XIII .
T TDA ~~ XI .
LG D ~~ AX XII .
T XBD GA MGX NMPD DD An Answer to Four Papers of Mr. Hobs , lately Published in the Months of August , and this present September , 1671 .
In the former part of his first Paper ; BY reason of a Proposition of Dr. Wallis ( Prop. 1 .
Cap. 5 .
De Motu ) to this purpose ( for he doth not repeat it Verbatim : ) If there he supposed a row of Quantities infinitely many , increasing according to the natural Order of Numbers , 1,2,3 , &amp;c. or their Squares,1,4,9 , ctc .
or their Cubes,1,8,27 , &amp;c. whereof the last is given .
It will be a row of as many , equal to the last , in the first case , as 1 to 2 ; in the second case , as 1 to 3 ; in the third , as 1 to 4 , &amp;c. ( Where all that is affirmed , is but ; If we SUPPOSE That ; This will Follow .
Which Consequence Mr. Hobs doth not deny : and therefore all that he saith to it , is but Cavilling .
) Mr. Hobs moves these Questions , ( and proposes them to the Royal Society , to pass a judgment on them .
) 1.Whether there can be understood ( he should rather have said , supposed ) an infinite row of Quantities , whereof the last can be given .
2 .
Whether a Finite Quantity can be divided into an Infinite Number of lesser Quantities , or a Finite quantity consist of an Infinite Number of Parts .
3 .
Whether there be any Quantity greater than Infinite , 4 .
Whether there be any Finite Magnitude of which there is no Center of Gravity .
5.Whether there be any Number Infinite .
6.Whether the Arithmetic of Infinites be of any use , for the confirming or confuting any Doctrine .
For answer .
In general , I say , 1 .
Whether those things Be or Be not ; yea , whether they Can or Cannot be ; the Proposition is not at all concerned , ( which affirms nothing either way ; ) but , whether they can be supposed , or made the supposition , in a conditional Proposition .
As when I say , If Mr. Hobs were a Mathematician , he would argue otherwise ; I do not affirm that either he is , or ever was , or will be such .
I only say ( upon supposition ) If he were , what he is not ; he would not do as he doth .
2 .
Many of these Quaere 's have nothing to do with the Proposition : For it hath not one word concerning Gravity , or Center of Gravity , or Greater than Infinite .
3 .
That usually in Euclide , and all after him , by Infinite is meant but , More than any assignable Finite , though not Absolutely Infinite , or the greatest possible .
4 .
Nor do they mean , when Infinites are proposed , that they should actually Be , or be possible to be performed ; but only , that they be supposed .
( It being usual with them , upon supposition of things Impossible , to infer useful Truths .
) And Euclide ( in his second Postulate ) requiring , the producing a straight line Infinitely , either may ; did not mean , that it should be actually performed .
( for it is not possible for any man to produce a straight line Infinitely ; ) but , that it be supposed .
And if AB * be supposed so produced , though but one way ; its length must be supposed to become Infinite ( or more than any Finite length assignable ; ) For , if but Finite , a Finite production would serve .
But , if so produced both ways ; it will be yet Greater , that is , Greater than that Infinite , or Greater than was necessary to make it more than any Finite length assignable .
( And whoever doth thus suppose Infinites ; must consequently suppose , One Infinite greater than another .
) Again , when ( by Euclide 's tenth Proposition ) the same AB* , may be Bisected in M. and each of the halves in m , and so onwards , Infinitely : it is not his meaning ( when such continual section is proposed ) that it should be actually done , ( for , who can do it ?
) but that it be supposed .
And upon such ( supposed ) section infinitely continued , the parts must be ( supposed ) infinitely many ; for no Finite number of parts would suffice for Infinite sections .
And if further , the same AB so divided , be supposed the side of a Triangle ABC* ; and , from each point of division , supposed lines ( as mc , Mc , &amp;c. ) parallel to BC : these parallels ( reckoning downward from A to BC ) must consequently be ( supposed ) infinitely many ; and those , in Arithmetical progression , as 1 , 2 , 3 , &amp;c. each exceeding its Antecedent as much as that exceeds the next before it ; ) and , whereof the last ( BC ) is given : ( and their Squares , as 1 , 4 , 9 , &amp;c. their Cubes , as 1,8,27 , &amp;c. ) And this I say , to show that the supposition of Infinites ( with these attendants ) is not so new , or so Peculiar to Cavallerius or Dr. Wallis , but that Euclide admits it , and all Mathematicians with him ; as at least supposable , whether Possible or not .
