An Extract of Letters from Dr. John Wallis to the Publisher , 1672.Sept.26 .
&amp;c. concerning the Suspension of Quick silver well purged of Air , much higher than the ordinary Standard in the Torricellian Experiment .
SIR , IAm not sorry to find , in your Transactions for the last Month , ( which I have newly received , ) that M. Hugens , an Ingenious and Inquisitive person , doth endeavour to give a Reason of that Odd phenomenon in the Torricellian Experiment( observed by my Lord Brouncker , and Mr. Boyle , many years since , in pursuance of an Order of the R.Society to that purpose , ) of which I give an account in my Treatise De Motu Cap. 14.Schol.prop .
13 .
The Phenomenon is this : Whereas in the Torricellian Experiment , the Quicksilver contained in the Inverted Tube , how long soever , whose open orifice C. is immerged in stagnant Quicksilver , does usually fall down to the height of about 29 .
inches above the surface of the stagnant Quicksilver AB , and there remains suspended , as at I : If the Quicksilver be well cleansed from Air , it has beed found to stand top-full , much higher , even to the height of 75 .
inches ( and how much higher it may stand , we cannot tell ; ) but upon the admission of the lest Air , or a concussion of the Tube , it falls down to the usual standard .
Two Reasons I did there hint ( though not perfectly satisfied in either : ) The one , of my own , concerning the Spring of the Air , necessary to put Heavy bodies in motion , not impelled by any other force : The other , of my L.Brouncker , that there might be in the Air yet a greater Weight or Pressure than is necessary for the height of 29 inches , in case there be nothing but the bare weight of Quicksilver to be supported .
I find , Monsieur Hugens to fall in with that of my Lord Brouncker , save that what we comprehend under the name of Air , he calls a more subtle Matter : which alters not the Case at all , but only the Name .
By Air , I find , Mr. Hobbes would sometimes(as in Dialogus Physicus p. 4 .
) have us understand a pure AEther , or ( as his words are ) Aerem ab omni Terrae Aquaeq ; effluviis purum qualis putatur esse AEther ; to which , I suppose , answers the Materia subtilis of Des Cartes , and Mons. Hugens his more subtle Matter than Air .
On the other hand , M.Hugens here , by Air , seems to understand that seculent matter arising from those the Earths and Waters Effluvia , which are intermingled with this subtle Matter .
We mean by Air , the Aggregate of both these , or whatever else makes up that Heterogeneous Fluid wherein we breath , commonly called Air ; the purer part of which is Mr. Hobbes 's Air ; and the seculent of it is Monsieur Hugens 's Air .
And therefore , where I speak of Vacuity caus 'd by the Torricellian Experiment , or such other ways , I do expressly caution ( De Motu C. 14 .
and Hobb .
Heaut .
p. 152 .
and elsewhere , ) not to be understood as affirming Absolute vacuity ( which whether or no there be , or can be in nature , I list not to dispute ; ) but at least an Absence of that Heterogeneous mixture which we call Air , such as that is wherein we breath ; without disputing against the purus AEther of Mr. Hobbes , or the Materia subtilis of Des-Cartes or M.Hugens ; as not necessary to the Inquiries in hand .
To the Pressure of this Purer matter ( which they suppose so subtle , as to penetrate the Mercury , Marble , and Glass it self , ) they adscribe the Suspension of the Quicksilver to so great an height .
And my Lord Brouncker in particular , while that Piece of mine was under the Press , had a design ( as He then signified to me ) of prosecuting the Experiment ( as Monsieur Hugens does now advise , ) to see if he could bring it to some Determination ( of which I might there have given an account , if it could have been dispatcht time enough ; ) what were the utmost height at which it might be thus made to stand ; thereby to determine the pressure of this Purer matter , as that of the Common Air is determined by the Torricellian Experiment .
But his leisure not then serving , I only gave that brief account of his Notion , as it is there inserted : And , whether he have since had leisure , amidst a great press of other business , to pursue it , I am not certain .
Now , though I would not wholly exclude this , if such shall be found to be ( but only suspend my Assent till it be evinced ; ) yet surely there must be somewhat more in it than that of this Subtle matter , to solve the Phenomenon , not withstanding the two Experiments now alleged by M.Hugens in favour of it .
