Numb. 28 .
PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS .
Monday , October 21 .
1667 .
The Contents .
An Account of more Trials of Transfusion , accompanied with some Considerations thereon , chiefly in reference to its Cautious Practise on Man ; together with a farther Vindication of this Invention from Usurpers .
The Method of Transfusing into the Veins of Men .
Answers to some of the Inquiries formerly published concerning Mines .
An Extract of a Letter sent from Paris about the Load-Stone ; where chiefly the suggestion of Gilbert touching the Circumvolution of a Round Magnet , and the Variation of the Variation is examined .
An Account of some Books and small Tracts : I. FREE CONSIDERATIONS about SUBORDINATE FORMS , by ROBERT BOYLE Esquire .
II .
JOH .
SWAMMERDAM , M.D. de RESPIRATIONE &amp; USU PULMONUM .
III .
OBSERVATIONS faites sir un RENARD MARIN , &amp; un LYON , a Paris .
IV .
HISTORIA AMBRAE GRISEAE , Auth. JUSTO KLOBIO , D. An Account Of more Trials of Transfusion , accompanied with some Considerations thereon , chiefly in reference to its circumspect Practise on Man ; together with a farther Vindication of this Invention from Usurpers .
THis Experiment , as it hath raised Disputes among the Curious both here and abroad ; so it hath put some of them upon considering such ways , and given such cautions , as may renG gg der der the use of it safe and beneficial .
Of the number of these seems to be that French Virtuoso , Gasper de Gurye de Montpoly , who in a late Letter of his to Monsieur Bour delot , declares to the World , that this is a very Ingenious Invention , and such an one , as may prove very useful ; but withal , that , in his opinion , it is to be used with much caution , as not being like to be practised innoxiously , if imprudent men do manage it , and the concourse of two differing sorts of Blood requiring many trials , and a careful observation of many circumstances , to give assurance .
He supposes , that the Blood of every Animal is endowed with its peculiar Temper , and contains in the Aggregate of its parts , different natures , principles , figures , and even a different Center .
Whence he concludes , that two Substances thus differing , and containing plenty of Spirits , are not reducible to one and the same Center , nor to one and the same Body without Fermentation ; and that this Operation may prove of danger to him , that shall have admitted into his Veins a strange Blood ( wont to be free in its native Vessels ) without passing through those degrees , that must give it Impressions sutable to the temper and functions of the Vitals of the Recipient : And taking for granted , that no considerate man will hazard a Total Transfusion , he acknowledges that a partial one may be in some cases and sicknesses very useful , provided , it be practised circumspectly , upon a Body yet strong enough , and in a moderate quantity , so as the Spirits and Blood of the Recipient may be able to dissolve and master the transfused strange Blood , and convert the same into its own nature by a gentle Ebullition ; to obtain by such a commixture a principle of motion , that may cause a better habit of Body .
And he believes , that this Ebullition must always happen in Bloods of differing parts and qualities ; and that very hardly two Animals , of differing species , ages and tempers , will be met with , that have Blood so like one another , as not to need Fermentation , to make a requisite mixture .
He doubts not , that if a substance could be found so resembling that of our Spirits , as that it would immediately unite it self with them , not needing any alteration , the Transfusion of such a Substance would be capable to produce effects little less than miraculous , by relieving the prostrated forces of Nature , and by fortifying in us the Spring of the motion and life : In a word , by exciting that Principle of continu al Motion , which , whilst it has strength enough , still subdues and gathers to it self whatever is proper to entertain it , and rejects what is not so .
But such an Invention as this he sees cause to esteem very difficult , in regard that different Moulds cannot but Characterize things differently .
Hence he proceeds to the Examples , wherein Transfusion hath been experimented , even upon Men ; alleged in that known ingenious Letter of Monsieur Denys .
And here he intimates , how much he was pleased to learn , that , according to his Conjecture , a Moderate Intromission of Blood hath well succeeded , and the Fermentation , which we foresaw would be caused by the commixture of two Bloods , was made with advantage to the Patient : Which he judges did manifestly appear by his Bleeding at the Nose , ( a sign of an Ebullition made in the Blood : ) confirmed to him by this , that an expert Acquaintance of his , transfusing a great quantity of Blood into several Doggs , observed always , that the Receiving Doggs pissed Blood .
And as to the other successful Experiment , made upon a healthy and robust man , he notes , that he being a lusty Fellow , stored with blood , and taking the Air , and working hard on the same day that the trial was made upon him , his vigorous Blood , Spirits , and Constitution , and the strong motion of his Heart , were able to convert into the substance of his own Blood that of the Lamb received , and to impart thereto his own nature , and to mould it into Figures sutable to the pores where it was to pass , and proper to the functions it was to perform .
