this by a peculiar method of his own .
But yet he acknowleges also , that sometimes he hath estimated it as 7 , to 3 .
and at other times as 13.10 5 .
and that if there do not happen a change in the magnitude of the Ring ( as it is not likely there does ) that must needs proceed from the Constitution of the air , or of the Glass 's having more or less Aperture , or from the difficulty of making an exact estimate of their proportions .
However it is not much wide ( saith he ) of two and an half , although Campani make the length of the Ring but double to its breadth .
Monsieur Auzout believes , that he was one of the first that have well observed this shadow of Saturn 's Body upon its Ring s which he affirms happened two years since ; when , observing in July , for the first time , with a Telescope of 21 .
and then another of 27 .
foot , he perceived , that the Angle of the obscure space on the right side beneath , was bigger and wider , than the three other Angles , and that some interruption appeared there , between the Ring , and the Body of Saturn ; of which he saith to have given notice from that time to all his friends , and in particular , as soon as conveniently he could , to Monsieur Hugens .
He consesseth , that he hath not had the opportunity of observing Saturn in his Oriental Quadrat ; yet he doubts not , but that the shadow appears on the Left-side , considering , that the Existence of the Ring can be no longer doubted of , after so many Observations of the shadow cast by Saturn 's Body upon it , according as it must happen , following that Hypothesis ; there being no reason , why it should cast the said shadow on one side , and not on the other .
Concerning the Observation of Jupiter and its satellites , the famous Astronomer of Bononia , Cassinus , having published , lished , that on the 30 .
day of July , 1664 .
at 2 1/ 2 of the clock in the morning , he had observed , with Campani 's Glasses , that there passed through the broad obscure Belt of Jupiter two obscuter spots , by him esteemed to be the shadows of the Satellites , moving between Jupiter &amp; the Sun , and eclipsing him , and emerging from the Occidental Brim thereof : This Author did first conceive , that they were not shadows , but some Sallies , or Prominencies in that Belt ; which he was induced to believe , because he perceived not , that that Prominency , which he there saw was so black , nor so round as Cassini had represented his spots ; wherefore , seeing it but little differing in colour , from the Belt , and so not judging it round , because it did stand only about half its diameter out of the Belt , he persuaded himself , that it was rather a Sally , or Prominency of the Belt , than a round shadow , as that of a Satellite of Jupiter must have bin .
But having been since informed of all the Observations made by Cassini and Campani , with the New Glasses , and seen his Figure , he candidly and publicly wishes , that he had not spoken of that Sally , or Prominency ; advowing that he can doubt no longer , but that it was the shadow of the Satellit between Jupiter and the Sun , having seen the other .
emerge , as soon as with a 20 .
foot Glass he made the Observation , and having not perceived these shadows with a 12 .
foot Glass : But although he grants that they did guess better than he , yet he doth it with this proviso , vid .
in case they made that Observation of July 30 .
not with their 36 .
but 12 .
or 17 .
foot Telescope .
If it be wondred at , that Monsieur Auzout did not see this shadow move , he allegeth his indisposition for making long Observations , and adds , that it may be much more wondred at , that neither Campani nor himself did see upon the obscure Belt the Bodies of the Satellites , as parts more Luminous than the Belt .
For ( faith he)although the Latitude was Meridional , it being no more than of 9 .
or 10.minutes , the Body of the Satellites should , thinks he , pass between us and the Belt , especially according to Campani , whomaketh the Belt so large , and puts the shadows far enough within the same .
This makes him conclude , that either they have not observed well enough , or that the motion of the Satellites doth not exactly follow the Belts , and is inclined unto them .
Whereupon he resolves , that when he shall know that they are to pass between Jupiter and us , and to be over against the Belt , that then he will observe , whether he can see them appear upon the Belt , as upon a darker ground , especially , the third of them , which is sensibly greater , and more Luminous , than the rest .
He hopeth also , that in time , the Shadow of Saturns Moon will be seen upon Saturn , although we are yet some years to stay for it , and to prepare also for better Glasses .
From this rare Observation , he inferrs the Proportion of the Diameter of the Satellites to that of Jupiter ; and judges , that no longer doubt can be made of the turning of these 4 .
Satellites , or Moons about Jupiter , as our Moon turns about the Earth , and after the same way as the rest of the Celestial Bodies of our Systeme do move:whence also a strong conjecture may be made , that Saturns Moon turns likewise about Saturn .
Hence he also takes occasion to intimate , that we need not scruple to conclude , that if these two Planets have Moons wheeling about them , as our Earth hath one that moves about it , the conformity of theseMoons with ourMoon , does prove the conformity of our Earth with those Planets , which carrying away their Moons with themselves , do turn about the Sun , and very probably make their Moons turn about them in turning themselves about their Axis ; and also , that there is no cause to invent perplexed and incredible Hypotheses , for the receding from this Analegie since ( saith he ) if this be truth , the Prohibitions of publishing this doctrine , which formerly were caused by the offence of Novelty , will be laid aside ; as one of the most zealous Doctors of the contrary Opinion hath given cause to hope , witness Eustachius de Divinis , in his Tract against Monsieur Hugen 's Systeme of Saturn , p.49 .
where we are informed , that that learned Jesuit , P.Fabry , Penitentiary of S. Peter in Rome , speaks to this purpose : * It hath been more than once asked of your Chieftains , whether they had a Demonstration for asserting the motion of the Earth ?
They durst never yet affirm they bad ; wherefore nothing binders , but that the Church may understand those Scripture-places , that speak of this matter , in a literal sense , and declare they should be so understood , as long as the contrary is not evinced by any demonstration ; which * Ex vestris , iisque Coryphzis non semel quaesitum est , utrum aliquam haberent demonstrationem pro Terrae motu adstruendo .
Nunquam ausi sunt id afferere N ligitur obstat quin loca illa in sensu literali Ecclesia intelligat , &amp; intelligenda esse declaret , quamdiu nulla de monstratione contrarium evin which , if perhaps it should be found out by you ( which I can hardly believe it wil)in this case the Church will not at all scruple to declare , that these places are to be understood in a figurative and improper sense , according to that of the Poet , Terraeque Urbesque recedunt .
citur ; quae si fotte aliquando a vobis excogitetur ( quod vix crediderim ) in hoc casu nullo modo dubitabit Ecclesia declarare , loca illa in sensu figurato &amp; improprio intelligenda esse , ut illud Poetae , Terraeque urbesque recedunt .
Whence this Author concludes , that the said Jesuite assuring us that the inquisition hath not absolutely declared , that those Scripture.places are to be understood literally , seeing that the Church may make a contrary declaration , no man ought to scruple to follow the Hypothesis of the Earths motion , but only forbear to maintain it in public , till the prohibition be called in .
But to return to the matter in hand , this Author , upon all these observations and relations of Cassini and Campani , doth find no reason to doubt any more of the excellency of the Glass used by them , above his ; except this difference may be imputed to that of the Air , or of the Eyes .
But yet he is rather inclined to ascribe it to the goodness of their Glasses , and that the rather , because , he would not be thought to have the vanity of magnifying his own ; of which , yet he intimates by the by , that he caused one to be wrought , of 150 Parisian feet ; which though it proved none of the best , yet he despairs not to make good ones of that , and of far greater Length .

