Numb. 36 .
PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS .
Monday , June 15 .
1668 .
The Contents .
An Account of a Controversy betwixt Stephano de Angelis , and John Baptista Riccioli , concerning the Motion of the Earth , An Enlargement of the Observations formerly published Numb. 27 .
imparted by a Curious Travellour to Jamaica ; Where do occurr Disccurses about the Steams of the Sea ; the Colour of the Sea ; various Plants and Animals in Jamaica , and other Islands of the Caribes ; the qualities of Tobacco growing in Nitrous Ground ; Hurricans ; a way to make a Boat ride at Anchor in the main Sea ; the effects of the Change of Climate on Human Bodies ; a probable way of Preventing and Curing Sickness in Travellors to the West-Indies , &amp;c. An Extract of a Printed Letter , addressed to the Publisher , touching a late difference , risen at Paris , about the Transfusion of Blood .
An Account of two Books I. THE PROGRESS and ADVANCEMENT of KNOWLEDGE since the days of ARISTOTLE ; by JOS .
GLANVILL .
II .
ABRAH .
COULEII Sex Libri PLANTARUM .
An Account Of a Controversy betwixt Stephano de Angelis , Professor of the Mathematicks in Padua , and Joh. Baptista Riccioli Fesuite ; as it was communicated out of their lately Printed Books , by that Learned Mathematician Mr. Jacob Gregory , a Fellow of the R. Society .
RIccioli in his Almagestum Novum pretends to have found out several new demonstrative Arguments against the Motion of the Earth .
Steph .
de Angelis , conceiving his Arguments to be none of the strongest , takes occasion to let the world see , that they are not more esteemed in Italy , than in other places .
Manfredi , in behalf of Riccioli , endeavours to answer the Objections of Angeli , and this latter replies to Manfredi 's Answer .
The substance of their discourse is this following .
Although the Arguments of Riccioli be many , yet the strength of them consists chiefly in these three : The first .
Multa corpora gravia , dimissa per Aerem , in Plano AEquatoris existentem , descenderent ad Terram cum Velocitat is Incremento reali &amp; notabili , &amp; non tantum apparenti .
Sed si tellus moveretur motu diurno tantum circa sui centram , nulla corpora gravia , dimissa per Aerem , in Plano Aequatoris existentem , descenderent ad Terram cum vclocitatis incremento reali ac notabili , sed tantum cum apparenti .
E. Tellus aut non movetur , aut non movetur diurno tantum motu .
The second .
Si Tellus moveretur motu diurno , aut ctiam annuo , multo debilior esset ietus Globi bombardici explosi in Septentrionem aut Meridiem , quam ab Occidente in Orientem .
At consequens est falsum .
E. &amp; antecedens .
The Third .
Si Tellus diurns revolutione moveretur , Globus argillaceus unciarum 8 .
ex altitudine Romanorum pedum 240 .
per acrem quietum dimissus , obliquo descensu in Terram delaberetur absque incremento reali ac physico velocitatis , vel certe nunquam tanto , quanta est proportio percu~ionis ac soni per casum ex dicta altitudine facti , Sed posterius est absurdum .
E. &amp; prius .
In Answer to the first of these Arguments , Angeli denies the Minor , which Riccioli pretends to prove thus ; Si Tellus moveretur solo diurno motu , aliquod Grave , dimissum ex Turris vertice C in Plano .
AEquatoris existentis , describeret suo motu naturali portionem linea CTI , quae esset ad omnem sensum circularis .
V. Fig. I. This Angeli denies , showing by Computation , that Riccioli his Observation proves no such thing .
For ( saith Angeli ) according to Riccioli , in one second of an hour the weight descends 15 foot ; in 2 seconds , 60 foot ; in 3 seconds 135 foot ; and so continually the spaces from the beginning are in duplicate proportion of the Time from the beginning ; and , according to the Gggg2 same Fig. 1 DLHGFC XVTS IRJPOB Fig. 2 MEA BGH CDEF same Author , AB ( the semi-diameter of the Earth ) is of 25870000 foot , and BC ( the height of the Tower of the Asinelli in Bononia ) of 240 foot ; and therefore AC is 25870240 , which hath the same proportion to FS , 15 foot , to wit , ye fall in one second , which AC in parts 20000000000 hath to FS 11596 54356 ; but supposing , with Riccieli , CSIA a semi-circle , 224189 FS is 53 parts , of which AC is 10000000000 : Hence concludes Angeli , that CSIA is no ways near to a semi-circle ; which is most sure , if so be the weight fall not to the Center of the Earth precisely in 6 hours : For , in this case of Riccioli , the weight falls to the Center of the Earth in 21 minutes and 53 seconds .
Manfredi in his Answer for Riccioli affirms , that Angeli understands not the Rule of Three , in giving out FS .
for 11596 54356/ 224189 , of which AC is 20000000000 : And Angeli in his Reply affirms his Analogy to be so clear , that there can be nothing said more evident than it self to confirm it ; referring in the mean time the further determination to Geometers .
Angeli might have answered Riccioli 's Argument , granting the weight to move equally in a semi-circle , by distinguishing his Minor thus ; Nulla Corpora gravia descenderent ad Terram cum velocitatis incremento reali ac notabili , si Velocitas computetur in circumferentia semi-circuli ; Minor propositio est vera .
