A Considerable Account touching Vegetable Excrescencies , given by that Learned and Observing Gentleman , Mr. Martin Lister , in a Letter to the Publisher , of July 17 .
1671 .
from York .
I Understand by yours of the 23th instant , that M. Ray cannot without much trouble retrieve the Letter , wherein I gave him formerly my opinion concerning Vegetable Excrescencies ; and yet not wholly to deny you the satisfaction of what you seem much to desire , I am willing to think again upon the same subject , at least to recollect part of my former thoughts , as my memory will serve me .
The occasion then of that Letter was upon the account given us by You in Numb. 57 , of the opinion of the Italian F. Redi ; Viz.that some live Plants or their Excrescencies do truly generate some Insects .
To which opinion of F.Redi I told my friend , as I remember , that I indeed had observed , that the By-fruits of some Vegetables , as of the Oak and wild Rose , for example , did grow up together with their respective worms in them from small beginnings to fair and large fruit , some of them emulating even the genuine off-spring of the plant , &amp; miratur non sua poma .
And further , that I did believe , the worms were furnished with food in and from them ; but not by any Navil-connexion , as that Author fancies , and which I said , to me was unintelligible , and that I should be glad of a notion , which might make out to me such monstrous relation , as half animal half vegetable , or which is all one , Vegetable vessels inserted into an animal , or , the contrary .
Strange Occonomy !
That it had never been my good fortune ( what ever diligence I had used ) to discern Eggs in the Center of Galls , but a worm constantly , even at the very first appearance , as near at least as my fortune led me .
Yet I would not deny , but that diligence might one day discover the egg it self , which I was of opinion was affixed to or near the place by the parentInfect , where the Gall rose .
That I ever found the worms in all the excrescencies , that I had yet met with , perfectly at liberty ; and for the filaments , our Author mentions , it was very possible he might be mistaken , it being very hard , and a matter not yet treated of in any public paper , which and what are the vessels that enter into the Texture of a Vegetable , as of a large Tree , for example ; much more hard would it be to say , this is a vessel in a small Gall That there were many By-fruits of different figure and shape ( though perhaps of a like Texture ) upon one and the same plant , every one of which did nourish and produce a different race of Insects : Whence , I told him , I thought might rather be argued the diverse workmanship of different Insects , then one and the same principle of vegetation to be Author of several sorts of Animals .
That the Animals themselves , produced of such Excrescencies , were for the kind of such a race , as were well known to us to be otherwise generated of animal parents , and therefore it was probable , that these were so too , as well as their tribefellows .
That the Insect-Animals produced of such Excrescencies were male and female ; and that , if so , we might argue with Aristotle ( lib. I. c. l. de Generat .
Animal .
) that Nature made not such in vain , and that , if from the coit of these Animals , which have their birth from no Animals , Animals should be born , they would either be like their parents and of the same species with them , and if so , it would necessarily follow ( since in the generation of all other creatures it so comes to pass ) that their very parents had such origin too : or unlike them , and if so ( if these also were male and female ) of this second unlike off-spring a third race of different animals or species would be begot , and of them a fourth , and so in infinitum .
And that these Insects , which he and I had observed to be produced of the Excrescencies of some vegetables , we had good cause to suspect they were male and female , since some of them had stings and were tripilous , and others not ( vide Catalog .
plant .
Cantab .
ad Rosam caninam &amp; alibi .
) These were some at least of the Arguments , as far as I remember , I used , when I formerly wrote on this subject to my friend ; but since that Letter , I have perused the Book of F. Redi it self , and do find , that the said opinion is barely proposed as a thing not unplausible , but the proofs thereof are reserved , till the publishing of a curious piece , concerning the Excrescen= cies of the Oak ; and therefore I shall be less earnest in the refutation of that opinion , which perhaps a more accurate search into Nature will in time make the Author of it himself find erroneous .
I presume not to venture to decide this controversy , my experience in these matters being too insufficient , and my leisure and health but little to hasten a convenient stock of particulars , and a due examination of them ; yet before I leave this subject , I am willing to run over and present you with a few abbreviated instances of some of the several kinds of Vegetable Excrescencies , and likewise some un-obvious ways of Insects feeding on plants ; and these I shall deliver in confirmation of the following Propositions .
1 .
That all are not truly Vegetable Excrescencies that are reputed such .
And here we may justly name the Purple-Kermes , for example , whose history you were pleased to publish in Numb. 73 .
This , I fay , both gives a clear light to the discovery of the nature of the Scarlet-Kermes , ( a thing wholly unknown to the Ancients , as far as we can see by their writings , and no less ignored by the moderns , and yet , which is admirable , in very great esteem and continued in use for some thousands of years , ) and also is an evident instance , that some things , confidently believed Vegetable Excrescencies , are no such matter , but Artificial things meerly contiguous to the plant , and which have no other relation to it than the patella-shellfish to the Rock it cleaves .
2 .
Generally , Infect Eggs laid upon the leaves of plants , or their respective worms feeding on them do not occasion or raise Excrescencies .
This truth every body , that hath been the least curious , is an Eye witness of .
Thus , for example , the Eggs of the common Red butter fly , laid upon the Nettle , are thereon hatched without blistering the plant into an Excrescence , and the stiff haired or prickly Caterpillars hatched from them Eggs , feed upon the leaves without any ill impression , puncture , or prejudice , save that they make clean work , and eat all before them .
I could produce some hundreds of instances , if this were to be doubred of .
3 .
Some Infect-eggs , laid upon the leaves or other parts of plants , do , as soon as hatched , pierce and enter within the plant to feed .
To give you a convincing instance to the truth of this proposition , take this from my notes .
May 22 , I observed on the back or underside of the leaves of Atriplex olida , certain final milk-white oblong Eggs , on some leaves four , on others fewer , or more ; these Eggs were on some plants yet unhatched , but on many of the same plants I found the Egg .
shells or skins yet adhering to the leaves , and the little maggots already entered ( through I know not what invisible holes ) within the two membranes of the leaf , and feeding on the inward pulp or substance of the leaf : in other leaves of that plant , ( he that shall make the observation after me , will find plants enough of this Species seized on , to vary , as I did , the observation in one day , ) I found those maggots grown very great , and yet the two membranes , that is , the uppermost and undermost skin of the leaf , entire , but raised and hollow like a blather .
Note I. That those magots were of a Conick shape .
2 .
That in July they shrunk into Fly Chrysalis 's , and accordingly came to perfection , &amp;c. To this unobvious way of feeding we think we may refer all worm-eaten fruits , woods , &amp;c. 4 .
Worms feeding within some of the parts of some plants do cause Excrescencies .
Thus the heads or seed-vessels of Papaver .
Spart .
Sylv. Ger .
Emac .
&amp;c. are disfigured for having worms in them , and grow thrice as big , as the not seized ones .
This is also plain in the Excresc , of Pseudo teucrium , and Barbarea , &amp;c. 5 .
The substance of most Vegetable Excrescencies is not the food of the worms to be found in them .
The instances given in confirmation of the last proposition do also confirm this : neither is an Oak-apple properly worm:eaten , or the Shagged Galls , or Sponges of the Wild Rose , or the Smooth ones on the leaves of the same plant , or the Baggs upon the leaves of the yellow dwarf Willow or the Elm , &amp;c. This is the sum of what I have to say at present concerning this subject , being very unwilling to advance further , than my own private observations will suffer me .