For , if this Matter be so subtle as to press , through the top of the Glass , upon the Quicksilver ( and consequently through the upper upon the nether of the two-Marbles , ) as is acknowledged ; ( and without which it is no more able to precipitate the Quicksilver while impure , and when it is in part subsided , than when it is pure , and the Tube top full : ) I do not see , why it should not balance it self ( above and below ) in the same manner as Common Air would do , if the Tube were previous to it at both ends , and the Quicksilver , by the preponderance of its own weight , fall presently .
And the Answer , That , though the Glass be penetrated by it , yet not in so copious a manner as where no Glass is ; doth not , to me , solve the difficulty : Because the same obstacle doth just in the same manner remain , when the Tube is in part emptied ; and , when the Quicksilver is un-purged : the pores of the Glass not being , by either of those , made more open or more pervious .
And if we suppose the Subtle matter by percolation to be strained through , with some difficulty , ( as Air or Water would be through a cloth , ) this might possibly cause the Quicksilver , when it does sink , to sink gradually ; but not ( as we see it , ) suddenly to fall to the height of 29 Inches ; as from D to I. The Connexion or Cohaesion of the parts of Quicksilver , either each to other , or to the sides of the Glass , which Mr. Hugens supposes to require for their separation a greater force , than is in these percolated particles till they have room made for them to combine ; seems to me the less considerable , because it is not so necessary to separate them from each other , since that they may un-separated slide down by the sides of the Glass ; to which , it is well known , and visible to the eye , the Quicksilver is not at all apt to stick , but doth rather decline that contact ; in like manner as we find Water not apt to Join with Oil or Grease ; though Water to Glass , and Quicksilver to Gold , do very readily apply themselves .
So that there needs no such Force to dis join the Quicksilver from the Glass , whatever there may be for dis-joyning its parts one from another .
C D 75 HG I 29 I 29 E F K AB D C If therefore we should suppose the pressure of the Grosser Air downwards on AB ( the surface of the stagnant Quicksilver , ) and consequently , by means-thereof , upwards at C , sufficient only to bear up that in the Tube to the height of I ; but the super-added weight or pressure of the Purer Air to hold it up as high as D ( 75 inches or more , ) while it is full , and the Quicksilver well cleansed ; as if so long it could not enter at D ; but in case it be not so cleansed , or be already sunk to H , this purer Air would enter at D , and thrust it downto I , counterballancing the pressure ( at C ) of the purer but not of the grosser Air ( which I take to be the sum of the Cause assigned by M. Hugens : ) I am yet to seek , why it may not as well penetrate D at first to begin the Descent , as afterwards to pursue it ; and , why not as well begin the Descent when the Quicksilver is well cleansed of Air , as when it is not so ; and why also , if the pure Air do freely enter at D , it does not presently fall ; or , if not freely , why , when it does fall , it falls suddenly and not leisurely from D to I ; especially since so small a weight as DH of pure Air ( for the grosser cannot enter , )is very inconsiderable ; if not at all , or not freely , pressed by that incumbent on D ; and the Adhesion not considerably less , by being separated only at the Top , while it yet continues to touch the sides .
I am apt therefore , as heretofore , to adscribe the Cause of this Phenomenon to the Spring that is in Air , and the want thereof in Quicksilver .
For , that in Air there is a Spring or Elasticity , is now undoubted ; but in Water , cleansed of Air , though many Experiments have been attempted to that purpose , it has not yet been found that there is any : And I am apt to think the like of Quicksilver ; though I do not know , that this has been yet so rigorously examined .
Now supposing , thatMatter , being at Rest , will so continue till it be put in motion by some Force ; this force may be either that of Percussion from some Body already in motion ( which is the Case , when the Quicksilver falls by shaking or striking the Tube ; ) or of Pulsion , from a contiguous Body beginning to move , as by the Expansion of some adjacent Spring ( which is the Case , when the Springy parts of the Air , either left in unpurged , or re-admitted in the Quicksilver , by expanding themselves put the Quicksilver in motion ; ) Or some Conatus or Endeavour of its own ; such as is that of a Spring ( from whatever cause it be , which I do not here inquire , ) but has place only in Springy bodies ; and therefore if Water and Quicksilver be not such , they will not on this account put themselves in motion .
Gravity or Heaviness is , I know ( if we knew what it were , ) reputed to be such a Conatus or Pronity to move downwards , and so to put it self in motion : And the wonder at present is , why it does not so here .
But if this , which we call Gravity , should chance to be not a Positive quality or Conatus originally of it self , but only the Effect of some Pulsion or Percussion from without , ( which possibly may be the Case , and principally from the Spring of the Air about us ; ) then , while this Pulsion and Percussion is wanting ( however obviated , ) the Bodies , accounted Heavy , will not of themselves begin to fall : which seems to be the present Case .
