An account of two Books I. DISCOURSE de M. STENON sir L ' ANAT OM IE du CERVEA U. A Paris 1669 .
in 12 .
IN the beginning of this Discouise the Author represents , that those , who search after solid knowledge , will find nothing satisfactory in all that hath been hitherto written concerning the Brain : that all , which Anatomists agree in , is only , that it consists of two Substances , a White and a Grayish , and that the former is continued with the Nerves , that are distributed through the whole Body ; and the latter serves in some places for a kind of Cortex to the White , and in others , severs the white filaments from one another .
But that they are yet ignorant , what those substances are ; in what manner the Nerves are Joined in the White ; and how far their extremities advance in it ; from which disposition yet depends all the diversity and variety of our sensations and motions .
And as for the Ventricles or Cavities of the Brain , he affirms them to be no less unknown , than its Substance ; some Anatomists lodging ing in them the Spirits , others making them the receptacles of the Excrements of the Brain ; and both perplexed in assigning the source and Issue of the Excrements , and the Spirits , and the manner of the product on of the latter .
Besides this , he finds a great defect in the way of dissecting the Brain , and having showed the imperfection in the common ways , he proposes and recommends that ( though difficult one ) of continuing the filaments or threads of the Nerves through the Substance of the Brain , to see , where they pass , and where they terminate .
Next he entertains the Reader with an Enumeration of the chief Errors of Anatomists touching the brain .
And here he examins particularly the systems of Dr. Willis and Monsieur DesCartes .
In the former asks special notice , that the Author thereof lodges the Common Sense in the corpus Striatum ; the Imagination in the Corpus Callosum ; and the Memory in the Grayish Substance which encompasses the White .
But then he declares , that these assertions are very obnoxious ; for , whereas Dr. Willis describ 's that Corpus striatum , as if there mere two so ts of streaks or Rays , someascending , some descending , he finds , that a separation being made of the Gray body from the White , those Rays will be found to be all of the samenature , that is , they make part of the White substance of the Corpus Callosum which passes towards the Marrow of the Back , separated in divers Layers by the intervening of the Grayish Substance .
Which being so , saith be , with what certainty can we be made to believe , that those three Operations are performed in those three Bodies ?
And who can tell us , whether the nervous Fibres have their beginning in the Streaked Body , or whether they rather pass through the Callous Body into the Gray Substance : In the latter of M. Des Cartes , he finds , that that Philosopher hath rather divised , in his Treatise of Man , such an Engine , that performs all the actions , Men are capable of , than described Man , as really he is ; which he undertaketh to prove by divers instances , taken from the Cartesian fabric of the parts of the Brain : in the doing of which our Author shows great dexerity , skill , and accuratenes .
And from hence he proceeds , To observe the want of exactness in the Cutts or Figures , hitherto given of the Brain : and although he acknowledges , that the best Figures , hitherto made of that part , are those of Dr. Willis , yet he finds several faults committed here and there , and conceives , there are many things to be added for making them perfect : which certainly this able Anatomist will consider further , and according to his Ingenuity , as he shall see cause , rectify , if the Author of the Book , reflected on , prevent him not .
Having thus discussed the hitherto practised way of dissecting the Brain , and the little light to be derived thence , together with the defectiveness of the Figures belonging thereto , he leaves it to the Consideration of Judicious men , what faith is to be given to the Explications made upon such unsolid foundations ; and that done , he declares , which are the two only ways for attaining the true knowledge of an Engine ; viz. One , by having the contrivance of it discovered by the Author himself ; the other , by taking it in pieces to the very least parts , and examining them all both severally and jointly .
The former not being to be expected , he excites the Lovers of real knowledge to the careful performance of the latter ; excusing in the mean time those two sorts of persons , that hitherto have addicted themselves to Anatomical researches , viz. Physicians and Chirurgions , for not having made satisfactory discoveries by their labors , and alleging on their behalf their want of time requisite for this purpose ; the ill consequence of which he represents to be , that they often undertake to cure a Body , of which they know not the Structure , which is no better , ( faith he ) then if a man would repair or wind up an Engine , the parts of which he is ignorant of .
And as for Professors of Universities or other Schools , he Judges them not so proper for that particular application , and the variety of methods of dissecting ; both which is necessary for examining every the smallest part , and the observeables thereof ; there being sometimes required whole years for finding out one only thing , that perhaps may afterwards be demonstrated to others in one hour ; which he exemplifyes by divers instances of Discoveries , made by some of the modern Anatomists .
He concludes his Discourse by recommending the method which seems best and most convincing to him , for making true Discoveries in Anatomy ; where he advises , that for obtaining the true history of the parts , we should examine and accordingly draw them in that State , in which they are found naturally , without at all forcing them ; thereby to find , whether the parts are indeed joined together or separated , and what situation is assigned them by Nature it self .
Where he desires , that the Anatomist would not only be intent upon the part , on which he is for the present employed , but also reflect upon all the Operations , he hath made before he came to that part , which may have caused some change or other in the same , as to its scituation , connexion &amp;c. Of which he also all edges divers Examples , especialy as to the Brain .
