An Extract of Mr. Isaac Newton 's Letter , written to the Publisher from Cambridge April 3 .
1673 .
concerning the Number of Colors , and the Necessity of mixing them all for the production of White ; as also touching the Cause why a Picture cast by Glasses into a darkned room appears so distinct notwithstanding its Irregular refraction : ( Which Letter , being an Immediate answer to that from Paris , printed No.96.p.6086 .
of these Tracts , should also , if it had not been mis-laid , have immediately followed the same .
) IT seems to me , that N. takes an improper way of examining the nature of Colors , whilst he proceeds upon compounding those that are already compounded ; as he doth in the former part of his Letter .
Perhaps he would sooner satisfy himself by resolving Light into Colors , as far as may be done by Art , and then by examining the properties of those colors apart , and afterwards by trying the effects of re-conjoining two or more or all of those ; and lastly , by separating them again to examine , what changes that re-conjunction had wrought in them .
This , I confess , will prove a tedious and difficult task to do it as it ought to be done ; but I could not be satisfied , till I had gone through it .
However , I only propound it , and leave every man to his own method .
As to the Contents of his Letter , I conceive , my former Answer to the Quaere about the Number of Colors is sufficient , which was to this effect ; That all Colors cannot practically be derived out of the Yellow and Blew , and consequently that those Hypotheses are groundless which imply they may .
If you ask , What colors cannot be derived out of yellow and blew ?
I answer , none of all those which I defined to be Original ; and if he can show by experiment , how they may , I will acknowledge my self in an error .
Nor is it easier to frame an Hypothesis by assuming only two Original colors rather than an indefinit variety ; unless it be easier to suppose , that there are but two figures , sizes and degrees of velocity or force of the Ethereal corpuscles or pulses , rather than indefinit variety ; which certainly would be a harsh supposition .
No man wonders at the indefinit variety of Waves of the Sea , or of sands on the shore ; but , were they all but two sizes , it would be a very puzling phenomenon .
And I should think it as unaccountable , if the several parts or corpuscles , of which a shining body consists , which must be supposed of various figures , sizes and motions , should impress but two sorts of motion on the adjacent Ethereal medium , or any other way beget but two sorts of Rays .
But to examine , how Colors may be explained hypothetically , is besides my purpose .
I never intended to show , wherein consists the Nature and Difference of colors , but only to show , that de facto they are Original and Immutable qualities of the Rays which exhibit them ; and to leave it to others to explicate by Mechanical Hypotheses the Nature and Difference of those qualities : which I take to be no difficult matter .
But I would not be understood , as if their Difference consisted in the Different Refrangibility of those rays ; for , that different Refrangibility conduces to their production no otherwise , than by separating the Rays whose qualities they are .
Whence it is , that the same Rays exhibit the same Colors when separated by any other means ; as by their different Reflexibility , a quality not yet discoursed of .
In the next particular , where N. would show , that it is not necessary to mix all Colors for the production of White ; the mixture of Yellow , Green and Blew , without Red and Violet , which he propounds for that end , will not produce White , but Green ; and the brightest part of the Yellow will afford no other colour but Yellow , if the Experiment be made in a room well darkened , as it ought ; because the Coloured light is much weakened by the Reflexion , and so apt to be diluted by the mixing of any other scattering light .
But yet there is an Experiment or two mentioned in my Letter in the Transactions Numb.88 , by which I have produced White out of two colors alone , and that variously ; as out of Orange and a full Blew , and out of Red and pale Blew , and out of Yellow and Violet , as also out of other pairs of Intermediat colors .
The most convenient Experiment for performing this , was that of casting the colors of one Prisme upon those of another , after a due manner .
But what N. can deduce from hence , I see not .
For the two colors were compounded of all others , and so the resulting White , ( to speak properly , ) was compounded of them all , and only de-compounded of those two .
For instance , the Orange was compounded of Red , Orange , Yellow and some Green ; and the Blew , of Violet , full Blew , light Blew , and some Green , with all their Intermediat degrees ; and consequently the Orange and Blew together made an Aggregate of all colors to constitute the White .
Thus , if one mix red , orange and yellow Powders to make an Orange ; and green , blew and violet colors to make a Blew ; and lastly , the two mixtures , to make a Grey ; that Grey , though de-compounded of no more than two Mixtures , is yet compounded of all the six Powders , as truly as if the powders had been all mixed at once .
