Numb. 110 .
PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS .
Januar .
25 .
16 74/ 75 .
The CONTENT S. A Letter of Franc .
Linus , animadverting on Mr. Newton 's Theory of Light and Colours ; with an Answer thereunto .
Extracts of two Letters written by Mr. Flamstead , of an Astronomical Nature .
Some Observations and Experiments made by Mr. Lister , touching the Esflorescence of certain Mineral Glebes ; an odd figured Iris ; a Glossopetra tricuspis non-serrata ; certain Lapides Judaici , for kind found in England ; the Electrical power of Stones in relation to a Vegetable Rosin ; the Flower and Seed of Mushroms ; and the speedy vitrifying the whole Body of Antimony by Cawk .
An Account of some Books ; I. Tracts containing , 1 .
Suspicions about some hidden Qualities in the Air , with an Appendix touching Celestial Magnets , and some other Particulars .
2 .
Animadversions upon Mr. Hobbs 's PROBLEMATA de V ACUO .
3 .
A Discourse of the Cause of Attraction by SUCTION .
By the Honourable R. Boyle , Esq ; Fell .
of the R. Society .
II .
R. P. Claudii Franc .
Milliet de Chales CURSUS seu MUNDUS MATHEMATICUS , &amp;c. III .
The SPHERE of M. Manilius , made an English Poem , with Annotations , and an Astronomical Appendix : By Edward Sherburn , Esq ; IV .
AVON A , or a Transient View of the Benefit of making Rivers of this Kingdom Navigable ; by R. S. V. An Essay to facilitate the EDUCATION of YOUT H , &amp;c. by M. Lewis , of Tottenham .
A Letter of the learned Franc .
Linus , to a Friend of his in London , animadverting upon Mr. Isaac Newton 's Theory of Light and Colours , formerly printed in these Tracts .
Honoured Sir , UNderstanding , that Things of the Nature I now write , are always welcome unto you , from what hand soever they come , I thought good , though unknown to you , to give you Notice , That perusing lately the Philosophical Transactions , to see what I could find therein , in order to a little Treatise of Opticks I have in hand ; I lighted in page 3075 , upon a Letter of Mr. Isaac Newton , Professor of Mathematicks in the University of Cambridge , wherein he he speaks of an Experiment he tried , by letting the Sun-beams through a little hole into a dark Chamber ; which passing through a glass Prism to the opposite Wall , exhibited there a Spectrum of divers Colours , but in a Form much more long then broad : Whereas , according to the received Laws of Refraction , it should rather have appeared in a circular Form .
Whereupon conceiving a defect in those usual Laws of Refraction , he frames his new Theory of Light , giving to several Rays , several refrangibilities , without respect to their Angles of Incidence , &amp;c. Truly , Sir , I doubt not of what this learned Author here affirms ; and have my self sometimes in like Circumstances observed the like difference between the Length and Breadth of this coloured Spectrum ; but never found it so when the Sky was clear and free from Clouds , near the Sun ; but then only appeared this difference of Length and Breadth , when the Sun either shined through a white Cloud , or enlightned some such Clouds near unto it .
And then indeed it was no marvel , the said Spectrum should be longer than broad ; since the Cloud or Clouds , so enlightned , were in order to those Colours like to a great Sun , making a far greater Angle of Intersection in the said hole , then the true Rays of the Sun do make ; and therefore are able to enlighten the whole length of the Prism , and not only some small part thereof , as we see enlightned by the true Sun-beams coming through the same little hole .
And this we behold also in the true Sun-beams , when they enlighten the whole Prism : For , although in a clear Heaven , the Rays of the Sun , passing through the said Hole , never make a Spectrum longer than broad , because they then occupy but a small part of the Prism ; yet if the Hole be so much bigger as to enlighten the whole Prism , you shall presently see the length of the Spectrum much exceed its breadth ; which excess will be always so much the greater , as the length of the Prism exceeds its breadth .
From whence I conclude , that the Spectrum , this learned Author saw much longer then broad , was not effected by the true Sun-beams , but by Rays proceeding from some bright Cloud , as is said , and by consequence , that the Theory of Light grounded upon that Experiment , cannot subsist .
What I have here said , needs no other confirmation than mere Experience , which any one may quickly try ; neither have I only tried the same upon this Occasion , but near 30 Years ago showed the same , together with divers other Experiments of Light , to that worthy Promoter of Experimental Philosophy , Sir Kenelm Dighy , who coming into these Parts to take the Spaw-waters , resorted oftentimes to my darkned Chamber , to see those various Phenomenon of Light made by divers Refractions and Reflexions , and took Notes upon them ; which industry if they also had used , who endeavour to explicate the aforesaid Difference between the length and breadth of this coloured Spectrum , by the received Laws of Refraction , would never have taken so impossible a Task in hand .
The rest is , Honoured Sir , That it is far from my Intent , that the Mistake here mentioned , do any way derogate from that learned Person : Which truly might have happened to my self , if at my first trial thereof , the Sun had been in a white Cloud , as it seems , it happened to him .
Wherefore ceasing further to trouble you , I rest , Yours to command , Francis Linus .
6 Octob. 1674 .
Sir , An Answer to this Letter .
THE Letter you thought fit to write by way of Animadversion upon Mr. Newton 's new Theory of Light and Colours , grounded upon an Experiment of letting the Sun-beams through a little hole into a dark Chamber , seems to need no other Answer but this , That you would be pleased to look upon , and consider the Scheme in Mr. Newton 's 2d Answer to P. Pardies , in Numb. 85 .
of the Ph. Transactions ; and rest assured , that the Experiment , as it is represented , was tried in clear Days , and the Prism placed close to the hole in the Window , so that the Light had no room to diverge , and the coloured Image made not parallel ( as in that conjecture ) but transverse to the Axis of the Prism .
London , Decem .
17 .
1674 .