But to these Reflections he subjoyns two other Instances , of an unlike success ; whereof the one is afforded by a Man , the other by a Dog .
As to the Man , it ought to be related beforehand , to prevent wonder or misconstruction , that his Intestines , when he was opened after death , were found to be gangren 'd , and consequently , that then he appeared to have been a subject altogether unfit for this Experiment , seeing it was naturally impossible for him to live with such a putrefaction .
But to come to the trial it self ; this Author saith , that Baron Bond , Son to the first Minister of State to the King of Sweeden , undergoing the Operation twice , appeared the first time to find new strength by it ; but expired soon after the second Operation : *The Ebullition , it seems , of the corrupt Blood having mastered and enervated all the Blood he had in his Body:which when opened , no Blood at all was found in his Heart : probably , as the Anthor conjectureth , upon this account , that there being not left in the Patient Blood enough of his own , nor strength sufficient to turn a strange Blood into a substance homogenius to that ; the Heart was not capable to admit the Blood of the Emittent , as consisting of parts disproportionate to his own .
But , as hath been already observed , his Entrails were altogether vitiated by a Gangrene , and he therefore out of the reach of being relieved by this Experiment .
* It were to be wished the Author had expressed the Interval of time , wherein these two Operations followed one another ; that seeming to be a material circumstance in the Case .
Concerning the other Instance , viz. of the Doggs , the Letter affirms , that the Trial was made by Monsieur Gayen with great exactness , after this manner .
He drew three great dishes of Blood from the Dog that was to receive , and weighed the other Dog that was to furnish ; and , the operation being performed , he weighed him again , and found him weigh less than he did by two pounds ; of which having abated an ounce more or less , for the Urine , made by the Dog , and an ounce or two more for the Blood spilt in the Operation , there remains at least one pound and a half of Blood , that was transfused .
But , the Recipient , though well dressed , and well fed , died five days after , the Emittent being yet alive .
Whence it seems evident to this Writer , that the too large Intromission of new Blood was predominant over the Native , and as 'twere , overwhelmed it .
Whence he again inculcates the dangerousness of infusing too much Blood at once , in regard that such Blood being now separated from the principle of life it had in the Emittent , and as yet destitute of the stamp necessary to live the life of the Recipient , it could not be moved and assimilated by the live Blood , which remained in the Recipient ; and the Fermentation , that was made , passed rather to an Eagerness or Sowerness , than to such an one as precedes Digestion .
And this kind of eager acidity he intimates was seen by the Spectators , and felt by the Receiving Animal , which sounded , and remained as dead for half a quarter of an hour : And when some alleged , that the Dog died , because he was wounded in the neck , where he could not lick himself , which rendred his wound incureable , answer was given , that Experiments had been made , wherein not only a Vein was opened , but also an Artery , yea , even the Asper a arteria cut of a Dog , that could not lick himself , and yet survived .
This whole Account is concluded with an Admonition , that all those , who have convenience , would make frequent and exact trials of this Experiment on Brutes , and carefully observe weight and Measure , and all other circumstances , before any thing be hazarded , that may damnify the public , and depreciate the Invention .
Abundans cautela non nocet , is a Maxim very fit to be minded here ; though several successful Experiments have been made in London , of very plentiful Transfusions ; and among others ( to mention a signal one ) that upon a Bitch , which lost in the operation near 30 ounces of blood , and was recruited accordingly .
This Animal does not only survive to this very day , but had another more severe Experiment soon after tried upon her , by which her Spleen was cut out , without tying up the Vessels , whence that viscus was separated : Since which time ( even before the wound was healed up ) she took dog , was with Puppy , and brought forth Whelps , and remains well and jocund , being kept for a piece of remarquable Curiosity in the House of a Noble-man , that is as severe in Examining matters of fact , as he is able in Judging of their consequences .
So that it is not too hastily to be concluded , that large Transfusions are dangerous ; but rather frequent Experiments should be made , before any thing be therein determined , with great as well as smaller quantities , both upon sound and sickly Beasts , carefully observing , how either is endured in either , and what are the Effects following thereon .
Before we dismiss this Subject , something is to be said of the Cause , why the Curious in England make a demurr in practising this Experiment upon Men .
The above mentioned ingenious Monsieur Denys has acquainted the World , how this degree was ventured upon at Paris , and what good success it there met with : And the Journal des Scavans glories , that the French have advanced this Invention so far , as to try it upon Men , before any English did it , and that with good success .
We readily grant , They were the first , we know off , that actually thus improved the Experiment ; but then they must give us leave to inform them of this Truth , that the Philosophers in England had practised it long ago upon Man , if they had not been so tender in hazarding the Life of Man ( which they take so much pain , to preserve and relieve ) nor so scrupulous to incur the Penalties of the Law , which in England , is more strict and nice in cases of this concernment , than those of many other Nations are .
