Considerations of Monsieur Auzout upon Mr. Hook 's New Instrument for Grinding of Optick-Glasses .
In the above-mentioned French Tract , there are , besides several other particulars , to be represented in due place~ contained some Considerations of Monsieur Auzout upon Mr. Hook 's New Engine for grinding Optick-Glasses .
Where he premises in General his thoughts touching the working of Great Optick-Glasses , and that by the help of a Turn lathe ; affirming first of all , that not only the Engine is to be considered for giveing the Figure , but the Matter also , which ought to be brought to greater perfection , than it hath been hitherto .
For , he finds is not so easy ( at least , where he is ) to procure Great pieces of Glass without Veins , and other faults , nor to get such , as are thick enough without Blebbs ; which , if they be not , they will yield to the pressure and weight , either when they are fitted to the Cement , or wrought .
Secondly , He finds it difficult to work these Great Glasses of the same thickness , which yet is very necessary , because , that the least difference in Figures so little convex , can put the Center out of the Middle , 2 or 3 Inches ~ and if they be wrought in Moulds , the length of time , which is required to wear and to smooth them , may spoil the best Mould , before they be finished .
Besides , that the strength of Man is so limited , that he is unable to work Glasses beyond a certain bigness , so as to finish and polish them all over so well , as small Glasses ; whereas yet , the bigger they are , the more complete they ought to be : And if any weight or Engine be used to supply strength , there is then danger of an unequal pressure , and of wearing away the Engines In the mean time , the preciseness and delicateness is greater than can easily be imagined .
Wherefore he could never , having some experience of this preciseness , conceive , that a Turn-lathe , wherein must be two different , and in some manner contrary motions , can move with that exactness and steadiness , that is required , especially , for any considerable length of time .
Having premised this , he discourses upon Mr. Hook his Turn , intimating first of all , that he was impatient to know what kind of Turn this was , imagining , that it had been tried , and had succeeded , as coming from a Society that professes , they publish norhing but what hath been maturely examined .
But that he was much surprised when he saw the Micrography of Mr. Hook , and found there , that his Engine was published upon a mere Theory , without having made any Experiment , though that might have been made with little charge and great speed ; expense of Money and Time being the only thing , that can excuse those who in matter of Engines impare their inventions to the public , without having tried them , to excite others to make trial thereof .
Whereupon he proposes some difficulties , to give the Inventor occasion to find a way to remove them .
He affirms therefore , that though it be true in the Theory , that a Circle , whose Plain is inclined to the Axis of the Sphere by an Angle , whereof half the Diameter is the Sine , and which touches the Sphere in its Pole , will touch in all its parts a spherical Surface , that shall turn upon that Axe .
But that it is true also , that that must be but a Mathamatical Circle , and without Breadth , and which precisely touches the Body in its middle : Whereas in the practice , a Circle capable to keep Sand and Putty , must be of some breadth ; and he knows not whether we can find such a dexterity of keeping so much of it , and for so long a time , as needs , upon the Brim of a Ring that is half an Inch broad .
He adds , that it is very difficult to contrive , that the middle of the Glass do always precisely answer to the Brim of this Bing , seeing that the position of the Glass does always change a little in respect of the Ring , in proportion as it is worn , and as it must be presied becanse of its inclination .
He believes it also very hard , to give to the Axis or to the Mandril , which holds the Glass , that little Inclination , that would be necessary for great Glasses , and to make the two Mandrils to have one and the same Plain , as is necessary .
And , having done all this , he persuades himself , that it is exceeding difficult , if not impossible , for two contrary motions , where so many pieces are , to rest for a long time steady and firm , as is requisite for the not swerving from it a hair 's thickness , since less than that can change all .
He goes on , and , seeing that this Inventor speaks of Glasses of a thousand , &amp; ten thousand foot , which he supposed not impossible to be made by this Engine , discourses of what is necessary for the making Glasses of such bigness ; which he believes this Inventor may perhaps not have thought of .
Wherefore he affirms , that if the Table , made by himself for the Apertures of Glasses ( which is that , that is above delivered ) be continued unto a thousand feet , by taking always the Subduplicate proportion of Lengths , it will be found , that for pretty good ones , the Aperture must be of 15 .
Inches ; for good ones , more than 18 .
and for such as are excellent , more than 21 .
Inches : whence it may be judged , what piece of Glass , and of what thickness it must be , to resist the working .
But he proceeds to speak of the Inclination , which the Mandril must have upon the Plain of the Ring , when the Ring should have 10 .
or 12 Inches ; and finds , that it would make but 6 .
or .
