Some Annotations of the Learned Dr. Walter Needham upon a Discovery pretended to have been made by the famous Monsieur Pecquet of a Communication between the Ductus Thoracicus and the Inferior Vena Cava .
The Relation it self of that pretended Discovery , as it is to be found in the Journal des Scavans , of Feb.8.1672 .
THE Discovery made about twenty years since by M. Pecquet of the Ductus Thoracicus , seemed not sufficient to clear up all the Difficulties to be met with in the New opinion , which this Channel hath occasioned , concerning Sanguisication .
It might be said among other things , That there appears no reason , why Nature , which does nothing without design , should carry the matter of the Blood into the Sub-clavials , and thence make it descend by the Trunk of the Vena Cava , ( A , ) unless it be to keep the Chyle from entring all at once and altogether pure into the Heart , ~and that the mixture , which is made of the Chyle with the Blood along this way , may dispose the Chyle , by a kind of contagious fermentation the The Annotations of Dr. Needham .
( A. ) I think the reason there mentioned to be very sufficient for the inserting of the Trunk of the Ductus Thoracicus into one place alone ; at least as good as any that are afterwards given to prove the contrary .
For , all proofs of this nature are but loose conjectures at the best : the matter admitting of no other demonstration than what is ocular .
( B. ) Till the Lower insertion be showed , we are bound to believe , that Nature thought the single more easily to receive the character of the Blood in the Heart : But that this might be more conveniently done , the Ductus Thoracicus being inserted into-that trunk of the Vena cava which ascends to the Heart , because that this way is shorter , and is equally favourable to this commixture .
It might also be objected , that , supposing this commixture were of importance , the Ductus Thoracicus should communicate with the inferior trunk of the vena cava as well as with the superior , to the end that the moiety of the Chyle being mixed with the blood that comes from on high , and the other moiety with the blood that comes from beneath , ( B ) it might the more easily be altered by this commixture .
And this Objection seemed the more rational , because , it being very likely that the Blood , which returns from the parts in which it hath received some impression in penetrating their porosities , communicates to the Chyle these same dispositions ; there was reason to desire , that the Blood which re-ascends might in some degree impress the peculiar character of the inferior parts , as that , which comes from the upper parts , impresses upon it that which belongs to it .
( C. ) Add hereunto , that the Blood which re-ascends to the Heart , must be more perfect than that which descends ; because it comes from being purified in the Liver , Spleen , and Kidneys ; so that it is capable to give ( D. ) to the Chyle good impressions .
( E. ) Lastly , it might be said , that , supporting it be necessary that not only a portion of the Chyle pass through the Heart , to give it some kind of refreshment , but also that all the Chyle be conveyed thither for to be converted into Blood ; the small orifices , which the ductus thoracicus hath in the subclavials , seem not to commixture of Blood and Chyle sufficient .
The reinforcement of that Objection answers it self , being proposed in no other terms than ( it seems very likely ; ) the whole conjecture having yet had but very slender foundation in Philosophy .
And if there be any thing in the notion of impressing characters , it is more attributable to the lympha .
See beneath lit .
D. ( C. ) That the Blood , which re-ascends to the Heart , is purer than what descends from the Head , &amp;c. is a notion that will not easily be granted , neither can it be made out by Experiment .
I have my self compared the Blood of the jugularlar vein with that of the Crural in a Dog , and found no difference .
The separations made by the Kidneys and Liver ( if they prove any thing ) prove the ascending blood to be thicker than the descending ; it having lost in those places much of its serum and its lixivial salts , which are the great instruments of attenuation .
But withal it is to be considered , that the Blood , which ascends from the Heart to the Head , parts with much excrement in the glandulae salivales , and nostrils , and the whole throat ; the quantities of which are much greater than will easily be imagined .
There is likebe be large enough for that purpose .
( F. ) The Observations , that have been made in the beginning of this year in his Majesties Library , by searching carefully the passage of the Ductus Thoracicus in the Body of a Woman , did show , that these difficulties were well grounded .
For , it hath been found by divers Experiments , made about this matter , that there ascends at least so much Chyle through the Trunk which is beneath the Heart , as there descends through that which is above it .
These Experiments have appeared considerable , in regard that they confirm those , which were also made by the same Royal Academy of the Sciences about five years since , and which were inserted in the 7th journal des Scavanis 1667 * .
But this last Experiment hath been clearer and ampler then the first , in that the Communi cation , which the first time appeared to be only with the left Emulgent Vein , hath been found this second time not only with this vein , but also with the two Lumbary veins , which are inserted in the Trunk of the inferior vena cava .
* See Numb.25 .
of these Tracts p. 461 .
where those Experiments were English't .
As to the manner of proceeding , in the presence of the whole Company , for finding this Communication , it was this : After there had been showed the Commerce of the Ductus thoracicus with the Right Ventricle of the Heart by an injection of Milk , which having been syringed into the beginning of this Channel , issued in great quantity through this ventricle ; we tied the Trunk of the vena cava above the Heart , so that nothing might pass that way ; and the Trunk of the Emulgent and that of the Vena Cava having been opened above long wise , some milk , ready to boil , was ( G. ) injected wise a great separation made in the brain ; which whether it be of the purest and best spirits of the blood , so as to leave is depauperated ; or only of a nutritious serum , such as is made in all the solid parts , is hard to say .
Only this may be certainly said , that the Lympha does wholly exonerate it self into the sub-clavial and jugular veins near the place of the insertion of the Chyle ; whereby the whole Chyle is diluted , and the mixture of it and the blood facilitated .
Which very phenomenon is a greater argument to prove , that the Chyle does wholly enter by that passage , than any can be produced on the other side .