The Publisher can assert bona fide , that several Moneths ago he saw himself the Instruments ready , and heard the Method agreed on , thought proper to execute this Operation upon Man .
And , for further proof thereof , he shall here insert the whole way , peculiarly contrived here for this purpose , by the Ingenious Dr. Edmund King , and by him communicated in a Letter ; Monsier Denys not having thought fit to describe the manner they used in France for Men ; nor any body else come to our knowledge .
The Letter is as follows , SIR , THe Method of Transfusing Blood you have seen practised , with facility enough , from Beast to Beast ; and we have things in a readiness to transfuse Blood from the Artery of a Lamb , Kid , or what other Animal may be thought proper , into the Vein of a Man .
We have been ready for this Experiment this six Months , and wait for nothing but good opportunities , and the removal of some considerations of a Moral nature .
I gave you a view , you may remember , a good while ago , of the Instruments , I think very proper for the Experiment , which are only a Silver Tube , with a Silver Stopper somewhat blunted at one end , and flatted at the other for convenience of handling , used already upon Beasts with good success .
The way is in short this .
After the Artery is prepared in the Lamb , Kid , &amp;c. let a Ligature be made upon the Arm , &amp; e. of a man ( hard enough to render the Vein turgid ; ) in the place you intend to insert the lesser end of the Silver pipe , which is so fitted , that the Silver Stopper , thrust into the Tube , reaches somewhat , by its blunt end , beyond one of the ends of that Tube .
This done , divide the skin of the part in the same manner , that is used in cutting an Issue , just over the vein , to be opened .
Then with a fine Lance open the vein ; or , if you please , in case the vein lye fair and high ( especially if the skin be fine ) you may open both together , according to the usual way of letting Blood .
Which done , let an Assistant clap his finger , or a little Bolster , prepared before hand , or the like , upon the Vein a little below the Orfice , to hinder the Blood from ascending .
Keeping that position , insert the blunt-ended Tupe upwards into the Vein ; when it is in , hold it and the skin close together between your finger and thubm .
Then pull out of the Tube the Stopper , and insert the Pipe , by which the Arterial Blood is to be infused from the Emittent Animal ; managing the remainder according to the known Method of this Experiment .
So far this Letter ; which makes the practicableness of this Method look so fair and easy , that nothing seems wanting to encourage the Trial , but the Direction and Assistance of discreet and skillful men , taking care , not to experiment it upon Subjects , that have their internal parts vitiated ; for as much as it seems not reasonable to expect , that this Transfnsion should cure Cacochymies , or restore a depraved constitution of the viscera .
We would have said no more of this Argument at this time , were we not obliged to remove a mistake found in one of the late French Journals , asfirming with confidence , that it is certain , the French have given the English the first thought or notion of this Experiment .
And why ?
because(say they ) they are witnesses , that a Benedictine Fryer , one Don Robert de Gabets , discoursed of it at Monsieur de Monmors , ten years ago .
Surely , all ingenius men will acknowledge , that the certain way of deciding such Controversies as these , is a Public Record , either written or printed , declaring the time and place of an Invention first proposed , the contrivance of the Method , to practise it , and the instances of the success in the Execution .
All this appears in the field for England .
Numb. 7 .
of these Transactions ( printed An. 1665.in Decemb. acquaints the World , how many years since Dr. Christopher Wren proposed the Experiment of Infusion into Veins .
And this was hint enough for the R. Society , some while after to advance Infusion to Transfusion ; for the trial of which latter , they give order at their Public Meeting of May 17 .
1665 .
as may be seen in their Journal , where it was registred by the care of their Secretaries obliged by Oath to fidelity : The trials proving then lame , for want of a fit apparatus , and a well contrived Method of operation , the Learned Physician and Expert Anatomist , Dr. Lower , since found out such a Method , which is not only registred in the same Book , but also published in Print Numb. 20.of these Tracts ; before which time it had been already practised by the said Doctor in Oxford , who was followed by several ingenious men at London , that successfully practised it by the Public Order of the aforesaid Society .
It seems strange , that so surprising an Invention should have been conceived in France , as they will have it , ten years ago , and lain there so long in the Womb , till the way of Midwiving it into the world was sent thither from London : To say nothing of the disagreement , there seems to be about the French Parent of this faetus , Monsieur de Gurye in the Letter above mentioned , fathering it upon the Abbot Bourdelot , but the Author of the French Journals , upon a Benedictine Fryer .
But whoever this Parent be , that is not so material , as that all that lay claim to the Child , should join together their endeavours and cares to breed it up for the service and relief of humane life , if it be capable of it ; and this is the main thing aimed at and solicited in this Discourse ; not written to offend or injure any , but to give every one his due , as near as can be discerned