7 .
minutes of inclination , and that a Glass would have less Convexity , and consequently , less difference from a Glass perfectlyplain , than the 7 .
or 8 .
part of a Line .
And then he leaves it to be judged , whether a Glass of such a Length being found , we ought to hope , that a Turn can be firm enough to keep such a piece of Glass in the same Inclination , so that a Mandril do not recede some Minutes from it : and , though even the Glass could be fastned perfectly perpendicular to the Mandril , that these two Mandrils could be put in one and the same place , &amp; that that little Inclination , which is requisite , could be given , and the Mandril be continued to be pressed in that same Inclination , according as the Glass is worn .
All which particulars , he conceives to be very hard in the practice ; not to mention , that the weight of the Glass , that should be inclined to the Horizon , as it is represented by Mr. Hook , would make it slide upon the Cement , and so change the Center ; and that the Glass is not pressed at the same time by the Ring but in one part on the side , vid .
about a fourth ; and that the parts of the Glass are not equally worn away , &amp;c. What then , saith he , would become of a Glass of 10000 feet , which , according to the said Table , would have more than four feet , or four feet and nine inches , or five feet , seven inches Aperture , and of which the Ring , though it were two fact nine inches , would have but one minut of Inclination , and the Glass of 5 feet Aperture would have .
but 4 minuts , and the curvity of it would be less than the eight part of a Line .
But , saith he , let us consider , only a Glass of 300 root , to see , what is to be hoped of that , and to know at least the difficulty , to be met with in making a Glass only of that Length .
A Glass then of 300 foot , according to his Table , must have more than 8 inches Aperture , which makes but 16 minuts of its Circle , and it should have more than 11 inches , if it be an excellent one .
If Mr. Hook ( adds he ) did use but his Ring of 6 inches , which he would use from twelve to an hundred foot Glass , the Inclination , which the Axis , or Mandril , that bears his Glass , should have , should be but 16 minuts , and the Curvity of the Glass would be less than the eighth part of a Line , and if he should use a bigger , the Inclination would be proportionable .
Whence it may be judged ( continues he ) that we are yet very far from seeing Animals &amp;c. in the Moon , as Monsieur Des Cartes gave hope , and Mr. Hook despairs not of .
For , he believes by what he knows of Telescopes , that we are not to look for any above 300 or 400 foot at most ; and he fears , that neither Matter nor Art will go even so far .
When therefore ( saith he ) a Glass of 300 foot should bear an Eye-glass of 6 inches ( which would appear wonderful ) it would magnify but 600 .
times in Diameter , that is , 360000 times in Surface : but suppose , that such could be made , as would magnify a 1000 times in Diameter , and 1000000 .
of times in Surface , admitting there were but 60000 leagues from the Earth to the Moon , and that the smallness of the Aperture of the Glasses ( which yet would diminish the Light more than 36 times ) and the obstacle of the Air were not considered , we should not see the Moon , but as if we were a 100 , or at least , 60 .
leagues distant from her without a Glass .
He here wishes , that those , that promise to make us see Animals and Plants in the Moon , had thought on what our naked Eyes can make us discern of such Objects , only at 10 or 12 leagues distance .
But this he would not have understood as a discouragement from searching with all care and earnestness after the means of making long Telescopes , or of facilitating the working thereof ; but only as an Advertisement to those , who light upon the Theory of any Engine , not to expose it presently as possible and useful , before they have tried it , or if it have succeeded in small , not to endeavour to persuade , that it will also succeed in great .
As it may happen ( saith he ) that the Engine of Mr. Hook may , by using all necessary precautions , succeed in the making of EyeGlasses , or small Optic .
Glasses , but not in making great ones ; as we see , that an instrument composed of two Rulers , wherewith are traced Portions of Circles , succeeds well enough in small , but when there is no more than half a Line , a quarter of a Line , or less convexity , it will be no longer just at all , as he tells us to have made the proof of it in Circles drawn by the means of one of these Instruments , made by one of the best Workmen in his time , who , whilst he lived , esteemed them above price , although they be not just ; as others and my self ( saith he ) have by trial found , when we endeavoured to make Moulds by their means , &amp; as those , who by the like Instrument laboured to trace portions of Circles of 80 or 100 foot , &amp;c. Diameter , can attest .
But , notwithstanding all this , he hath thought upon two or three things , which he thinks may remedy some inconveniences of Mr. Hook his Turn .
The first is , to invert the Glass , and to put it under the Ring , that so not only the Glass may be placed more Horizontally , and not slide upon theCement , but that the Sand also , and the Putty may stay upon the Glass .