For we see , all the Lympha , not only of the Liver and Intestines , but also of the lower limbs , to power it self into the receptaculum chyli , and not into any of the lower veins : Whereas the Lymphaticks of the Head , Neck and Arms , think it sufficient to meet the Chyle at the place of its entrance ; which same thing might have been done by the lower Lymphaticks , had they any Chyle to meet : The principal use of the Lympha seeming to be , to serve the uses of the Chyle and its mixture with the Blood .
( D. ) What impressions are made on the Blood by the Liver , Spleen , Kidneys , &amp;c. is into the Emulgent through the left Lumbary vein ( which we have ever observed to come from the Emulgent , ) and at the same time we saw it come away through the other Lumbary .
This Experiment having been several times repeated without our being able to see the track , which we had observed under the Pleura , when the first Discovery of this Communication was made ; which track seemed to show the way , which the Thoracick branch keeps to entertain a communication with the inferior vena cava : We resolved to attempt a more easy and a more certain method of discovering this branch , than the usual dissection of the vessels , performed by severing their proper tunicles from a multitude of membranes and fatnesses , which lying and embarassing them , render this work very difficult ; especially when the vessels are not filled with blood to make them visible , and because they are composed of more delicate tunicles , than those of the Veins .
( H. ) This way was , to syringe into the Trunk of the ductus thoracicus a Composition , that might run into it being hot , and which by being refrigerated might become solid enough to afford a greater facility to follow and trace the channels , in the cavity of which it should be thus hardened .
And this design succeeded in part .
For , the Composition filled the whole ductus thoracicus and ascended a far as into the sub-clavial ; but there pasted nothing into the channel that makes the communication fought for , though care was had to warm the ambient parts by several injections of warm milk , to the end that the Composition might not harden before it had penetrated into all the conduits .
We also tried to inject the same Composition through the Lumbary that issues out of the Trunk , if its valves would permit it ; but they stopped all that we endeavoured uncertain : But if there be any such made , the Liver and Kidneys do so readily exonerate themselves into the vena cava , that the impressions ; be they what they will , are quickly conveyed to the Heart without any great diminution of them .
And whereas the Author mentions the characters impressed from parts ; those , ( if any such be ) may more justly be supposed to be conveyed in the lympha , which liquor seems to be a product of those parts curiously elaborated in the very substance of them .
( E. ) What is sufficient and not sufficient , must be judgea of by Nature , and not by Us .
Yet , if we consider the time that is spent in carrying the Chyle up into the Blood , it is easy to believe , that a much greater quantity of liquor may be discharged by that ductus , than is usually pretended to .
( F. ) What those Experiments are , we should be glad to know .
But the Experiment of 1667 ( if I rightly remember it ) was only a lusus naturae , found by M. Pecquet .
Which I therefore call so , because neither he , nor any one else hath found it since : whereas the vasa lactea , and the ways of ordering them , are so well known , that , if any such thing were , it could not long be hid .
( G. ) An Injection into the Lumbary vein with its to make pass that way , and neither the milk nor the wind would ever enter there .
( J. ) The advantage we had from the Injection of this Composition into the said Ductus , was , that we very distinctly saw the figure and the whole structure of it , when the Composition wherewith it had been filled , was refrigerated and hardned .
For we found , that that ductus did ascend unto the right side of the heart , keeping one and the same size , which was no more than 1/ 12 of an inch ; that afterwards it was enlarged to 1/ 6 of an inch in diameter ; that in this enlargement its tunicle on the right side of the vertebrae was , as 'twere , pierced by four small holes , distant 1/ 12 of an inch from one another , and all disposed in a row ; into which holes the said Composition had not been able to penetrate ; that the same ductus , after having retaken its first size , had two appendixes fashioned like sacks ; that there was yet a third appendix beneath the dilatation ; that the first and highest appendix was of the form and bigness of a small phaseolus ; that the third , which was beneath the dilatation , was like to the second ; that they had all a straight orifice ; and that the last was full of chyle conspissate , so that the Composition could not enter there , as it had done into the other .
The Importance of these Observations ought to incite the Curiosity of those that are addicted to Anatomical researches , and to engage them to examine with care this New communication , to attain at last a clear account thereof .
effects mentioned can prove nothing but the Inosculation of the two Lumbary veins with each other : which is acknowledged to be such in all theCapillary vessels of the same kind , viz. Veins with veins , and Arteries with arteries .
But the thing required here is , the passage from the Receptaculum to the Lumbary vein , or to any other vein besides the Subclavial .
( H ) The way of syringing a liquor , which is apt to coagulation , into the ductus thoracicus , &amp; c I think to be needless and unprofitable as to this Inquiry , when there is a more easy Experiment to be made , which is more demonstrative , viz. Open a Dog at a convenient distance of time from his feeding , and then tie a ligature upon the ductus thoracicus nigh the Sub-clavial : your receptaculum chyli will continue full , 48 hours or longer , if you please : So that , if there be any such ductus , it must remain likewise full with its own natural liquor , and be all that while visible .
But , if there were any such ductus , it would in a quarter of the time empty the whole receptacle ; whereas upon a ligature you 'll find the clean contrary , viz.all the Lacteal vessels ( that are acknowledged to be such , ) fully distended : Which is a full demonstration , that they have no way of evacuation by any other duct than the thor acique .
( J. ) The other use of the coagulating Injection I applaud ; though the same may be done by the Ligature abovesaid .
However the event of the Experiment , made by the Learned Pecquet , makes against the opinion of a New ductus , and not for it ; as appears by the Narrative .
The haste , in which this was written , begs your excuse .

