Compare herewith what Mr. Newton saith in Numb. 80 .
of these Tracts , page .
3079 .
Mr. Newtons Answer to the foregoing Letter further explaining his Theory of Light and Colors , and particularly that of Whiteness ; together with his continued hopes of perfecting Telescopes by Reflections rather than Refractions .
-Concerning the business of Colors ; in my saying that when Monsieur N. hath shown how White may be produced out of two uncompounded colors , I will tell him , why he can conclude nothing from that ; my meaning was , that such a White , ( were there any such , ) would have diffe= rent properties from the White , which I had respect to , when I described my Theory , that is , from the White of the Sun 's immediate light , of the ordinary objects of our senses , and of all white Phenomenon that have hitherto fallen under my observation .
And those different properties would evince it to be of a different constitution : Insomuch that such a production of white would be so far from contradicting , that it would rather illustrate and confirm my Theory ; because by the difference of that from other whites it would appear , that other Whites are not compounded of only two colours like that .
And therefore if Monsieur N. would prove any thing , it is requisite that he do not only produce out of two primitive Colors lors a white which to the naked eye shall appear like other whites , but also shall agree with them in all other properties .
But to let you understand wherein such a white would differ from other whites and why from thence it would follow that other whites are otherwise compounded , I shall lay down this position .
That a compounded color can be resolved into no more simple colors then those of which it is compounded .
This seems to be self evident , and I have also tried it several ways , and particularly by this which follows .
Let ae represent an oblong piece of white-paper about 1/ 2 or 1/ 4 of an inch broad , and illuminated in a dark room with a mixture of two colours cast upon it from two Prisms , suppose a deep blew and scarlet , which must severally be as uncompounded as they can conveniently be made .
Then at a convenient distance , suppose of six or eight yards , view it through a clear triangular glass or crystal Prism held parallel to the paper , and you shall see the two colors parted from one another in the fashion of two images of the paper , as they are represented at ~ and ~ , where suppose ~ the scarlet and ~ the blew , without green or any other color between them .
Now from the aforesaid Position I deduce these two conclusions .
1 .
That if there were found out a way to compound white of two simple colors only , that white would be again resolvable into no more than two .
2 .
That if other whites ( as that of the Suns light , &amp;c. be resolvable into more than two simple colours ( as I find by Experiment that they are ) then they must be compounded of more than two .
To make this plainer , suppose that A represents a white body illuminated by a direct beam of theSun transmitted through a small hole into a dark room , and ~ such another body illuminated by a mixture of two simple colors , which if possible may A~ B~ may make it also appear of a white color exactly like A. Then at a convenient distance view these two whites through a Prism , and A will be changed into a series of all colors , Red , Yellow , Green , Blew , Purple , with their intermediate degrees succeeding in order from B to C. But ~ , according to the aforesaid Experiment , will only yield those two colors of which it was compounded , and those not conterminate like the colors at BC , but separate from one another as at ~ and ~ , by means of the different refrangibility of the rays to which they belong .
And thus by comparing these two whites , they would appear to be of a different constitution , and A to consist of more colors then ~ .
So that what Monsieur N contends for , would rather advance my Theory by the access of a new kind of white than conclude against it .
But I see no hopes of compounding such a white .
As for Monsieur N.his expression , that I maintain my doctrine with some concern , I confess it was a little ungrateful to me to meet with objections which had been answered before , without having the least reason given me why those answers were insufficient .
The answers which I speak of are in the Transactions from page .
5093 to page .
5102 .
And particularly in page .
5095 ; to show that there are other simple colors besides blew and yellow , I instance in a simple or homogeneal Green , such as cannot be made by mixing blew and yellow or any o ' there colours .
And there also I show why , supposing that all colors might be produced out of two , yet it would not follow that those two are the only Original colors .
The reasons I desire you would compare with what hath been now said of White .
And so the necessity of all colors to produce white might have appeared by the Experiment page .
5097 , where I say , that if any color at the Lens be intercepted , the whiteness ( which is compounded of them all ) will be changed into ( the result of ) the other colors .
However , since there seems to have happened some misunderstanding between us , I shall endeavour to explain myself a little further in these things according to the following method .
