A New Discovery touching Vision .
This is the Title of two or three printed sheets of paper , lately sent from Paris to the Publisher , by the no less Obliging than Ingenious Monsieur Justel ; In which are contained both an Epistle of the Discoverer Monsieur L ' Abbe Mariotte , of Dyons , to Monsieur Pecquet , and the Answer to it .
Of both which we cannot omit to give the Reader the substance in English , as follows , HAving often observed in Anatomical Dissections of Men as well as Brutes , that the Optic Nerve does never answer just to the Middle of the bottom of the Eye , i.e. to the place , where is made the picture of the Objects , we directly look on ; and that in man it is somewhat higher , and on the side towards the Nose ; to make therefore the Rays of an Object to fall upon the Optic Nerve of my Eye , and to find the consequence thereof , I made this Experiment ; I fastened on an obscure Wall about the hight of my Eye , a small round paper , to serve me for a fixed point of Vision ; and I fastned such an other on the side thereof towards my right hand , at the distance of about 2 .
foot ; but somewhat lower than the first , to the end that it might strike the Optic Nerve of my Right Eye , whilst I kept my Left shut .
Then I placed my self over against the First paper , and drew back by little and little , keeping my Right Eye Fixed and very steady upon the same ; and being about 10 .
foot distant , the second paper totally disappeared .
That this cannot be imputed to the Oblique position of the second paper , is hence evident , That I can see other Objects further extant on the side of it ?
so that one would believe , the second paper were by a slight taken away , if one did not soon find it again by the least stirring of one 's Eye .
This Experiment I made often , varying it by different distances , and removing or approaching the Papers to one another proportionally .
I made it also with my left Eye , by keeping my Right shut , after I had fastned the Second paper on the Left side of my point of Vision ; so that from the Site of the parts of the Eye , it cannot be doubted , but that this deficiency of Vision is upon the optic Nerve .
This Discovery I communicated to many of my friends , who found the same thing , though not always just at the same distances ; which diversity I adscribed to the different situation of the Optic Nerve .
You have made it your self , in his Majesties Library , where I showed it to those of your Illustrious Assembly ; and you as well as I , found the like variety , there being some , who , at the distances mentioned , lost the sight of a Paper , 8 inch .
large , and others , who ceased not to see it , but when it was somewhat less ; which appears not how it can be caused but by the differing magnitudes of the Optic Nerve in different Eyes .
This Experiment hath given me cause to doubt , Whether Vision was indeed performed in the Retina ( as is the Common opinion ) or rather in that other Membrane , which at the bottom of the Eye is seen through the Retina , and is called the Choroides .
For if Vision were made in the Retina , it seems that then it should be made whereever the Retina is ; and since the same covers the whole Nerve , as well as the rest of the bottom of the Eye , there appears no reason to me , why there should be no Vision in the place of the Optic Nerve where it is : on the contrary , if it be in the Choroides that Vision is made , it seems evident , that the reason , why there is none on the Optic Nerve , is , because that that Membrane ( the Choroides ) parts from the Edges of the said Nerve , and covers not the middle thereof , as it does the rest of the bottom of the Eye .
Upon this , I desire , you would give me your thoughts with freedom , since I am none of those that love to obtrude Conjectures for Demonstrations .
To which the main of M. Pecquets Answer is , as follows ; EVery one wonders , that no person before you hath been aware of this Privation of Sight , which every one now finds , after you have given notice of it .
But as to the Sequel , you draw from this Discovery , I see it not cogent , to abandon the Plea of the Retina for being the principal Organ of Vision .
For ( not to insist here on other considerations ) it will be sufficient , now to take notice , that at the place of the Optic Nerve there is something thing , that may very well cause this loss of the Object .
There are the Vessels of the Retina , the trunks whereof are big enough to give a hindrance to Vision .
These Vessels , which are no other but the ramifications of the Veins and Arteries , are derived from the Heart , and having no communication with the brain , they cannot carry thither the Species of the Objects .
If therefore the Visual rays , issuing from an Object , fall on these Vessels at the place of their Trunk or main Body , it is certain that the Impression , made thereby , will produce no Vision , and that the picture of that Object will be deficient ; as when on a white paper in an obscure Chamber , there is some black spot , or in it some hole considerably big : for the more sensible this blackness or hole is , the more of the image of the object it intercepts from our Eyes .
It is not so in respect of the small ramifications , that issue from those trunks , and shoot into the Retina .
For if they be met with at the place of the bottom of the Eye , where Vision is made distinct , they will not render the image of the Object deficient , because they are so small , as not to be sensible .
Thus it is , that in Looking-glasses , when they want lead or tin in any place big enough to be perceived , the image , we there see , appears to have a hole ; which happens not , when there is but so small a one , as might be made by the point of a needle .
Thus much being observed as to the deduction , made from this Experiment , I shall further note , That that paper , the sight whereof is lost , must be further or nearer off , according to the diversity of the structure of Eyes .
For some loose this paper at the distance of two feet some at a less , others at a greater distance ; some loose it a little higher , others a little lower , according as the trunks of the vessels are situated in respect of the Optic Nerve ; and some loose more of it than others , according as those vessels are bigger or smaller .
And because us hard to determine precisely the place , where the object is lost in all sorts of Eyes , we have ground to believe , that this loss is not always made on the extent of the Nerve , where the Retina is , but sometime besides it , where the Choroides is found .
For the trunks of the Vessels of the Retina are big and long enough to extend on this or that side of the Nerve , and so to hide some part of the Choroides , according to their Magnitude .
And in this case it will be true , that Vision is not made in all the parts where the Choroides is found , though they be exposed to the light .
Which may very well give a check to your opinion , forasmuch as those trunks would hinder the objects , falling on them , from coming to the Choroides ; which would render the image deficient in that place , in regard that those species would not be able to make an impression on the Organ of Vision through those vessels .
In the mean time , so pretty a discovery , as this is , could not belong without being confirmed .
For as the secret of your Experiment consists in contriving , that the picture of an Object may fall just on the Optic Nerve , or thereabout , M. Picard hath devised a way , by which an object is lost keeping both Eyes open , by letting the image of the object fall on both the Optic Nerves at one and the same time , after this manner ; Fasten against a wall a round white paper , of the bigness of an inch or two , and on the side of this paper put two marks one on the right , the other on the left side , each about two foot distant ; then place your self directly before the Paper , at the distance of about nine foot , and put the End of your finger over against your both Eyes , so that it may hide from the right Eye the left mark , and from the left Eye , the right mark .
If you remain firm in that posture , and look steddily with both Eyes on the end of your finger , the paper , which is not at all covered thereby , will altogether disappear ; which must be the more surprising , because that without this particular encounter of the Optic Nerves , where no Vision is made , the paper would appear double , as you will find as often as the finger shall not be placed as it ought to be , or when the sight is carried any thing sideways ; whereof the reason is sufficiently known .
The application of this way is easily made to that of yours .
For when one looks steddily with both Eyes on the End of one 's finger , held before the marks , it is the same thing , as if you directed each eye by it self to the place , which is to be looked on to loose the paper ; So that one may with both Eyes do the same thing , that you do with one , keeping the other closed , &amp;c.