At non computatur ita Motus descensivus : nam hic motus aequalis in circumferentia semi-circuli CIA .
componitur ex motu aequali in quadrante CD , &amp; motu accelerato in semidiametro mobili CA ; &amp; hic motus acceleratus in semidiametro est verus &amp; simplex motus descensivrs ; in qua acceptione Minor propositio est falsissima , &amp; Riccioli etiam experientiis contraria .
But it seems , that Angeli answers otherwise , to make Riccioli sensible , that CIA is no semicircle ; concerning the nature of which Line they debate very much throughout the whole discourse .
The second Argument is much insisted upon by Angeli , to make his solution clear to vulgar capacities ; but the substance of all is , That the Canon-ball hath not only that violent motion , impressed by the Fire , but also all these motions proper to the Earth , which were recommunicated to it by the impulse received from the Earth : for , the Ball , going from West to East , hath indeed two impulses , one from the Earth , and another from the Fire ; but this impulse from the Earth is also common to the mark , and therefore the Ball hits the mark only with that simple impulse , received from the Fire , as it doth being shot towards the North or South ; as , Angeli doth excellently illustrate by familiar examples of Motion .
To Riccioli his third Argument Angeli answers , desiring him to prove the sequel of his Major , which Riccioli doth , supposing the curve , in which the heavy body descends , to be composed of many small right lines ; and proving , that the motion is almost always equal in these lines ; and after some debate , concerning the equality of motion in these right lines , Angeli answers , that the equality of motion is not sufficient to prove the equality of percussion and sound , but that there is necessary also equal angles of incidence ; which in this case he proves to be very unequal .
To illustrate this more , let us prove , that , other things being alike , the proportion of two percussions is composed of the direct proportion of their velocities , and of the direct proportions of the Sines of their angles of incidence .
Supponamus autem sequens principium , nempe , quod percussiones ( caeteris paribus , ) sint in direct a proportione cum velocitatibus , quibus mobile appropinquat planum resistens .
Fig. 2da .
Sit planum CF , sintque duo mobilia omni modo aequalia , &amp; similia , quae motu aequali accedant a puncto A. ad planum CF , in rectis AD , AF : dico , percussionem in puncto D ad percussionem in puncto F. esse in ratione composita ex ratione velocitatis in recta AD .
ad velocitatem in AF , &amp; ex ratione sinus anguli ADE ad sinum anguli AFE .
Ex puncto A in planum CF , sit recta AE normalis , sitque recta AC aequalis rectae AF , &amp; AB aequalis rectae AD , &amp; planum BGH , parallelum plano CF : supponamus mobile , prioribus simile &amp; aequale , moveri aequaliter in recta AC , eadem velocitate , qua movetur mobile in recta AD : quoniam plana BGH , CF , sunt Parallela , &amp; motus in recta AC est ~ , igitur mobile eadem velocitate accedit ad planum BH , qua ad planum CF , &amp; proinde percussiones in punctis B , C , sunt aequales ; atque percussio in puncto D , est ad percussionem in puncto B , ut recta AE ad rectam AH , sen ( ob aequales rectas AD , AB ) ut sinus anguli ADE ad sinum anguli ABH , quod sic probo ; velocitas mobilis in recta AD , est aequalis velocitati mobilis in recta AB , ipsi AD equali , &amp; ideo eodem tempore perficitur utraque recta AD , AB ; &amp; proinde eodem tempore perficiuntur accessiones adplanaresistentia AE , AH ; ideoque velocitates accessionum ad plana resistentia sunt in directa ratione AE ad AH , atque ideo percussio in puncto D. est ad percussionem in puncto C. in eadem ratione AE ad AH ; nempe ut Sinus anguli incidentiae ADE .
ad sinum anguli incidentiae ACE , vel AFE .
Quoniam autem rectae AC .
AF , aequaliter inclinant ad planum CF , mobilia in rectis AC , AF , accedunt ad planum CF , in eadem proportione qua moventur in rectis AC , AF ; &amp; ideo percussio in C est ad percussionem in F in ratione velocitatis motus in AC seu in AD ad velocitatem motus in AF ; At demonstratum est ante , percussionem in puncto D ad percussionem in puncto C , esse in ratione sinus anguli ADE ad sinum anguli AFE , &amp; nunc demonstratum est , percussionem in puncto C esse ad percussionem in puncto F , ut velocitas motus in AD ad velocitatem motus in AF .
Igitur ex 5 defin .
6 .
Elementorum , percussio in D , est ad percussionem in F , in ratione composita exratione sinus anguli incidentlae ADE , ad sinum anguli incidentiae AFE , &amp; ex ratione velocitatis in AD ad velocitatem in AF ; quod demonstrare oportuit .
Neminem moveat , quod haec demonstratio adstricta sit motibus aequalibus in lineis rectis &amp; planis resistentibus ; est enim vera in omni casu : nam , cumpercussiones fiant in puncto , in hoc coincidunt rectum , curvum , aequale , &amp; inaequale ; si autem in punctis percussiones non fiant , de illis non potest dari consideratio geometrica , sed judicandus est conclusionis defectus secundum defectum materiae a conditionibus requisitis , sicut semper fieri debet , dum demonstrationes geometricae corpori physico applicantur .
In Angeli his reply to Manfreddi , he makes mention of an Experiment , which ( as was related to him by a Swedish Gentleman ) had been made with all due circumspection by Cartesius to prove the Motion of the Earth .
The experiment was ; He caused to be erected a Canon perpendicular to the Horizon ; which being 24 times discharged in that posture , the Ball did fall 22 times towards the West , and only twice toward the East .