And this is the more considerable , because we cannot ( at lest not yet ) find , what is the Utmost height at which the Quicksilver thus accumulated will remain suspended ; there having been ( for ought I know ) no height yet attempted , at which , if cleansed , it will not stand ; and that of 75 inches , considering the weightiness of Quicksilver , is a very great one , being more than equivalent to 80 foot of water .
My Lord Brouncker doth a little alter the case , from what I take to be the Hypothesis of Monsieur Hugens .
For he supposes this purer part of the Air to be of like nature with the grosser part , ( which I think M.Hugens doth not ; ) and , though finer than the rest , so as to penetrate Glass , which the grosser will not(there being in all sorts of grains , some greater than others , and which will not pass so fine a Sieve ; ) yet of a Springy nature , as the grosser parts are : Which therefore acts , not by its Weight only , but by its Spring ; and therefore when once entered , though in a small proportion , acts as effectually , at its first entrance , as if the whole incumbent Air had admission ; its Spring being of a like tensure with that of the outward Air ; ( as I have heretofore showed Cap. 14 .
De motu prop.11,12,13 : ) But M. Hugens 's more Subtle matter than Air though he must allow it Weight ( for else its entrance would be nothing to the purpose , ) yet whether he allow it a Spring , I cannot tell ; nor doth he inform us .
And when he says , this more Subtle matter than Air doth without difficulty penetrate Glass , Water , Quicksilver , and all other bodies , which we find impenetrable to Air ; I know not whether he mean , without any difficulty ( as the words seem to import , ) or ( as I conjecture by what follows ) without great difficulty , though with some .
But his Lordship ( if I mistake not ) though he allow his ( Springy ) Subtle matter to penetrate Glass , yet not without difficulty ; and , till it have some room made ( as HD)wherein it may recollect it self , cannot exert its Spring , and therefore not while top-full of cleansed Quicksilver ; but , so soon as some room is made for it : Whereas , if the Quicksilver be not purged of Air , that little Air remaining doth by its Spring begin the motion .
He thinks it also not improbable ( and if it so prove , it will be a good confirmation of this Hypothesis , ) that a large but low Tube of Glass ( shorter than 29 inches ) may stand top-full of Quicksilver , though with a small hole in the Top , as at K ; at lest , if immerged in Water , in case Air be too Subtle for our Mechanicks .
He might also , suitably enough to his own Hypothesis , have so explained himself , as to allow his more Subtle parts of common Air to penetrate Quicksilver , but not Glass ; and therefore , in case of room for it at HD , it might through the Stagnant Quicksilver , and that at C , pass upwards to HD , and there exert its Spring .
I shall forbear to dispute against this Hypothesis for the present ; because I think it more proper to examine by Experiment ( which I think hath not yet been done , ) whether well-purged Quicksilver may not be made to stand higher than C I , the ordinary standard , suppose at CH , with a void space about it , as HD .
For the issue of this Experiment ( amongst others to be after mentioned , ) seems very proper for determining of this doubt ; which therefore I am not willing to pre-judge .
There is yet another way of explicating the same Hypothesis , without allowing this Subtle matter to pierce the Glass ; which is this : Our common Air being an aggregate of very Heterogeneous parts , we may well suppose some of them to be Springy , and others not to be so .
The Springy parts we may conceive to be so many consistent Bodies , like small hairs or springy threads wrapped up in different forms and variously entangled , and so as to form many vacuities capable of admitting(what other parts of the Air may be supposed to be)some Fluid matter , which may insinuate into those vacuities , ( as water in a bundle of Bushes , ) without disturbing the Texture of those Springy parts ; and which may press as a Weight , but not as a Spring , ( of which distinction see Cap. 14 .
De motu , Schol.prop 11 .
&amp; Schol prop. 13 .
page .
729 , 730,732,733 .
) Now if , in the Torricellian Tube , there be a quantity of such Springy matter , the Spring hereof will be of equal strength with that of External Air , ( and therefore able to counterbalance it , though its weight be much less , ) because admitted with such a tensure , ( ibid.prop .
