Mr. Isaac Newton 's Considerations upon part of a Letter of Monsiur de Berce printed in the Eight French Memoir , concerning the Cata-drioptrical Telescope , pretended to be improved and resined by M. Cassegrain .
That the Reader may be enabled the better to Judge of the whole , by comparing together the contrivances both of Mr. Newton and Mr. Cassegrain ; it will be necessary , to borrow from the said French Memoir what is there said concerning them : which is as follows .
I Send you ( saith M. de Berce to the Publisher of the Memoir , ) the Copy of the Letter , which M. Cassagrain hath written to me concerning the proportions of Sr. Samuel Morelands Trumpet .
And as for the Telescope of Mr. Newton it hath as much surprised me , as the same Person , that hath found out the proportions of the Trumpet .
For it is now about three months , that that person communicated to me the figure of a Telescope , which was almost like it , and which he had invented ; but which I look upon as more witty .
I shall here give you the description of it in short .
ABCD .
is a strong Tube , in the bottom of which there is a great concave speculum CD , pierced in the middle E. F. is a convex speculum , so disposed , as to its convexity , that it reflects the species , which it receives from the great speculum , towards the hole E , where is an Eye-glass , which one looks through .
The advantage , which I find in this Instrument above that of MrNewton , is first , that the mouth or aperture AB of the Tube may be of what biguess you please ; and consequently you may have many more rays upon the Concave Speculum , than upon that , of which you have given us the description .
2 .
The reflexion of the rays will be very natural , since it will be made upon the axis it self , and therefore more vivid .
3 .
The vision of it will be so much the more pleasing , in that you shall not be incommoded by the great light , by reason of the bottom CD , which hides the whole face .
Besides that you 'll have less difficulty in discovering the Objects , than in that of Mr. Newtons .
A CF B D so far this French Author .
To which we shall now subjoin the Considerations of Mr. Newton , as we received them from him in a Letter , written from Cambridge May 4th 1672 , as follows .
SIR I Should be very glad to meet with any improvement of the Catadioptrical Telescope ; but that design of it , which ( as you inform me)Mr .
Cassegrain hath communicated 3 months since , and is now printed in one of the French Memories , I fear will not answer Expectation .
For , when I first applied myself to try the effects of Reflexions , Mr. Gregory 's Optica Promota ( printed in the year 1663 ) being fallen into my hands , where there is an Instrument ( described page .
94 ) like that of Monsieur Cassegrain 's with a hole in the midst of the ObjectMetal to transmit the Light to an Eye-glass placed behind it ; I had thence an occasion of considering that sort of constructions , and found their disadvantages so great , that I saw it necessary , before I attempted any thing in the Practique , to alter the design of them , and place the Eye glass at the side of the Tube rather than at the middle .
The disadvantages of it you will understand by these particulars .
1 .
There will be more light lost in the Metal by reflexion from the little convex speculum , than from the Oval plane .
For , it is an obvious observation , that Light is most copiously reflected from any substance when incident most obliquely .
2 The convex speculum will not reflect the rays so truly as the oval plane , unless it be of an Hyperbolique figure ; which is incomparably more difficult to form than a plane ; and if truR rrr2 lie lie formed , yet would only reflect those rays truly , which respect the axis .
3 The errors of the said convex will be much augmented by the too great distance , through which the rays , reflected from it , must pass before their arrival at the Eyeglass .
For which reason i find it convenient to make the Tube no wider than is necessary , that the Eye glass be placed as near to the Oval plane , as is possible , without obstructing any useful light in its passage to the object metal .
4 .
The errors of the object-metal will be more augmented by reflexion from the convex than from the plane , because of the inclination or deflexion of the convex on all sides from the points , on which every ray ought to be incident .
5 .
For these reasons there is requisite an extraordinary exactness in the figure of the little convex , whereas I find by experience , that it is much more difficult to communicate an exact figure to such small pieces of Metal , than to those that are greater .
6 Because the errors at the perimeter of the concave Object-Metal , caused by the Sphericalness ofits figure , are much augmented by the convex , it will not with distinctness bear so large an aperture , as in the other construction .
7 .
By reason that the little convex conduces very much to the magnifying virtue of the instrument , which the Oval plane doth not , it will magnify much more in proportion to the Sphere , on which the great concaveis ground , than in the other design ; And so magnifying Objects much more than it ought to do in proportion to its aperture , it must represent them very obscure and dark ; and not only so , but also confused by reason of its being overcharged .
Nor is there any convenient remedy for this .
For , if the little convex be made of a larger Sphere , that will cause a greater inconvenience by intercepting too many of the best rays ; or , if the Charge of the Eye-glass be made so much shallower as is necessary , the angle of vision will thereby become so little , that it will be very difficult and troublesome to find an object , and of that object , when found , there will be but a very small part seen at once .
By this you may perceive , that the three advantages , which Monsieur Cassegrain propounds to himself , are rather disadvantages .
For , according to his design , the aperture of the instrument will be but small , the object dark and confused , and also difficult to be found .
Nor do I see , why the reflexion is more upon the same axis , and so more natural in one case than in the other : since the axis it self is reflected towards the Eye by the Oval plain ; and the Eye may be defended from external light as well at the side , as at the bottom of the Tube .
You see therefore , that the advantages of this design are none , but the disadvantages so great and unavoidable , that I fear it will never be put in practise with good effect .
And when I consider , that by reason of its resemblance with other Telescopes it is something more obvious than the other construction ; I am apt to believe , that those , who have attempted any thing in Catoptricks , have ever tried it in the first place , and that their bad success in that attempt hath been the cause , why nothing hath been done in reflexions .
For , Mr. Gregory , speaking of these instruments in the aforesaid book page 95 , says ; De mechanica horum speculorum &amp; lentium , ab aliis frustr a tentata , ego in mechanicis minus versatus nihil dico .
So that there have been trials made of these Telescopes , but yet in vain .
And I am informed , that about 7 or 8 years since , Mr. Gregory himself , at Londen , caused one of six foot to be made by Mr. Reive , which I take to have been according to the aforesaid design described in his book ; because , though made by a skilful Artist , yet it was without success .
I could with therefore , Mr. Cassegrain had tried his design before he divulged it : But if , for further satisfaction , he please hereafter to try it , I believe the success will inform him , that such projects are of little moment till they be put in practise .

