Some Considerations Relating to D. Witties Defence of Scarborough Spaw ( abbreviated in Numb. 51 .
) together with a brif Account of a less considerable Salt-spring in Somersetsh ; and of a Medical Spring in Dorsetshire ; by the Learned Dr. Highmore in a Letter to Dr J. Beale at Yeavil in Somersetsh .
Worthy Sir , I Give you many thanks for the last Letters , and the loan of your Book .
The Dr. indeed hath gotten ground of his Adversary ; but whether either of them hath gotten the right on his side , I cannot Judge , being a stranger to that Water , much differing ( it seems ) from these about Us ; and therefore may participate of other Minerals , and more , both in quantity and number .
But , whether all those distinct Minerals , reckoned up by the Dr , do conspire to makeup this Medicinal water , and that none of them can be left out , may be doubted : And it seems , he doth himself speak very doubtfully as to Salt ; acknowledging it to be the least of all the other , if there be any differing from the Salt of the Metals ; thought it be sometimes covered by the Sea , as he saith page .
89 .
Next , I wonder , why he should set Allom in the front of the Constituents of his Medicinal water : Alumen exiccat astringit , incrassat .
Now how the Water should be so highly deopilative , and so beneficial to Hypochondriacal and Cachectical persons , being impregnated with so great an Astringent , I understand not , neither doth the Dr. declare : Besides , he confesses , Allum-water will not tinge with Galls as he acknowledges this will Further , why he should make Iron and Vitriol two distinct Mineral Constituents of this Water , and call it Ferrum Vitriolatum .
I do not see : As it Vitriol were a stranger to Iron , or that they were here two distinct Minerals ; when indeed Iron alone will supply both .
Vitriol is the Salt of Iron , and there is no Iron without it .
And that Vitriol , which he saith is found alone in the Rocks near this Water , will by the Summer-heat be hardned into Iron , which in a forge will melt and run .
So that , though Vitriol may be found alone without the Iron-stone , it is not because it is no Ingredient in the Composition of Iron , which cannot be Iron without it ; but because those Vitriolin Earths are not grown to that perfection , but either by some accidental mixture of other Bodies is clapped up into the Composition of some other Mettal or Mineral ; or else wants those Bodies , or time , that should fix it into Iron .
And truly that opinion of Learned Dr. Jordan , that Waters are tinged by Minerals while they are in fieri ( though it seems to some ridiculous , as importing , that they should remain for many hundreds of Years in the same imperfect state , ) may yet have much of truth in it here .
And what can the Water receive from a perfectly wrought and mixed Metal , in its passage by it ; But when the whole mass is in solutis principiis , no part fixed by its neighbour , but every one at liberty , the water , passing through , may easily lick up something of every Body dissolveable in it .
And that these Bodies may continue in this State of Liberty for many years , without a copula to fix them into such a Metal , is not a matter either un-intelligible or ridiculous .
The Salts in the Earth may combine with different Bodies , and make up several compounded masses , which yet , when dissolved , may communicate the same properties .
The Vitriol of Copper makes water acid as well as that of Iron .
But it is not my business to undertake the quarrel ; only I must note , that his Colouring of Roman Vitriol page .
21 .
is erroneous .
Note , that Vitriol was omitted in the Print of Numb. 51 .
p. 1039 .
l. 40 .
In the 120th page .
he is dislatisfied , that his Adversary allows the Saltness of the Sea to proceed from the Fossile Salt ; or from such Rocks and Bodies of Salt which are often found in the Sea ; besides the Saltness dispersed throughout the whole Body of the Earth , easily imbibed by water .
He will rather allow the Peripatetical Torrefaction by the Sun to be the Cause ; which seems very improbable : For , the Suns heat cannot act more powerfully on water to this Effect , than Fire doth ; yet this will never give saltness to water , that is not already impregnated with saline particles .
And his Argument against his Adversary seems not convincing ; namely , That it should , if made by Fossil Salt , kill all Fish , as well Sea-fish , and Fresh-fish ; for so , faith he , Saltput to fresh water doth .
As the matter of Fact is not evident , that Salt put to fresh-water should kill Sea-fish ( the countrary of which I have experimented in Oysters ; ) so it seems not probable , that the Salt , which was lately imbodied with the water in the Sea , and was then natural to Fish , should , after its separation and reunion again in the like proportion , prove so fatal .
That the Salt of Sea-water and Salt-springs is the same with Fossil Salt , will be no hard matter to show .
The Inland Salt springs do receive their Saltnes from this Salt , or from nothing else that coms within our imagination .
From the Sea it cannot be supposed to come at such remote distances , as we do frequently find it .
Concerning the Salt-spring at East Chenock in Somersetsh .
I shall tell you , That the last week , being at Mr. Rs .
house , I made trial of that Salt-spring , above 20 .
miles from the Sea ; which , though not so salt then ( by reason of the late Rains ) as in Summer , yet from a Wine-quart , by Evaporation , we obtained near 80 .
grains , part of which I here send you .
Neither can these Springs be salt from the Suns Torrefaction , since they lye no nearer to the Sun 's force than many other Springs about them ; which yet continue fresh .
Moreover , if I may guess at the Ingredients of those Waters , which we call Chalybcate , and particularly of this at Farrington in Dorset-shire ; *I think them to be impregnated principally from the Vitriol or Salt of Iron , which is very Volatile ; so that little of it can be found , by evaporation of a great quantity , or from the precipitated sediment .
The proportion of Salt in this , Water I found after this manner .
I put 4 ounces of ordinary clear water into a Glass , and * Which is the same , that was , by a mistake , said ( in Numb. 51 .
p. 1039 .
l. 2 .
) to be at Stalbridge in Somersetsh .
and impregnated it with a known proportion of Gatt : then by degrees I let fall into it the Salt of Iron , until I found it thereby as deeply tinged red , as the same quantity of Farrington-waters would be by the same proportion of Gall : The quantity of the Salt of Iron , that performed this , was near two grains .
This water , so tinged , smelt and smelt just as the natural water from the Spring with Gall did : If I added a greater proportion of Salt , it would make it nauseous and Emetical .
Sherborn , Decemb.