*See Tab. 1 .
n. II .
* See Tab. 1 .
n. III .
* See Tab. 1 .
n. IV .
In particular , therefore , to his Quaere 's , I answer , 1 .
There may be supposed a row of Quantities Infinitely many , and continually increasing , ( as the supposed parallels in the Triangle ABC , reckoning downwards from A to BC , ) whereof the last ( BC ) is given .
2 .
A Finite Quantity ( as AB ) may be supposed ( by such continual Bisections ) divisible into a number of parts Infinitely many ( or , more than any Finite number assignable : ) For there is no stint beyond which such division may not be supposed to be continued ; ( for still the last , how small soever , will have two halves ; ) And , all those Parts were in the Undivided whole ; ( else , where should they be had ?
) 3 .
Of supposed Infinites , one may be supposed greater than another : As a , supposed , infinite number of Men , may be supposed to have a Greater number of eyes .
4 .
A surface , or solid , may be supposed so constituted , as to be Infinitely Long , but Finitely Great , ( the Breadth continually Decreasing in greater proportion than the Length Increases , ) and so as to have no Center of Gravity .
Such is Toricellio 's Solidum Hyperbolicum acutum ; and others innumerable , discovered by Dr. Wallis Monsieur Fermat , and others .
But to determine this , requires more of Geometry and Logic than Mr. Hobs is Master of .
5 .
There may be supposed a number Infinite ; that is , greater than any assignable Finite : As the supposed number of parts , arising from a supposed Section Infinitely continued .
6 .
There is therefore no reason , on this account , why the Doctrine of Euclide , Cavallerius , or Dr. Wallis , should be rejected as of no use .
But having solved these Quaere 's , I have some for Mr. Hobs to answer , which will not so easily be dispatched by him .
For though Supposed Infinites will serve the Mathematicians well enough : yet , howsoever he please to prevaticate ( which , he saith , is for his Exercise , ) Mr. Hobs himself is more concerned than they , to solve such Quaere 's .
Let him ask himself therefore , if he be still of opinion , that there is no Argument in nature to prove , the World had a Beginning : 1 .
Whether , in case it had not , there must not have passed an Infinite number of years before Mr. Hobs was born .
( For , if but Finite , how many soever , it must have begun so many years before .
) 2 .
Whether , now , there have not passed more ; that is , more than that infinite number .
3 .
Whether , in that Infinite ( or more than infinite ) number of Years , there have not been a Greater number of Days and Hours : and , of which hitherto , the last is given .
4 .
Whether , if this be an Absurdity , we have not then ( contrary to what Mr. Hobs would persuade us ) an Argument in nature to prove , the world had a beginning .
Nor are we beholden to Mr. Hobs for this Argument ; for it was an Argument in use before Mr. Hobs was born .
Nor can he serve himself self ( as the Mathematicians do ) with supposed Infinites ; For his Infinites , and more than Infinites of Years , Days , and Hours , already past , must be Real Infinities , and which have actually existed , and whereof the last is given ; ( and yet there are more to follow .
) Mr. Hobs shall do well(for his Exercise ) to solve these , before he propose more Quaere 's of Infinites .
And this I say , to show that Mr. Hobs is , as much as any , concerned to solve the Quaere 's by himself proposed .
In the latter part of his first Paper , HE gives us(out of his Roset .
Prop.5.)this Attempt of Squaring the Circle .
Suppose DT be 2/ 5DC , and DR a mean proportional between DC and DT~ the Semidiameter DC will be equal to the Quadrantal Arc RS , and DR to TV .
That the thing is false , is already showed in the Latin Confutation of his Rosetum , published in the Philosophical Transactions for July last past .
As it is now in the English ; his Demonstration is peccant in these words , ( Col. 2.lin.31,32,33 .
) Therefore the Arc on TV , the Arc on RS , the Arc on CA , cannot be in continual proportion ; ( with all that follows : ) There being no ground for such Consequence .
And the thing is manifest* ; for since that , by his construction , DC .
CA.Arc on CA extended~ are in the same cantinual proDR .
RS.Arc on RS extended~ portion , of the Semidiameter DT .