12.13 ) But if only an Un-soringy Fluid ( which presses but as a Weight not as a Spring , ) and this defended by the glass-Tube from any other pressure , save that of its own weight ; it will still be too weak to force its own way , till its single weight be equivalent to that with which it is to encounter ; which is , not only the Springy part of the Air , but also that Fluid Un-springy part ; which though ( because Fluid ) it would give way to a Springy body pressing through it ; yet not to this Fluid , like it self , and destitute of such a Spring ; and is therefore able to keep it up to a much greater height than it could do if un-cleansed of Springy Air : So long at least as till some Springy body be admitted , or some concussion , equivalent to it , put it in motion ; but being once in motion , it will so continue ( as a Bullet impelled by Gun-powder , or an Arrow out of a Bow , ) till stopped by some Positive force equivalent .
I do not deny , but that this explication may be subject to some Difficulties and Exceptions ; but I think , fewer than that of allowing the Glass penetrable by this Subtle But the best way to settle this business , being some suitable Experiments ; I should recommend ( because I am not so well accommodated for this purpose , ) these , or some of these , Experiments , to those of the Royal Society , who are in that kind better provided than I. 1.(That hinted by my Lord Brouncker , )Whether a large low Tube , of less height than the common Standard ( of about 29 Inches English , or 27 Inches French , )might be made to stand top-full of Quicksilver , though a small hole be left open at the Top ; at least under Water ?
I am apt to think , that it will rather sink slowly and with a hissing noise , than fall suddenly and silently .
2 .
Whether of two polished Marbles or metalline Plates , the lower will be found to stick to the upper , in the exhausted Receiver , longer than is accountable for from the ordinary Counter-ballance in the Torricellian Experiment .
For though Monsieur Hugens now , and Mr. Boyle ( if my memory do not much fail me ) have long since intimated this from his own Experience ; yet I judge the Experiment worth repeating .
And if it be ( as I suppose it may ) found to succeed , I should think it may proceed from a want of a Spring or Elastick power between the Plates to force them asunder ; and in particular ( since with this it hath been tried ) that Spirit of Wine is not a Springy body .
3 .
Whether a Siphon of unequal Legs will be made to run , in an exhausted Receiver , with Water or Quicksilver , at a greater height than is accountable for ; which though Monsieur Hugens have tried it , I think it worth repeating in this Society .
This when it doth succeed , I take to proceed from the Spring of that little remaining Air in the Receiver not quite empried .
4.(Which seems of a like nature with the former , ) Whether a Tube of greater length than 29 Inches , but so immerg 'd as to be less than so much above the level , as CE , may not , if filled with well cleansed Quicksilver , be gently listed up with the Quicksilver in it , not only to I ( as when it is unpurged ) but to H or D , higher than the usual Standard .
5.(which 5 .
( Which is equivalent , but more easily administred , ) Whether if such a Tube , so filled , be at first so inclined ( as CF ) that its height above AB be less than 29 Inches , may not be leisurely and gently erected , so as to remain full , not only to the height of I , but of G or D ?
6 .
Whether cleansed Quicksilver will , in the open Air , run in a Siphon higher that 29 Inches ?
7 .
If not in the Air , whether it will so run , if the lower Leg open into well cleansed Water ?
8 .
( Which I do principally recommend ; ) In a Tube so filled with cleansed Quicksilver , as to stand top-full at a greater height than the usual Standard , as CD ; in case some part be forced out , not by admission of Air but by Jogging the Tube , ( I suppose as much as HD , ) and a stop then made : Whether the rest CH ( at a greater height than I , the usual Standard , ) may be made so to stand of it self , notwithstanding the voidance of HD ?
For by this Experiment alone , if it succeed , it will appear , that it is not only want of room for the Subtle matter to recollect it self , which hinders the suspended Quicksilver from falling ; but rather ( unless some probable cause can be found , ) the want of a Spring to put it in motion .
If it will not succeed , I should rather think , the Springy Air doth make its way through the Quicksilver than through the Glass .
9 .
Whether cleansed Quicksilver will remain suspended in an inverted Tube ( at least a short one , and with a small Orifice , ) though its Orifice C be no immerg 'd in Quicksilver , but either in the open Air , or at least in Water ?
10 .
If so ; then whether it will do the like , if , a little being forced out , there be some void room left at the Top , at HD ?
These are nice Experiments , and of some difficulty ; but if carefully administred , may be of good use in our search after the true nature of Gravity : Which may possibly have a greater connexion with the Spring of the Air , than men are a ware of ; since on the presence or absence thereof doth mainly depend the falling or not falling of Bodies accounted Heavy .
But I am not willing , by interposing my own Conjectures , to pre-judge the Experiments .