Besides this exact attention on all the Operations , he further counsels the Change of the ways of Dissecting , and deduceth the ill consequences of binding ourselves to certain fixed Laws of dissecting each part ; this benefit resulting from that Change , that if it doth not always discover something new , it lets us know at least , whether we have been deceived in what we have seen formerly , especially in things dubious and contested .
Of the necessity of this Change he brings manifest proofs ; and having done so , he alleges the reason why he says nothing of the Use of the parts of the Brain , nor of the actions called Animal ; it being impossible to explain the motions , that are made by an Engine , if the artifice of the parts be not known , and those Anatomists rendring themselves ridiculous , that discourse so magisterially of the Use of the parts , of which they know not the structure .
Last of all , he observes , that when all this , he hath discoursed of , is done , that is but the least of what is to be done ; in regard that for the acquiring of some good Knowledge of the Brain , there must be Dissections and Examinations made of as many Heads , as there are different species 's of Animals , and different States and Conditions of each kind ; since that in the fetus 's of Animals it will be seen , How the Brain is formed ; and what could not be seen in sound and entire Brains , may be seen in such , as have been changed by sickness .
II , Instead of the other Book , of which we purposed to give here au Account , we find our selves oblieged somewhat to enlarge that which was , for want of more leisure , too cursorily given in Numb. 49 .
of Dr , Witties Answer to Hydrologia Chymica , concerning the Scarbrow Spaw .
To do therefore right to this Worthy person , we ought among other things to take notice of what he saith in his Preface ; That when he first published his Book , he had found the Scarbrough Spaw , even in 20 years Experience , to be eminently successul in the Cure of very many diseases , which had resisted all rational Methods , that had been used either by himself , or others of his Faculty .
That now his Practice had been near 30 .
years , and that now he can add some considerable Cures , which he hath not hitherto expressed .
Now to solicit this Learned Doctor and others for their farther Discovery 's of Sanative Waters , and to add weight to the Argument ; we may observe , that A. 1634 .
Dr. Thobias Whitaker , a famous Physician of Norwich , Published in English a discourse ~ ~ , or Of Drinking Mineral Waters ; particularly reflecting upon a Mineral Water then discovered in Norfolk , and producing the Joynt-advice of all Antiquity ( as he pretends , ) at least of the best Writers , namely of Hippocrates , Galen , Avicenna &amp;c. generally against all use of Mineral Waters either to be taken inwardly , or for any outward application .
This Discourse is recommended by the express approbation and elogies of Dr William Clement , Fellow and Register of the College of Physicians in London , and by Dr. Alex .
Read Fellow of the same College .
This may give fit Caution against the rash Use of such Waters , when ordinary Medicins may be effectual ; and to take the advice of skilful Physicians in the Use of them .
And for the Poor , which are not able to retain Physicians , nor to pay Apothecaries , they must abide the adventure of repairing to those kind Fountains , which doe not unfrequently cure , when all other costly and tedious Methods doe fail .
And here they may find the suffrage of many Curious and inquisitive Authors , and the evidence of much Experience : Here they may see the real and great performances of Cures , and what are the particular Cures , what the particular Ingredients , and what the mixtures , together with the several ways of Analysing the Waters &amp;c. As to the Sanative Properties in general of many Mineral Fountains ( besides the numerous Experiments of all sorts of people for many Ages in some places , and oflate discovery in other places ) Dr. Witty recites the Judicious testimony of Dr. French and Dr Dean concerning the Knarsborough Spaw ; Doctor Jordan concerning the Baths in Somersetshire ; Dr. Heer 's Spadocrene ; Doctor Frambesarius and Dr. Ryetius of the Sauvenir in Germany , Dr. Fallopius de Therm. Aquis and the Spaws in Germany and Rome , de Balneo Aponitano , and the water at ~ : Of such waters in general , Paracelsus and Helmont : And this ~~ description of St. Mungo 's Well at Cockgrave .
To which we may now add Astrap-well in Northampton , lately discovered , together with that at Stall-bridge in Somersetshire , which last begins also to be in high esteem for extraordinary Cures of the Scorbute , Asthma &amp; c which , besides common fame , is ( as we were freshly informed by a worthy friend ) attested by Dr. Highmore , who affirms also upon his own Trial , that it hath a larger proportion of the Minerals , than Astrap-water ; but that the force holds not , if removed from the Spring-head .
And Dr. Witty hath himself sufficiently asserted the Virtues of the ScarboroughSpaw ; and particularly , that it cured the Asthma , Inveterate Catharrs , Hecticks , Consumptions , Seurvy , Dropsy , and other diseases , when they seemed incurable : That anAlderman of Hull ( to whom himself , and the famous Dr. Primrose , were , 15 .
years ago , jointly Physicians for the Asthma ) had in few days perfect cure by the Spaw , and is yet living to vouch the testimony : So that all the neighbourhood are taught by frequent experience to sing the old Song of Claudian , which he made for his Aponus .
Publica morborum requies , commune medentum Auxilium , praesens Numen , inempta Salus .
