A Letter of Mr. Martin Lister , written at York August 25 1671 .
confirming the Observation in No 74 .
about Musk sented Insects ; adding some Notes upon D.Swammerdam 's book of Insects , and on that of M.Steno concerning Petrify 'd Shells .
SIR , I Have observed the two Insects , which Mr. Ray saith , smell of Musk , which indeed they do in an high degree .
The small Bees are very frequent in the Wooles in Lincoln shire , and about the latter end of April are to be found in pastures and meadows , upon the early-blown flowers of a sort of Ranunculus , as You have been rightly informed ; but it is something improper to say Bees feed on flowers : And likewise the same Bees are no less frequent on the flowers of Dens Leonis , &amp;c. The sweet Beetle , is a very large Insect , and well known about Cambridge .
All the trials I have made to preserve them with their smell , have proved ineffectual : For , both sorts of these Insects will of themselves in a very few weeks become almost quite sent-less .
To these I shall add another sweet-smelling Insect , which is a Hexapode-worm feeding on Gallium luteum .
The Observation of the Vespae Ichneumones , as it hath relation to Spiders , I willingly reserve for other Papers : yet I may tell you in general , that this kind of Insect is one of the greatest puzzels in nature ; there being few Excrescencies of Plants , and very many births of Insects , wherein these slender Wasps after divers strange ways are concerned .
Though I be at present from my Books , yet I well remember the passage , which Mr. Willonghby refers you to in Muffet * .
And he is well able to judge , whether the Observation be made upon the same sort of Insect .
I conceive it a fault not consistent with Ingenious Spirits , to pass by in silence the Industry Sss2 of * See N mb .
of Moderns as well as of Ancient Writers ; according to that of C.Celsus : Oportet neque recentiores viros in his fraudare , quae vel repererunt , vel recte secuti sunt ; &amp; tamen ea , quae ab antiquioribus posita sunt , authoribus suis reddere .
You can best inform me , what D. Swammerdam does in a matter of this nature : when I read in the Account given us by you of his Book , Numb. 64 ; that Snails are both Male and Female ; that Caterpillars may teach us , by their feeding , the correspondence of the virtues of Plants , &amp; c ; I am desirous to know , whether he quote Mr. Ray for the former , as having publish't the Observation ten years ago at least ; and for the latter , the Learned and Noble D.Columna , who did propose the way of essaying the virtues of Plants by the palats of Insects in the beginning of this Age .
But I leave this , and proceed to a remark of my own ; and it shall be , if you please , concerning Petrified Shells ; I mean such Shells , as I have observed in our English stone Quarries , But Sir , let me premise thus much , that I am confident , that you at least will acquit me , and not believe me one of a litigious nature .
This I say in reference to what I have lately read in Steno 's Prodromus , that , if my sentiments on this particular are somewhat different from his , it proceeds not from a spirit of contradiction , but from a different view of Nature .
First then , we will easily believe , that in some Countries , and particularly along the shores of the Mediterranean Sea , there may all manner of Sea shells be found promiscuously included in Rocks or Earth , and at good distances too from the Sea .
But , for our English-inland Quarries , which also abound with infinite number and great varieties of shells , I am apt to think , there is no such matter , as Petrifying of Shells in the business ( or , as Steno explains himself p. 84 .
in the English Version , &amp; alibi , that the substance of those shells , formerly belonging to animals , hath been dissolved or wasted by the penetrating force of juices , and that a stony substance is come in the place thereof , ) but that these Cockle-like stones ever were , as they are at present , Lapides sui generis , and never any part of an Animal .
That they are so at present , is in effect confessed by Steno in the above cited page ; and it is most certain , that our English Quarry-shells ( to continue that abusive name ) have no parts of a different Texture from the rock or quarry they are taken , that is , that there is no such thing as shell in these resemblances of shells , but that Iron-stone Cockles are all Iron stone ; Lime or marble all Lime-stone and Marble ; Sparre or Chrystalline-shells all Sparre , &amp;c. and that they never were any part of an Animal .
My reason is : That Quarries of different stone yield us quite different sorts or species of shells , not only one from another ( as those Cockle stones of the Iron-stone Quarries of Adderton in York-shire differ from those found in the Lead mines of the neighbouring mountains , and both these from that Cockle Quarry of Wan~fordbridge in Northampton shire , and all three from those to be found in the Quarries about Gunthrop and Beavour-Castle , &amp; c ; ) but , I dare boldly say , from any thing in nature besides , that either the land , salt , or fresh water doth yield us .
Tis true , that I have picked out of that one Quarry of Wan~ford very resemblances of Murices , Telinae , Turbines , Cochleae , &amp;c. and yet I am not convinced , when I particularly examined some of our English shores for shells , also the fresh waters and the fields , that I did ever meet with ( N. B. ) any one of those species of shells any where else , but in their respective Quarries , whence I conclude them Lapides sui generis , and that they were not cast in any Animal mold , whose species or race is yet to be found in being at this day .
This argument perhaps will not so readily take place with those persons , that think it not worth the while exactly and minutely to distinguish the several species of the things of nature , but are content to acquiesce in figure , resemblance , kind , and such general notions ; but when they shall please to condescend to heedful and accurate discriptions , they will , I doubt not , be of that opinion , which an attentive view of these things led me into some years ago .
Though I make no doubt , but the Repository of the R. Society is amply furnished with things of this nature ; yet if you shall command them , I will send you up two or three sor s of our English Cocklestones of different Quarries , nearly resemoling one the other and all of them very like a common sort of Sea-shell , and yet if there shall not be enough specifically to distinguish them , and hinder them from being sampled by any thing of the spoils of the Sea or fresh waters or the land-snails ; my argument will fall , and I shall be happily convinced of an Error .

