Mr. Hook 's Answer to Monsieur Auzout 's Considerations , in a Letter to the Publisher of these Transactions .
SIR , Together with my most hearty thanks for the favour you were pleased to do me , in sending me an Epitome of what had been by the ingenious Monsieur Auzout animadverted on a description , I had made of an Engine for grinding spherical Glasses , I thought my self obliged , both for your satisfaction , and my own Vindication , to return you my present thoughts upon those Objections .
The chief of which seems to be against the very Proposition it self : For it appears , that the Objector is somewhat unsatisfied , that I should propound a thing in Theory , without having first tried the Practicableness of it .
But first , I could wish that this worthy Person had rectified my mistakes , not by speculation , but by experiments .
Next , I have this to answer , that ( though I did not tell the Reader so much , to the end that he might have the more freedom to examine and judge of the contrivance , yet ) it was not mere Theory I propounded , but somewhat of History and matter of Fact : For , I had made trials , as many as my leisure would permit , not without some good success ; but not having time and opportunity enough to prosecute them , I thought it would not be unacceptable to such , as enjoyed both , to have a description of a way altogether New , and Geometrically true , and seemingly , not unpracticable , whereof they might make use , or not , as they should see reason .
But nothing surprised me so much , as , that he is pleased ( after he had declared it a fault , to write this Theory , without having reduced it to practice)to lay it , as he seems to do , in one place of his book , p.22 upon the Royal Society .
Truly , Sir , I should think my selfmost injurious to that Noble Company , had I not endeavoured , even in the beginning of my Book , to prevent such a misconstruction .
And therefore I cannot but make this interpretation of what Monsieur Auzout saith in this particular , that either he had not so much of the Language wherein I have written , as to understand all what was said by me , or , that he had not read my Dedication to the Royal Society , which if he had done , he would have found , how careful I was , that that Illustrious Society should not be prejudiced by my Errors , that could be so little advantaged by my Actions .
And indeed , for any man to look upon the matters published by their Order or Licence , as if they were Their Sense , and had Their Approbation , as certain and true , it is extremely wide of their intentions , feeing they , in giving way to , or encouraging such publications , aim chiefly at this , that ingenious conceptions , and important philosophical matter of Fact may be communicated to the learned and enquiring World , thereby to excite the minds of men to the examination and improvement thereof .
But , to return ; As to his Objections against the Matter , I do find that they are no more against mine , than any other way of Grinding Glasses , nor is it more than I have taken notice of my self in this Passage of the same Paragraph , of which sort are also those difficulties he raises about Long Glasses , which are commonly known to such , as are conversant in making them .
It would be convenient also ( these are my words ) and not very chargeable , to have four or five several Tools : One , &amp; C. And , if curiosity shall ever proceed so far , one for all lengths , between 1000 .
and 10000 .
foot long ; for indeed , the Principle is such , that supposing the Mandrils well made , and of a good length , and supposing great care be used in working and polishing them , I see no reason , but that a Glass of 1000 .
nay , 10000 .
foot long may be made , as well as one of 10 .
For , the reason is the same , supposing the Mandrils and Tools be made sufficiently strong , so that they cannot bend ; and supposing also , that the Glass out of which they are wrought , he capable of so great a regularity in its parts , as to its Refraction .
But next , I must say that his Objections to me , seem not so considerable , as perhaps he imagines them .
For , as to the possibility of getting Plates of Glass thick and broad enough without veins , I think that not now so difficult here in England , where I believe is made as good , if not much better Glass for Optical Experiments , than ever I saw come from Venice .
Next , though it were better , that the thickest part of a long Object-Glass were exactly in the middle , yet I can assure Monsieur Auzout , that it may be a very good one , when it is an Inch or two out of it .
And I have a good one by me at present , of 36 .
foot , that will bear an Aperture , if Saturn or the Moon in the twilight , be looked on with it , of 31/ 2 Inches over , and yet the thickest part of the Glass is a great way out of the middle .
And I must take the liberty to doubt , whether ever my Animadversor saw a long Glass , that was otherwise ; as he might presently satisfy himself by a way I could show him ( if he did not know it)whereby the difference of the thickness of the sides might be found to the hundreth part of a Line .
As to the exceeding exactness of the Figure of Long ObjectGlasses , tis not doubted , but that it is a matter difficult enough to be attained any way : but yet , I think , much easier by Engine , than by Hand ; and of all Engines , I conceive , none more plain and simple , than that of a Mandril .
And for making spherical Glasses by an Engine , I am apt to think , there hardly can be any way more plain , and more exact , than that which I have described ; wherein there is no other motion , than that of two such Mandrils , which may be made of sufficient strength , length , and exactness , to perform abundantly much more , than I can believe possible to be done otherwise than by chance , by a man 's hands or strength unassisted by an Engine , the motion and strength being much more certain and regular .
I know very well , that in making a 60.footGlass by the strength of the hand , in the common way , not one of ten that are wrought , will happen to be good , as I have been assured by Mr. Reeves ; who , I am apt to think , was the first that made any good of that length .
For the Figure of the Tool in that way is presently vitiated by the working of the Glass , and without much gaging will not do any thing considerable .