And this old Record may put us in mind , that lofty Groves and healing Fountains have been reputed Holy in old times , and we can show the Hospitals , which have been long ago built and endowed on purpose to entertain the poor passengers in their travels to such waters .
This I had not here mentioned , but to introduce our Authors weighty remark ; That these Waters loose all their virtues , yea their quantity and bulk also , though in Glasses , and under the Hermetick Seaie , if removed from the Fountainhead ; that then they became suddenly putrid , ill-colored , loosing the taste and sent , and being very noxious , and begetting the Jaundise and worse diseases The like is affirmed by Dr French , that the Knarsborough Water expires through Glass and the firmest Seals .
And Dr. Heer affirms of his Spadocrene , that by such removals , illas a communibus nihil diserepasse , ut quibus fingulis lagenis aquae vitrum ( which is guessed to be half a pint ) decesserat .
He adds ; Decedit etiam quantitati-si fons hic alio transferaturquia spiritu turgentia plus loci , quam eo privata , occupare amant .
And Fram besarius reports as much of the Sauvenir , that in bottles well healed up , there wanted to every lagena ( flask ) one Glass of its measure ( doubtless through the loss of the volatile Spirits .
) Here we want instruction , Whether the decrease was as well of Weight as of Bulk or Quantity .
Whatever these Spirits be , which will neither endure to travel from the place , nor will be confined in any botle , not under any Seal ; Dr Witty undertakes to evince by good Proofs , and manifold indications , that these Scarborough waters have a mixture or tincture of Iron , Alum , Nitre , and probably of a small dose of Common Salt : Nay , he affirms punctually ( p. 175 as upon his own Experiment , that 5 .
quarts of this water contain at the least an Ounce of Minerals , and in dry years , 10 .
drams ; And yet that the usual dose for women to remove the Green sickness is a , quarts of water , and sometimes more , He He further vouches his own Trial ( p. 179 .
) that Knarsborough water hath 2 .
Ounce of Salt in a Gallon , though it be 40 .
miles distant from the Sea : And that he hath found also by trial , the 16th part of the Nothern Sea water near Scarborough to be a body of Salt ( an Ounce of Salt for every pint ; ) and he conceives the Southern Seas to contain a greater proportion of Salt .
Here we must distinguish , that the 2 .
Ounces of Salt above mentioned , to be found in every Gallon of Knarsborough water , belong to the Well there called the Sulphur-well : And for the healing properties of the Sweet well ( as they call the other Well at Knarsborough ) he refers to the Ingenious and illustrious Experiments of Dr. French and Dr. Dean .
All which being considered , we cannot but add , that whoever discovers such healing waters , and publicly prescribes the safe and right use of them , does really distribute larger and nobler Alms , than if he built and endowed a Savoy .
For this prolongs life , and restores health , ( wheh is sometimes better than life ) both to rich and Poor , to Natives and strangers , to Neighbors and Travellors .
We cannot take off our hands here , without annexing our Authors related Experiment of Carps ( p. 25 .
) which were taken out of Ponds newly drained , and being put with fresh watter into a Copper Brewing-vessel , to be preserved but for one night , were all found dead in the morning .
This he imputes to the poisonous steams of the Copper communicated to the cold water .
Among the Causes of Hot-Springs , he doth ( p. 181 .
) allege a considerable remark on an Observation , made by the late Lord Fairfax , of some heaps of White powder , which he found sweat out of the Earth near Bath ( in Somersetshire , ) which being put into the water , makes it hot ; as my self ( saith the Doctor ) did experience 5 .
or 6 .
years after his Lordship had taken it up .
As to his last Experimental Demonstrations and Observations , How the fall of Rain and Snow may generally and most frequently be the cause of our purest , liveliest and most lasting Springs , they doe all agree most punctually in all circumstances , with the Experiences and Observations of an Ancient and very Worthy Gentleman , who lives on the fire of Mendip hills , and hath had his Eyes always from his Youngest days upon the fairest and fullest Sources and Amnery 's , I say not of Mendip but I think I may say of this Island .
This Gentleman hath given to a friend of his the Instances and Particulars under his own hand , both for the Springs about Mendip , and in other parrs of England ; and hath many other Ancient Witnesses to join with him in the same Certificate .
And yet Dr. Witty attributes much ( some will say , more than enough ) to the Conversion of Air into Water in the Subterraneous Channels : For the Illustration of which he himself knew a Sergeant , belonging to Hull , who in a Diabete did void above 6 .
quarts or 12 .
pounds of Urine every 24 hours , for some weeks together , till all his Musculous parts were dissolved into Urine ; the measure whereof did far exceed the weight of his whole Body , and of his Meat and Drink : In all this time he drank not 3 .
pints of drink in a day .
I know not whether I dare allea alleadg here Sir Kine 'm Digby 's relation , he recited of the Nun , which voided 200 pounds of water , as from her bladder , every 24 hours , for some weeks together : or that Older record of a sick Maid in Italy , who did every day void 36 .
pints or pounds of Urine for the space of 60 .
days ; during which time there were collected 1740 .
pounds of Urine more than the weight of all her Meat and Drink , that she had taken .
Horum &amp; similium sides penes Authors esto-

