Two other Letters to the same purpose with the former : The first of the Right Honourable the Lord Vis-count Brouncker , Chancellor to her Majesty , and President of the R. Society , &amp;c. SIR , IT is very sure , that Mr. William Neil had in the year 1657 .
found out and demonstrated a Straight line equal to a Paraboloeid ; and did then communicate and publish the same ( though not in print ) to my self and others , who used to meet at Gresham College , and it was there received with good approbation ; and the same was , presently afterwards , otherwise demonstrated by my self and others : And therefore ancienter than that of Monsieur Heurat , which ( as it seems , ) is not pretended to have been done before the year 1659 ; and ancienter too than that of Sr. Ch.Wren , finding a Straight line equal to a Cycleil in the year 1658 ; and by him admitted so to be .
Nor ought it at all to prejudice Mr. Neil , that M. Heuraet 's was somewhat sooner abroad in print , than that of M.Neil , ( though both in the same year 1659 ; ) since it is well known to many of us , that Mr. Neil 's was done before .
Otherwise M. Hugens , by the same reason , will grant the precedence to Heuraet , of that which he now claims to be his own invention ( that Rectifying the Parabolical Line and Squaring the Hyperbolical Space do mutually depend on each other : ) for this was published in print by M.Heuraet ( or M.Schooten for him ) in the year 1659 , and not by M. Hugens till now , 1673 : And yet M. Hugens thinks , he may well claim that invention to be his own , because he now tells us , that he found it out about the end of the year 1657 , and did ( some time after ) communicate it privately to some friends .
And whereas , he doth suppose , that this invention of his might give occasion to that other of Heuraet ; we may also as well suppose , that he might have taken such occasion from hearing of Mr. Neil having done the like , ( for this had been then commonly known for a great while : ) Or might have taken occasion ( as well as Mr. Neil ) from that of Dr. Wallis Schol .
prop.38 .
Arith .
Infin .
or from that of Sr. Ch.Wren having found a Straight equal to another Curve the year before : Or , if it were necessary to know their symbolization between the Parabolical Line and the Hyperbolical Space ; he might have had it earlier from Dr. Wallis .
For , when he had demonstrated ( Schol .
prop. 38 .
Are .
Infin .
) that the Particles which compose the Xxxxxx2 Para Parabolical line , are in power equal to a Series of Squares increased by a series of Equals , suppose ~:A2 + b2 : And ( prop.35,41.Conic .
Sect. ) that c the Ordinates to the Conjugate Diameter of an Hyperbola , ( that is , the particles of which that Hyperbolical space consists , ) are so also , viz. ~:1/ 4T2+T/ Lh2 : ( where A , T , L , are permanent quantities , and b , h , taken successively in Progression Arithmetical ; ) It was easy ( for M.Heuraet , or M.Hugens , or any other , ) to infer , That , if we can Rectify the one , we may Square the other , &amp; vice versa But from whence soever M.Heuraet had it ; we may , as before , reasonably conclude , that Mr. Neil had it before him : And M. Hugens is a person of that ingenuity , that , when he shall better consider of it , he will(I doubt not ) be of the same mind .
London , Oct.8.1673 .
The other Letter is of Sr. Christopher Wren Kt .
Surveyor General of his Majesties Buildings , &amp;c. SIR , THat I did , in the year 1658 .
find a Straight line equal to that of a Cycloid , and the parts thereof , was then very well known , not in England only , but in France and Holland .
And I have not yet heard of any , who do pretend to have known it , before I discovered it : which was the same year acknowledged in Print by those of France .
But I do not pretend to have been the first that did ever find a Straight line equal to a Crooked .
For I very well know , that Mr. William Neil had , the year before , found out and demonstrated , How to construct a Crooked line so as to be equal to a Straight , by a certain series of Numbers after the method of Dr. Wallis .
And though He did not therein demonstrate the other properties of that Line ; yet the same were presently after demonstrated by my self and others , and the nature of the Line fully discovered , being a certain Paraboloeid .
And that which M. Heurat is said afterwards to have found out , in the year 1659 , and M.Fermat in the year 1660 , are but the same with that of Mr. Neile .