TV.Arc on TV extended~ to the Quadrantal Arc ; Let that proportion be what you will ; suppose , as 1 to 2 ; and consequently , DC to CA being as 1 to 2 , it will be to the Arc on CA , as 1 to 4 : And by the same reason , DR to the Arc on RS , and DT to the Arc on TV , must also be as 1 to 4 : And therefore the Arcs on TV , on RS , on CA ; that is,4 DT,4 DR,4 DC ; will be in the same proportion to one another , as ( their singles ) DT , DR , DC : But these ( by construction ) are in continual proportion ; therefore those Arcs also , as they ought to be .
Indeed , if ( by changing some one of the terms ) you destroy ( contrary to the Hypothesis ) the continual proportion of DT , DR , DC , you will destroy that of the Arcs also ( which are still proportional to these : ) but so long as DT , DR , DC , be in any continual proportion * See Tab.1 .
portion ( whether that by him assigned or any other ) those will be in the same continual proportion with them .
As if for DT , DR , DC , be taken Dt , Dr , DC , in any continual proportion ( greater , less , or equal to his ) the Arcs on tu , on rs , on CA , ( extended ) will be in the same continual proportion .
But ( which is the common fault of Mr. Hobs 's Demonstration ) if this Demonstration were good , it would serve as well for any proposition as that for which he brings it .
For if , instead of 2/ 5 , he had said , 4/ 9 , 1/ 2 , 1/ 100 , or what else he pleased ; the Demonstration had been just as good as now it is , without changing one syllable : That is , it will equally prove the proportion of the Semidiameter to the Quadrantal Arc , to be , what you please : As any may presently see , who doth but read over his Paper .
In his second Paper , HE pretends to consute a Theorem , which bath a long time passed for truth ; ( and therefore doth no more concern Dr. Wallis , than other men .
) And tis this , The four sides of a square being divided into any number of equal parts , for example , into 100 ; and straight lines drawn through the opposite points , which will divide the Squares into 100 lesser Squares : The received opinion ( faith he ) and which Dr. Wallis commonly uses , is , that the Root of those 100 , namely 10 , is the side of the whole Square .
Which to confute , he tells us , The Root 10 is a number of squares , whereof the whole contains 100 ; and therefore the Root of 100 Squares is 10 of those squares , and not the side of any Square ; because the side of a Square is not a Supersicies , but a Line .
For An.s I say , that'tis neither the opinion of Doctor Wallis , nor ( that I know ) of any other ( so far is it from being a Received Opinion , which Master Hobs insinuates as such ) that 10 is the Root of 100 Squares ( For surely a Bare Number cannot be the side of a Square Figure : ) Nor yet ( as Master Hobs would have it ) that 10 Squares is the Root of 100 Squares : But that 10 Lengths is the Root of 100 Squares .
Tis true that the Number 10 is the Root of the Number 100 , but not , of a 100 Squares : and , that 10 Squares is the Root ( not of 100 Squares , but ) of 100 Squared Squares : Like as 10 Dousen is the Root , not of 100 Dousen , but of 100 Dousen dousen , or Squares of a Dousen .
And , as , there , you must mnltiply not only 10 into 10 , but Dousen into Dousen , to have the Square of 10 Dousen 3 so here 10 into 10 ( which makes a 100 ) and Length into Length ( which makes a square ) to obtain the Square of 10 Lengths , which is therefore 100 Squares , and 10 Lengths the Root or side of it .
But , says he , the Root of 100 Soldiers , is 10 Soldiers .
Answer .
No such matter : For 100 Soldiers is not the product of 10 Soldiers into 10 Soldiers , but of 10 Soldiers into the Number 10 : And therefore neither 10 , nor 10 Soldiers , the Root of it .
So 10 Lengths into the Number 10 , makes no Square , but 100 Lengths ; but 10 Lengths into 10 Lengths makes ( not 100 Lengths , but ) 100 Squares .
So in all other proportions : As , if the number of Lengths in the Square side be 2 ; the number of Squares in the Plain will be twice two , ( because there will be two rows of two in a row : ) If the number of Lengths in the side , be 3 ; the number of Squares in the Plain , will be 3 times 3 , or the Square of 3 : If that be 4 , this will be 4 times 4 : And so in all other proportions .
Of which , if any one doubt he may believe his own eyes * .
*See Tab. I. n. VI .
VII .
VIII .
IX .
And this Mr. Hobs might have been taught by the next Carpenter ( that knows but how to measure a Foot of Board ) who could have told him , that because the side of a Square Foot , is 12 Inches in Length , the Plain of it will be 12 times 12 Inches in Squares : Because there will be 12 Rows of 12 in a Row .
His third Paper , WHich came out just as the Answer to the two former was going to the Press , contains , for substance , the same with his second , and the Latter part of the first : And so needs no farther Answer .