The other is , that there must be two Poppetheads , into which the Mandril must pass , where the Ring is to be fastned ; and the Mandril must be perfectly Cylindrical , that so it may advance upon the Glass as it wears away by the means of its weight , or by the means of a spring , pressing it , without wrigling from one place to another , as it would presently happen in the fashion , as the Turn is composed .
For , when the Glasses do wear , especially when they are very convex , it cannot be otherwise , but the Mandril will play and wrigle , before the Sorue be made firm .
But he doubts , whether all can be remedied , which he leavs to the industry of Mr. Hook , considering what he saith in the Preface of his Micrography , touching a Method , he knows , of finding out as much in Mechanicks , as can be found in Geometry by Algebra .
Besides this , he takes notice , that most of those that meddle with Optick-Glasses , give them not as much Aperture , nor charge them so deep as they ought .
And he instances in the Teleseope , which His Majesty of Great Britain presented the Duke of Orleans with , videl .
that it did bear but 2 inches , and 9 lines French , for its greatest Aperture , though there be 5 or 6 lesser Apertures , of which it seems ( saith he ) the Artificer would have those , that use it , serve themselves more ordinarily , than of the greatest ; which conveys but almost half as many Rays as it should do , according to his Calculation , which is , as 9 to 16 ; Whereas , according to his Table of Apertures , an excellent 35 foot Telescope should bear 4 inches Aperture in proportion to excellent small ones .
He notes also , that the Eye-glass of the said Telescope , composed of 2 Glasses , hath no more effect , when it is most charged , than a Glass of 41/ 2 inches ; which makes it magnify not a 100 times .
And he finds by Mr. Hook , that he esteems a Telescope made in London of 60 feet , ( which amount to about 57 feet of France , the foot of France being to that of England as about 15 to 16 ) because it can bear at least 3 English inches Aperture , and that there are few of 30 feet , that can bear more than 2 inches , ( which is but 221/ 2 Lines French ) although he ( M. Auzout ) gives no less Aperture .
than so , to a 15 foot-Telescope , and his of 21 feet hath ordinarily 2 Inches , 4 Lines , or 2 inches , 6 Lines Aperture .
This Discourse he Concludes with exhorting those , that work Optick-Glasses , to endeavour to make them such , that they may bear great Apertures and deep Eye-glasses ; seeing it is not the length that gives esteem to Telescopes ; but on the contrary renders them less estimable , by reason of the trouble accompanying panying them , if they perform no more , than shorter ones .
Where , by the by , he takes notice , that he knows not yet , what Aperture Signor Campani gives to his Glasses , seeing he hath as yet signified nothing of it ; but that the small one , sent by him to Cardinal Antonio , hath no more Aperture , than ordinary ones ought to have .
He promises withal , that he will explicate this way in his Treatise of the usefulness of Telescopes , where he intends to assign the Bigness of the Diameter of all the Planets , and their proportion to that of the Sun ; as also , that of the Stars , which he esteems yet much less , than all those have done , that have written of it hitherto ; not believing , that the Great Dog , which appears to be the fairest Star of the Firmament , hath 2 Seconds in Diameter , nor that those , which are counted of the sixth Magnitude , have 20 thirds ; nor thinking , that all the Stars , that are in the Firmament do enlighten the Earth as much as a Luminous Body of 20 seconds in Diameter would do , or , because there is but one half of them at the same time above our Horizon , as a Body of 14 seconds in Diameter ; and as the 18432 th part of the Sun would enlighten us , or as the Sun would do , if we were 14 times more distant from it , than Saturn , and 137 times further , than the Earth : Which , he saith , would not be credible , if he did not endeavour to evince it both by Experience and Reason .
And he doubts not , but that Venus , although she sends us no Light but what is reflected , does sometimes enlighten the Earth more , than all the Stars together .
Yet he would not have us imagine , from what he hath spoken of the smallness of the Stars , that Telescopes do not magnify them by reason of their great distance , as they do Planets ; for this he judges a Vulgar Error , to be renounced .
Telescopes magnify the Stars ( saith he ) as much in proportion , as they do all other Bodies , seeing that the demonstration of their magnifying is made even upon Parallel rays , which do suppose an infinite distance ; though the Stars have none such : And if the Telescopes did not magnific the Stars , how could they make us see some of the fiftieth , and it may be some of the hundreth , and two hundreth ' Magnitude , as they do , and as they would show yet much lesser ones , if they did magnify more ?