Besides , the strength of a man 's hands , applied to it for the working and polishing of it , is very unequal , and the motions made , are very irregular ; but in the way , I have ventured to propose , by Mandrils , the longer the Glass and Tool are wrought together , the more exact they seem to be , and if all things be ordered , as they should be , the very polishing of the Glass , does seem most of all to rectify the Figure .
As to what he objects , that the Tool does only touchthe Glass in a Mathematical Circle ; that is true , perhaps , at first , but before the Glass is wrought down to its true Figure , the Edge of the Tool will be worn or ground away , so as that a Ring of an inch broad may be made to touch the Spherical Surface of the Glass ; nay , if it be necessary(without much trouble , especially in the grinding of longer Glasses ) the whole Concave Surface of the Tool may be made to touch a Glass .
Besides , that as to the keeping a quantity of the same sand and Powders of several finesses , according as the glass wears , the same is possible to be don , as with the same Sand wrought finer by working in the Ordinary way .
The giving the Inclination to the Mandrils , is not at all difficult ; though perhaps to determine the length exactly which the Glass so made shall draw , is not so easy : But it is no matter , what length the Glass be of , so it be made good , whether 60 or 80 foot , or the like .
Nor is it so very difficult , to lay them both in the same Plain .
And to keep them steady , when once fixed , is most easy .
As to the Calculation of the propriety of a Glass of a thousand foot , perhaps for that particular Length , I had not , nor have as yet calculated , that the Convexity of one of eighteen inches broad , will not be above a seventh part of a Line .
But it does not thence follow , that I had not considered the difficulties , that would be in making of it .
For , I must tell him , that I can make a Plano convex Glass , though its convexity be of a smaler sphere than is usual for such a length , to be an Object-Glass of about 150 foot in Length , nay of 300 foot , and either longer or shorter , without at all altering the convexity .
So that , if he will by any Contrivance he hath , give me a Plano-convex Glass of 20 , or 40 foot Diameter , without Veins , and truly wrought of that Figure , I will presently make a Telescope with it , with a single Eyglass shall draw a thousand foot : Which Invention , I shall shortly discover , there being , I think , nothing more easy and certain .
And if a Plano convex Glass can be made of any Sphere between twenty and forty foot radius , so as that both the Convex and Plain side of the Glass be exactly polished of a true Figure , I will shortly show , how therewith may be made a Telescope of any Length , supposing the Glass free from all kind of Veins , or inequality of Refraction .
As for the sliding of the Glass upon the Cement , I see no reason at all for it , at least in the Cement , I make use of , having never observed any such accident in hard Cement .
And And for the Bearing of the Ring against one side of the Glass only at a time , I cannot see , why that should produce any inequality , since all the sides of the Glass have successively the same pressure .
His ratiocination concerning a Glass of 300 foot , is much the same with the former , about the difficulty of working a true surface of a convenient figure ; which how considerable both that and his Conclusion thereupon ( videl .
That we are not to expect Glasses of above 300 or 400 foot long at most , and that neither Matter nor Art will go so far ) is , may be judged from what I have newly told you of making any object-Glass of any Length .
And for his good wishes , that those , who promise to make him see Plants or Animals in the Moon ( of which I know not any , that has done so , though perhaps there may be some , notwithstanding his Objections , that do not yet think it impossible to be done ) had considered , what a Man is able to see with his bare Eye at 60 Leagues distance : I cannot but return him my wishes , that he would consider the difference between seeing a thing through the Gross and Vaporous Air near the Earth , and through the Air over our heads : Which , if he observe the Moon in the Horizon , and near the Zenith with a Telescope , he will experimentally find ; and , having done so , he will perhaps not be so diffident in this matter .
Concerning his Advertisement to such , as publish Theories , I find not , that he hath made use of it in his own case .
For , in his Theory about Apertures he seems to be very positive , not at all doubting to rely upon it , vid .
that the Apertures must be thus and thus in great Glasses , because he had found them so or so in some small ones .
For his Proposal of amendments of some inconveniences in this way , I return him my thanks ; but as to his first I believe , that the matter may be contained as wel in the concave Tool , as on the convex Glass .
And as to that of 2 Poppet-heads , I do not well understand it , if differing from mine ; and the keeping of the Tool upon the Glass with a spring or weight , must quickly spoil the whole ; since , if either of the Mandrils will easily yield backwards , the regularity of all will be spoiled : and as to the wrigling and playing of the Mandril , I do not at all apprehend it .
His Theory of Apertures , though he seems to think it very authentic , yet to me it seems not so clear .
For , the same Glass will endure greater or lesser Apertures , according to the lesser or greater Light of the Object : If it be for the looking on the Sun or Venus , or for seeing the Diameters of the Fixed Stars , then smaller Apertures do better ; if for the Moon in the daylight , or on Saturn , or Jupiter , or Mars , then the largest .
Thus I have often made use of a 12 foot-Glass to look on Saturn with an Aperture of almost 3 inches , and with a single Eye-glass of 2 inches double convex : but , when with the same Glass I looked on the Sun or Venus , I used both a smaller Aperture , and shallower Charge .
And though M. Auzout seems to find fault with the English Glass of 36 foot , that had an Aperture of but 23/ 4 inches French , as also , with a 60 foot Tube , used but with an Aperture of 3 inchess yet I do not find , that he hath seen Glasses of that length , that would bear greater Apertures , and it is not impossible , but his Theory of Apertures may fail in longer Glasses .