This is so plain , that I conceive there can be no further scruple ; especially to them who know how to examine , whether a colour be simple or compounded , and of what colors it is compounded ; which having explained in another place , I need not now repeat .
If therefore N would conclude any thing , he must show , how White may be produced out of two Uncompounded colors ; which when he hath done , I will further tell him , why he can conclude nothing from that .
But I believe , there cannot be found an Experiment of that kind ; because , as I remember , I once tried , by gradual succession , the mixture of all pairs of Un-compounded colors ; and , though some of them were paler , and nearer to White , than others , yet none could be truly called White .
But it being some years since this trial was made , I remember not well the circumstances , and therefore recommend it to others to be tried again .
In the last place , had I thought , the Distinctness of the Picture , which ( for instance ) a Twelf foot Object glass casts into a darkened room , to be so contrary to me as N. is pleased to affirm , I should have waved my Theory in that point before I propounded it .
For , that I had thought on that difficulty , you may easily guess by an expression , somewhere in my first Letter * to his purpose ; That I wondered , how Telescopes could be brought to so great perfection by Refractions which were so Irregular .
But , to take away the difficulty , I must acquaint you , first , That , though I put the greatest Lateral error of the rays from one another to be about 1/ 50 of the Glasses diameter ; yet their greater error from the Points on which they ought to fall , will be but * See Numb. 80 .
but 1/ 100 of that diameter : And then , that the rays , whose error is so great , are but very few in comparison to those , which are refracted more Justly ; for , the rays which fall upon the middle-parts of the Glass , are refracted with sufficient exactness , as also are those that fall near the perimeter and have a mean degree of Refrangibility ; So that there remain only the rays , which fall near the perimeter and are most or least refrangible to cause any sensible confusion in the Picture .
And these are yet so much further weakened by the greater space , through which they are scattered , that the Light which falls on the due point , is infinitely more dense than that which falls on any other point round about it .
Which though it may seem a Paradox , yet is certainly demonstrable .
Yea , although the Light , which passes through the middle parts of the Glass , were wholly intercepted , yet would the remaining light convene infinitely more dense at the due points , than at other places .
And by this excess of Density , the Light , which falls in or invisibly near the just point , may , I conceive , strike the sensorium so vigorously , that the impress of the weak light , which errs round about it , shall , in comparison , not be strong enough to be animadverted , or to cause any more sensible confusion in the Picture than is found by Experience .
This , I conceive , is enough to show , Why the Picture appears so distinct , notwithstanding the Irregular refraction .
But , if this satisfy not , N. may try , if he please , how distinct the Picture will appear when all the Lens is covered excepting a little hole next its edge on one side only : And if in this casche he please to measure the breadth of the colors thus made at the edge of the Suns picture , he will perhaps find it to approach nearer to my proportion than he expects .
An Answer ( to the former Letter , written to the Publisher June 10.1673 .
by the am Parisian Philosopher that was lately said to have written the Letter already extant in No.96.p.6086 .
-TOuching the Solutions , given by M Newton to the scruples by me proposed about his Theory of Colors , there were matter to answer them , and to form new difficulties ; but seeing that he maintains his opinion with so much concern , I list not to dispute .
But what means it , I pray , that he saith ; Though I should show him , that the White could be produced of only two Un-compounded colors , yet I could conclude nothing from that .
And yet he hath affirmed in p. 3083 .
of the Transactions , that to compose the White , all primitive colors are necessary .
As to the manner , whereby he reconciles the effect of Convex glasses for so well assembling the rays , with what he establishes concerning the different refrangibility , I am satisfied with it ; but then he is also to acknowledge , that this aberration of the rays is not so disadvantageous to Optic glasses as he seems to have been willing to make us believe , when he proposed Concave speculums as the only hopes of perfecting Telescopes .
His invention certainly was very good ; but , as far as I could perceive by experience , the defect of the Matter renders it as impossible to execute , as the difficulty of the Form obstructs the use of the Hyperbole of M.Des-Cartes : So that , in my opinion , we must stick to our Spheric Glasses , whom we are already so much obliged to , and that are yet capable of greater perfection , as well by increasing the length of Telescopes , as by correcting the nature of Glass it self .
So far He .
To this Letter is to be referred that , which is already extant in N.96.p.6087 .
as being an Answer thereto .