Only I cannot but take notice of his usual trade of contradicting himself .
His second Paper says , The side of a Square is not a Superficies , but a Line : His third says the quite contrary , ( Prop. 1 .
) A Square root , ( speaking of Quantity ) is not a Line , but a Rectangle .
Other faults , falsities , and contradictions , there are a great many .
As for Instance : He tells us first , In the natural Row of Numbers , as 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , &amp;c. every one is the Square of some number in the same Row ; ( that is , of some Integer number ; which is notoriously false .
) This he contradicts in the very next words , But Square numbers ( beginning at I ) intermit first two numbers , then four , then six , &amp; c ; so that none of the intermitted numbers is a Square number , nor hath any Square root .
( If these intermitted numbers , between 1 , 4 , 9 , 16 , &amp;c. be not Squares how is it that every one in the whole row is a Square , and that of some Integer number ?
) But this again is contradicted prop.2 .
where 200(one of such intermitted numbers ) is made a Square , and 14 4/ 14 the Root of it .
Again ; in his Definition he tells us , that a Square Root multiplied into it self produces a Square : But ( prop.2 .
) he multiplies the Root 14 4/ 14 ( not into it self , but ) into 14 ( a part thereof , ) to make 200 , which he will have to be the Square of that Root .
Nor is it a mere slip of negligence in the computation , but his Rule directs to it ; Any number given is produced by the greatest Root multiplied into it self , and into the remaining Fraction .
Whereof he gives this instance : Let the number given be 200 Squares , the greatest Root is 14 4/ 14 Squares ( he should rather have said Lengths ; but that is a small fault with him ; ) I say , that 200 is equal to the product of 14 into it self ( which is 196 , ) together with 14 multiplied into 4/ 14 ( which is equal to 4 : ) that is 14 4/ 14 multiplied into 14 .
But this calculation is again contradicted in his third proposition , where he calculates the same Square otherwise , as we shall see by and by .
In the mean time let 's consider this alone , and see the contradictions within it self .
His Rule bids us multiply the greatest Root into it self , &amp;c. This greatest Root he says is 14 4/ 14 ; yet doth he not multiply this , but 14 ( a part thereof ) into it self and into the Fraction 4/ 14 .
Again ; if 14 4/ 14 be the greatest Root , what shall be the remaining Fraction ?
Doth he take the Root of 200 to be more than 14 4/ 14 by some further remaining Fraction ?
If so , he should have told us what that Fraction is ; for 4/ 14 it is not , this being part of his greatest Root 14 4/ 14 .
But if we should allow ( as I think we must , ) that by the greatest Root he means sometimes 14 4/ 14 , sometimes 14 , ( that is , if we allow him to contradict himself , ) yet how comes he by the Fraction 4/ 14 ?
For , 2/ 14 is too much ( the square of 14 2/ 14 being more then 200 , as by multiplying 14 2/ 14 into it self will appear ; ) which destroys his whole design ; for 14 , multiplied into 14 2/ 14 , will not make 200 , but 198 ; contrary to his rule .
But further , it is so gross a mistake , to make 200 the Square of 14 2/ 14 , that every Apprentice boy , ( that can but multiply whole numbers , and fractions , ) could have informed him better , who would first have reduced the fraction to smaller terms , putting 14 2/ 7 for 14 4/ 14 , and then multiplying 14 2/ 7 into it self , would have showed him , that the Square of 14 4/ 14 , that is , 14 1/ 14 multiplied into it self , is ( not 200 , but ) 204 4/ 49 .
But the Root of 200 , is the surd number 10~2 , which is less than 14 2/ 14 , and bigger than 14 2/ 15 : the Square of that being somewhat more than 200 ; and , of this , somewhat less ; but either of them within an unite of it .
But this second Proposition , is ( as I said ) contradicted by his third , which makes the Square of 14 4/ 14 to be 200 1/ 49 , ( by what computation , we shall see by and by ; ) and then finds fault , that this and the former do not agree .
( But it is no wonder they should disagree , when both are false .
) The same Square ( saith he ) calculated Geometrically , consists ( by Euclid.2.4 ) of the same numeral great Square 196 , and of two Rectangles under the greatest side 14 and the Remainder of the side , and further of the Square of the less seg= meant ; which altogether make 200 1/ 49 .
( He might have learned to reckon better ; but let us see how he makes it out .