1I call that Light homogeneal , similar or uniform , whose rays are equally refrangible .
2 .
And that heterogeneal , whose rays are unequally refrangible .
Note .
There are but three affections of Light in which I have observed its rays to differ .
viz Refrangibility , Reflexibility , and Color ; and those rays which agree in refrangibility agree also in the other two , and therefore may well be defined homogeneal , especially since men usually call those things homogental , which are so in all qualities that come under their knowledge , though in other qualities that their knowledge extends not to there may possibly be some heterogeneity .
3 .
Those colors I call simple , or homogeneal , which are exhibited by homogeneal light .
4 .
And those compound or heterogeneal , which are exhibited by heterogeneal light .
5 .
Different colors I call not only the more eminent species , red , yellow , green , blew , purple , but all other the minutest gradations ; much after the same manner that not only the more eminant degrees in Music , but all the least gradations are esteemed different sounds .
Propositions .
1 .
The Sun 's light consists of rays differing by indefinite degrees of Refrangibility .
2 .
Rays which differ in refrangibility , when parted from one another do proportionally differ in the colors which they exhibit .
These two Propositions are matter of fact .
3 .
There are as many simple or homogeneal colors as degrees of refrangibility .
For , to every degree of refrangibility belongs a different color , by Prop.2.And that color is simple by Def. 1 .
and 3 .
4 .
Whiteness in all respects like that of the Sun 's immediate light and of all the usual objects of our senses cannot be compounded of two simple colors alone .
For such a composition must be made by rays that have only two degrees of refrangibility , by Def. 1 .
and 33 and therefore it cannot be like that of the Sunslight , by Prop. 1 ; Nor , for the same reason , like that of ordinary white objects .
5 .
Whiteness in all respects like that of the Sun 's immediate light cannot be compounded of simple colors without an indefinite variety of them .
For to such a composition there are requisite rays endued with all the indefinite degrees of refrangibility , by Prop. 1 .
And those infer as many simple colors , by Def. 1 .
and 3 .
and Prop. 2 .
and 3 .
To make these a little plainer , I have added also the Propositions that follow .
6 .
The rays of light do not act on one another in passing through the same Medium .
This appears by several passages in the Transactions page .
5097 , 5098 , 5100 , and 5101 .
and is capable of further proof .
7 .
The rays of light suffer not any change of their qualities from refraction .
8 .
Nor afterwards from the adjacent quiet Medium These two Propositions are manifest de facto in homogeneal light , whose color and refrangibility is not at all changeable either by refraction or by the contermination of a quiet Medium .
And as for heterogeneal light , it is but an aggregate of several sorts of homogeneal light , no one sort of which suffers any more alteration than if it were alone , because the rays act not on one another , by Prop. 6 .
And therefore the aggregate can suffer none .
These two Propositions also might be further proved apart by Experiments , too long to be here described .
9 .
There can no homogeneal colors be educed out of light by refraction which were not commixt in it before : Because , by Prop. 7 , and 8 , Refraction changes not the qualities of the rays , but only separates those which have divers qualities , by means of their different Refrangibility .
10 .
The Sun 's light is an aggregate of an indefinite varieety of homogeneal colors ; by Prop. 1 .
3 , and 9 .
And hence it is , that I call homogeneal colors also primitive or original .
And thus much concerning Colors .
Monsieur N. has thought fit to insinuate , that the aberration of rays ( by theirdifferent refrangibility ) is not so considerable a disadvantage in glasses as I seemed to be willing to make men believe , when I propounded concave mirrors as the only hopes of perfecting Telescopes .
But if he please to take his pen and compute the errors of a Glass and Speculum that Oooooo collect collect rays at equal distances , he will find how much he is mistaken , and that I have not been extravagant , as he imagins , in preferring Reflexions .
And as for what he says of the difficulty of the praxis , I know it is very difficult , and by those ways which he attempted it I believe it unpracticable .
But there is a way insinuated in the Transactions page .3080.by which it is not improbable but that as much may be done in large Telescopes , as I have thereby done in short ones , but yet not without more then ordinary diligence and curiosity .