) As by the operation it self ( saith he ) appears thus : The side of the greater segment is 144/ 14 ( this was , but now , the side of the whole square , how comes it now to be but the side of the greater Segment ?
) which multiplied unto it self ( saith he ) makes 200 : ( no ; but 204 4/ 49 : ) The product of 14 the greatest Segment into the two Fractions 4/ 14 is 4 , and that added to 196 makes 200 : ( if by two fractions 4/ 14 , he mean , as he ought by his Rule , the Fraction 4 twice taken , or the double of it , it will be not 4 , but 8 , and this added to 196 make 204 ; But all this he puts in his pocket , for it comes not into account at all .
) Lastly , the product of 2/ 14 into 2/ 14 , or 1/ 7 into 1/ 7 is 1/ 49 ; which with the first 200 makes 200 1/ 49 : ( But he forgets him= self , for his lesser segment was not 2/ 14 , but 4/ 14 ; he should there= fore have said 4/ 14 into 4/ 14 , or 2/ 7 into 2/ 7 , is 4/ 49 .
) His calculation therefore should have been this : The greater segment is ( not 14 ~/ ~ , but ) 14 ; which multiplied into it self makes ( not 200 , but 196 .
The Rectangle of the greater segment 14 , into the lesser 4/ 14 , is 4 : And this taken a second time , is another 4 : The lesser segment ( not 2/ 14 , but ) 4/ 14 , or 2/ 7 , multiplied into it self , is ( not 14 2/ 7 14 2/ 7/ 56 14 4 4 4/ 49 ( not 1/ 49 , but ) 4/ 49 : All which added together make not 200 1/ 49 , but 196 +4+4+ 4/ 49 = ) 204 4/ 49 , which is just the same with 14 4/ 14 multiplied into itself .
So that , had he known how to multiply a number into a number , especially when encumbered with fractions ( which it is manifest he doth not , ) he would have found no disagreement between the Arithmetical calculation , and what he calls the Geometrical .
But I am ashamed ( for him ) that so great a pretender to such high things in Geometry , should be so miserably ignorant of the common operations of practical Arithmetic .
His repeated Quadrature he now expresses thus , The Radius of a Circle is a mean Proportional between the Arc of a Quadrant and two fifths of the same .
But instead of two fifths , he might as well have said the half , or tenth , or hundredth part , &amp; c ; or ( taking T in DC produced beyond C , ) the double , decuple , centuple , &amp;c. or what you please : For his Demonstration would have proved it , which is this .
Describe a Square ABCD , and in it a Quadrant DCA .
In the side DC ( continued if need be , ) take DT two fifths of DC , ( or its Half , Double , Hundredth part , or what you please ; ) and between DC and DT a mean proportional DR ; and describe the Qua= drantal Arcs RS , TV .
I say , the Arc RS is equal to the straight line DC .
For seeing the proportion of DC to DT is duplicate of the proportion of DC to DR , it will be also duplicate of the Proportion of the Arc CA to the Arc RS , and likewise duplicate of the Proportion of the Arc RS to the Arc TV .
Suppose some other Arc , less or greater than the Arc RS , to be equal to DC , as for examplers ; Then the proprrtion of the Arc rs to the straight line DT will be duplicate of the proportion of RS to TV , or DR to DT , which is absurd ; because Dr is by construction greater or less than DR. Therefore the Arc RS is equal to the side DC ; which was to be demonstrated .
Which demonstration therefore proving indifferently every proportion , doth nct indeed prove any .
In brief : The force of his Demonstration is but this ; DT being to DC as 2 to 5 ( or in any other proportion ) and DR a mean proportional between them ; RS will be so between TV and CA ; and therefore rs ( greater or less than RS , )will not be a mean proportional between TV and CA : which is true ; but why it may not be equal to DC , we have nothing but his word for it ; there being nothing to show , that DC is equal to such a mean proportional .
Again ; though rs be not a mean proportional between TV and CA , yet it may be between tv and CA , which serves his Demonstration as well ; which is indifferent to any three continual proportionals , as was showed before .
So that now we have had three Demonstrations of this Quadrature , ( in his Rosetum , in his first paper , and in his third , ) and this common fault in all of them , that they equally prove the proportion by him proposed , or any other what you please .
But such his Demonstrations use to be .
And this is what I thought fit to say to Mr. Hobs 's three Papers ( rather to satisfy the importunity of others , than because I thought them worth Answering : ) And submit the whole , with all Respects , to the Royal Society , to whom Mr. Hobs makes his

